News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by rany_ on Thursday January 25, 2024 @01:21PM (#39132712)
> Notarization for iOS apps — a baseline review that applies to all apps, regardless of their distribution channel, focused on platform integrity and protecting users. Notarization involves a combination of automated checks and human review.

Does anyone know if notarization is something you could turn off? If you can't, then I'm pretty sure the EU won't like this; obviously "malicious compliance."

Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by samcat116 on Thursday January 25, 2024 @01:52PM (#39133287)
Notarization has been enforced for all apps on the Mac for years. Would the DMA have an issue with requiring signed drivers? Seems a similar baseline. Personally I’m totally ok with that. I haven’t seen a single instance of them not notarizing something or revoking it for something that wasn’t actually malicious.
Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by LudwigNagasena on Thursday January 25, 2024 @02:12PM (#39133667)
That would be crazy if it were true. The only thing that is enforced on Mac is a scary pop up window.
Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by rany_ on Thursday January 25, 2024 @02:06PM (#39133561)
You could actually disable the notarization enforcement entirely on the Mac or selectively depending on the file. So I don't think it's that bad.
Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by yreg on Thursday January 25, 2024 @04:15PM (#39135400)
>I haven’t seen a single instance of them not notarizing something or revoking it for something that wasn’t actually malicious.

Do you think they would notarize a PornHub app?

Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by Wowfunhappy on Thursday January 25, 2024 @05:25PM (#39136253)
...if it works like on Mac, then I would, yes. It's an automated process and I'm not aware of any content requirements.
Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by johnnyanmac on Thursday January 25, 2024 @07:54PM (#39137623)
>Through a combination of automated checks and human review, Notarization will help ensure apps are free of known malware, viruses, or other security threats, function as promised, and don’t expose users to egregious fraud.

I wouldn't be 100% confident there. I wouldn't be surprised if porn got through, but plenty of other companies have blocked such content under "security threats".

Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by FateOfNations on Thursday January 25, 2024 @07:14PM (#39137292)
Apple doesn't care about porn on iOS devices, they just don't want it in the App Store. Unless a PornHub app is full of malware, it shouldn't have any problem getting notarized.

App Store Review = Content and Quality

Notarization = Safety and Security

Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by Ukv on Thursday January 25, 2024 @03:17PM (#39134621)
> I haven’t seen a single instance of them not notarizing something or revoking it for something that wasn’t actually malicious.

Apple did threaten to cut off Epic's ability to notarize Unreal Engine[0], until ordered not to by the court[1].

[0]: https://www.macrumors.com/2020/08/17/apple-terminate-epic-de...

[1]: https://www.theverge.com/2020/10/9/21492334/epic-fortnite-ap...

Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by threeseed on Thursday January 25, 2024 @05:02PM (#39136005)
That's because Epic maliciously violated the terms of service.

In fact they did so deliberately to help them in their court cases.

Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by Ukv on Thursday January 25, 2024 @06:10PM (#39136743)
Gatekeeper/notarization are intended to stop malware, which Unreal Engine is not. Apple may well have a valid business dispute (over another application on another platform), but it's an abuse of the system and control they have to obstruct a Mac owner from running non-malware software on their own computer.

Luckily the court stopped them retaliating in this case, but it gives me reason to be concerned about expansion of the "it's Apple's device and will always act in Apple's interests over the owner's" mentality from iOS towards Mac desktops.

Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by paulryanrogers on Thursday January 25, 2024 @06:36PM (#39136979)
Maliciously is a stretch. If a rule is unjust then violating is just IMO.
Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by martimarkov on Thursday January 25, 2024 @07:00PM (#39137174)
Not when you have signed a contract… come on this is law not Robin Hood…
Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by paulryanrogers on Thursday January 25, 2024 @07:30PM (#39137420)
Plenty of contracts include dubious and outright illegal things, depending on the jurisdiction. I'd say Apple is violating the public trust as they increasingly corner the market in apps and phones.
Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by kj99 on Thursday January 25, 2024 @07:14PM (#39137299)
It’s not a stretch at all. The court explicitly found against Epic on this point.
Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by Dylan16807 on Thursday January 25, 2024 @10:18PM (#39138523)
They had to violate it to be able to sue. That's not malicious.
Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by kj99 on Friday January 26, 2024 @10:45AM (#39143949)
That’s simply a false statement, and it’s hard for me to believe you don’t know that, since it’s easily checked.
Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by paulryanrogers on Friday January 26, 2024 @10:48AM (#39143997)
How would they have standing to bring a suit if they had not tried to challenge the Appstore rule?
Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by kj99 on Friday January 26, 2024 @11:29AM (#39144491)
Anyone can sue over unlawful contract terms without needing to breach the contract.

