News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by BiteCode_dev on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:16PM (#39149419)
It's going to suck for a while, but eventually, it will be one more thing we can thank the EU for.

Universal chargers, informed tracking consent, separation of accounts...

US and EU balance each other pretty well.

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by floydnoel on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:25PM (#39149563)
Well, perhaps you'll thank the EU for it. I personally hate the cookie banners (that don’t do anything to stop ad tech) and the annoyance of needing new (expensive) cables for no real reason. I had very nice cables which worked great for years, that was fun to explain to the wife. And now the car stereo doesn't work through a wire to my phone any longer.

The last thing I want is another App Store. I enjoy the privacy and security of its payment disintermediation. An App Store from Facebook or Amazon is just going to be 'yet another spying apparatus.' No doubt employers and schools will be demanding their use soon.

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by wackget on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:29PM (#39149636)
1. Cookie banners allow for informed consent. I like to see which companies are abusing my data, and take the extra couple of clicks to stop them from doing that.

2. USB-C cables are ludicrously cheap and massively preferable to needing to hunt for the Apple-specific proprietary cable. Not sure why you had to explain the purchase of a $2 cable to your wife.

3. Freedom of choice means you are free to continue using the walled garden, should you wish, but others are also free to explore alternatives which is currently impossible.

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by St0n3d on Friday January 26, 2024 @06:39PM (#39150446)
3.) that’s not exactly true. Currently, you can choose for an open system or a walled garden in which you can’t be de facto blackmailed in to leaving the walled garden. With this so called freedom of choice you mention, I am no longer able to choose for a true walled garden. If I rely on certain apps that are moved to their own store, I am forced to go there and break the walled garden. Ergo: my choice is taken away from me. For completely arbitrary reasons.

As it was you had choices as a consumer; open, closed - whatever you want. But the thing I deliberately want to choose for is now taken away from me through one of the worst and most unfair business laws I’ve ever seen, that only does harm to the majority of consumers whose choice is taken away and whose privacy and safety is being weakened to destroyed. But “they have a choice to stay in their walled garden” (they just can’t use their phone the way they want and were always used to anymore if they do, but we don’t mention that part and we don’t care those millions of people are getting royally screwed over).

You know, true choice could’ve been achieved if the EU had made a fair law. They didn’t and now we as consumers are going to pay a very heavy price.

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by Fire-Dragon-DoL on Friday January 26, 2024 @09:15PM (#39151731)
I should point out that even with android being way more open, big apps are on the playstore
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by darklion on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:45PM (#39149841)
> USB-C cables are ludicrously cheap

Shitty USB-C cables are ludicrously cheap. Quality cables are merely not expensive, and when you have to replace them in quantity [1], it leads to a decent amount of money having to be spent to replace otherwise perfectly fine non-USB-C cables and a whole bunch of electronic waste as those now-obsolete cables make their way to the trash bin.

— [1] I easily have over a dozen and a half Lightning cables between the ones in my bedroom, my living room, my laptop bag, and my home desk. At ~$10-12 for a pair of braided Anker USB-C replacements, I’m looking at nearly a hundred dollars to replace them all.

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by BiteCode_dev on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:47PM (#39149856)
For charging, you don't need quality USB-C cables.

And don't tell me lightning is quality, I've seen my friends consume them by the dozen.

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by hellotomyrars on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:55PM (#39149948)
Certainly the Apple cables aren’t quality. Or perhaps the better word is durable. The jacketing on the cables is a joke and gets worn through by a swift breeze.

Third-party cables, for whatever connector, you get what you pay for. Is it a shame I have a good number of lightning cables that I will have no use for in the near future? Yes.

I also have countless other cables that I longer have use for. I still haven’t been able to fully remove micro-usb from my life but we’re getting close and I’m glad for it. It would be much nicer to only have one type of cable in my bag, that’s for sure.

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by jemmyw on Friday January 26, 2024 @06:21PM (#39150253)
10/2*15 = $75

And presumably you only have to replace them if you replace your phone? It's not like the change came in and you had to rush down the shops straight away for new cables.

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by darklion on Friday January 26, 2024 @10:03PM (#39152033)
I’m not sure how you got 10 from “a dozen and a half”; 18/212 = $108.

