News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by khzw8yyy on Monday February 05, 2024 @10:07AM (#39261953)
All wars have something in common: they end. That thought in your head about lack of hope of normalizing relations is just the current propaganda working.

Edit: it's amazing just how short-sighted people can be. Look, we still bring up the Nazis as an unassailable argument for how something is bad. And yet the war with Germany ended and they are now a US ally fighting Russia. I'm sure in the midst of WW2 the common folk also believed that there can be no peace with Germany, after all the man on the radio said so.

Besides, during WW2 the situation was the opposite: Russia was an ally. And hey, if you study European history at all you'll note that it's a series of wars with shifting alliances.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by rurp on Monday February 05, 2024 @10:49AM (#39262385)
So do countries, if we're looking at a long enough time scale. There is no end in sight for the war in Ukraine and when the end comes it's likely to be messy. It might be more of a pause than a true end, and one or both sides will likely be pretty unhappy with the outcome. It could be many years before Russia and the west go back to a comfortable economic relationship.
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by khzw8yyy on Monday February 05, 2024 @12:02PM (#39263480)
Maybe the problem is the shortness of sight rather than the lack of an end?

Rest assured, if the powers that be decide that "Russia is good now" they will convince you of the same within 6 months.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by The_Colonel on Monday February 05, 2024 @02:08PM (#39265520)
My grandparents carried some anti-German sentiments 70 years after the war ended. Maybe you are able to switch your opinions that quickly, most people can't.
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by khzw8yyy on Monday February 05, 2024 @02:59PM (#39266273)
The people who have Ukraine bumper stickers on their cars couldn't point at the country on the map just 2 years ago. I think you overestimate most people.
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by The_Colonel on Monday February 05, 2024 @03:16PM (#39266510)
Are you still talking about yourself?
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by khzw8yyy on Monday February 05, 2024 @07:34PM (#39269223)
I can change the topic too!

Do you still think "Operation Iraqi Freedom" brought Iraquis freedom? Or maybe you know where all those WMDs are?

[dead]
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by saintfire on Monday February 05, 2024 @12:08PM (#39263564)
No comment on your politics but saying "Prove me wrong" is basically just saying "Argue with me".

You can rarely prove a prediction or opinion wrong, especially if they're this vague. Only time can, sometimes.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by jcranmer on Monday February 05, 2024 @11:35AM (#39263103)
> Prove me wrong.

Neoconservatives are not, and indeed have not held power in the US for the better part of a decade. Indeed not even back when Russia invaded Crimea if memory serves me correctly.

Of course, there's a decent probability that you've redefined "neoconservative" to mean "people whose politics I don't like" as opposed to any definition that's actually useful for an analysis of foreign policy, and concomitantly that you are so myopically focused on one specific component of foreign policy that you would refuse to admit any evidence that might actually prove you wrong.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by ecommerceguy on Monday February 05, 2024 @11:44AM (#39263227)
You are correct, I do not side with warmongers, of which Clinton, Obama, Biden, Bush, Cheney et al are solidly in favor of. War.

You proved nothing.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by kergonath on Monday February 05, 2024 @11:14AM (#39262741)
Talking to people actually living in the place could give you a clue. Putin is a neocon, sure, but no bureaucrat started this war and Ukraine is very unlikely to just fold and submit if the US stop their support. Liberals have also nothing to do with Russian aggression.
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by ecommerceguy on Monday February 05, 2024 @11:48AM (#39263282)
>>no bureaucrat started this war

2 bureaucrats that have incessantly called for war quickly come to mind, Jake Sullivan and Victoria Nuland.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by kergonath on Monday February 05, 2024 @06:12PM (#39268514)
What? You haven’t been paying attention. These people had no power to start anything.

Also, last time I checked, it was Russia who invaded, not the US, which are not a party in this war.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by whimsicalism on Monday February 05, 2024 @11:18AM (#39262816)
This war will likely end with Ukraine losing some amount of land - it is just a matter of if they ever accept this or whether they want a Korea style frozen conflict.
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by para_parolu on Monday February 05, 2024 @11:29AM (#39263004)
That happens in 2014 when Ukraine lost Crimea. They accepted it and lived on. There is zero safety guarantees for them.
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by somenameforme on Monday February 05, 2024 @12:02PM (#39263479)
Not quite! The immediate history here plays a huge role in where we're at today. In the 2014 the US backed a [coup, revolution, insurrection - whatever you want to call it] in Ukraine that saw their democratically elected pro-Russian President overthrown. Numerous Ukrainian territories that also leaned pro-Russia refused to recognize the new government and declared their independence, the Donbas region and Crimea among them.

For the 8 years from 2014 to 2022 Ukraine was intermittently attacking and shelling these breakaway territories (excepting Crimea, which had become part of Russia) which were (and are) largely populated with ethnic Russians, and Russia was "secretly" protecting them. This led to a series of treaties, The Minsk Accords [1], to try to arrange peace between Russia and Ukraine, and give the breakaway territories some sort of special status while remaining under Ukraine.

These treaties were always violated. And while this was happening Ukraine was increasingly fortifying and arming itself, as well as seeking to join NATO - which NATO was, sincerely or not, indulging. This all really set the stage for where we are today. It also sets the stage for where we're going tomorrow, because the inability to maintain any sort of a peace over these regions is going to make obtaining a 'minimally unfavorable' settlement for Ukraine, over this war, much more difficult.

[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minsk_agreements

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by mopsi on Monday February 05, 2024 @12:45PM (#39264081)
None if this is true. For example, the "pro-Russian President" wasn't overthrown. At Russian pressure, he ditched a very favorable trade agreement with the EU that would've opened up many new business opportunities for Ukrainians. When protesters assembled, he ordered police snipers to shoot at them, killing 108 people. He fled to Russia the next day and Ukraine's parliament voted to remove him from office, and scheduled new elections, which were held three months later.
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by somenameforme on Monday February 05, 2024 @01:30PM (#39264867)
Wiki has a surprisingly good timeline of the event. [1] Even the identity of the snipers has, again, a quite reasonable page on Wiki. [2] You might want to at least add in the whole thing about "protesters" shooting at police officers to try to escalate the conflict, occupying government buildings and seizing substantial quantities of weapons, Western cities (which tend to be very pro-EU and anti-Russia for those not familiar with the geography of Ukraine) spontaneously refusing to acknowledge the President's authority, and ultimately the military as well.

Even the end of it all was quite odd. There was a settlement agreed upon, but far right types refused to accept anything short of the President's ouster, and the government was then subsequently directly threatened by the now in control "protesters". Following said threats riot police and others that were guarding the presidential compound "vanished." [3] And it was in this context that Yanukovych fled. Had he not, he probably would have been killed.

[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolution_of_Dignity#Detailed...

[2] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maidan_casualties#Identity_of_...

[3] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolution_of_Dignity#Agreemen...

