News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by oivey on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @12:01AM (#39450320)
This is really some next level victimhood. Building houses often does involve dealing with whiny homeowners/builders with bad taste and no clue who want everything but also don’t want to pay. That’s the job. Good software engineers know working with stakeholders and users is also the job.

I’ll add another shocker: sometimes blueprints are poorly specified and/or incorrect. And yet, people build the houses. That’s the job!

Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by twelvechairs on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @12:22AM (#39450440)
Yes.

Conversely if programmers had to work like Architects they'd be paid a fraction, not get promoted to run serious projects until they are 50+, work copious unpaid overtime, not be allowed to work from home, be held legally liable for their work, spend most of their days focussing on compliance rather than outcomes, be more client focussed than they have ever considered regardless of above, etc.

Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by throwitaway222 on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @12:51AM (#39450590)
Some architects get hired to do a 50 unit apartment complex for 200k that only takes them a few months. The owners of those businesses farm it out to a junior to do the entire thing, then look over it quickly.

Said junior usually only does this for a maximum of 10 years and graduates to owning their own business. However 85% of them graduate to running a drafter business which just draws plans.

Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by freddie_mercury on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @01:16AM (#39450699)
There is not enough industry growth for every junior to own their own business in 10 years.
Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by whatshisface on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @01:34AM (#39450784)
There is if the average size of said business is between 2 and 1.
Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by darkwater on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @04:49AM (#39451890)
BUT if there is a serious issue in the houses built by following the project you had signed, well, you will go to jail (or pay the fine). I still have to see a software engineer held PERSONALLY accountable, in front of the law, for a PII leak, for example.
Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by adrianN on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @05:50AM (#39452291)
Try working in safety critical software. There liability is the norm.
Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by darkwater on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @07:13AM (#39452874)
Yes, but basically every architect work is safety critical. If a construction collapses on itself, it will kill you.
Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by sojournerc on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @09:10AM (#39453985)
Architects design, a structural engineer makes sure it stands up
Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by darkwater on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @10:12AM (#39454772)
I think it depends on the type of work (and also legislation). For example I had architects calculating which kind/size of iron girder/joist (IDK the exact English word for it) put to replace a supporting wall. If they calculate that badly, the roof comes down at some point, and I die.
Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by whiterknight on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @09:57AM (#39454584)
I am ignorant about this industry. But is it really the architect who is held liable? Not the civil engineer who signs off on the analysis?
Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by wwilim on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @04:11AM (#39451674)
And be used as factotums if the investors ever notice they're good at getting things done. The amount of times my dad was asked to drive 5 hours somewhere to deliver a giant stack of paperwork to a local administration office to secure a building permit...
Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by oivey on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @12:30AM (#39450469)
Yes, and, if they wanted to just build to a spec like a construction worker, they’d get to look forward to getting paid even worse still, physically demanding labor, working in the hot, working in the cold, shitting in boiling portapotties, and shitting in frozen portapotties.
Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by watwut on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @03:46AM (#39451517)
Programmers are rarely promoted to run serious projects. Many work a lot of unpaid overtime. Many of use spend our days focusing on compliance rather then outcomes.
Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by shrimp_emoji on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @09:43AM (#39454412)
> not get promoted to run serious projects until they are 50+

Uh, based?

Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by seemaze on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @11:28AM (#39455858)
> be held legally liable for their work

I've always been amazed that in software, you can call yourself an 'architect', 'engineer', or 'contractor' without any legal accountability. But I'm from the brick-and-mortar side of the fence.

Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by yen223 on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @12:30AM (#39450472)
The charitable take is that this is a way to tell architects what life as a programmer is like.

(I 100% believe that if an architect read this article, their takeaway would be that programmers have it too easy)

Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by magicalhippo on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @01:17AM (#39450706)
> I’ll add another shocker: sometimes blueprints are poorly specified and/or incorrect.

A family member bought a plot, some blueprints for a two-story house from an architect firm and hired someone to build it.

Well into the construction, the builders asked if he would like them to raise the roof of the building by one meter, as it would be a negligible increase in cost.

He was going to reject the offer but changed his mind and accepted.