The one finding in Epic’s favor was that Apple violated California’s Unfair Competition law by preventing Epic from linking to an outside payment method.

Epic could have sued over that at any time.

Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by tsimionescu on Thursday January 25, 2024 @05:18PM (#39136172)
You can install any app you want on the Mac, notarized or not. You might get some kind of warning, but that's irrelevant.

And Apple only allows certain kinds of apps through their notarization process. They can't have pornogrpahy, they can't allow things that could break copyright etc.

Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by Wowfunhappy on Thursday January 25, 2024 @05:23PM (#39136220)
No, notarization can be turned off on the Mac in ~15 seconds. Open a Terminal and type `sudo spctl --master-disable`. Enter your password and press enter.

You can also right click an individual unnotarization .app bundle and select `open`, then affirm your intention in the scary warning prompt.

P.S. The Mac also lets you disable SIP, install unsigned kernel extensions, and rewrite kernel memory to your heart's content. This is admittedly a bit more involved.

Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by chatmasta on Thursday January 25, 2024 @06:09PM (#39136740)
Does Apple charge Mac developers a price per notarization? Because it sounds like that's effectively what they're doing here with iOS developers, since they require notarization and also require a fee per install for distributing outside the app store.

It's a protection racket - pay us and we won't flag your app as malware.

Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by martimarkov on Thursday January 25, 2024 @07:01PM (#39137189)
Not really. It’s a condition. You can also choose the old rules.. you can also chose to not develop for iOS. There is no gun to your head if you don’t develop for iOS
Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by chatmasta on Thursday January 25, 2024 @08:20PM (#39137808)
But the "old rules" were explicitly deemed illegal. Is there a limit to your logic? What if Apple had set the per-installation fee to $50 instead of $0.50? Developers have a choice! If they don't want to pay $50 per installation, they can choose the old rules. There is no gun to their head.

Where is the line? Surely at some point, the choice is so unreasonable that Apple has effectively forced developers into "the old rules," thus circumventing compliance with the new rules, which may as well not exist if no developers can afford to play within them...

Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by martimarkov on Friday January 26, 2024 @11:28AM (#39144476)
Develop for other OS-es. Don't develop for a platform you dislike and have so many issues with.

I never write code for Windows and actively tell any client I have to not use it if they want my product. If they don't want it so much - there are plenty of alternative. If they really want it - they will use the OS I write the app for.

Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by octacat on Friday January 26, 2024 @10:02AM (#39143385)
It is in plans though. I think EU should make alternative notarisation entities though, antivirus companies could do it. If we care about "privacy and security" here.
Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by heavyset_go on Saturday January 27, 2024 @03:46PM (#39159668)
There's a $100 yearly fee if you want to Notarize apps.
Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by gumby on Thursday January 25, 2024 @01:40PM (#39133036)
Apple and the EU have been discussing the implementation for some time so it seems extremely likely this has all been OKed already. In particular, I’m sure the issue of apps (FB app with a virus or spyware) on a random App Store is a concern to the EU.

Not defending Apple per se (they sure don’t need help) but going with the public statements of both Apple and the EU leading up to this.

Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by layer8 on Thursday January 25, 2024 @02:39PM (#39134102)
From yesterday’s WSJ article [0]:

“Officials from the European Commission, the EU’s executive body, have been holding meetings in recent months with Apple and other tech companies to discuss the new rules. Apple hasn’t provided a final package describing its solution to the commission or tested its plans with market participants.

Once it does, the commission will review the full package to look at whether it will make the market more open and contestable, and whether the company’s plans meet all the individual provisions of the law, according to a person familiar with its plans.”

We’ll see how that goes.