Also, to your second point, because of the EU, everybody* who currently uses Lightning will be replacing all of their cables eventually. That’s money out of pocket sooner or later. Maybe it’s easier to swallow when it’s $12 every three months instead of $100 all in one go, but the sum doesn’t change.

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by jemmyw on Saturday January 27, 2024 @01:15AM (#39153095)
I got 15 from a dozen and a half because I'm stupid and halved half a dozen. 10 was the lower bounds price. Anyway, $108 on cables. We're not breaking the bank here. You'll probably get to keep those cables for quite a few years. The waste bothers me more. I'm still stoked to have a single charging cable standard though.
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by parl_match on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:26PM (#39149587)
The cookie banners are an unfortunate side effect of some pretty good data handling policy.

> the annoyance of needing new (expensive) cables for no real reason

A USB C cable is like $5 and one with a built in dac is $20

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by ponector on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:35PM (#39149709)
Mandatory USB-C charger is awesome. With one power adapter I can charge everything! Laptop, phone, power bank, Bluetooth speaker, ever car seat for my child (yes, car seat nowadays have a battery).

I hope everything will be with USB-C, all home appliances as well.

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by jemmyw on Friday January 26, 2024 @06:25PM (#39150289)
> I hope everything will be with USB-C, all home appliances as well.

I'm not sure I want a kettle pulling 2400w over a usb cable

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by ponector on Saturday January 27, 2024 @05:02PM (#39160328)
Does your kettle have a separate charger? What connector is there?

USB kettle is not a joke you can find plenty on Amazon.

But I'm thinking about cordless appliances: shaver, toothbrush, vacuum cleaner, etc.

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by jemmyw on Saturday January 27, 2024 @10:20PM (#39162235)
My kettle is a boiler wired under the sink. But a normal 2400w kettle in countries with 240v outlets plugs into the wall. It's not really the kind of appliance you want battery operated either.

My toothbrush is already USB charged. I think for those small / battery charged applications you mentioned we'll get there pretty soon.

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by adastra22 on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:30PM (#39149654)
And one capable of safely charging your computer is $50. Yet they all look exactly the same.
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by nixpulvis on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:31PM (#39149671)
Agreed. Postfix is hard. Best to avoid the issues in the first place. USB-C remains a thorny subject because it’s probably a net win, but there’s a lot to dislike still. No I don’r want a high speed cable just to charge my damn phone.
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by BiteCode_dev on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:38PM (#39149748)
- There is no cookie banner law, only an informed tracking consent law. Companies could follow the DNT header. They don't. They chose to inflict the banner on you, the worst way to comply to the law they could find, and managed to make you blame a pro privacy text for their choice.

- Apple changed cable without the EU once and would have changed again (remember the 30 pins?). They even didn't bother providing one at a point. At least this way we all get a uniform version that is cheap and can charge non phone devices.

- "yet another spying apparatus". Apple is one of the biggest advertiser in the world, and was part of the PRISM program. Their genius is to make you believe they don't spy on you. And noone force you to use the alternative store. That's called choice. Something I know Apple users are not big on.

If only people spent 10% of the energy they use to defend billion dollar bullies on caring about freedom.

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by doublepg23 on Friday January 26, 2024 @06:46PM (#39150497)
Why does the official EU site use cookie banners then? https://european-union.europa.eu/index_en
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by gls2ro on Saturday January 27, 2024 @12:58PM (#39157989)
here is the text where it explains about each cookies: the name, the purpose and so on https://european-union.europa.eu/cookies_en
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by floydnoel on Friday January 26, 2024 @10:44PM (#39152302)
i didn't "defend bullies." i just expressed my annoyance at the second order effects of the EU's diktats, which are a bunch of annoyances to me personally. i guess i should be glad i have the "freedom" to see useless cookie banners all over the net, and the "freedom" to not use my perfectly functional cables.

in my view, you’re the one defending bullies. wielding the power of the state to control free enterprise is like pointing a gun at somebody to get your way. "do what i say, or else" is what a bully does.

> noone force you to use the alternative store

i get the strong feeling you didn't really read what i wrote

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by joshspankit on Friday January 26, 2024 @10:49PM (#39152325)
>> And now the car stereo doesn't work through a wire to my phone any longer.