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by kergonath on Monday February 05, 2024 @06:14PM (#39268529)
> Wiki has a surprisingly good timeline of the event. [1] Even the identity of the snipers has, again, a quite reasonable page on Wiki. [2]

None of these link support your point of view, though.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by somenameforme on Monday February 05, 2024 @10:37PM (#39270454)
If you lack interest in reading all the sources yourself, feel free to ask for the specific reference of any single thing I've said and I'll happily cite it for you.
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by whimsicalism on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:19AM (#39290404)
the second link is obviously counter to the narrative of

“ When protesters assembled, he ordered police snipers to shoot at them, killing 108 people.” as it describes interviews with Maidan snipers

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by Const-me on Monday February 05, 2024 @12:46PM (#39264095)
You’re telling the false version of these events spread by the Russian state propaganda.

> US backed a [coup, revolution, insurrection - whatever you want to call it] in Ukraine

People of Ukraine did the revolution. The western backing you’re talking about was limited to vague verbal expressions of support.

> territories that also leaned pro-Russia refused to recognize the new government and declared their independence

That only happened on the territories invaded by the Russians.

Crimea: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_occupation_of_Crimea#H...

Eastern Ukraine: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Igor_Girkin#Sloviansk

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by whimsicalism on Monday February 05, 2024 @01:26PM (#39264774)
> People of Ukraine did the revolution. The western backing you’re talking about was limited to vague verbal expressions of support.

Obviously no revolution can happen without popular dissatisfaction and massive popular support for an alternative. But I think the Nuland-Pyatt call leak firmly puts to bed the notion that US involvement was 'limited to vague verbal expressions of support.'

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by Const-me on Monday February 05, 2024 @02:01PM (#39265411)
Are you referring to that leaked call? https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-26079957 If the leak is true, the people in the call are doing precisely what they publicly said they were doing — trying to negotiate a peaceful political resolution of the ongoing crisis.

As shown by the events which followed, all their talks achieved absolutely nothing.

The resolution of the crisis in Ukraine was neither peaceful nor political. Instead, couple weeks after the alleged call the crisis was resolved after the bloodshed on February 18-20.

Then Russia has launched military invasion, escalating the internal political crisis into an international war. Sadly, the war is still ongoing, despite almost 10 years have passed since these events.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by whimsicalism on Monday February 05, 2024 @03:03PM (#39266333)
They're literally picking out the next PM to replace yakunovich and it turned out exactly as they said.
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by Const-me on Monday February 05, 2024 @03:37PM (#39266809)
The logical error you just made is called “post hoc fallacy” https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post_hoc_ergo_propter_hoc

The reason Yatsenyuk became a prime minister, on February 27, 2014 the parliament of Ukraine made him so, with 371 out of 450 deputies supporting the decision. Just because some western politicians also viewed the guy as a good fit for the role doesn’t prove they affected the events in any way.

BTW, President of Ukraine has way more executive power than the PM. As the immediate result of the revolution, Turchynov became the acting president. He received way more political power than Yatsenyuk, yet the unknown people speaking on the leaked call never mentioned his name.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by twixfel on Monday February 05, 2024 @12:29PM (#39263833)
So do you think all of Russia's annexations should be recognised by the international community?
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by somenameforme on Monday February 05, 2024 @01:40PM (#39265053)
No, I think the people of these regions should have been allowed to decide their own fate, which then should be internationally recognized. This is, of course, impossible now because the war means that the demographics have shifted substantially and irreversibly. But this would have at least been a viable path forward in 2014. The problem is that nobody wants this sort of democracy unless they like the answer they're going to get.

Like imagine if in 2020 the January 6th rioters had somehow managed to overthrow the government and get Trump in office again. It would seem, to me, perfectly reasonable for e.g. California to then say 'No thank you.' and refuse to acknowledge his authority. That probably would have led to a civil war but if you're asking what I think - it's that people in such scenarios (which, granted, are not so easy to define) ought be allowed to decide their own fate.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by The_Colonel on Monday February 05, 2024 @02:14PM (#39265613)
All Ukrainian regions have voted for Ukrainian independence in the 1991 referendum. All the way until 2014 there wasn't actually any relevant pro-independence movement in Crimea or Donbas, until the Russian soldiers showed up, and dictated the course of events, of course.
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by seryoiupfurds on Monday February 05, 2024 @01:59PM (#39265379)
How about if trucks full of soldiers without uniform crossed the border from Mexico to go on a sunny vacation, and decided on the spur of the moment to help their new friends out by imposing martial law and holding sham elections and shooting down airliners?
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by kergonath on Monday February 05, 2024 @06:21PM (#39268581)
> No, I think the people of these regions should have been allowed to decide their own fate, which then should be internationally recognized.

This means that Russia needs to go back to its border and free and fair elections need to be held, in accordance with the country’s constitution. Right? You realise that Russia leaving the country is a pre-requisite for the people to vote freely? Unless you count what we’ve seen in Crimea, in the Donbas and in the Kherson and Zaporizhzhia oblasts as somehow free and fair. You know, when the ballot boxes were brought to each house by armed Russian soldiers with tanks on the streets.

> But this would have at least been a viable path forward in 2014.

2014 was when Putin put everything in motion, having spent the previous years setting it up. If you think that anything reasonable could happen under Yanukovich, well, you were not paying attention.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by jcranmer on Monday February 05, 2024 @11:37AM (#39263135)
Ukraine has been fighting Russia for nearly a decade, with active if low-level warfare in the Donbass region the entire time. I wouldn't exactly call that "accept[ing] it and liv[ing] on."
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by The_Colonel on Monday February 05, 2024 @01:28PM (#39264809)
From about 2017 the war was very low-level, limited to some artillery duels. And those duels weren't entirely Ukrainian choice, if Russia shoots at you, you can't just ignore it.
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by Log_out_ on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @02:26AM (#39271775)
Remember when the local "insurrection" to kijev marched into the theater in kherson because they thought it the regional governments office. For all their propaganda multitudes fines online, they are just lethal clowns on the ground, unable to innovate, because bound by puppeteer strings. Ukraine will win. Moscovia will fall apart once again.

Empires die and vanish all the time.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by kergonath on Monday February 05, 2024 @11:28AM (#39262978)
You say it like it’s their choice. Moldova never asked for Transnistria. It’s fairly SOP for Russia to take bites from its neighbours, let’s stop blaming the victims. Whatever Russia ends up doing, they are preparing for themselves a second Chechnya at the very least.
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by whimsicalism on Monday February 05, 2024 @11:35AM (#39263094)
Of course it is not just their choice. Russia has indicated their willingness to accept current holdings (for now, you are right there are no guarantees).

Ukraine could and should get better than just that, but this notion of taking back Crimea is a pipe dream and I don’t support continued funding until that goal is realized.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by twixfel on Monday February 05, 2024 @12:03PM (#39263492)
If you want to be extremely cynical and seek to strictly extend and project the USA's power as harshly and effectively as possible, the war in Ukraine was God's gift to the USA. They get to basically take out Russia (China's key geopolitical ally) without losing a single American life, for a tiny fraction of the amount they're used to spending on wars.

