News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by latentcall on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:02AM (#38936415)
Not just social media, but always online mentality. Spending all your time online gives you a skewed perception of the world and I believe being online always is a major negative.

Spending time outside is good for you. Socializing with real people in front of you is good also.

Not sure if we can ever go back to that without some major catastrophe.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by JohnMakin on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:37AM (#38936610)
Being always online wasn’t quite so shitty til the last 10-15 years. Many people did it and were just fine for a long time. To me this feels like blaming food poisoning on the fact you have to eat food. Maybe the food is just bad.

the current state of online is the food. it just really sucks.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by drukenemo on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:29AM (#38936943)
In the past we could stay online for long hours doing some few activities (chatting, playing games, browsing few sites).

These days we can barely survive without a mobile phone always on, permeating every little interaction we have with the world. It’s quite a difference.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by JohnMakin on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @02:14AM (#38937177)
Before cell phones there were beepers. and people could always reach you on a landline. or leave a message on the machine. payphones. people weren’t really that much farther than they are now, it just required a little more coordination.

and cell phones have been around a lot longer than 10 years when this really picked up steam. even if you filter this statement to exclude everything but smart phones - smart, internet connected phones were around well before ~2012 when we saw a sharp spike begin in this trend, and that’s really the dawn of dominance of the YT/FB/IG/etc era.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by Klonoar on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @03:35AM (#38937758)
I would be surprised if the parent you’re responding to is even remotely discussing phone calls or answering machine messages, but rather the depth of what smartphones enable distraction-wise nowadays. Cell phones existed before but you weren’t browsing the entire web on them. ;P

A beeper isn’t even in the same league and it’s really not a point here.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by JohnMakin on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @09:51AM (#38939495)
You were definitely browsing the entire web well before 2012 on smart phones. And even before then there were internet enabled phones.
Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by itishappy on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @11:58AM (#38940646)
What percentage of the population do you think had them? What percentage of school children?

Nerds doing nerd stuff aren't going to affect the zeitgeist much, it's the network effect of having essentially 100% of your peers spending much of their time on social media.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by Klonoar on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @03:34PM (#38942706)
Not everyone was there by 2012, and yes, there were internet-enabled phones but the experience was substantially worse.

You are attempting to put a square into a circle here.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by kredd on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @11:05AM (#38940062)
15 years ago, we would somewhat choose whom to be “always online with”. It was more of a selected in-group of people, having similar interests and ideas. Right now, it just feels like “everyone screaming into the void” as “every app is for everyone”. It feels much different for some reason. Or maybe I’m just getting older and not a teen anymore.
Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by KittenInABox on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @11:25AM (#38940301)
I agree this might be the distinction. Communities are too permeable. The constant conflict we're seeing now reminds me a lot of e.g. harry potter fandom ship raids, except at a broad scale and for everything. We're not hissing about how people who want Harry and Hermione to fuck are dirty traitors to Ron and Hermione, we're trying to get someone's source of healthcare (employment) to kick them off for whatever they said about Ukraine/Russia.
Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by serf on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @11:26AM (#38940319)
>These days we can barely survive without a mobile phone always on, permeating every little interaction we have with the world. It’s quite a difference.

reading all of these 'royal we' anecdotes makes me feel grateful that I can survive without a mobile quite fine. HN is as close to social media as I get -- so I guess i'm stuck wondering : are all these 'conditions' of the modern world inexorably linked and self-perpetuating?

Like, if I wanted to develop a mobile-phone habit would it be best for me to get interested in social media, and vice versa?

Maybe my ducking of these trends just stems from my aversion to social media all together, and that saved me from mobile-phone overuse?

I don't know. But it is interesting, and wildly segmenting, that everyone around me refers to these problems that 'we' have -- but I don't. I can't be alone in this feeling.

p.s. to be clear, i'm not gloating -- if anything it's kind of loneliness inducing that I can't relate to the struggle.. but it's kind of a bittersweet feeling like being one of the few who doesn't catch a plague and has to watch others suffer.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by dgfitz on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:24PM (#38940890)
> I don't know. But it is interesting, and wildly segmenting, that everyone around me refers to these problems that 'we' have -- but I don't. I can't be alone in this feeling.

I feel the same way. HN is as close as I get to social media, I don't even look at reddit.

I think it is a "good thing" people use your "royal we" term in that at least people see phone addiction as a problem. It is usually always couched in the tone of "the problem is too far gone" which isn't a good thing.