> Remember 30 pin?

I’ll do you one better: The first 30pin was widely deployed to all sorts of cars, and the majority of those hardwired the end that plugged in to the car. Then Apple changed the 30pin wiring while keeping the actual connector the same. The 30pin still plugged in, but it no longer charged the device nor passed audio through to the stereo.

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by capitainenemo on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:31PM (#39149664)
Huh. Odd. Most car stereos support USB. What car only supports lightning?
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by BiteCode_dev on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:46PM (#39149850)
Or jack. Or BT.

Besides, before lightning, apple obsolated all 30-pin compatible devices.

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by floydnoel on Friday January 26, 2024 @06:32PM (#39150368)
the car has USB-A ports, but none of the half dozen USB-C cables I tried could handle the connection. I guess I'll have to continue buying more USB A-to-C cables until i find one that works, or give up the feature i had before. It's just a silly inconvenience with a smattering of e-waste.
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by capitainenemo on Friday February 09, 2024 @01:20PM (#39318304)
Clearly a couple of people disliked this line of inquiry, but FWIW, I've never had any issues connecting our honda's USB-A to USB-C on android phones. But I might not be trying advanced functions - I've just used it as a media player. The jack works well to, as well as bluetooth, so those are what I usually use. At least in android, depending on your device, you might have to change settings related to file sharing over USB.
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by jasonm23 on Friday January 26, 2024 @11:40PM (#39152638)
Hopefully you receive compensation, for the wonderful astroturfing
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by nonethewiser on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:19PM (#39149468)
> informed tracking consent

In theory I think people would thank the EU for this, but in practice people generally dislike the new cookie banner status quo.

We can quibble about whether the legislation necessarily dictates the shitty scenario we find ourselves in, but its the scenario it did lead to nonetheless.

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by wedernoch on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:28PM (#39149622)
I thought there's a fix incomming. But I can't find a link right now. Something about exactly the issue with "big green accept button", "small half hidden reject button".
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by joshspankit on Friday January 26, 2024 @10:52PM (#39152351)
Makes sense.

EU: “You need to respect PII”

The market: malicious compliance and obvious dark patterns

EU: sigh Ok, we’ll also have to tell you how you’re allowed to ask. drafts new legislation

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by ceejayoz on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:21PM (#39149501)
The cookie banner status quo is malicious compliance by the tracking industry that the EU should come down hard on. In many cases they violate the GDPR by not giving accept and reject equal billing.
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by wmf on Friday January 26, 2024 @08:10PM (#39151241)
GDPR supposedly came into effect six years ago and they haven't fixed low-hanging fruit like cookie banners. Now imagine how long it will take them to fix Apple's bullshit.
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by ChadNauseam on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:23PM (#39149525)
Is it malicious compliance? How else were they supposed to comply?
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by viraptor on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:30PM (#39149659)
1. Remove the third party tracking so they don't need to notify you, or

2. Provide a simple "can we share your data with third parties Allow/Decline" box, and

3. Apply DNT value automatically so they don't need to ask.

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by wharvle on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:28PM (#39149613)
Use a much-less-intrusive notification, and just use “necessary” cookies unless the user engages with the notification to say “yes, track me”.

Or drop the unnecessary ones.

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by joshspankit on Friday January 26, 2024 @10:54PM (#39152361)
Anyone else think “necessary cookies” should only be asked when do you something that actually requires them (such as on the login screen)?
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by wharvle on Friday January 26, 2024 @11:13PM (#39152482)
They don't need to ask at all for those.
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by palata on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:30PM (#39149653)
Many of those popups are clearly engineered to make it painful to "reject all" and easy to "accept all". This is malicious compliance, and it should be fined big time.
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by marssaxman on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:30PM (#39149651)
Doing less tracking would have been the better option.
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by marginalia_nu on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:27PM (#39149602)
You don't need to ask consent for data processing that is needed for operating a service, just stuff like user tracking.
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by BiteCode_dev on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:40PM (#39149778)
They could follow the DNT header. Non intrusive. Automatic.

They could also... not track you?

It's crazy that we have to explain that every time a thread about the cookie banner comes in.