And yet it's American nationalists themselves who want it all to stop, to throw all of its European allies under the bus and burn the alliance with the rest of the Western world to the ground. An amazing and almost impressive act of self harm.

It's not so much "America first" with you lot, it's "America alone".

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by whimsicalism on Monday February 05, 2024 @12:07PM (#39263562)
You are assuming I am some Trump American-first Republican. I think you are severely misjudging the politics of Ukraine support in the US, which has collapsed in the last few months.

Perhaps I am opposed to harsh projections of American power in an increasingly multipolar world? The global playing field is leveling, I think that is precisely the wrong time to be making even bitterer enemies.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by twixfel on Monday February 05, 2024 @12:15PM (#39263659)
Yes I am assuming that very much, but it does not matter that much, either you're America first or you agree with their foreign policy anyway on Ukraine. I understand that Ukraine support has been politicised even when it should not be. This says much more about the utterly dysfunctional state of American politics and the decline of American society whereby you're seriously entertaining reelecting Trump next year. It does not say much at all about Ukraine. If it were not Ukraine, it would simply be something else equally irrelevant to domestic American politics but equally politicised.

>Perhaps I am opposed to harsh projections of American power in an increasingly multipolar world?

I don't know, are you? Put another way the USA is helping support a free and independent country against an imperial genocidal conqueror. Isn't that what the USA is kind of supposed to do? Otherwise what exactly does it stand for?

Or another way: In forcing "détente" on Europe, are you happy to trade good relations with most of Europe, your oldest allies, for maybe better relations with Russia, your enemy who hates you and seeks your destruction? Really? Sounds like a shit and moronic deal to me.

>The global playing field is leveling, I think that is precisely the wrong time to be making even bitterer enemies.

It's too late lad. Russia hates you even more than they hate your mother country, my homeland, the UK. In fact Russia hates you more than any other country on the planet. They utterly despise you and Anglo-American cultural hegemony. In for a penny, in for a pound and all that. They've been working to undermine the USA since well before the war started. There is no going back any time soon. Instead you advocate surrender to the same people who wish to destroy you. Weak.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by cmrdporcupine on Monday February 05, 2024 @12:31PM (#39263860)
It's pretty typically American to only be able to see the world through the lense of their own parochial internal interests and partisan conflicts. Their economy and military and geography of the country are so big that the gravity field of the place is massive, and both liberals and conservatives there rewrite things in terms of their own dysfunctional political cultural battles. Not to say other places in the world don't have ideological blinders, but the US is extreme.

The prime example of this was the nonsense that got Trump impeached ... Trump trying to strong-arm Zelensky into intervening into US domestic politics. "Art of the deal" wasn't so much that, as it was just total blindness to anything outside his own internal interests. American tribal politics were clearly so important that the survival of Ukraine itself was a bargaining chip.

FWIW up here in Canada none of the 5 mainstream political parties have taken a position against supporting Ukraine, financially and militarily. Given the size of the Ukrainian-Canadian population (third largest Ukrainian population after Ukraine and Russia) such a position would be electorally toxic.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by whimsicalism on Monday February 05, 2024 @12:52PM (#39264186)
> it does not matter that much, either you're America first or you agree with their foreign policy anyway on Ukraine

It does matter because you basically said "if you really cared about maintaining American unipolarity no matter the cost, you would be all in on Ukraine" - and I don't care about maintaining American unipolarity no matter the cost. A multipolar world is an inevitability.

> you advocate surrender to the same people who wish to destroy you. Weak.

Somehow I suspect that I am not the jingoistic nationalist here.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by twixfel on Monday February 05, 2024 @03:14PM (#39266476)
That was a hypothetical. I was just observing that the Ukraine war is amazing for US interests in a strictly Machiavellian, geopolitical sense. We Europeans are getting fucked over by the Russians, Ukrainians most of all and of course Russians are destroying themselves too for the sake of land (as if Russia hasn't got enough...). The USA is laughing here. I mention this because it's clear that it isn't a humanitarian issue for the US isolationists, they just don't want to spend the money (at least in theory, of course it's really all about domestic political tribalism and almost nothing to do with Ukraine for at least one side of the divide in the US), so I am speaking to them here on those terms.

>Somehow I suspect that I am not the jingoistic nationalist here.

Yes indeed how nationalistic of me to checks notes oppose wars of imperial conquest in Europe.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by kergonath on Monday February 05, 2024 @06:34PM (#39268702)
> In forcing "détente" on Europe, are you happy to trade good relations with most of Europe, your oldest allies, for maybe better relations with Russia, your enemy who hates you and seeks your destruction? Really? Sounds like a shit and moronic deal to me.

There won’t be any détente in Europe. There was an opportunity in the early 2000s but both Russia and Western European countries fumbled it. Now the door was closed and Russia’s actions ensured that it won’t open for quite a while. It is difficult to grasp how profound the effects on European politics has been.

This is what is so pathetic about those Americans who delude themselves thinking that if they close their eyes it will be ok. The world is slipping through their fingers and they don’t realise that this is accelerating the disintegration of American power. This war is fundamentally different from Iraq in a way they do not seem to grasp.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by somenameforme on Monday February 05, 2024 @12:59PM (#39264318)
That rhetoric, outside of being sociopathic, is also almost certainly just not true.

I'm sure you've also been watching this war play out. When Russia first invaded their army was disorganized, relatively ineffective, and on extremely unstable footing. And when NATO entered the picture there was genuine fear about Western weaponry. Now Russia's military is much more effective, the visage of dominance of Western weaponry has been completely destroyed (along with large amounts of said weaponry itself), Russia's military production has reached highly competent levels, and they're altogether in a much better place. Even the no American lives part is false. Not only have numerous mercenaries and contractors been killed, but I think it's extremely safe to assume that there have been casualties among the inevitable individuals who are not officially there.

Also, one mistake you make is in claiming that withdrawing will have negative consequences (which I agree with), and then jumping from there to 'well, then we shouldn't withdraw!' Unfortunately in real life the choice is often not between a good choice and a bad choice, but between a bad choice and an awful choice. This is even more true when acting under poor leadership, or leadership with insufficient foresight. And I don't see how continuing this war is anything but negative for basically everybody, except perhaps Boeing and other arms dealers.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by The_Colonel on Monday February 05, 2024 @01:29PM (#39264848)
If the Russian army is in a much better shape than in 2022, why are they stuck?
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by somenameforme on Monday February 05, 2024 @02:23PM (#39265742)
Have you noticed near to everything "we" say, as far as analysis of this war goes, ends up being simply not true? Russia's running out of missiles, the Russian economy is collapsing, this counter-attack's going to destroy Russia, this weapon or that weapon will be a 'game-changer.' So forth and so on. And now we're at "well it's just a stalemate."