I wonder what it would be like if an entire country picked one hour during one day, and everyone just somehow disabled data on their phones, calls only, with the idea being that you only make calls that are required, not to stymie boredom.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by DiscourseFan on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:21PM (#38940861)
I don't use social media, but I have Whatsapp groups for organizing, and its useful if I want to read something I don't have immediately on hand on the go, or if I want to take a picture, or take a call, or check the map if I want to go somewhere or if I get lost. I can look up recipes or set timers while cooking, use it as an alarm clock, stopwatch. Plus the one, billion, quadrillion apps; though, they were a lot cooler back when smartphones first came out, and, as I said, I usually don't use any apps besides email and the browser and maybe also a music streaming app.

I think those are the main things I use my phone for, and getting rid of it would be very inconvenient at this point, especially since I have an iPhone anyway so I can shut off all push notifications and all tracking software and what have you. It's not 100% secure, but what can you do. Though, to be honest, I think this will be my last smartphone, I won't get another one after it breaks. I was in my local library the other day, just checking it out, and there happened to be a travel guide for a city I'm visiting soon. My god, that thing was way better than any info I've found online, and it was quite pleasant to sit down and read a book for a few hours, instead of frantically browsing through one million websites to find out what was cool, interesting, and legit, and what was a tourist trap. Its a shithole, the internet, its just a means for large-scale fraud, theft, and surveillance. But there are still a few good things left, and that redeems it somewhat.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by mindslight on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:37PM (#38941660)
I don't think it's a plague, but more like a bunch of attractors now that ~everyone has expectation that everyone else is "always online". I'd say I'm in a similar position as you with regards to not opting into most of it, yet I still feel the social pressure of being drawn into crap like group texts. People, who a decade or two ago wouldn't call you back for days, now pile on within the hour with walls of emote-laden content-free well-wishes. If I were 10 years younger I'd probably have declared bankruptcy already and written an LLM autoresponse bot.

The other half of the mobile 1-2 punch is that the UX is terrible, due to both the limited form factor and the hostile software. People are social animals so most just suffer through it for the connection, and not knowing that the experience can be so much better on a real computer. Using software that functions across devices, I do feel the same attractors on a fully fledged desktop. But it's much less concentrated as I can read the entire context without scrolling, type out a response at a comfortable speed, and then switch away from that window until I poll it again. Whereas even with a phone running mostly libre software it feels like being sucked into a tap-tap-tap morass that I'm only using because I have to.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by brazzy on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @02:15AM (#38937189)
Nobody except a very small minority of techno-nerds (and most of those not teenagers) was alawys online until about 15 years ago, the advent of the smartphone. It took easily another 5 years before a significant amount of teenagers had them, especially outside the richest countries.

But of course it's not the technical capability that's the problem, it's the always-online culture, the network effects, the constant doomscrolling through algorithm-optimized feeds, the instant notification when someone replies to your kneejerk vitrolic comment with even more vitrol.

And then again, that culture was not possible without the technical capabilities and widespread adoption of them. Nobody was motivated to build a site or app optimized for doomscrolling until there were enough eyeballs and advertising dollars to capture.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by JohnMakin on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @02:23AM (#38937231)
Then why does this trend disproportionately affect girls? There is nothing particular special about “onlineness” that should affect them particularly worse than boys, but plenty of very real evidence that shows social media sites like IG are very harmful to girls (and meta knows it).

There are plenty of millennials that have been terminally online since at least their early teens and weren’t showing this same trend. I’m saying there’s nothing inherent about “online-ness” that should warrant mass levels of depression like this.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by AlecSchueler on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @04:15AM (#38938053)
Why do you assert that onlineness doesn't affect women disproportionately?

Women face all sorts of abuse and minimization online. I've heard of many women using male sounding names online in order to be taken seriously or avoid harassment. The general advice on subreddits dominated by women is to turn off personaal messaging to avoid the inevitable rape threats.

Take a look on Instagram and take a look at some musicians that are men and some that are women. The level of hatred directed towards women and the extra barriers they face will be very clear.

You also have subreddits that glorify misogyny like WomenAreThings or MisogynyKink. You have others where guys steal pictures from girls' social medias and redistribute them with captions about rape fantasy or where they use AI to force their victims into sexual media.

You look on YouTube and the algorithm wants to push misogynistic content aimed at disillusioned young boys and more and more of them are tuning in and blaming women for all their problems, asserting that feminism was a mistake.