Isn't HN supposed to be a forum full of tech saavy people?

What kind of blind spot people have to not be able to reach this conclusion themself and instead blame a protective law for what clearly is an abusive move from companies that have a long track record of abuses?

Or do they just repeat what the PR of those companies tell them?

I mean in what world have you been living in the past 30 years with companies lying, trying to escape all possible constraining laws, spying on users and generally bullying at every occasion they could? And your first conclusion is that they did the annoying banners because they are the good guys and took the best solution possible because they like you?

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by weikju on Friday January 26, 2024 @07:48PM (#39151076)
> Or do they just repeat what the PR of those companies tell them?

Most people do, and techies/HN people are people.

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by floydnoel on Friday January 26, 2024 @10:46PM (#39152312)
bureaucrats don’t understand second order effects. it's in their interest not to. indeed, a lot of people seem to struggle with the concept based on the comments here.
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by BitwiseFool on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:25PM (#39149566)
Can they make us adopt the Metric system while they're at it?
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by palata on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:31PM (#39149667)
Nah, I think it's fun to read US people trying to explain how the imperial system is "more intuitive" :-).
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by cheriot on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:39PM (#39149761)
Generally agree, but unfortunately the EU screwed up informed tracking consent. By giving control of the consent UI to the website owner, it's as painful as possible to use (incentives!). Make the requirement an API so the browser controls the UI and there's a competition to make users happy.
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by BiteCode_dev on Saturday January 27, 2024 @06:04AM (#39154540)
If you do this, tech-challenged law makers will do even worse than the companies.

It sucks, but it's less bad to let them do all the wrong things, and then say "not that", until only what's good remain.

I wish companies would not start by being assholes to save a step, but politicians is terrible.

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by deviantbit on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:29PM (#39149630)
Question, why do you tolerate it at all?

I have 4 stores installed on my Samsung phone.

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by BiteCode_dev on Saturday January 27, 2024 @06:05AM (#39154547)
Same. And 3 on my laptop.

It's fair the average consumer don't want to deal with those things. It's not that we can't.

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by poisonborz on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:28PM (#39149614)
Each of those achievements were half-heartedly done, companies got around them, and the EU never followed up on the issues.
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by Powdering7082 on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:21PM (#39149494)
Yeah not sure that informed tracking consent was actually good.

I do love GDPR's ability to download your data, but I am unsure of how much actual good that's done.

Universal chargers is great!

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by declan_roberts on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:18PM (#39149451)
Ah yes clicking “I accept” on every single website. We’re all reaping the rewards right now.
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by robinsonb5 on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:30PM (#39149658)
There's just one unintended benefit: when I'm looking for in-depth information on a subject, I've found that the presence of a cookie popup seems to correlate with a site containing only superficial information; it's an indicator that the site's primary purpose is harvesting eyeballs rather than imparting knowledge, so I should keep looking.
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by skeletal88 on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:26PM (#39149571)
"I reject everything non essential"

Has to be as easily clickable as the "accept all" button, otherwise sites are not compliant

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by kansface on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:32PM (#39149677)
We judge law by effect, not intent, because only it is real.
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by orwin on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:44PM (#39149826)
By effect, i can quick judge a website by its cookie banner. When i'm looking for quality content (most of the time), i know immediately if i've been clickbaited by my google search.
Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by BiteCode_dev on Saturday January 27, 2024 @04:12AM (#39153955)
We also judge humans depending on how they follow the law.

Turns out you chose not prioritize judging the humans that run those billion dollars companies.

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by BiteCode_dev on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:42PM (#39149804)
Yes we are: we know now which companies that are assholes instead of it being a secret.

We know:

- the ones that track you

- the ones that track you and use a cookie banner but no allow DNT, annoying you for no good reason

- the ones that track you and use a dark pattern

That's a good way to avoid their product.

Let the bastards self identify loud and clear.

Have you noticed that HN doesn't have a cookie banner?

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by palata on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:32PM (#39149682)
There are browser extensions like "I don't care about cookies" who click "reject all" before you even see the popup, on every single website.

Works really well for me.

Re:Mozilla says Apple's new browser rules are 'as painful as... by Minor49er on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:28PM (#39149618)
I just adblock those like i do for every other popup