News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: Hacker News now supports IPv6 by greyface- on Monday January 22, 2024 @11:02PM (#39099497)
That sure sounds like a lot. But "billions" is less than a /64. Try "sextillions" (/56) or "septillions" (/48). Of course, when the denominator is "undecillions", it becomes clear that this is actually a non-issue.
Re:Tell HN: Hacker News now supports IPv6 by joering2 on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @01:20AM (#39100187)
I'd even go out of my way and say that undecillion of IP addresses ought to be enough for anybody.
Re:Tell HN: Hacker News now supports IPv6 by dns_snek on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @03:11AM (#39100737)
Bold prediction! Let's see if it holds true in 200 years when every cybernetic cell in your body is individually addressable from the public internet.
Re:Tell HN: Hacker News now supports IPv6 by ale42 on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @03:51AM (#39101016)
This is almost IPv9 (RFC1606)! https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc1606

   The up to 42 deep hierarchy of routing levels built into IPv9 must
   have been one of the key features for its wide deployment. [...]
   As yet, no requirement has been found for levels 40-42, with level 39
   still being used for experimental interrogation of atomic structure
   of components where required.
Of course, it's a 1st April RFC. For those who don't know them, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/April_Fools'_Day_Request_for_C...: they include thinks like terminals with subliminal messages, IP over pigeons...
Re:Tell HN: Hacker News now supports IPv6 by Nition on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @04:04AM (#39101109)
98% of all IPv6 addresses will be set aside for self-replicating nanobots and our bodily cells will have to fight over only the remaining 2%.
Re:Tell HN: Hacker News now supports IPv6 by mike_d on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @03:16AM (#39100757)
ARIN recently handed out a /16 allocation to Capital One. That is one 65,025th of all of IPv6.

A reasonable sized /32 allocation would have allowed for giving every ATM they operate worldwide its own globally routable /48.

Re:Tell HN: Hacker News now supports IPv6 by greyface- on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @03:56AM (#39101050)
Too bad ARIN tickets aren't public - I would love to read the one in which that was justified. Reading NRPM 6.5.2.1, it seems that they must have submitted documentation claiming at least 2^28 distinct serving sites in order to qualify for an assignment that large.
Re:Tell HN: Hacker News now supports IPv6 by ta1243 on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @03:58AM (#39101059)
I find the insistence of using /64s everywhere for networks frustrating. Any network larger than a /112 seems crazy, that's already 65k IPs per subnet. A /104 for every normal end user (256 subnets per user), or a /80 for massive companies like Capital One (4 billion subnets) should be more than enough.
Re:Tell HN: Hacker News now supports IPv6 by tuetuopay on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @04:17AM (#39101196)
There is a really practical reason behind this, and it is called "routers". Due to longest prefix match, you'll end up wasting resources on the networking hardware. And you waste both precious and expensive TCAM and LPM latency for matching the prefixes. So routers do optimize for anything shorter than /64, and have special lookup memory for /64 and /128. But nothing in-between.
Re:Tell HN: Hacker News now supports IPv6 by ta1243 on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @05:56AM (#39101812)
That's fair enough, in which case ipv6 is really only a /76 (having more than 1000 hosts on a subnet isn't a great thing, even with no broadcast and arp and other traffic, and /76 allows 4000 on a /64)

Those fanboys going "we'll never run out of 2^128 IPs" are being disingenuous when about 2^59 of them have been burnt straight away (I'd guess most subnets have less than 30 devices)

2^64 subnets is a reasonable number, but when they are handed out like candy that number dwindles quickly. ARIN is allocating the equivalent of a /15 every year. That's fine if it's a constant allocation, there's 100,000 years worth, but if that rate grows, the space will be eaten in a matter of a few decades.

Re:Tell HN: Hacker News now supports IPv6 by Dagger2 on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @02:22PM (#39121533)
It's not being burnt, there are two useful things we're doing with the 64-bit network size:

* Sparse networks. 64 bits is too big to feasibly do a brute force scan on, which reduces how often servers get exploited by random network attacks. * SEND secures NDP by using those 64 bits for a public key

Reducing network sizes to 12 bits would destroy both advantages.