If you're on Instagram compare how many women have their profiles set to private than men. This is to avoid the constant harassment they'd otherwise face.

I'm seeing more research every year that suggests women are actively self-censoring, silencing themselves or pretending to be men when online.

Here's a few interesting bits of further reading. I've been told off in the past for sharing these things here because women's rights are politics and therefore against the guidelines of the site but I hope it's relevant enough to the discussion here:

1. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.1177/089443931986551... 2. https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2018/03/online-violen... 3. https://www.womankind.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/brea...

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by jstarfish on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @11:50AM (#38940565)
While all of that is true, nobody hates women like other women. Men are just way more conspicuous and aggressive about it. Women conceal their abuse through rhetoric and political games.

Everyone is a girl, online.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37469575

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by itishappy on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:10PM (#38940746)
I'm trying to comprehend the point of your comment, particularly how it relates to the article you linked. If nobody hates women but women, but we're all women online... where does that leave us?
Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by AlecSchueler on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @07:33PM (#38945713)
On what basis are you making these assertions? I'm not sure what you mean by "rhetoric and political games" but it's the conspicuous agressive kind of hatred that would lead to women being disproptionately affected in a negative way, I would think.

I didn't actually say anything about men being the problem. Hatred against women hurts women was my whole point. I hope you can appreciate the irony in your comment: I pointed out some of the ways that women might struggle online, even linked to a variety of articles about it, and you felt the need to jump in and baselessly assert that women are the worst offenders.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by naasking on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @09:35AM (#38939382)
> There is nothing particular special about “onlineness” that should affect them particularly worse than boys

Females are on average far more social than males. If there's a dose-response effect social media time and mental health, then we should plausibly expect girls to be affected more.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by AlexandrB on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:12PM (#38940775)
I don't know about other social media, but IG combines a culture of posting visual content with heavy use of face/body filters. If you're already feeling self-conscious about your body, this is a recipe for body image issues and self-hate. Girls were facing the same issue from advertising and the fashion industry in the pre-internet era, but now it's beamed directly to everyone's phone.
Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by everdrive on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:16PM (#38940806)
There are well-founded stereotypes regarding women's need for gossip. Men compete in other ways. It's women who are most addicted to social media, instagram, etc.
Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by croutonwagon on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @11:53AM (#38940603)
I feel like the inflection point was about here:

https://imgur.com/ALMObBv

Not that I am blaming porn. I am not. But once the screens and bandwidth became large enough, UI's easy enough to navigate etc AND the devices themselves became quite commonplace, the always online mentality became one used much less for essential communication and business and transitioned more to a cultural way of life (porn is just an easy and funny way to drive that point home).

Doom scrolling wasnt really as much of a thing until Android and iOS matured enough and gained enough acceptance that it was no longer a status symbol. Heck i cant even tell you most of the social media apps these days, much less dating, but having some conversations with my younger cousins over break, there really arent many ways to meet folks outside of some of these apps (at least to them), which is sad. Apparently something as simple as "why not just join some type of IRL hobby and meet people that way" was scoffed at.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by rescbr on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:15PM (#38940804)
Infinite scrolling was also present in desktop.

I blame the pivot from the chronological feeds to algorithmically generated feeds based on engagement (or whatever other metric).

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by croutonwagon on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:28PM (#38940920)
It was. And I agree that plays a part. But Desktops are, by nature, much less accessible. Even a laptop is.

You didnt have people nearly as commonly doomscrolling on the subway on the way to work, or in the car, or in the living room around family, when the computer was restricted to a specific space/time etc.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by rchaud on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:20PM (#38940855)
agreed, chronological feeds have a visible signal to users telling them how far they've scrolled. If you're seeing posts from Feb of the past year, you've been scrolling too long.

Ad-based social apps (all of them) replaced that with algorithmic, so you have no real signifier of how long you've spent scrolling.

Tiktok takes this one step further by stripping the date from the videos.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by Sohcahtoa82 on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:47PM (#38941114)
> algorithmically generated feeds based on engagement

This is one thing that really gets me.

Your feed is based on engagement. It doesn't have to be GOOD engagement, just engagement.

So when you angrily reply to a tweet you hate, that's engagement. You will be shown more content that makes you angry.

