News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by KomoD on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @09:35PM (#38935430)
> It's not clear if the author was hired to do this pentest or is a guerilla/good samaritan

Pretty clear to me, "it was searching for exposed Firebase credentials on any of the hundreds of recent AI startups.", running a script to scan hundreds of startups

> Sadly, many companies will freak out and get the law involved, even if you are a good samaritan.

Yeah, but that also ends with that company being shamed a lot of the time

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by pests on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @09:56PM (#38935576)
What is wrong with shaming when it's warranted?
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by redcobra762 on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @10:12PM (#38935678)
It’s an ineffective tool if your goal is change.
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by pests on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:25AM (#38936918)
How so?
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by pastage on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:43AM (#38937035)
Because everyone makes mistakes, if you antagonize someone they are less likely to care about you and feel more obligation to protect their own.
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by janalsncm on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @02:31AM (#38937283)
Using plain text passwords goes well beyond a simple “mistake” in my book. It is negligent.
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by bruh2 on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @11:11AM (#38940137)
This is absolutely true at the scope of personal relationships. Not at all when it comes to companies, which have a different set of incentives
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by godelski on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @02:06PM (#38941927)
I think this is more because we also are quick to shame what are more clear unintentional mistakes or not give positive rewards to good actors. I'm also not unconvinced there are people that want to up-play any controversy (not as any specifically collective and directed force, but an emergent behavior may look that way. More "never let a tragedy go to waste" thing).

But that's different than shaming. That's over-saturating the system with false positives. To combat this I'd encourage you to not respond, in __any__ way to bullshit fake controversy and to also give positive reinforcement for when companies do something good.

I'll give an example, you've probably seen companies like Meta occasionally do something good. For example, they released the source of LLaMA. But people tend to use those opportunities to not congratulate Meta for doing the good thing but rather complain about other bad things they do. Then yes, it fits your model, because you've reached bad steady state and you can no longer turn good because nothing you do that is good will get any signal to continue in that direction.

Us humans are weird and routinely shoot ourselves in the foot only to ask who fired the bullet, smoking gun in hand.

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by Eisenstein on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @02:44AM (#38937381)
Shame is absolutely a valuable tool for change. Without it society would not function since many of our 'rules' are self-enforced.
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by redcobra762 on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @02:47AM (#38937406)
Nope, shame is ineffective as a tool for change. More often people shut down or ignore you if you attempt to shame them than actually make the change you want. Besides, it's frequently just about vengeance anyway. Shame is really hate of other, for the most part.

As a tool for oppression however, yes it's quite effective.

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by bryanrasmussen on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @04:08AM (#38937985)
>More often people shut down or ignore you if you attempt to shame them than actually make the change you want.

shame as a tool of change does not work on the person being shamed at the time, it works on that person for the future hopefully as they will be afraid to be shamed again and it works on changing the behavior of other peoples because they don't want to get shamed either.

Thus as a tool of oppression, as you pointed out, it works great. But also as a tool for enforcing otherwise non-enforced social rules - until of course you meet someone shameless or who feels at least that they can effectively argue against the shaming.

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by Eisenstein on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @03:39AM (#38937794)
There are different types of shame. Shame related to a decision situation (endogenous) and shame not related to a decision situation (exogenous). In the endogenous case the shame is said to be a 'pro-social' emotion.

This is backed by studies.

"Using three different emotion inductions and two different dependent measures, we repeatedly found that endogenous shame motivates prosocial behavior. After imagining shame with a scenario, proself participants acted more prosocially toward the audience in a social dilemma game (Experiment 1). This finding was replicated when participants recalled a shame event (Experiment 2). Moreover, when experiencing shame after a failure on performance tasks, proself participants also acted prosocially toward the audience in the lab (Experiment 3). Finally, Experiment 4 showed that this effect could be generalized beyond social dilemmas to helping tendencies in everyday situations. Therefore, it seems safe to conclude that shame can be seen as a moral emotion motivating prosocial behavior." [1]

You can also contrast 'humiliation' shame with 'moral shame', with moral shame being prosocial. This is also backed by studies.