The latest 'big battle', so far as I know is ongoing in Avdiivka. [1] I have not read the Wiki page on it, but if you're interested in following the war, that'd probably be a reasonable starting spot.

[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Avdiivka_(2022%E2%80...

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by The_Colonel on Monday February 05, 2024 @02:36PM (#39265930)
Nice cherrypicking and building strawmen. How about the Russia's obvious failures? Was Kyiv offensive a "feint" according to you?

Avdiivka is a village of 1000 inhabitants, and it's the biggest Russian assault since Russia took the town of Bakhmut about a year ago. With this pace, Russia is going to take Kyiv in the year 3000.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by somenameforme on Monday February 05, 2024 @03:08PM (#39266411)
No, the Kyiv offensive was obviously a poorly executed failure. And it happened right at the start of this war, which is exactly what I am saying. "That" Russian military lost to a relatively improvised small scale counter-offensive, while the "new" Russian military beat back a massive Ukrainian counter-attack directly backed (and probably directed) by NATO. These are practically two different forces. We're not weakening Russia, we're hardening it.

As for Avdiivka, read the Wiki on it for more info. It's an industrial city, one of the most heavily fortified locations in Ukraine, and of significant strategic value. Every inch in that place comes at a high price, and both sides desperately want to control it. So it's a pretty reasonable bellwether to keep your eyes on.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by The_Colonel on Monday February 05, 2024 @03:38PM (#39266827)
You don't have to worry about my knowledge of Avdiivka. It's a village which has a value only for Russia, because it's very close to Donetsk city and is a major thorn in the Russian propaganda - can you explain to me how is Russia so strong and at the same time after 2 years of war still can't push Ukrainians more than 10 kilometers from the downtown of Donetsk city, the capital of DPR?

For Ukraine, the only value Avdiivka represents is that it allows them to bleed Russians for it, because it just matters so much for them. Otherwise, Avdiivka is even less important than Bakhmut (that one was at least a logistics node) and the loss of it did not lead to any frontline collapse - on the opposite, Ukrainians were able to recover Bakhmut flanks since then.

> We're not weakening Russia, we're hardening it.

What military analysts are you following? Because from what I hear from my sources (e.g. Kofman, Massicot) Russia's forces are very much degraded with many of the best units lost.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by monetus on Monday February 05, 2024 @04:39PM (#39267610)
> * it allows them to bleed Russians for it,*

The scale of it is astounding. In the past few weeks, it has been a wave every hour or two, sometimes faster, with 5 to 20 vehicles a wave; minesweepers and a 2:1 bmp to tank ratio. Lots of troops and they barely get anywhere. It is horrid. The only real breakthrough that the Russians have made was through a long waste pipe into town. They rushed a ~150 people through after smaller groups, but those mostly ended up cut off from any resupply with the AFU having retaken their 3rd, main line of defense in that area. Destroyed a massive Russian column in that too.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by somenameforme on Monday February 05, 2024 @11:30PM (#39270823)
I find analysis for this war quite inane to consume. The reality of war is that very often even the participants themselves are not entirely sure what's going on, let alone what will happen. See, for the most obvious example, the Ukrainian counter attack. So I simply prefer to look at what little data we can get that both sides agree upon and use that to get an indication of the broad "direction" of the war.

So for instance the average Ukrainian soldier is now up to 43 years old [1], more than a decade older than when the war began. And Ukraine has been turning to increasingly aggressive conscription efforts, with the military demanding even more. There's now also major friction between the head of the Ukrainian military and Zelensky, with Zelensky looking to replace him. [2] These sort of little nuggets, which are not disputed by either side at this point, give you an indication of the "direction" of the war.

It's the same reason I find Avdeevka relevant. Avdeevka does have strategic value, but what really matters is that it's a hill both sides have decided to die on. It's similar to something like Verdun. Verdun is a completely irrelevant town in France, far smaller than Avdeevka and with much less strategic value, yet hundreds of thousands of people lost their lives fighting over it. The reason the result mattered is not because this side or that now controlled Verdun, but because it was a major bellwether for the "direction" of the war.

[1] - https://time.com/6329188/ukraine-volodymyr-zelensky-intervie...

[2] - https://www.nytimes.com/2024/01/30/world/europe/ukraine-zele...

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by kergonath on Monday February 05, 2024 @06:27PM (#39268644)
> If you want to be extremely cynical and seek to strictly extend and project the USA's power as harshly and effectively as possible, the war in Ukraine was God's gift to the USA. They get to basically take out Russia (China's key geopolitical ally) without losing a single American life, for a tiny fraction of the amount they're used to spending on wars.

In a sane timeline, support for Ukraine should be unanimous amongst US politicians. Whether they would be neocons (following the calculation you outlined), liberals out to support oppressed people, cold-hearted capitalists out to make a buck both during wartime and in reconstruction, anyone supporting the military who will get an influx of new toys as their old ones are shipped out to Ukraine at basically no cost for the taxpayer, testosterone-addicted macho patriots who get to see American technology crush the remains of a former peer adversary.

It really should be a no brainer. And yet…

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by cmrdporcupine on Monday February 05, 2024 @12:25PM (#39263783)
The war will not end there. Just pause.

It will not "end" until Russia has installed a subservient client regime in Ukraine like it has in Belorussia.

If you doubt this, I encourage you to look at actual opinions within Russia itself. Interviews with Russians (the 1420 channel on Youtube for example), Russian media, Russian politicians. Their objection is far more than "there's Russian speakers being persecuted by Ukraine." Their national chauvinism leaves them unable to tolerate actually-sovereign nation states on their borders, especially one with an intertwined cultural-linguistic-political history like Ukraine.

"Split Ukraine into two and give the far western half to Poland and absorb the rest into Russia" is a commonly held "solution".

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by The_Colonel on Monday February 05, 2024 @01:22PM (#39264689)
Those same people on 1420 will tell you that Poland and UK need to be denazified. It's just propaganda working, you can't mistake it for real strategic goals.
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by cmrdporcupine on Monday February 05, 2024 @01:26PM (#39264753)
Absolutely, it's not scientific at all, but it shows the strong presence of a chauvinistic compliant population.

FWIW I think you could find similar nonsense on the streets of many (but not all) American cities. It's the kind of hubris that comes from being a huge country that is its own centre of gravity and a political leadership that runs around saying it's the "best country in the world" and stuff like that. That's how it looks from up here in Canada, anyways.

Anyways, you don't have to look at 1420, just the public pronouncements of Putin himself

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by whimsicalism on Monday February 05, 2024 @01:28PM (#39264818)
I love how you all create these little side threads where you imagine people's views and then argue against them rather than taking the actually stated views of people in this thread at face value.
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by The_Colonel on Monday February 05, 2024 @01:56PM (#39265318)
Putin says a lot of things. No, he's not laying out his grand strategy in front of you, he's saying what is politically useful at the moment.