Once completed he realized that if he had rejected the offer, he wouldn't be able to use the second floor at all. The house had a Gable-style roof[1], and the stairs a U shape along one of the outer walls. Had he not raised the roof, one couldn't have walked up the stairs due to the roof being so low along the outer walls. Even after raising the roof, tall people would still need to tilt their heads going up.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gable_roof

Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by dasil003 on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @02:00AM (#39450901)
I love that they just asked it but they didn't explain why.
Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by magicalhippo on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @02:31AM (#39451062)
Yeah I've always assumed they figured this wouldn't work, but ya never know...

The guy did get the drawings independently checked BTW, they were indeed drawn with the roof too low.

Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by whstl on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @04:01AM (#39451618)
Maybe the builder assumed they noticed too, and if they had said no the builder would try to explain.

I only ever did one big renovation and built one house, but I've seen builders fixing mistakes from engineers and architects sooo many times.

Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by mjevans on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @06:15AM (#39452460)
Minimum height in the stairway isn't part of the specification. The house being structurally sound so it doesn't collapse / otherwise cause a safety hazard in the building is.

Not sure if there's a type of architect that has to think about the wholistic picture including function, usability and general ergonomics. They probably cost more too.

Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by brenschluss on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @08:33AM (#39453541)
> Minimum height in the stairway isn't part of the specification

Uh, yes it is? It's in most building codes, as well as in the IBC (International Building Code).

Architects don't deal with structural soundness; that's a misconception. That's the domain of the structural engineer. The architect IS the generalist.

Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by whstl on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @09:00AM (#39453880)
> Not sure if there's a type of architect that has to think about the wholistic picture including function, usability and general ergonomics.

Pretty much every architect I ever had to work with was like that.

Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by ozim on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @01:48AM (#39450832)
Not really.

Most of developers jobs are “here is Jira ticket build what is written there”.

You get product owners, business analysts, scrum masters that should take away 90% of BS.

But still it is not the case and a lot of those business roles seem like they are just useless and I would do much better job directly talking to the customer.

Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by rurban on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @02:47AM (#39451143)
You are a bit naive here. Those type customers are extremely common, and there are specialized jobs to deal with such customers.

In SW they are the PM's. Without a good PM to shield you from the customers insanities you are lost. In architecture or other engineering professions it's the same. As architect you have a special man to deal with politicians and special clients, and in many other professions even with the press, who has no idea either.

Never talk directly to the customer. Or if so, you are not allowed to make promises.

Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by runtu on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @03:44AM (#39451496)
You shouldn't be talking to the customer to hear what monstrosity of an application they think they want months from now, or even what "features" they think they want added.

You should talk to the customer to understand the problems they have, and work with them to figure out the smallest thing that might help them solve their biggest problem. Build and deliver that small thing fast, then iterate.

Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by whstl on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @05:38PM (#39460594)
25 years ago I thought Office Space would be enough to kill the meme of "technical people can't talk to customers".

It's amusing but sad to see that Agile rent-seekers have managed to creep into the process once again.

And developers have bought it.

Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by ozim on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @09:30AM (#39454239)
Not naive - it is only disappointing level of insanity that still gets through and some business people like PMs or BAs are there to shield devs yes - but there are also vast amounts that don't do their job properly and all turns into basically game of "Chinese whispers" or "human telephone". I don't need someone to copy over what customer wrote from e-mail to Jira that is not what the job is about.
Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by whstl on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @05:39PM (#39460609)
> Without a good PM to shield you from the customers insanities you are lost

Nice but now there isn't anyone to shield us from the insanity and micromanagement of PMs.

Especially the ones who "dabble in programming every weekend".

Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by stormfather on Thursday February 22, 2024 @10:04AM (#39468116)
Sure, but its impossible to be a good PM without coming from a programming background. Otherwise you won't know the difference between the easy, hard and impossible.

My current company has been run into the ground because we had a salesperson in charge of product map making wild promises to customers. What they wound up settling on was a PDF report that costs us $5-$20 to make and we sell for $1!!! Utter insanity. We'll be pivoting out of necessity but we could have saved 6 months by putting someone technically competent in the role.

Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by t_luke on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @02:17AM (#39450982)
If Programmers Had to Work Like Architects

- you aren't allowed to do any programming yourself, you just write a specification

- the majority of the people doing the programming are incapable of reading the specification

- many of those who can will deliberately ignore it to save money

- nevertheless, it's your fault if it's realised incorrectly

Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by baud147258 on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @03:55AM (#39451576)
> If Programmers Had to Work Like Architects

According to my brother who work in construction, architects are often clueless on how to build stuff and existing material limitation, especially with the money he's given.

Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by blauditore on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @04:07AM (#39451650)
I get the same impression: There are many head-in-the-cloud architects who see themselves as artists. The equivalent totally exists in the software world; it's people who want to be pure "software architects", designing what others should implement. In my experience, this dictating mindset never works - designers (technical or not) should evolve their ideas with the implementors/builders, otherwise such disconnects happen.
Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by nazka on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @07:03AM (#39452799)
Yes they have to work with a structural engineer for that. Just like a car designer have to work with a mechanical engineer or a product manager with an software architect.

Architectes are not engineers they are designers and visionaries.

You can check this video for more info:

Structural Engineer vs Architect - Design Meeting https://youtu.be/29-xtjX8rAk?si=7dupEMwy3DEbs_Yi

Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by Izkata on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @10:19AM (#39454857)
Around 15 years ago in college, a friend who was doing an architecture degree was complaining that LEED certification was making people ignore a lot of that kind of thing. That the certification was the most important thing to go for, above just about everything else.
Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by carlmr on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @02:53AM (#39451181)
This sounds a lot like normal software architect work at big corp. You write the spec, it gets sent off somewhere cheap, the people there lied on their CV or got their degree from a diploma mill, they will ignore your spec and make all the tests green instead of checking if they do something, and then you need to take responsibility.
Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by marcosdumay on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @11:27AM (#39455848)
Is this about software architects?

But anyway, no, if the house is built incorrectly, the builders are liable, not the architect.

Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by timeon on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @03:45AM (#39451506)
Still there is one difference. Architect needs to design not only within client's and technical constraints but also within legal regulations.
Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by blauditore on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @04:01AM (#39451616)
...and so do programmers, increasingly so nowadays (at least it's very tangible in Europe).
Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by whstl on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @04:03AM (#39451623)
Also true for a while for some industries like finance.
Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by timeon on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @07:29AM (#39452980)
Some programmers. All architects.
Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by zarathustreal on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @06:03AM (#39452386)
Such a flippant dismissal yet so little consideration given.. ironically, the reality of what you’re doing is exactly what you’re accusing OP of: assuming a state of victimhood.

Shouting “that’s the job!” when it is ostensibly not the job (whatever your experience of the “reality” of it may be) is really an implied assertion that you must make concessions in your work arrangement regardless of the explicit agreement you make with your employer when accepting a job.

The desperation to communicate this comes across, to me, as a cry for help with asserting yourself in the workplace. In my experience this is a result of a power imbalance in the employment relationship. Unfortunately the reasons for this imbalance are often extremely complex but some generic, potentially not helpful, advice for anyone in common scenarios I’ve seen would be:

1. Improve your skillset. It will help your (implied) negotiating power when they start adding more meetings or pulling you off task

2. Learn how to politely assert yourself in a work environment. We’re all playing games of imperfect information and light assertiveness and confidence can put an adversary in a position where they can’t afford to assume you’re wrong (in the moment)

3. Know what you’re signing up for and be candid about what you’re bringing to the table. If you’ve spent the last four years in intensive study of algorithms and data structures, be candid about the fact that you’re taking the job to solve computational problems. Let them know ahead of time that you’re not another head to count or butt to fill a seat.

Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by is_true on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @07:24AM (#39452952)
The architect would be a PM in the real world. The guys working on site are always fixing issues with the design. And owners always want some changes.

The thing with the construction industry is that the user can "see" the frontend before, it would be like if you build the frontend and when the user accepts you build the backend.

Re:If Architects had to work like Programmers by al_borland on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @09:25AM (#39454184)
I’d be more accepting of these things from outside clients. I am less accepting of it from internal stakeholders.