"Our data show that the common conception of shame as a universally maladaptive emotion does not capture fully the diversity of motivations with which it is connected. Shame that arises from a tarnished social image is indeed associated with avoidance, anger, cover-up, and victim blame, and is likely to have negative effects on intergroup relations. However, shame that arises in response to violations of the ingroup’s valued moral essence is strongly associated with a positive pattern of responses and is likely to have positive effects on intergroup relations."[2]

[1] de Hooge, I. E., Breugelmans, S. M., & Zeelenberg, M. (2008). Not so ugly after all: When shame acts as a commitment device.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 95(4), 933–943.

[2] Allpress, J. A., Brown, R., Giner-Sorolla, R., Deonna, J. A., & Teroni, F. (2014). Two Faces of Group-Based Shame: Moral Shame and Image Shame Differentially Predict Positive and Negative Orientations to Ingroup Wrongdoing. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 40(10), 1270-1284.

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by xpe on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @11:03AM (#38940036)
Would you care to summarize what "related to a decision situation" means for those of us who don't have access to those articles?
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by dataflow on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:27PM (#38940910)
Just a guess, but I imagine it's the difference between "I'm ashamed I can't make enough money to save anything" vs. "I'm ashamed I blew all my savings on crypto". One is shame about your situation (which are likely to be out of your own desires and control too), the other is shame about your decision (which you likely had better control over).
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by Eisenstein on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:43PM (#38941718)
This is correct, according my understanding of the study I sourced.
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by redcobra762 on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:22PM (#38940873)
There’s a reason your citations are nearly a decade old at best; the science has changed.

A 2021 meta-analysis showed that, “shame correlates negatively with self-esteem and is large effect size.” [0] So unless the goal of your shame is to actively harm the people involved, then no, shame is not an effective tool at behavior change, given the damage it causes.

You may be thinking of “guilt” rather than shame:

> In sum, shame and guilt refer to related but distinct negative “self-conscious” emotions. Although both are unpleasant, shame is the more painful self-focused emotion linked to hiding or escaping. Guilt, in contrast, focuses on the behavior and is linked to making amends. [1]

[0] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8768475/

[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3328863/

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by Eisenstein on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:40PM (#38941698)
Regarding your sources:

One has to do with self-esteem, which has nothing to do with whether it is pro-social or beneficial, just that some types of shame harm self-esteem, which was never contested.

The second study is about criminal populations, and I specifically mentioned that shame is about self-policing, and that obviously didn't work if someone is incarcerated for a crime.

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by redcobra762 on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:42PM (#38941715)
Did you read them? If your goal is to effect change, hurting people's self esteem is a negative effect that is entirely unnecessary to change.

And criminals aren't some ungovernable animals...

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by Eisenstein on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @10:24PM (#38947131)
> If your goal is to effect change, hurting people's self esteem is a negative effect that is entirely unnecessary to change.

Yes, your self esteem will likely be harmed if you do something bad and it gets found out.

> And criminals aren't some ungovernable animals...

?

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by pests on Thursday January 11, 2024 @01:12AM (#38948426)
I'm confused too. People live inside such safe spaces now. The thought of a negative emotion is to be avoided at all costs.

Shame makes people feel bad, so we must do all we can do avoid making anyone feel that.

What's next? Is "disappointment" next? Having someone disappointed in you feels bad, therefore no one can ever show disappointment to others?

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by redcobra762 on Thursday January 11, 2024 @11:49AM (#38954765)
You’re confused about how shame could make someone unproductive? How shame could drive a behavior underground rather than eliminate it, thus exacerbating the issue rather than reducing it?

As you are demonstrating, shame is more about causing pain than changing behavior. You seem to want to hurt people, and that’s one reason why shame is not effective. You don’t care that equally or more effective means exist for improving behavior.

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by Eisenstein on Thursday January 11, 2024 @12:22PM (#38955351)
It isn't letting me reply to you above because it locks down comment chains that get replied to quickly to avoid flame wars, so I will reply here and be done.