Most of the things people complain about in terms of what Twitter shows them, I don't experience. I don't follow people I hate, and if someone quote-tweets, I avoid replying. Definitely don't click the original tweet to see what other people have said.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by AlexandrB on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:04PM (#38940707)
Doom scrolling is an intentional social media "feature". Before infinite scrolling, algorithmic feeds doom scrolling required some effort on the users part. Now you can just keep flicking your thumb up and keep getting more shit.
Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by lupusreal on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:07PM (#38940724)
10-15 years ago roughly aligns with the popularization of smartphones. Before that, almost nobody was going around all day with the internet in their pocket so the experience of "always" online was very different.
Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by NoMoreNicksLeft on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:57PM (#38941209)
If you look at the people who did it early, they're very different in personality than the people who are now doing it. I was the kid who would have preferred to sit in the library all day reading. Not that they let me. For me, I've been plugged into the absolutely largest library mankind has ever been built, since 1994 or so... and I still find myself amazed at what can be found online even now. Some of it are recently digitized works that because they were obscure, I could never have known they existed. Other things are discoveries (even amateur ones) that people post online today that would have been forgotten or unknown in the 1980s (unlikely for the people to have even put it in one of those crappy xeroxed newsletters).

I check out Facebook once or twice a month because my wife tells me to like something on it. I didn't even create the account, she did it for me years ago.

Even now, I read. And read. And read. Everything from rigorous scientific studies on down to the weirdest shitposting. From great works of literature down to fringe science theories. But all I see other people doing, if I notice at all, is watching Tiktok videos. Are any of the rest of you out there reluctant to bother with consuming video/audio content, even if a search seems to indicate that it might be the only place the information you seek might be found? Well, then you might be one of those personalities for which being online wasn't/isn't so shitty.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by 303uru on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:44AM (#38936662)
So quick to blame social media, even the article just waves it's hand and makes the assumption.

Why not declining social mobility? Why not climate change anxiety? Why not late stage capitalism? Nah, it's always easy to blame Tik Tok as if the chosen release isn't indicative of something much greater going on.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by pmontra on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:28AM (#38936939)
The archive of that site has many posts answering your question. Some have been on HN in the past months.

Archive https://www.afterbabel.com/archive

Here are 13 Other Explanations for the Adolescent Mental Health Crisis. None of Them Work. https://www.afterbabel.com/p/13-explanations-mental-health-c...

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by WarOnPrivacy on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @02:26AM (#38937251)
> Here are 13 Other Explanations for the Adolescent Mental Health Crisis.

She finally gets to the deciding modern condition - the one where kids are systemically denied critical growth time (daily blocks of adult-free time & safe places to roam [safe=no threat of police or other compulsive adults]).

And even tho she has this on her list of false suppositions she admits probably isn't as false as she infers.

But she then immediately minimizes this historic erasure of development by saying it's just 'independence' kids have lost. Gaslighting done, she bizarrely accuses devices & social media of causing it, even tho it was obvious by the 1980s that options for free-roaming and adult-free time were well on the way to being eradicated.

Perhaps being so invested in pregurgitated conclusions, she's unable to notice super-obvious competing factors.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by granshaw on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @02:37AM (#38937324)
Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by watwut on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @03:43AM (#38937825)
The article is about mental health crisis being international. Meanwhile, German, French, Swiss, Japan or Scandinavian kids walk around towns free without adults. They walk to school at age of 6 or even sooner.

If it was just about independence, countries like Germany or France would not had the issue.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by naasking on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @09:43AM (#38939448)
Exactly. Everybody just immediately jumps to their pet theory without actually digesting the full set of data that needs to be explained. The article very clearly lays out why those other explanations are less plausible than social media, and the cross-cultural nature of it is a big point.

All that said, the authors who publish on that site are also very pro-unsupervised free play and think its decline has caused mental health issues of its own (see Haidt's The Coddling of the American Mind).

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by pixl97 on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:30PM (#38940946)
People are really bad about interpreting complex multifactor causations, it seems in every discipline.

I think human social systems have a lot of 'anti-fragile' built into them. That is any one factor, unless it is insanely serious, isn't going to cause a mass collapse of society. We adapt and smooth things over. This is something we see in ecological systems all the time. The problems start cropping up when multiple stressors are introduced to the environment. For example, I'd say the disappearance of 'third places' forces more youth to social media thereby increasing said harm of social media.