You can't really know the Russia's strategic thinking from public proclamations. You need to read between the lines, and even then it's mostly guesswork.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by BlueTemplar on Monday February 05, 2024 @09:06PM (#39269895)
Well, could go many ways. Depends who is going to "succeed" to Putin (which isn't getting any younger) and especially how.
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by kiba on Monday February 05, 2024 @10:21AM (#39262122)
War didn't technically "end" between North and South Korea, North Korea is still a pariah state even if we were to accept the Korean war ended many decades ago.

Relationship between Russia and the west will probably be restored at some point but not without a lot of Russians and to a lesser extent Ukrainian getting killed, their economy and infrastructure gutted.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by thriftwy on Monday February 05, 2024 @10:36AM (#39262241)
Well, at the current point of time Russia's economy and infrastructure are mostly intact. I'm not sure why is that for a dramatic change.

If you look at Iran, it also has its infrastructure in quite OK conditions - perhaps in better shape than all of their neighbours, and now that may even include Turkey. Russia is larger and has not self-inflicted being a theocracy.

As for the losses of both sides, I'd suggest leaving that to military experts.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by nradov on Monday February 05, 2024 @10:45AM (#39262335)
As the war drags on we can expect to see escalation in Ukrainian strikes against Russian infrastructure targets such as refineries. Russia is already short of air defense systems and isn't able to provide much coverage for civilian targets. Whether this works will depend on the level of sustained foreign aid for Ukraine.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/davidhambling/2024/01/25/ukrain...

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by Throw73747 on Monday February 05, 2024 @11:33AM (#39263059)
Kremlin will just use those attacks as an excuse to occupy larger parts of Ukraine. Bombing of Belgorod is now used as an excuse to create "demilitarized zone" that includes Kharkiv (second largest city in Ukraine). I guess another "demilitarized zone" will follow in Odessa, after some attack on Crimea.
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by u320 on Monday February 05, 2024 @12:38PM (#39263968)
Russia has been trying to occupy a larger part of Ukraine for almost 2 years now without success. They don't need excuses.
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by The_Colonel on Monday February 05, 2024 @01:24PM (#39264724)
The only reason Russia doesn't occupy Kharkiv, Odesa and Kyiv is that they can't. They don't need any excuse.
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by thriftwy on Monday February 05, 2024 @11:20AM (#39262860)
With the current rate of attacks Ukraine is not able to cause any noticeable infrastructural issues, and anything beyond approximately the Volga river is not reachable by any weapon systems.

It's sort of a moving target like "How long would it take for Freddy Krueger to kill all Chinese teenagers"

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by cmrdporcupine on Monday February 05, 2024 @11:16AM (#39262780)
Depends on if Trump takes the Whitehouse in the fall and how European elections go :-(

In either case, even a Ukrainian defeat means Russia will be a pariah state to countries with reasonable governance. Trade will be difficult and diminished, same as it is with Iran.

Putin&Lavrov have clearly made this calculation and decided this is in their own interests. Whether it's in the interest of the Russian people I think is questionable.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by khzw8yyy on Monday February 05, 2024 @12:05PM (#39263535)
It's interesting that you bring up Iran. They are actually doing pretty well considering that the US stole all their foreign currency reserves (and also precipitated the original conflict in the first place).
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by vkou on Monday February 05, 2024 @12:49PM (#39264145)
Not to mention having their neighbours destabilized into the most insane civil wars, over the past two decades (with gems like ISIS/Daesh having their year or two in the sun).

If anyone's wondering why Iran has its fingers into Syria and Iraq militias, note they've been invaded (with US support) by one, and are allied with the other.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by kergonath on Monday February 05, 2024 @11:04AM (#39262621)
Ending wars and normalising relations can take a hell of a lot of time, though. Just ask people who lived in the Balkans, central or Eastern Europe, Korea, or in Palestine at some point in the 20th century, to name but a few examples. Or those who lived in a constant background of warfare basically anywhere in the world at any point in time. The pax romana and the stability brought by well-managed empires are remarquable for a reason.
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by whimsicalism on Monday February 05, 2024 @11:17AM (#39262796)
I agree that animosity is deep rooted between neighbors. But I suspect it is less deep between distant countries that have had working relationships in the past.
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by twixfel on Monday February 05, 2024 @11:28AM (#39262981)
I think there's deep animosity between Russia and much of the West.

It's very easy for Americans to shrug their shoulders and say "we don't care it's a long way away", regardless of whether or not that would be a historic surrender for the global hegemon, but we Europeans cannot. It's on our doorstep. Russia has not just attacked Ukraine, but all of Europe. There will never be normalised relations with Russia whilst he is in power, just as there never could be normalised relations with Adolf Hitler once he had crossed the Rubicon and started WW2.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by thriftwy on Monday February 05, 2024 @12:49PM (#39264134)
I wonder when you will arrive at the understanding that if Russia is not going to have more revolutions, then you are going to have to live alongside Russia on the tiniest of continents and it would be best for both sides to learn how.

Is's not like you're going in with a military action and capturing Volgograd, after all. Adolf Hitler could be neutralized by capturing Berlin. Good luck dealing with Russia that way.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by The_Colonel on Monday February 05, 2024 @01:35PM (#39264956)
Learning to live is arming the eastern NATO border to the teeth. Russia has never stopped trying to expand westward, is still very far from giving up on its imperialism and strength is the only language it understands.
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by thriftwy on Monday February 05, 2024 @01:45PM (#39265113)
Then you will have a permanent war in Europe, get used to it and make yourself comfortable.
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by The_Colonel on Monday February 05, 2024 @01:52PM (#39265253)
Can you explain? European (NATO) countries will "provoke" Russia into invading by securing their internationally recognized borders?

So far, we have seen the opposite pattern of Russia messing with countries which didn't make it into NATO in time.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by thriftwy on Monday February 05, 2024 @02:15PM (#39265632)
There is no good way out of the situation where both sides are armed to the teeth. The best bet is a political failure of one of the sides.

If that does not happen, these sabers will be rattling from time to time. If Russia's (and China's) immediate borders are packed with countries armed to their teeth, there would be wars.

Buffer states happen for a reason.

I believe USA kind of understands this (see how they reacted to Cuba) and EU surely understands this too (see how Sweden reacts to any signs of Russian militarization), but they have trouble projecting it on other countries or still believing they can coerce these countries into "dealing with it".

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by The_Colonel on Monday February 05, 2024 @02:28PM (#39265813)
> If Russia's (and China's) immediate borders are packed with countries armed to their teeth, there would be wars.

I like this Putin's style of passive threats like "there would be wars". Just say the threat explicitly, Russia would invade their western neighbors.

> Buffer states happen for a reason.