> So you admit that shame can be bad? Then you’re close. Next you need to realize that shame’s effectiveness is dependent on a person feeling shame the way you want them to. But that’s not how it actually works, is it? Instead, shame is sourced from the judgements of others, so one way of effectively mitigating shame is to hide the behavior from others, rather than stopping it. So shame is ineffective.

I never claimed that shame couldn't be bad -- I said it is essential for society to function properly. I cited two studies which demonstrated that shame can be prosocial and beneficial depending on circumstances.

> And I’m not being silly. You tried to dismiss the legitimacy of my citation by dismissing an entire category of people. That was inconsiderate.

I dismissed your studies because they were both irrelevant to my point and did not contradict anything I cited. If you feel that I am othering prisoners because I said that the situation of the people in the study made it useless to make your point, then I object to that and say that you are grasping at straws since you have no reasonable argument otherwise.

Look, you have every right to be absolutely wrong in this case, so don't bother changing your mind or looking at my actual standing on the issue and instead imagine I am some kind of meany pants who wants people to feel bad if you want, but I am done with this conversation.

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by redcobra762 on Thursday January 11, 2024 @01:44PM (#38956758)
That’s not how HN works, individuals are slowed by IP, there is no “slow a specific conversation”, but thanks for making it clear you’ve been flagged by dang as a troll.

And one of the clearest indicators to me that a person knows their argument is weak is when they declare themselves correct (or me wrong). Of course I’m free to be wrong, the problem you have is you’ve done a terrible job demonstrating that fact.

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by Eisenstein on Thursday January 11, 2024 @04:58PM (#38959846)
You talk about how others 'want people to feel bad', but have you considered that you are expressing the most desire to belittle others and make them feel bad? Your abrasiveness and need to triumph in what should otherwise be a genial conversation must really make it difficult to engage with people without them disliking you. Have you considered self-reflection?
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by redcobra762 on Thursday January 11, 2024 @05:47PM (#38960568)
Oh yeah, I'm a terrible person, no doubt about that. Doesn't change the argument one bit, however.

(See how your attempt at shame failed? That's why shame is not a useful tool.)

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by Eisenstein on Thursday January 11, 2024 @08:40PM (#38962419)
The problem with thinking you know everything is that you miss genuine opportunities to learn things -- I wasn't trying to shame you, I was pointing out the irony of your crusade in this thread (which is completely apparent to everyone) and urging you to self-reflect on things that could improve your life.

Even if you think I am an asshole, self-reflection can only be beneficial. One thing that may be helpful is to take a look at your actions over the thread and think about it from the other perspective, and seeing how you may appear from someone else's point of view. I do that often and though it isn't always pleasant, it does give a reality check in some key areas.

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by redcobra762 on Friday January 12, 2024 @12:17AM (#38964174)
Nope sorry; I didn't say I know everything, I just provided an apparently undefeatable argument (why attack my character otherwise?).
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by Eisenstein on Friday January 12, 2024 @02:02PM (#38972376)
You can lead a horse to water...

Refusing to acknowledge that other people have valid arguments and continuing to repeat the same thing over an over again is indeed 'unbeatable'.

People then ceasing to continue to argue with you because you aren't listening to them is them recognizing they are wasting their time.

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by redcobra762 on Thursday January 11, 2024 @11:47AM (#38954734)
Keep thinking beyond the immediate for another step and you will see how harming self esteem means a person won’t productively alter their behavior. It’s in the literature I’ve cited if you’re actually curious.

And you made a value judgement about the people who end up in jail/prison, which was completely uncalled for.

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by Eisenstein on Thursday January 11, 2024 @12:03PM (#38955021)
You know that things can be bad sometimes and not bad some other times? Shaming people to make them feel bad is not good; however feeling shame for having done something wrong is good -- it motivates one to avoid doing that again.

> And you made a value judgement about the people who end up in jail/prison, which was completely uncalled for.