Re:Tell HN: Hacker News now supports IPv6 by fossdd on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @08:52AM (#39103254)
This still not justifies a /16 allocation
Re:Tell HN: Hacker News now supports IPv6 by tuetuopay on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @08:59AM (#39103339)
thankfully I replied to a comment speaking about a tangent (/64s) and not to its parent. /s

Snark aside, very much agreed, and I don't like that they got away with it. It's precisely with the mindset of "we'll have enough" that companies like ford have a /8 or the DoD has more /8s that we can count. And with this mindset we'll run out of IPv6 the same we ran out of IPv4.

Re:Tell HN: Hacker News now supports IPv6 by JustFinishedBSG on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @05:13AM (#39101535)
Except you need at least a /64 for v6 to properly work.
Re:Tell HN: Hacker News now supports IPv6 by RedShift1 on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @06:38AM (#39102100)
You only need it for SLAAC, and only because SLAAC was made that way.
Re:Tell HN: Hacker News now supports IPv6 by ta1243 on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @05:34AM (#39101679)
You only need it because that's how the protocol was designed.
Re:Tell HN: Hacker News now supports IPv6 by dajonker on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @06:34AM (#39102073)
It's not just about the number of devices. Stateless Address Autoconfiguration for example basically needs a /64 subnet.
Re:Tell HN: Hacker News now supports IPv6 by ta1243 on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @07:04AM (#39102300)
because it was designed that way. "we need it because we need it".
Re:Tell HN: Hacker News now supports IPv6 by patmorgan23 on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @07:03PM (#39111765)
Having a ludicrously large address space is kinda the point of IPv6.

You're not ment to utilize every address assigned to you. Trying to do so will always lead you to situations where you messed up and need to renumerate.

Re:Tell HN: Hacker News now supports IPv6 by jasode on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @05:19AM (#39101577)
>ARIN recently handed out a /16 allocation to Capital One. That is one 65,025th of all of IPv6. A reasonable sized /32 allocation [...]

The more one digs, the more egregious it seems. If the NETIFY webpage is accurate, it shows that Capital One already had "/32" and "/36" blocks, and yet they also got "/16" : https://www.netify.ai/resources/networks/capital-one

And if I'm reading the ARIN fees correctly, it only costs $4000 annually for a "/16" allocation: https://www.arin.net/resources/fees/fee_schedule/

There doesn't seem to be any public transparency of the approval process to explain how a non-ISP company could justify a "/16" block so it just leaves everybody guessing.

John Sweeting from ARIN only confirmed that the "/16" was allocated to Capital One according to policy but he didn't elaborate on the rationale: https://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]/msg0...

Example reddit discussion : https://old.reddit.com/r/ipv6/comments/17yuqvp/til_capital_o...

Re:Tell HN: Hacker News now supports IPv6 by neojima on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @09:25AM (#39117667)
> And if I'm reading the ARIN fees correctly, it only costs $4000 annually for a "/16" allocation:

For better or worse, you're not; that's for IPv4 /16. For IPv6 /16, it'd be the X-Large service category, so $16,000/year.

Re:Tell HN: Hacker News now supports IPv6 by Dagger2 on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @08:20PM (#39125002)
And for $256,000/year you can... exhaust the entirety of 2000::/3?

Yeah, that's not okay. Either the price needs to go up a lot or they need to include factors other than money in the allocation criteria.

Re:Tell HN: Hacker News now supports IPv6 by greyface- on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @08:40PM (#39125181)
> they need to include factors other than money in the allocation criteria

They already do, and simply being able to pay the fee does nothing to qualify you for an allocation: https://www.arin.net/participate/policy/nrpm/#6-ipv6

At least, in theory. I'm not going to attempt to defend the Capital One allocation.

Re:Tell HN: Hacker News now supports IPv6 by Dagger2 on Thursday January 25, 2024 @10:21AM (#39130448)
They might have included them in the published policy, but it seems they aren't in whatever policy they're actually following.
Re:Tell HN: Hacker News now supports IPv6 by greyface- on Thursday January 25, 2024 @07:55PM (#39137629)
It seems more likely to me that ARIN is following the text of published policy, but Capital One found a way to interpret it that violates its spirit. My guess is that they're treating each customer debit/credit card as a serving site that qualifies for a /48. To address this, ARIN should fix the policy, not raise fees.
Re:Tell HN: Hacker News now supports IPv6 by Dagger2 on Sunday January 28, 2024 @10:15AM (#39166520)
It's ARIN's job to call BS on BS justifications, otherwise they're not following the policy, they're following whatever they allow. "The purpose of a system is what the system does" and all.