Also, social media likely needs broken into a series of different factors on what is harmful about it. You have the direct "Kids going things to kids", but neglecting what social media is doing to their parents would be missing the forest for the trees. The 24 hour news cycle tapped into the fear sells, and online has taken it to 'fear gets eyeballs'. Add in advertisers being unscrupulous, and countless bots attempting to manipulate you, it's no wonder we're not all insane.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by roenxi on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:01AM (#38936771)
Even if it were one of those things; nothing has changed since 2010 to make them worse. The current negative economic trends set in around 1970, "social mobility" isn't a thing most people ever have access to.

I've never been able to figure out what the problem is with climate change was so I dunno; maybe that is fair. But nothing new seems to have happened in the last decade that wasn't also happening in the 2000s.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by paulryanrogers on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @11:59AM (#38940656)
Microplastics have accumulated as well as other forever chemicals, and awareness of them.

It's likely several factors at play and at different severities in different places.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by AlexandrB on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:06PM (#38941325)
I think awareness of microplastics, etc. kind of undermines this theory. In the 60s we were spraying all kinds of crazy crap - CFCs, DDT - into the environment and plastic was already pretty widely used, while recycling was nowhere in sight. 5-6 decades of additional plastic accumulation is not nothing, but people are much more aware - hence the return of metal water bottles, for example. Many pesticides/herbicides have also either been banned outright or are much harder to get since then.

Plus microplastics likely accumulate over your lifetime - a mental health issue caused by microplastics would show up much more quickly in the elderly of middle aged than in teens.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by alienicecream on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:58AM (#38936743)
Yeah that's what the kids are thinking about, late-stage capitalism and declining social mobility.
Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by irrational on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:06AM (#38936797)
I’m in my 50s and I’m not even thinking about those things.
Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by CalRobert on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:27AM (#38936937)
I was very worried about climate change as a kid, and still am.
Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by ben_w on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @10:43AM (#38939854)
I was worried when I was a kid, now I'm much less worried. Plenty of other things to worry about, and there's still a non-zero risk, but I think there's enough money to be made fixing that particular issue that we'll probably be OK.
Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by CalRobert on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @11:09AM (#38940108)
I hope you're right!
Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by PawgerZ on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @11:24AM (#38940299)
In comparison to other generations? Yeah, they are.
Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by 303uru on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @06:44PM (#38945265)
I'd challenge you to enter a school. I volunteer and run two clubs and they very much are talking about these things.
Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by LAC-Tech on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @02:53AM (#38937449)
I think the sort of people who push "climate change anxiety" and espouse theories about "late stage capitalism" are a huge, huge part of the problem. Near every communist I've met was miserable.
Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by nradov on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:38PM (#38941018)
There is a high degree of correlation between mental illness and leftist political views.

https://twitter.com/ZachG932/status/1248823584111439872

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by 303uru on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @06:48PM (#38945306)
It's easier to refer to the true and highly studied issue here, depressive realism. "Leftists" have more accurate knowledge of the world and that leads to depression. Ignorance is bliss. That's not even mentioning the fact that the right belittles mental health and those who seek help.
Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by nkohari on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @11:58AM (#38940642)
Constant doomscrolling on social media is what causes anxiety about those topics.
Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by AlexandrB on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:21PM (#38940863)
> Why not late stage capitalism?

What is social media if not an aspect of late stage capitalism? Unlike a normal customer <-> business relationship social media companies don't give the slightest shit about your well-being or satisfaction. Indeed, you're not the customer at all.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by hanniabu on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:04AM (#38936784)
> Spending all your time online gives you a skewed perception of the world

I'd say it gives you an accurate depiction, exposing the shit in the world around us.

Whereas people not online so much are happy because ignorance is bliss.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by brazzy on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @02:19AM (#38937205)
No, exposing the shit and concentrating on it is not accurate. Building your world view on the part of the world you can personally observe, which has some good and mostly boring normal aspects, is not ignorance. I'd argue that for most people it's in fact more accurate.
Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by hanniabu on Saturday January 13, 2024 @06:45PM (#38985915)
When you're not online you don't see how the world truly operates, it's obfuscated from you. Ignoring that is literally ignorance.
Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by j4yav on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:24AM (#38936913)
I feel like there must be some generation coming that feels like being highly online is weird and embarassing, having grown up and seen the way their parents and other adults behave, and use the internet more as a utility rather than a place to try to primarily live. What makes this hard I think is how addictive it is for children, so by the time they might realize how embarassing it is they have already been addicted by devices their parents gave them.
Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by granshaw on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @02:33AM (#38937293)
What makes it hard is the stigmatization of letting children roam free unsupervised, and the isolating nature of suburbs coupled with both parents being working parents.