You are being silly.

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by redcobra762 on Thursday January 11, 2024 @12:11PM (#38955162)
So you admit that shame can be bad? Then you’re close. Next you need to realize that shame’s effectiveness is dependent on a person feeling shame the way you want them to. But that’s not how it actually works, is it? Instead, shame is sourced from the judgements of others, so one way of effectively mitigating shame is to hide the behavior from others, rather than stopping it. So shame is ineffective.

And I’m not being silly. You tried to dismiss the legitimacy of my citation by dismissing an entire category of people. That was inconsiderate.

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by xpe on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @11:00AM (#38940004)
The comment above lacks essential nuance and is overly confident.
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by redcobra762 on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:09PM (#38940744)
The comment above lacks contributory value and is also (ironically) overly confident.
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by xpe on Thursday January 11, 2024 @11:11AM (#38954134)
Shall we continue into an infinite regress of zingers?

You are correct that I didn't provide supporting reasons myself. Fair point. I suppose I didn't think your comment warranted it. Saying that might come across as harsh, which isn't my goal. I'd rather shift into a constructive and specific discussion instead. In that spirit, I'll elaborate on my criticism. Let's start with your leading sentence:

> Nope, shame is ineffective as a tool for change.

There are lots of ways to improve this sentence; here is one suggestion: consider a phrasing like "In comparison to _X_, shame tends to be less effective for _particular purpose_."

I'd suggest avoiding empirical claims about likelihoods you aren't able to defend. Take this sentence fragment:

> More often people shut down or ignore you if you attempt to shame them...

If done forcefully, this _might_ lead to "shutting down" or "ignoring"; however, on what basis can one say this happens "more often"? More often than what? The writing here overreaches -- this is why I called it "overconfident".

There are many situations where one person points out a shameful behavior in another, who recognizes it, feels bad, and i.e. apologizes and modifies their behavior. My point: it would be faulty to dismiss the idea of shame as useless in social contexts.

Finally, the next sentence also struck me as an overreach:

> As a tool for oppression however, yes it's quite effective.

Care to elaborate your thinking on that one? What do you mean by oppression?

By oppression I think of a power dynamic where the weak are kept in a lower position by the more powerful. Is this what you mean? Why do you think shaming is particularly effective way to oppress? In my mind, military, physical, legal, and economic mechanisms tend to be more effective, historically speaking.

I could speculate. Perhaps you are referring to the practice by certain religious systems to make people feel ashamed for merely doing things that all humans do (make mistakes) and thus deserve punishment (e.g. by the religious elites, or worse, by yourself, thus making yourself feel weak and unworthy).

In short, I'm sufficiently enough in these ideas to be rather unsatisfied with writing that doesn't unpack the ideas at all. No offense intended. I look forward to learning what you mean.

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by redcobra762 on Thursday January 11, 2024 @11:58AM (#38954917)
Eh, you either seem unaware that your comments aren’t the only ones in this discussion, or narcissistic enough to believe only you deserve a full response, because every answer you’re looking for and more are in sibling comments around you, yet you choose to engage only in my shortest comment that had context you could pretend didn’t exist.

If you were trying to show some of the worst faith engagement possible on HN, you did it.

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by boredtofears on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:43PM (#38941067)
Shame isn't always for oppression, although it certainly can be - it's also a pretty useful tool to impose reasonable rules that allow you to live peacefully among your neighbors.
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by redcobra762 on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:11PM (#38941368)
That's not shame, that's guilt. Shame is existential, guilt is situational. The cost of shame is too high for whatever value it may bring.
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by boredtofears on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:36PM (#38941655)
Nope:

> According to cultural anthropologist Ruth Benedict, shame arises from a violation of cultural or social values while guilt feelings arise from violations of one's internal values.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shame#Comparison_with_guilt

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by redcobra762 on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:44PM (#38941738)
Yep:

> In sum, shame and guilt refer to related but distinct negative “self-conscious” emotions. Although both are unpleasant, shame is the more painful self-focused emotion linked to hiding or escaping. Guilt, in contrast, focuses on the behavior and is linked to making amends. [0]

[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3328863/

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by pests on Thursday January 11, 2024 @01:13AM (#38948435)
Why is a painful emotion a bad thing?
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by redcobra762 on Thursday January 11, 2024 @11:55AM (#38954856)
People react poorly to it, and in situations where it is unnecessary, it’s just cruel.
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by filoleg on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:34PM (#38941639)
> people shut down or ignore you if you attempt to shame them

Sure, but large businesses entities (as opposed to individuals) often cannot afford such luxury.