Ukraine was a buffer state, yet it was invaded by Russia three times in the last 10 years. People have now justified doubts about this model.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by thriftwy on Monday February 05, 2024 @03:02PM (#39266319)
If these countries are "armed to the teeth", Russia will invade some of these countries. Both sides will point fingers at each other while some Eastern European homes burn. Eventually the prospect of horrible death while grasping the Western-provided arms will dissuade these countries from being armed to the teeth. I sincerely believe the preferred lifestyle of Eastern Europeans is sitting on a porch of their nice tiny house, not dying from a mortal wound in a ditch.

Arms do not win wars without people holding them, and even then, fighting off an agressor does not mean your country isn't ruined.

Ukraine was in the process of ditching its buffer state status by choosing a side. They bragged for a decade how they are going to do that. Needless to say it didn't go so well for them, and only them so far. Other countries in thir position turned out to be smarter as not to win the first Russian invasion target prize.

Please note that I'm not asking for a moral judgement because everybody else who may pass it has worse skeletons in their own closet than Russian Ukraine affair.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by The_Colonel on Monday February 05, 2024 @03:28PM (#39266672)
Good that we established who was, is, and will be the aggressor. I'm looking forward to the mental gymnastics about those who invade being actually the ones who defend themselves. As is the tradition in the Russian propaganda, invasion of Finland, Baltics, Poland etc. were all just defensive wars.

But I'm more optimistic about that and don't believe your empty threats. If the NATO strengthens its eastern border, Russia's military has simply no chance there. It's a suicide, it doesn't make sense to bang your head against the wall. Russia has many other weaker neighbors it can abuse instead.

> Ukraine was in the process of ditching its buffer state status by choosing a side.

Ukraine was invaded because it wanted to get closer to EU in the form of the association agreement.

Interestingly, the roughly analogous CIS was never a problem in this concept of "buffer state". Or does "buffer state" actually mean "Russia-aligned"?

And that's the crux of the issue. You can stay as a buffer state only as long as you're a Russian puppet.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by khzw8yyy on Monday February 05, 2024 @07:47PM (#39269315)
All small countries are someone's puppets. The US tried to take a puppet state away from Russia and somewhat succeeded so far.

The first move was at the end of the Cold War. The drunken President Yeltsin took the existing administrative map of the USSR and created a new state that had artificially attached Russian regions. This set up the time delay fuse. Second was the US-backed coup in 2014. And third - what we have today. The US is good at playing the long game. Only China is better.

Downvote away, it seems to make you happy. But maybe before you write this off as "Russian propaganda" go read what Solzhenitsyn had to say on the subject. Yes, that Solzhenitsyn, the dissident who wrote "Ivan Denisovich".

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by khokhol on Monday February 05, 2024 @08:05PM (#39269456)
The US-backed coup in 2014

No one in Ukraine believes in this narrative. Why do you?

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by twixfel on Monday February 05, 2024 @03:26PM (#39266639)
There is no scenario where Eastern European countries, who had been living under Russian tyranny for several centuries, only recently to secure their independence and security as part of the EU or NATO, are going to unilaterally disarm just to please Russia.

Other countries just managed to join NATO fast enough before Putin lost his mind. Ukraine's mistake was joining too slowly. Now Russia and Ukraine both suffer for basically no reason other than the fantasies of a senile 71 year old man.

>Please note that I'm not asking for a moral judgement because everybody else who may pass it has worse skeletons in their own closet than Russian Ukraine affair.

I don't know if that is true, the Ukraine War stands out as particularly evil. Russia is guilty of particularly evil crimes against humanity in this war that they chose to start.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by thriftwy on Monday February 05, 2024 @05:31PM (#39268154)
> who had been living under Russian tyranny for several centuries

Most of these countries Russia never touched, or fought off of Turks and then let them be. They never lived under Russia's anything. Were it Czechs live under several centuries of Russian tyranny? Because these ones are particularly obnoxious now, despite many years of feeding off of Russian statesmen in Karlovy Vary.

I don't think you even remotely understand what you are talking about, and people are going to die in great numbers before they start reading history books instead of NYT columns on the subject.

> stands out as particularly evil

I guess they just don't hand out history textbooks in the child care...

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by kergonath on Monday February 05, 2024 @06:59PM (#39268913)
> Most of these countries Russia never touched, or fought off of Turks and then let them be.

Does the Molotov-Ribbentrop pact ring any bell? Do you know what the Baltic states went through? Did you hear about the Prague spring or that glorious sister republic in eastern Germany? Fuck, do you know about the Holodomor?

It’s a bit rich to say these countries never knew Russian oppression. It may not have lasted very long, but it was particularly brutal. The first thing they did is get away at the first occasion and all of them are traumatised to this day. Ukraine and Belarus tried to play nice. Belarus is now subservient and annexed in all but name, and Ukraine is being torn apart. So tell me why those Eastern European countries would not do anything they can to stay out of Russia’s reach?

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by thriftwy on Monday February 05, 2024 @07:36PM (#39269249)
I'm not sure what's wrong with socialist Czech or DDR. They've got the Communism lite try before you buy inoculated package and now they squeal like a pig being butchered. Russians saw many orders of magnitude worse things than any of the stuff DDR or Soviet Czech was up to. The way Eastern Europeans are trying to show how they require special treatment is a disgrace to any Russian. They literally complain how Soviets curbed their access to white privilege they were entitled to.

XX century was a disaster, you had to grind your teeth and survive through it. Holodomor is a pathetic Ukrainian attempt to privatize a much greater Communist hunger and frame it on its victims. They do so because they believe that they should get a specific, better treatment than everybody east of them. Rings any bells?

Needless to say Russians did not invent Communism and you can find a huge number of fans for it in any HN thread. Russians sincerely believed they have a traumatic experience of struggle to share with the rest of "socialist camp" only to discover that the whole 500 million strong camp frames it on their small ethnic fraction.

Belarus is a paradise now compared to Ukraine (and to extent Russia). You can do whatever you like and there is no fear of draft. There are also jobs and industry intact. You can cross the border if you are male but is not economically obliged to do so.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by khokhol on Monday February 05, 2024 @07:46PM (#39269307)
You can do whatever you like [in Belarus]

Another patently bizarre thing to say, given any knowledge at all about day-to-day life in that country.

And there is no draft

Unfortunately this is also plainly false.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by twixfel on Monday February 05, 2024 @06:08PM (#39268485)
Czechs were only part of the Russian Empire for about 45 years, and only in the 20th century. Could have been worse.

I think you just struggle to understand how fundamentally your country is hated by Eastern Europeans. Russia is like Germany, if Germany still was proud of its Nazi heritage. You just don't get it, it's sad, you're so hated but you have no idea why, you're just so blinded by ultranationalism. Russia could have chosen to enter the 21st century but instead decided to enter the 18th. Meanwhile most of your people outside of Moscow and St Petersburg don't even have indoor toilets. It's honestly tragic what a gigantic shithole your country is, and yet you're so proud of it being such a gigantic shithole. Just tragic.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by thriftwy on Monday February 05, 2024 @06:17PM (#39268549)
I think I don't struggle to imagine how Eastern Europeans loved Russia, Soviet Union and Communism just 40 years back. 80 years back, Eastern Europeans just loved Germany and Hitler. Now they are huge fans of the USA. This time it's for real. Genuine Eastern European feeling and honest hatred for everybody who came before.