[0] https://archive.is/Hk39s

Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by Maxion on Friday January 26, 2024 @04:00AM (#39140311)
Feels like negotations broke down, and Apple published this publically to put pressure on.
Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by rany_ on Thursday January 25, 2024 @01:44PM (#39133105)
If they actually okayed it, then I hope the EU reconsiders. In effect, Apple's tight grip on what apps you could run remains. I am also disappointed that those changes are EU-only, I hope most governments impose similar laws so that Apple just gives up and makes it global.
Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by pertymcpert on Thursday January 25, 2024 @02:07PM (#39133571)
This is different from the usual App Store review. It's to prevent malware.
Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by zamadatix on Thursday January 25, 2024 @02:38PM (#39134081)
My concern mostly lies with "what will qualify as malware". When we think of malware we think of things the user would consider malware, i.e. the traditional use case of notarization. Is Apple thinking the same or is malware just apps that do things they don't like and haven't been otherwise forced to approve (e.g. like JIT is now allowed for browser engines)? Overall though I'm optimistic on it, just also cautious.
Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by rany_ on Thursday January 25, 2024 @02:26PM (#39133911)
IMHO it seems like it's there only to enforce that "Core Technology Fee" and even then I don't buy that argument. Malware already slips through Apple's "strict" App Store review process.
Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by lwkl on Thursday January 25, 2024 @11:39PM (#39139012)
Malware also slips through sandboxes and other security measures. That doesn‘t mean they are useless. App review and notarization helps a lot with security. But there will always be errors.
Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by chatmasta on Thursday January 25, 2024 @06:15PM (#39136790)
Sure, but if Apple assumes that any non-notarized app is malware, then they're not just preventing malware - they're requiring non-malware to notarize every install. And since this is coupled with a new policy where non-app store installs cost money, this means it will be enforced through the notarization mechanism.

It's not the notarization itself that's an issue, but the fact that it's also the enforcement mechanism for collecting fees per-install. It's basically a mafia protection racket where you need to pay Apple to say you're not malware.

Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by dns_snek on Thursday January 25, 2024 @07:19PM (#39137336)
That's what they claim but I've yet to see any evidence to support this.
Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by octacat on Friday January 26, 2024 @10:06AM (#39143436)
I think in this case some antivirus companies from EU could do notarisation. Of course, companies that have a good track record and would actually do the proper job. No need to depend on Apple to do it. We do not have a single SSL CA, for example.
Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by flumpcakes on Thursday January 25, 2024 @02:03PM (#39133500)
I think perhaps notarization is OK, for example you have to pass requirements to publish on other closed platforms like games consoles. What I think is very underhanded is charging per install for 'core services' rather than per app review. It's not like the app has to be notarized/reviewed for every install.
Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by yreg on Thursday January 25, 2024 @04:16PM (#39135422)
>I think perhaps notarization is OK, for example you have to pass requirements to publish on other closed platforms like games consoles.

In that sense, the old system is OK as well, no?

Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by kmlx on Friday January 26, 2024 @04:29AM (#39140527)
Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by rany_ on Thursday January 25, 2024 @02:04PM (#39133522)
I assume the notarization is there to enforce this, which is why I think it is way worse than the fee itself.
Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by samcat116 on Thursday January 25, 2024 @02:25PM (#39133889)
Notarization is a completely automated system to scan for malware. It has existed for many years
Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by Vespasian on Thursday January 25, 2024 @03:39PM (#39134938)
How else are they gonna obligate developers to pay the core fee then.

Once tooling catches up, in theory, developers don't have a contractual relationship with apple anymore, except to get notarized.

The devices belong to the users apple sold the hardware and licensed the software to them not app developers. They could charge the users but obviously this would be a terrible idea.

Getting notarized will either directly require payment of the platform fee or will force the use of the official tools which will mandate that.

Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by kaba0 on Thursday January 25, 2024 @04:36PM (#39135682)
Nonprofits, governments etc don’t have to pay a fee, so in effect it means we will have the AppStore, and a few free, open-source alternatives.

That is absolutely a win to the common people. And it’s not like other companies taken a hit - they can either stay on the AppStore and have their finances go through their “taxing”, or create an alternative store and find a proper monetizing strategy. They can calculate what makes sense, but it makes it hard for Facebook/google to exercise their network effect for creating a new app store at the expense of users.

Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by trumpeta on Thursday January 25, 2024 @05:49PM (#39136518)
no it says it includes “human review”
Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by FateOfNations on Thursday January 25, 2024 @07:11PM (#39137266)
The announcement indicates that notarization for iOS platforms will include human review. They are basically dividing the App Store review process in half, with the platform safety side (for all apps) and the content/quality side (only for App Store).
Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by yreg on Thursday January 25, 2024 @09:22PM (#39138230)
If they honestly do exactly that, then it's not bad at all. But a lot of rules could be hidden under safety reasons.
Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by squeaky-clean on Thursday January 25, 2024 @06:58PM (#39137164)
> for example you have to pass requirements to publish on other closed platforms like games consoles

But those would be the requirements of those platforms.

I can make and publish games for the Pico-8 console without any requirements. Could you imagine if Microsoft had the ability to veto any Pico-8 game I wanted to make?

Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by dns_snek on Thursday January 25, 2024 @07:00PM (#39137179)
The entire point of this legislation is to open up the Apple's mobile platforms to competition. It's not (supposed to be) a closed platform. With notarization requirements, third party app stores are just an extension of Apple's app store with a different logo!
Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by musictubes on Thursday January 25, 2024 @07:12PM (#39137272)
If that was the entire point then the law should have been written to do that. Apple thinks they are complying with the law.

I think this is another classic case of people getting mad over what they think the law should be vs. what the law actually is.

Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by dns_snek on Thursday January 25, 2024 @07:51PM (#39137598)
Apple has a history of bad faith & malicious non-compliance, what they "think" is pretty much irrelevant at this point. We know what the spirit of the regulation is, and I trust that the EU regulators are interested in effecting those changes, otherwise what's the point of this entire ordeal if Apple only has to pay lip service to anti-trust intervention?
Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by musictubes on Friday January 26, 2024 @09:40AM (#39143102)
I am getting the same vibes from this as I did when Google was found guilty of abusing monopoly power. People lost their minds because “Apple is so much worse!” Never mind that the two lawsuits filed by Epic against Google and Apple were over different things and had different results because of it.

The DMA targeted different companies in different ways all under the rubric of combatting “gatekeeping.” They then went on to say how different companies were guilty of that crime in different ways. It would not surprise me at all if Apple has complied with what the EU singled Apple out for. It also wouldn’t surprise me if casual observers have conflated all the different flavors of gatekeeping that the DMA has directed at all companies.

Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by lozenge on Friday January 26, 2024 @02:18AM (#39139725)
Apple has probably calculated the risk of a legal challenge as 99%, the risk of losing it is 80%, but they expect a small/affordable penalty and at least a couple of years where they can hold onto their rent seeking in the iPhone space.
Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by bandergirl on Thursday January 25, 2024 @07:10PM (#39137263)
I don’t agree. Anyone can notarize non-malicious apps at any time on the Mac already. Please look at what you can do with Mac apps before judging.

I think the issue here is just the additional payment, not the notarization. That part is hopefully rejected as a non-solution to the issue.

Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by dns_snek on Thursday January 25, 2024 @07:48PM (#39137577)
I'm well aware of how the notarization process works on macOS. I considered supporting it for an open source project I was working on, but I abandoned the macOS version after I realized that I would have to pay Apple's annual $100 fee.

Notarization could theoretically be used for "good", even though I strongly dispute its effectiveness. It only ensures that someone's card is on file to potentially aid in investigation after the damage has been done. In the case of malware, that card is likely to be stolen anyway.

The more likely option is that Apple will start abusing notarization as a way to take down apps it finds objectionable in some way, even though they do exactly what they say on the tin.

Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by johnnyanmac on Thursday January 25, 2024 @07:46PM (#39137557)
I guess as usual this will come down to porn. if those apps get rejected despite being non-malicious that shows how this "notarization" process truly is.

To be honest, it's not even like I care that much about the additional payment. Scummy but expected. It's more that the current prices, similar to Unity, seem to pretty much punish any innovative idea that takes off, to a point where Apple will not just make the product unproftiable but bankrupt the developer in the process. Most mobile apps are free so people underestimate how quickly you can hit 1M. At least make it something like $0.05 at a million and ramp it up at 5m or 10m to these larger prices. by 10m downloads you are much more likely a larger business or have figured out a way to properly scale your app.

oh and don't count updates, discouraging devs from maintaining their apps. Devs don't profit from an existing user updating, why should Apple?

Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by chatmasta on Thursday January 25, 2024 @06:08PM (#39136721)
I don't see how this isn't effectively an app store in itself. If Apple can forbid an app from running on user devices, then they need to approve every app that is installed. More importantly, they are effectively blackmailing developers to pay them "per install," which is only enforceable through the notarization process.

That sounds an awful lot like an app store.

I agree, the EU will not like this. Too bad it'll take another 3-5 years to fix.

Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by bandergirl on Thursday January 25, 2024 @07:08PM (#39137242)
> Too bad it'll take another 3-5 years to fix.

Sounds like we’re getting a fat paycheck from Apple via the EU in the meanwhile then.

Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by johnnyanmac on Thursday January 25, 2024 @07:39PM (#39137510)
I didn't know "we" were lawyers here.

I don't have any IOS devices, but I'm expecting maybe $50 (and I'm being generous) to come as a result of a similar lawsuit on Google over over-charging for IAPs.

Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by bandergirl on Friday January 26, 2024 @02:17PM (#39146807)
We Europeans in form of fines. I’m not talking about class actions. Completely different market.
Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by sircastor on Thursday January 25, 2024 @06:18PM (#39136820)
While I don't disagree that the EU won't like it, I don't see this as malicious compliance. The only reason this hasn't been in iOS up until now was distribution was already restricted through the app store. There was already signing going on. This just moves the signing to being an explicit step because distributors won't be signing for the App Store.
Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by derefr on Thursday January 25, 2024 @07:10PM (#39137254)
The problem with disabling notarization, is that it's something any trojan-horse malware author would have a glossy slideshow walking you through doing as part of the install process for their "meet sexy singles in your area and double your money instantly!" app.

And then you'd run the app, and it wouldn't blow up your phone, but just be a bit disappointing and something you'd delete — but meanwhile, the app would have used some 0day exploit to get a foothold outside the app sandbox, and so now your phone would be a silent node in a botnet, able to be C&Ced to DDoS targets or act as a VPN for nefarious account registrations or so forth.

(Did you know that there are many such botnets made of Android devices? But none so far for iOS devices. There's a reason for that!)

---

If it's not clear, by the way, Apple's "notarization" is, under the covers, just plain-old code signing. Just like every modern consumer OS has for apps, regardless of whether you get them from an app store or from the web. So that the platform can protect users from obvious viruses by just revoking the code cert.

Mind you, notarization is code-signing that requires you to submit your binary to Apple... but it's my understanding that this notarization still operates in two phases — a quick, synchronous phase, and a slower, asynchronous phase — and that the synchronous checks in the notarization process, before you get your cert signed, are only checks against the known signatures of various exploit techniques. (Again, just like every other consumer OS comes up with some way to get done — whether that be through required submission at signing time, or by submission of novel software by virus scanners that find the software on your disk, or even by web browsers as they download the software. Just try to develop Windows software, on Windows, without implicitly submitting binary "samples" to Microsoft through some route or another. It's very hard!)

Apple is somewhat unique among platforms, in having certain other virus-signature like patterns that their notarization backend takes note of, that won't trigger synchronous rejection, but rather will trigger Apple employees to do an async review of the application. (AFAIK, when this happens, you still get your app's cert signed right away; the cert might just get blacklisted some time later, if it turns out under closer human scrutiny that you were in fact doing something malicious.)

It is my understanding that the things Apple flags for human investigation, consist of use of certain system framework calls, that only very powerful and low-level system software should be doing — think, the sorts of calls unique to Virtual Machine hypervisor software, or to third-party file-system driver software. Rootkit code-smells, in other words.

Note that none of this is about what your app does for the user. Apple's notarization system — as Gatekeeper on macOS, or as part of Enterprise MDM iOS app deployment — has never suppressed or censored any app due to its nature. It's only about what it's doing that it's not supposed to be doing "according to what's on the tin." Apple is doing the same thing through notarization that the FDA does to foods and drugs: holding companies to their claims of their products being fit-for-purpose and non-adulterated.

(And although this is currently entirely a thing Apple is simply trusted to do in good faith, there's nothing stopping the EU from mandating that Apple's notarization going forward, consist of exactly these kind of technical checks and no more. I think that'd be a great idea, personally.)

Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by turquoisevar on Friday January 26, 2024 @02:20AM (#39139733)
This falls squarely under the exemptions for security reasons under article 6 sub 4 of the DMA.

> The gatekeeper shall not be prevented from taking, to the extent that they are strictly necessary and proportionate, measures to ensure that third-party software applications or software application stores do not endanger the integrity of the hardware or operating system provided by the gatekeeper, provided that such measures are duly justified by the gatekeeper. Furthermore, the gatekeeper shall not be prevented from applying, to the extent that they are strictly necessary and proportionate, measures and settings other than default settings, enabling end users to effectively protect security in relation to third-party software applications or software application stores, provided that such measures and settings other than default settings are duly justified by the gatekeeper.

Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by julkali on Friday January 26, 2024 @04:18AM (#39140441)
The key here is "proportionate". Notarization surely adds to the security of the platform, but it may be misused by Apple easily ...
Re:Apple announces changes to iOS, Safari, and the App Store... by diffeomorphism on Friday January 26, 2024 @04:44AM (#39140613)
The "duly justified" might not be that far reaching. Sure, notarization seems like a valid cause, but there is no reason why it should be exclusively the provider of one specific app store who offers notarization. In particular, if it happens that it is more onerous or restrictive on non-Apple stores, that justification starts looking very shaky.