Try being a bank in a western country and ignoring a public security blog post, outlining exactly how one can exploit your online banking auth flow to gain unauthorized access to customer accounts.

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by redcobra762 on Thursday January 11, 2024 @12:08PM (#38955096)
That’s not shame, that’s risk. Corporations don’t have the capacity for shame, it’s the major thing people gate about corporations in the first place…
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by filoleg on Friday January 12, 2024 @05:20PM (#38974915)
> That’s not shame, that’s risk

Risk of what? Risk of losing credibility and revenue due to… people shaming them, perchance?

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by direwolf20 on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @03:37AM (#38937770)
Shame can't fight lawyers and handcuffs.
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by gosub100 on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @02:21PM (#38942049)
It ends up leading to "word-inflation" where you have to keep shouting louder, stretching the truth to be acknowledged. The word "racist" changing meaning over the last 30-40 years is a great example.
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by pnutjam on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @05:17PM (#38944161)
Please elaborate on the change in meaning?
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by gosub100 on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @08:36PM (#38946275)
why isn't the word "prejudice" used anymore?
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by pnutjam on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @09:46PM (#38946820)
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by gosub100 on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @10:27PM (#38947149)
I didn't ask what GPT or 3 random people said. why can't you articulate your own position?
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by pnutjam on Thursday January 11, 2024 @06:26AM (#38950796)
Well you didn't answer my question. But I'm going to assume you're hinting at the false equivalency conservative line to trot out about prejudice against poor it rural people.

Prejudice is rooted in lack of knowledge and unfamiliarity. Racism is familiar and has it's own body of knowledge; all wrong, but vehemently defended. Racists try to build their own narrative.

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by gosub100 on Thursday January 11, 2024 @09:38AM (#38952731)
I didnt ask what the difference was, I asked why one word isn't used anymore. Why are you not paying attention?
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by pnutjam on Thursday January 11, 2024 @02:51PM (#38957930)
You still haven't answered me, but I'll leave this for you consideration. Sub in racist for anti-semite. I believe this applies to you

"Never believe that anti-Semites are completely unaware of the absurdity of their replies. They know that their remarks are frivolous, open to challenge. But they are amusing themselves, for it is their adversary who is obliged to use words responsibly, since he believes in words. The anti-Semites have the right to play. They even like to play with discourse for, by giving ridiculous reasons, they discredit the seriousness of their interlocutors. They delight in acting in bad faith, since they seek not to persuade by sound argument but to intimidate and disconcert. If you press them too closely, they will abruptly fall silent, loftily indicating by some phrase that the time for argument is past." Jean-Paul Sartre

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by pnutjam on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @09:45PM (#38946818)
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by Spivak on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @02:52PM (#38942330)
I don't know why you're being downvoted, shame is one of the most powerful motivators that exists in humans; I'd put money on it being the most powerful. People who are loudly disagreeing don't understand that "shaming (v.)" doesn't always equate to shame actually being felt in the target of said shaming. The act of shaming loses a lot of effectiveness when you can find a community of people who will tell you that it's not actually shameful and that, "no actually the people shaming you are wrong" because those people will suddenly be your best friends. This can be good thing, homosexuality, or bad thing, nazis. And the internet has made every one of those communities 0 distance from everyone. It's why people who try to employ it cut you off from your support networks.

Shame is so effective when it actually lands that you can never fully deprogram it -- I will live with my Catholic guilt for the rest of my life.