The problem with most Eastern Europeans is that they'll sing and dance on anybody's 5 cents. You can buy and sell them and they will always be eager to serve.

That is frankly revolting to Russians who are able to maintain long term loyalties, and will be heartbroken to betray long term commitments. Russians do not hate Eastern Europeans, neither do they want to invade and occupy their countries, but Russians do despise Eastern Europeans now. Every stupid thing you say gets laid on these scales.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by medstrom on Monday February 05, 2024 @07:42PM (#39269286)
Oh, loyalties? Do you know Russia is committed to defend Armenia thru the CSTO, but apparently just said meh and now Armenia is on their own?
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by khzw8yyy on Monday February 05, 2024 @11:03PM (#39270625)
Armenia is run by a US-backed stooge, so Russia expected the US to defend Armenia. But whoops, the US chose to win a favor with Turkey by backing Azerbaijan instead :)
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by thriftwy on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @02:51AM (#39271947)
Armenia has suffered a national tragedy which they then turned into circus by their accusations against Russia. They neither recognized Karabakh as their own nor did they put up a serious fight. But they can's shut up telling everybody how they expected somebody else to fight instead of them.

Still, Russians did not write Armenia off completely even after all this.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by medstrom on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @07:15AM (#39273419)
That "writing them off completely" is even on the table shows that this "ability to loyalty" is BS. It's like if you have a boyfriend that say "well, at least I won't leave you over this" every day. Don't make you feel very secure do it?
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by thriftwy on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @11:03AM (#39275878)
I won't call the bearded Pashinyan "a girlfriend", but it is the other way around:

Armenia basically tell Russia they break up with them to join another relationship. However, the other side does not look like they want Armenia. No breakup exchange of personal effects happens. In the end, Russia lingers there to see what happens and is not closing the door yet. Again, it is a bad analogy because even the closest country to country relations are not monogamous.

The reason of why the breakup is discussed: your bearded girlfriend taunted another girl (with a mustache) and got serious bruises in return. Now she thinks you should've fought with that another girl instead of her doing so. Your girlfriend was the cause of the fight but you do think the mustached one has overreacted.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by twixfel on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @03:02AM (#39272014)
Lol. Like I said, you just don't get it.
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by kergonath on Monday February 05, 2024 @06:51PM (#39268842)
> There is no good way out of the situation where both sides are armed to the teeth. The best bet is a political failure of one of the sides.

Look, we tried normalising relations. In the end, Russia just takes what it can. It’s lunacy to believe that everything would be better if European countries just rolled over, accepted being bullied, and just gave Putin what he wants. It’s insane.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by thriftwy on Monday February 05, 2024 @07:48PM (#39269329)
I just don't remember any of those attempts. Which year was that? I remember the disastrous Obama's great reset which caused these relations to deteriorate at greatly accelerated rate.

I also remember how bad they were during COVID time, etc.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by petre on Monday February 05, 2024 @05:27PM (#39268111)
We'll have another cold war, carefully watching each other like Koreans on both sides of the DMZ do. Russia likes frozen conflicts so that what they'll get, until it collapses again like the USSR did and like all empires do. The trouble with that is a bunch of unstable dictators with nukes instead of one czar with nukes.
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by BlueTemplar on Monday February 05, 2024 @09:24PM (#39270018)
Not sure how much (more) arming to the teeth of NATO is needed when France / UK / USA have thermonuclear ICBMs.

The problem is what to do with the likes of Georgia and Ukraine (which has been deeply regretting giving up nukes against Russian/US/UK "protection" for some years now).

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by whimsicalism on Monday February 05, 2024 @11:36AM (#39263116)
The comparison between Putin and Hitler is ridiculous.

Europe’s economy is in shambles, they do not have the power to push back if Russia and the US were to push for détente never mind that the country with the most EU influence (Germany) is a major dove on this issue.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by twixfel on Monday February 05, 2024 @11:53AM (#39263372)
It's not ridiculous at all. Not all leaders can be negotiated with, that is simply my point. Maybe as an American you do not understand the depth of feeling, it does not affect you because you don't live here and subsequently you don't care. You can regress into the isolationism that the US likes to embrace every now and then. But we still have to live with an imperialist Russia on our door step.

> (Germany) is a major dove on this issue.

No, they're not dovish, they're just not leaders and not willing to take initiative and require others to move first. That stems from their history. They've sent huge amounts of aid already to Ukraine (~1% of GDP versus 0.2% of GDP for the USA).

> Europe’s economy is in shambles

I mean, it's not as good as the USA's, but it's not in shambles. It's relatively OK. I live here. I'd rather live here than in Russia. Russia is a glorified petrol station with nukes and a military. Europe's economy still absolutely dwarfs Russia's. When I speak to my (many) Russian colleagues, it's clear they'd rather be here in Germany than in Russia.

> US were to push for détente

It's not realistic. The only person who is going to do that is Trump. There's no scenario where we Europeans just give up our security and let imperial war conquests become acceptable on our continent (not yours, yank) for the sake of Trump's ego. Why? Because we think he's completely retarded. Only Americans like him. And how would we benefit exactly from trading away our security? How can the US force us? All it would do is seal the USA's historic break from its European allies (And I know it's not popular at the moment in the USA, but any one with a basic understanding of geopolitics knows that the USA's strongest asset its just how many rich and powerful allies it has). Good luck standing up to China alone, in that case. Then the West is truly fucked!

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by whimsicalism on Monday February 05, 2024 @12:49PM (#39264133)
> Not all leaders can be negotiated with, that is simply my point.

Putin isn't Hitler. People are way too quick to write off negotiation when it is people's real lives at play.

> They've sent huge amounts of aid already to Ukraine (~1% of GDP versus 0.2% of GDP for the USA).

False? not sure where you are getting your numbers from but USA has sent both considerably more in magnitude and as a percentage of the GDP through the end of 2023.

Germany doesn't even spend 2% of GDP on all military expenses (they recently pledged to as it is a new NATO requirement), they are not spending half of that on Ukraine allocation.

> It's not realistic. The only person who is going to do that is Trump.

Wavering support for the Ukraine war is not just a Trump-ism phenomenon. I am not sure how the media reports this in the UK but support is collapsing across both parties in the polls.

A majority of Americans think Trump is stupid too and you are very unlikely to meet a supporter on HN.

> Good luck standing up to China alone, in that case

US policymakers already perceive no will to stand up to China among EU lawmakers.

> And how would we benefit exactly from trading away our security? How can the US force us?

EU+UK citizens will not be willing to pay the full brunt of this conflict for an extended period of time.

The fact of the matter is that most Europeans are much more ambivalent about this conflict than you are implying [0] which is obvious from the polling. Ratchet up the spending and energy price impact to considerable portions of GDP and what will happen?