Kids can’t go anywhere and are stuck at home. None of their friends are within walking distance. What do you expect them to do?

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by pixl97 on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:15PM (#38940799)
No, I would say this is a totally different issue actually.

It doesn't matter where kids go these days because every single one of them has an internet connected cell phone at their side.

When they are with their friends, they are still with the internet. Their actions are moulded by it, as well they should be. If anything you do could be captured in video and posted online forever, you're going to change your behavior to reflect that reality.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by bongodongobob on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @03:06AM (#38937538)
I can see it to some extent in gen Z. Once alpha ages a bit, I could totally see that being their counterculture.
Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by kredd on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @11:10AM (#38940127)
Looking at my nephews, it’s highly unlikely to happen. From what they’ve told me, if you’re not online and at least aware of the “latest trends”, you become an outcast in school. Their way of trying to be less cringe and protesting is just being on “less mainstream apps”. Which yields the same results but with different colors. Not having any social media is also pretty awful as you’ll just be an outsider again. I wish there was some sort of a national effort where parents would unite and not let their children be on social media.
Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by j4yav on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:59PM (#38941244)
Maybe it will just be a counterculture thing but I could imagine a group of people thinking it’s really lame to follow all the latest internet trends. We need a version of punk rock that hates the internet.
Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by scotty79 on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:58AM (#38937093)
People don't tolerate information well. When we are young we need our small safety bubbles where we are sufficiently isolated from information so that we can fantasise that we matter. That we amount to something. Social truth that (nearly?) all of us don't is apparently too hard to bear.

And I don't think we can come back from this. That we can go back to ignorance. We need to adapt, the way species always adapted. By letting weaker ones die. And that's exactly what will happen unless by sheer accident some technological miracle pops up to save us from this problem. We won't step back from profitable technologies. We never did.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by barrenko on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @02:33AM (#38937295)
Screens of any and all kind.
Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by wait_a_minute on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @11:41AM (#38940467)
> Not sure if we can ever go back to that without some major catastrophe.

We easily can. With the network effect, we can just encourage everyone we know that socializing with real people in real life is important and set up some coffees, lunches, dinners, walks, board games, etc, and then encourage those people to do the same with the people they know.

Won't take very many hops to reach everyone this way and get back on track.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by everdrive on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:23PM (#38940884)
This is like saying we can easily stop the obesity epidemic. The problem is pretty simple conceptually, but it's not going to be solved. The requirements for ignoring social media and practicing true impulse control lay outside of the bell curve of impulse control for much of humanity. People _could_ stop using social media, but they're not going to. Same reason why most people are fat. Yes, I know there are environmental factors, but all those do is squeeze a tighter box around the percentile of people who have the impulse control and resources to eat and exercise properly to maintain a good physique.
Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by s1artibartfast on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:46PM (#38941106)
However, global behavior does change, and not always for worse. It is usually just slow and people and culture adapt.

The good news is that individuals don't have to wait on society. They can choose to be early adapters.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by pixl97 on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:10PM (#38940752)
>We easily can. With the network effect,

Sometimes I wonder if people read what they actually write?

What you're saying is you want everyone to disconnect and no longer be part of the network effect we're currently under.... This thinking seems to have a few flaws.

1. You have to remain within the supposed 'bad' network effect to broadcast your message. If you leave and go do your IRL things, you won't be there to broadcast your message (maybe bots doing it for you?).

2. You expect said networks to carry your message. You: "Lets all go outside", X: "Your message has been deleted due to violations of community standards".

3. You assume that being terminally online is not an addiction. That is just saying "Hey, lets go outside" has any effect on the vast majority of people that need to hear the message. Don't think of being on like smoking, it's not something you can just ban because it's part of life now. Think of it like eating, and how poorly that is going for the world at the moment with ever increasing obesity rates.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by s1artibartfast on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:14PM (#38941416)
Sticking with the tech analogy, People can and do switch networks all the time. You also don't have to wait for average user to become an early adopter.
Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by Taylor_OD on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:16PM (#38940814)
A lot of people want to spend more time with people irl but just dont know how/dont have access to like minded people irl.

Part of the allure of the internet is that if I want to talk about Mass Effect tabletop roll playing, there are plenty of other people to talk about that with. If I want to have a conversation about the same thing in person... Maybe there is someone in my city who might want to talk about that? But it is so much more work to make that happen than online.