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by redcobra762 on Thursday January 11, 2024 @12:07PM (#38955075)
Setting aside how wrong everything you just wrote is, companies aren’t people and do not have shame.
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by Spivak on Thursday January 11, 2024 @01:22PM (#38956340)
Sounds like someone is jealous they didn't get to have any of the apple.

This is why words have meanings. Companies aren't people and hence "shaming a company" can't possibly mean "shaming the legal entity" because that's nonsense but instead shaming the humans that make up that legal entity. Saying such a thing is impossible actually treats the company as an autonomous metamind.

I interpreted what you said as nonsensical and I'm making that your problem isn't really an argument.

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by redcobra762 on Thursday January 11, 2024 @01:41PM (#38956685)
You’re saying things like “metamind” but I’m the person writing nonsense? Okay, bud.
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by boxed on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @09:39AM (#38939406)
Like how Apple says about the App Store rejections:

> Running to the press never helps.

Except of course, in reality we know that it ABSOLUTELY DOES. In fact, it has been often times the ONLY thing that has helped.

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by BeetleB on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @11:07AM (#38940081)
With humans. With companies it's pretty effective - especially if the post hits front page.

Ask Troy Hunt: https://www.troyhunt.com/the-effectiveness-of-publicly-shami...

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by zelon88 on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @11:47AM (#38940534)
Security is at a point where shame is required. You deserve to feel shame if you have an unjustifiable security posture like plain text passwords. The time for politely asking directors to do their job has passed. This is even the governments take at this point. Do it right or stop doing it at all.
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by sleepybrett on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:28PM (#38940927)
Is it, often times hacks like this drive people out of business.
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by Dah00n on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @03:27PM (#38942637)
It is? I'd say shaming is the best tool there is.
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by redcobra762 on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @03:48PM (#38942873)
Positive interactions trump negative interactions when your goal is to encourage lasting change.
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Thursday January 11, 2024 @02:10AM (#38948811)
"Change" could mean a careless, incompetent or reckless company going out of business, a net positive for possible future victims of their conduct.
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by samstave on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:28PM (#38940928)
>What is wrong with shaming when it's warranted?

Says some pests

---

Shaming for businesses and politicians should be encouraged, not just warranted.

Product Recalls are a form of corporate shaming, but public discourse about companies or politicians should be encouraged, and shaming them should always be warranted.

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by refulgentis on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:44AM (#38936661)
Read their partner's post they link to, the way they put it, they were hanging out in a chat, "remembered chattr.ai" and then downloaded a Firebase pwn GUI. No mention of scanning .ai domains or anything of the like. That combined with the odd self-promotion of "half of America's fast food chains" (?), leads me to a rather negative assessment of intentions and talent here.
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by KomoD on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:04PM (#38941303)
> "remembered chattr.ai"

They didn't say that, you just made that up.

This is what they said:

"when we remembered the existence of a scanner we made for firebase and found https://chattr.ai"

And in MrBruh's post, the way they found it was scanning .ai domains, using the same scanner that Eva remembered they had made.

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by deboostedstory on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @02:16PM (#38942000)
it was changed after being called out

https://archive.is/jUtip

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by refulgentis on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:07PM (#38941342)
You're absolutely right: thing is, they rewrote it between the comment you're replying to and your comment. (overnight EST)
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by xxs on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:56AM (#38937083)
Plain text passwords, seriously. At that point, I'm not sure what would be a similarity with any other engineering profession. The plain text passwords are beyond any rhyme or reason... and then returned to the end user client. If anything, I'd consider it malicious negligence - in the EU the leak would be a GDPR issue as well.
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by MrBruh on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @02:17AM (#38937198)
Don't worry, it was only a couple passwords for their admin accounts.
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by bitexploder on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @11:29AM (#38940346)
The issue is it is often impossible to distinguish from a white hat or a black hat hacking your live systems. It can trigger expensive incident response and be disruptive to the business. Ethically, I think it crosses a line when you are wasting resources like this, live hacking systems. There is usually a pretty clear and obvious point where you can stop, not trigger IR, and notify the companies. Not saying that was the case here, but I have been doing cybersecurity assessment work for 17+ years. Even when you have permission sometimes the juice isn't worth the squeeze to keep going as you often have proven the thing you needed to or found the critical defect. There is a balance to whtie hat activities and using good sense to not waste resources.
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by logifail on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:21PM (#38940866)
> There is usually a pretty clear and obvious point where you can stop [..] sometimes the juice isn't worth the squeeze to keep going as you often have proven the thing you needed to or found the critical defect