That's an interesting idea for how they justified it. There might be something like 4 billion active credit/debit cards in the US (but they probably weren't all issued by Capital One).

Re:Tell HN: Hacker News now supports IPv6 by iLoveOncall on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @04:14AM (#39101171)
I'm sure people said exactly this about IPv4 back in the days.
Re:Tell HN: Hacker News now supports IPv6 by dns_snek on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @07:03AM (#39102296)
Can you even begin to imagine a use case that could come close to exhausting an IP space that is perfectly capable of assigning a /60 subnet to every single grain of sand on earth?

That subnet is large enough to then assign an IP address to every individual atom in that grain of sand.

For comparison, if we wanted to assign every living person on Earth a grain of sand, we would only need a few cubic feet of it (less than 1 cubic meter).

Re:Tell HN: Hacker News now supports IPv6 by diggan on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @08:38AM (#39103137)
> Can you even begin to imagine a use case that could come close to exhausting an IP space that is perfectly capable of assigning a /60 subnet to every single grain of sand on earth?

As parent said, I'm sure people made the exact same argument about IPv4 back in the day, but comparing it to something else.

And when IPv16 finally appears in the future, people will yet again make exactly the same argument.

Re:Tell HN: Hacker News now supports IPv6 by dns_snek on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @11:19AM (#39105383)
> As parent said, I'm sure people made the exact same argument about IPv4 back in the day, but comparing it to something else.

You're ignoring the sheer scale of this question. We don't have enough raw materials on this planet, or likely in the observable universe, to produce enough devices that would consume that many IPs.

We could colonize 1 billion planets.

Each of those planets could have 100 billion people.

Each of those 100 billion people could own 1 billion "things" that could be considered "networked devices".

Each of those "things" could consume 1 billion IPs.

We could have all that, and we would still have 70% of the IPv6 space left.

> The decision to put a 32-bit address space on there was the result of a year’s battle among a bunch of engineers who couldn’t make up their minds about 32, 128 or variable length. And after a year of fighting I said — I’m now at ARPA, I’m running the program, I’m paying for this stuff and using American tax dollars — and I wanted some progress because we didn’t know if this is going to work. So I said 32 bits, it is enough for an experiment, it is 4.3 billion terminations — even the defense department doesn’t need 4.3 billion of anything and it couldn’t afford to buy 4.3 billion edge devices to do a test anyway. So at the time I thought we were doing a experiment to prove the technology and that if it worked we’d have an opportunity to do a production version of it. Well — [laughter] — it just escaped! — it got out and people started to use it and then it became a commercial thing.

- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mZo69JQoLb8&t=816s

They were contemplating 128 bits addresses all the way back then, but settled on 32 bits as a mere proof of concept that got out of hand.

Re:Tell HN: Hacker News now supports IPv6 by corobo on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @08:35AM (#39103100)
Nanites might give you a good start

Of course we'd all be paperclips long before they need to worry about networking

Re:Tell HN: Hacker News now supports IPv6 by nerdponx on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @09:22AM (#39103605)
One use case is private entities squatting on massive ranges that they have no hope of ever practically using, and thereby extorting other people and organizations as the rest of the address space gets massively over-allocated to other uses.
Re:Tell HN: Hacker News now supports IPv6 by bombcar on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @10:49AM (#39104946)
Allowing a credit card company to have a /16 is one way to do it. Do that 65,535 more times and IPv6 is exhausted.
Re:Tell HN: Hacker News now supports IPv6 by dns_snek on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @11:24AM (#39105474)
Fair point, but that's politics and bad actors, no standard can survive that.
Re:Tell HN: Hacker News now supports IPv6 by soneil on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @02:08PM (#39108065)
So the funny thing is .. they didn't. They really didn't.

The original numbering plan for IP was that each network number became a /8. Which is how we miraculously ended up with 10/8, because network 10 was ARPANET itself, so 'flag day' left 10/8 vacant.

But back to the point at hand. IP itself is RFC 791, September 1981, nice and famous. The addition of classful networking because 255 network numbers wasn't going to last long, was RFC 790.

The first workaround for IP exhaustion was published before IP. It's been a Known Issue since day negative-one.