I dont mind talking about sports/local stuff/mass media/small talk all that much but that is most of what I'm going to get from the folks I'm interacting with on a regular basis IRL.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by faeriechangling on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @11:57AM (#38940634)
The issue I’ve been seeing in wealthy industrialized countries, is that people are becoming poorer as they grow older, the prices of energy are rising, the prices of land are rising, so simply getting people together is less viable than even 20 odd years ago.

The internet gives you an instant connection to people who have interests specific to you better than even an expensive international convention can do for essentially free. If you decide this is worth it anyways, well you’re going to end up financially behind somebody using the internet in a cheap apartment on undesirable land, and that is going to undermine you bit by bit.

Those who thrive in this era of humanity I think are just going to be well adapted to an online world, or just be wealthy enough that they can afford the luxury of meeting in person. The only way in which I see this trend moving in the opposite direction is that the average amount of people living in each home is likely to rise due to land cost.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by thfuran on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:10PM (#38940749)
>If you decide this is worth it anyways, well you’re going to end up financially behind somebody using the internet in a cheap apartment on undesirable land, and that is going to undermine you bit by bit. Money can't help you when you're dead, so if you don't use it to improve your life or someone else's, it doesn't help at all.

How is the depressed person living in an undesirable place ahead exactly?

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by faeriechangling on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:45PM (#38941739)
In my thought experiment I’m trying to compare somebody who is perfectly happy in this new world spending much time behind screens, and somebody who needs more face to face interaction to be happy. I think the latter are doomed to try and keep up with the former by making personal sacrifices.

I think about this because in my youth the kids who spent all day in front of a computer were treated as disabled, disordered, and aberrant who needed to be pushed to be more social to succeed. Mostly boys were treated in this way. Yet I feel it’s these socially driven people who are fucked. Mostly women.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by karaterobot on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @11:54AM (#38940608)
Okay, I traveled back in time 30 years and convinced people to recognize the danger of being online all the time. I even made sure there would be innumerable studies suggesting it, and that pretty much everyone was at least aware of the danger. So, now that I'm back in 2024, everybody should already know that being online all the time is not healthy. I haven't checked yet, did it stop them from being addicted? I'm sure it did, right?!
Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by s1artibartfast on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @11:54AM (#38940614)
I think this is an issue of "can" in the "technically possible" vs "realistically possible".

There are lots of people who have done exactly what you said, and others that never became terminally online, yet real-world re-adoption has been slow.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by pixl97 on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:11PM (#38940764)
Technically possible: "We all stop eating too much and obesity drops"

Realistically possible: "Obesity levels keep going up"

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by wait_a_minute on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:16PM (#38940808)
I think what you are both missing is that everyone reading this thread can, right now, schedule coffees and lunches and dinners for a month out and text people and get the ball rolling. We should not underestimate the impact of a few people making this effort, it will compound into great and positive results. I will be doing this myself since I recommended it. I expect to have at least five coffees or dinners scheduled for the next week by the end of the day. Let’s do it! Let’s get it done!

It has to start somewhere after all. <3

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by s1artibartfast on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:40PM (#38941048)
I already have a several social dinners and social activities a week, and have been doing this for years. Most of my friends at this point are people who also socialize in real life at this point.

I say this not to by cynical or cop-out. Im actually pretty optimistic about that things will swing back in the opposite direction. I just dont think it will be a quick snap out of it, but a painful lesson for many people, and a lot of people will be left behind.

That is to say, a quick global anti-online revolution is compatible with the laws of physics, but I dont think it is likely.

The good news is that nobody has to wait for the global revolution. They can do whatever they want starting today. I find physical interactions more rewarding and healthy, so I put in the effort to have them. I suspect most people would be happier if they did the same.

Re:The teen mental illness epidemic is international by mindslight on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:47PM (#38941111)
I've actually got to wonder if part of it is the disappearance of frontier-type online spaces in favor of corporate real-name social media. Spending "too much" time online used to be a refuge that allowed you to be a completely different person - IRC, forums, etc. I'd say that most people who grew up online 20-30 years ago view the digital world as a welcome escape.

Now that outlet has been replaced by a digital version of the exact same inescapable social matrix from school. Perhaps this theory is less supported by the observed effect being greater on girls (at first glance one would think a frontier would be more important to boys). But on the other hand psuedonymity allowed everyone to have personas not tied to gender, and perhaps girls actually need the escape more.