Those who are tasked - and are being paid(!) - to "[do] a cybersecurity assessment" will typically be given a brief.

For those who aren't tasked - or being paid(!) - to do this stuff, things are much less clear. There's no defined target, no defined finish line, no flag you have been requested to capture.

(I don't work in cybersecurity now, but <cough> I did get root on the school network way back when, and man, that took some explaining..)

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by bitexploder on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @07:55PM (#38945918)
If you aren't being tasked and you aren't being paid it is still really clear. Go look at almost any bug bounty and they will give you really clear "when to stop terms" Often the moment you access data you aren't supposed to access (exposing PII) or come to a point where you could even potentially disrupt the operation of the system you need to stop.

When we begin any assessment on a production system we have a very clear discussion about the rules of engagement. But we are often authorized to access data someone that is not authorized can't legally access with their unauthorized bug hunting. Once you have some experience and understand the relevant laws it is pretty clear when you should stop without violating the law. The general threshold when you are authorized is that you stop if it would risk the stability of the system. If you aren't being paid the general rule is once you have accessed others' PII you need to stop. If you broke an authorization control or accessed any functionality a regular user can't, you need to stop.

Gaining root to any network you don't own or have authorization to operate is clearly crossing the line. You went from finding issues to actively exploiting them. If you have to actively exploit to find an issue and you don't own the system and you don't have permission you don't do it.

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by logifail on Thursday January 11, 2024 @08:41AM (#38952044)
> Gaining root to any network you don't own or have authorization to operate is clearly crossing the line

Q: As an attacker - whatever colour your hat - how are you supposed to know if any particular action may gain you root unless/until you try it?

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by anticorporate on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:26PM (#38940908)
> Ethically, I think it crosses a line when you are wasting resources like this, live hacking systems.

I agree with everything you wrote except this sentence. There is no ethical obligation not to waste a company's time.

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by bitexploder on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @02:17PM (#38942006)
Well, for me there is. As an actual cybersecurity professional I feel bound to not create extra work unless it is for some clear and valuable purpose. Coordinating with the company expends minimal effort and can save them a lot of effort. That is just the right thing to do. It is mostly the wrong, already overworked, people's time getting wasted anyhow if you do trigger an incident or investigation.
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by apetresc on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:39PM (#38941682)
Why not?
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by troupe on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @11:39AM (#38940447)
The potential downside of stopping once you find a critical defect is that the company may not take it seriously unless you go just a bit further and show what you can do with the defect. In this case, showing that it gives you access to the admin dashboard.
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by bitexploder on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @02:19PM (#38942031)
Generally, hacking into a live system without permission is strictly illegal. Once you have discovered some surface level vulnerability you are legally obligated to stop, at a minimum. You can't just keep hacking and exploiting things that cross a certain, generally clear threshold, without permission. Intent definitely matters, but you can still end up in jail if a prosecutor has a hair up their ass and decides they have a good case against you.

I do agree, some of the time you need fireworks to get the right people's attention. You could argue there is some moral imperative there, but ethically you are in the wrong if you keep going. Just have to decide of the moral imperative outweighs clearly breaking the law in situations where you don't have permission.