[0]: https://www.europarl.europa.eu/at-your-service/files/be-hear...

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by twixfel on Monday February 05, 2024 @03:40PM (#39266849)
>Putin isn't Hitler. People are way too quick to write off negotiation when it is people's real lives at play.

No he's not Hitler, he's Putin. Putin cannot be negotiated with, that is the point.

>False? not sure where you are getting your numbers from but USA has sent both considerably more in magnitude and as a percentage of the GDP through the end of 2023.

No it is not. My numbers are from the Financial Times: https://www.ft.com/content/ca7fa865-97a1-4013-bde6-b69731b03...

Where are yours from? If you have better numbers, share them.

>Wavering support for the Ukraine war is not just a Trump-ism phenomenon. I am not sure how the media reports this in the UK but support is collapsing across both parties in the polls.

Wavering or collapsing? The majority still support aid for Ukraine. That much is a fact. I am not in the UK anyway, I live in Germany.

Your source for polling is sadly incoherent, just quoting random countries, but judging by this poll, it looks clear that Europeans support Ukraine:

https://neighbourhood-enlargement.ec.europa.eu/news/european...

But to some extent it does not matter, there is no choice, because Europe is being attacked. It's not as if we have choice but to support them. Arguably more importantly, our establishment supports Ukraine.

>US policymakers already perceive no will to stand up to China among EU lawmakers.

US policymakers firmly believe that the best way to counterbalance China is through strengthening alliances around the world.

>EU+UK citizens will not be willing to pay the full brunt of this conflict for an extended period of time.

We already are. I think a lot of you yanks like to get high on the idea of Europe being seconds from collapse, but actually things here are OK. The worst is over, that first winter after the invasion? Yeah that was tricky, but it's already past now. The way you talk it's like we're rationing supplies to make ends meet to raise money for another missile. Yes the USA is richer than Europe, but Europe is the richest place in the world after the USA, so it's OK, there's no shame in being second place. Everything's OK. Europe will ultimately do whatever it takes to see out Russia's invasion. There's no way a country with an economy the size of Spain can outlast the entirety of Europe. Russia is a paper tiger, as evidenced by how shit its military has performed ever since it invaded.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by kergonath on Monday February 05, 2024 @06:46PM (#39268794)
> The comparison between Putin and Hitler is ridiculous.

And yet, here we are with another ultranationalist dictator hell bent on getting back that vital space and dreaming of fallen empires. Hitler had Charlemagne, and Putin has Catherine and Peter the Great. Putin did not gas anybody that I know of, but the gulags remained the whole time. It’s true that he is closer to Stalin than Hitler in many respects, but I am not sure it’s much better.

> Europe’s economy is in shambles, they do not have the power to push back if Russia and the US were to push for détente never mind that the country with the most EU influence (Germany) is a major dove on this issue.

That is a terrible misreading of how the EU functions. By design it cannot be dominated by a single country and Germany is basically following others. It’s not a major dove in any way, it’s just in the middle of the pack and they started from a fundamentally pacifist political background. The fact that they are merely talking about rearming is a demonstration of the seismic shift in domestic politics there.

Détente won’t happen in the current situation, regardless of what the US push for. They simply have no power to force that outcome. What would happen is another Korea, Georgia or Moldova: a country split in two, with one half living under yet another brutal dictatorship.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by jcranmer on Monday February 05, 2024 @11:47AM (#39263276)
> All wars have something in common: they end.

Not really? Many conflicts routinely simmer on for decades, and peace treaties that officially end a war rarely resolve conflicts. Israel is fighting I believe it's 4th war against Hamas this century, for example; its broader conflict against its neighbors has been going on arguably at least a full century. The Balkans are somewhat infamous for the depth of history of its conflicts: the assassination of Franz Ferdinand was chosen to occur on the 500-somethingth anniversary of another conflict, for example.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by ufmace on Monday February 05, 2024 @11:20AM (#39262856)
It's true that all wars end eventually. But this happening seems to me a sign that relations might not normalize quite so easily after. Why else would businesses with operations in both Russia and EU be seeking to split themselves apart neatly in advance of sanctions that would make such operations extremely difficult?
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by ekabod on Monday February 05, 2024 @11:19AM (#39262832)
Hundred Years' War between the Kingdom of England and France.
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by WinstonSmith84 on Monday February 05, 2024 @10:59AM (#39262534)
Everything has something in common: it ends. Whether it's Peace, Countries, Humans, Planets or, yes ... Wars. It's just a question of timescale.
Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by cmrdporcupine on Monday February 05, 2024 @11:14AM (#39262752)
> All wars have something in common: they end.

The Korean peninsula would like a word with you.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by foofie on Monday February 05, 2024 @01:03PM (#39264389)
> All wars have something in common: they end. That thought in your head about lack of hope of normalizing relations is just the current propaganda working.

I don't think your comment is grounded on reality, and it's ironic how it parrots one of Russia's anti-ukraine propaganda tropes: the collective west should just stop backing Ukraine because the faster they cave in, the faster all relationships normalize.

Even if you believe fairy tales about forgetting Russia's perpetual threat of nuclear annihilation and Russia's "our empire will extend to Lisbon" threats, all you need to do is look at the Soviet Union's rejection of peace and a free world up to it's collapse to understand that any talk of normalization is at best thoroughly unsupported and at worst more Russian propaganda.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by phatfish on Monday February 05, 2024 @01:14PM (#39264552)
Putin will need to put a gun to his head in a bunker before anything "normal" happens. Russia is a Third Reich level regime at the moment. Hence 300k killed and wounded causes zero reaction from the Russian public.

The Soviet-Afgan war was ended due to public discontent with 100k killed and wounded

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by throw-the-towel on Monday February 05, 2024 @08:32PM (#39269665)
Russian independent media have only confirmed 43k Russian casualties, not 300k. (Yes, Russian independent media exist; they are forced to operate in exile.)

https://www.bbc.com/russian/articles/c2xj7yny4zgo

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by phatfish on Tuesday February 06, 2024 @08:40AM (#39274051)
Nice try, but that link says 41,731 deceased in the first paragraph, and 43,014 deceased under the the visualisation with the Soviet stars (bit weird). I admit this is based on a machine translation, but I expect that Google and DeepL can get the meaning of "killed" correct.

You seriously think there are only 43k killed and wounded in total?

No Russian attracting enough attention is outside the reach of the Kremlin anyway, unless you avoid tea and underwear your whole life. So i put only marginally more trust in this report than the official figures of 7000 or whatever it is from Puntin himself.

Re:Yandex (Russian Google) sells all of its Russian businesses by The_Colonel on Monday February 05, 2024 @01:32PM (#39264887)
Germany was utterly defeated, that's why there could be a reconciliation. Neither Russia nor the West will be defeated like that, Russian regime will likely survive. That means a chance of some meaningful reconciliation is slim during next couple of decades.