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by Dah00n on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @03:26PM (#38942625)
It is illegal as soon as you break in. Going as far as possible, without destroying anything, is no more illegal than stopping early, but gives less proof of security problems.
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by bitexploder on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @07:49PM (#38945864)
"Break in" in a modern web app pretty much happens the moment you access data you aren't supposed to access. Not damaging anything is irrelevant. I mean, no one destroyed anything in the Equifax hack. They just retrieved all the data.
Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @02:37PM (#38942180)
> The issue is it is often impossible to distinguish from a white hat or a black hat hacking your live systems. It can trigger expensive incident response and be disruptive to the business.

If your servers are connected to the internet, you can expect that people from countries that won't prosecute them will try to break in. This will happen, almost immediately, as soon as they're connected to the internet.

If your servers have been properly secured, this doesn't matter. If they have not, you are paying for that incident response regardless and the only question is if the context is today because of some innocuous kid or a month from now because of some black hats from Eastern Europe and your company's internal database of everything is now public information.

You want it to be the innocuous kid.

> There is usually a pretty clear and obvious point where you can stop, not trigger IR, and notify the companies.

This is obviously not the case.

Suppose you suspect the company could be using a default admin password. Contacting them without confirming this a pointless waste of everybody's time. Checking it takes two seconds, and if you're wrong you just won't get in and will be one of ten billion failed login attempts against a public-facing server. If you're right, the successful login to an admin account from a novel external IP address could very reasonably trigger some kind of alert, which could very reasonably trigger an incident response when the staff knows that nothing should be logging into that account from there. Or it might not, because the kind of company that uses default passwords may not have thorough monitoring systems either, but you have no way to know that.

There is no point at which it would be reasonable to contact them prior to doing the thing that could trigger an incident response.

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by bitexploder on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @07:58PM (#38945958)
> This is obviously not the case.

It really is though. People just don't understand the ethics of white hat hacking.

> Suppose you suspect the company could be using a default admin password

Putting in that password on a system you don't own without any sort of permission to do so is very clearly against the law. You are accessing the system without permission. You just walk away if you want to be ethical about it.

The only ethical path is to let them know you have some reason to believe they are not using secure passwords or whatever. Accessing their system illegally is not the move. It just isn't the white hats problem.

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by AnthonyMouse on Thursday January 11, 2024 @01:48AM (#38948676)
> People just don't understand the ethics of white hat hacking.

People just think they understand ethics, even if they don't.

"Don't break the law" is an incredibly poor foundation. Many laws are ill-conceived, ambiguous, overly broad and widely ignored or manifestly unjust. Using this as the basis for ethical behavior would require you to be unreasonably conservative and pedantic while regarding complicity in an injustice as ethical behavior. (It also implies that you could never use ethics to inform what the law should be, since it would just tautologically be whatever you make it.)

"Don't knowingly cause net harm" is at least as valid, but then admits the possibility of curiosity-based shenanigans that could lead to the revelation of a vulnerability that saves innocent people from the consequences of it being later exploited by someone nefarious.

> Putting in that password on a system you don't own without any sort of permission to do so is very clearly against the law.

Driving 1 MPH over the speed limit is very clearly against the law, even if the orphanage is relying on you to have the funding letter postmarked by end of day.

Walking your date home while you're intoxicated is very clearly against the law (public intoxication), even if the alternative is that they drive themselves home while intoxicated.

Ethics is something else.

> The only ethical path is to let them know you have some reason to believe they are not using secure passwords or whatever.

But you don't, really. Your belief may even be purely statistical -- suppose you expect that if you try the default on many servers at different companies, there will be at least one where it works, and you'd like to report it to them, but you have no idea which ones unless you try.

> It just isn't the white hats problem.

If you have the capacity to prevent likely harm and instead do nothing, what color is your hat?

Re:How I pwned half of America's fast food chains, simultane... by bitexploder on Friday January 12, 2024 @10:22PM (#38977035)
I mean, I am a literal expert in this field <appeal to authority> what do I know. I will just state I have read the relevant laws and feel I have a good understanding of what underpins the ethics of this industry and white hat hacking after almost 2 decades immersed in it. You are mixing up morals with ethics. With ethics we have clear and unambiguous lines. Morals, that’s on you more or less.