News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by geraldwhen on Friday January 05, 2024 @01:01PM (#38882244)
Owl doesn’t have a mother. Miscellena is from an interracial household. Crissy has a physical disability of some kind and cannot walk.

Daniel tiger jams in diversity at every opportunity.

It’s handled far better than anything Disney creates, I’ll give you that, but it is not simply the story of a nuclear family.

Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by afavour on Friday January 05, 2024 @01:12PM (#38882412)
> Daniel tiger jams in diversity at every opportunity.

It clearly doesn't given that Daniel Tiger's family, the primary family unit of the show, is a heterosexual couple.

> interracial

I guess I'm losing track of what we're supposed to be offended about now. OP suggested that depicting a heterosexual couple was “brave”, I pointed out that it happens all the time. Are we now arguing that there should be absolutely no instances of mixed-race, orientation or disabilities in kids shows at all?

Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by eterpstra on Friday January 05, 2024 @01:52PM (#38883003)
Jack has ADD Chili's sister is infertile Winton, Judo, and the Terriers are from single parent households There's a deaf kid featured in Turtleboy There's a wheelchair kid in Quiet Game "Chocolate Milk" from Tradies is in a mixed breed relationship In fact, the whole fact that different breeds are interacting is an allegory for racial inclusion.

So yeah, Bluey gets a little "woke" here and there. Sorry, not sorry.

Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by skyyler on Friday January 05, 2024 @01:07PM (#38882350)
Chrissie is based on a character from the original Mr Rogers show.

You are trying to find things to be mad about, it seems.

"interracial household"? That's something you take issue with?

Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by nindalf on Friday January 05, 2024 @01:14PM (#38882441)
> Miscellena is from an interracial household

I’m so sorry you and your child had to witness that. Must have been quite traumatic.

Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by sophacles on Friday January 05, 2024 @01:29PM (#38882653)
Wow, so you're offended by:

diversity (aka the acknowledgement that people of different ethnic/racial/religious/etc backgrounds can interact without conflict)

single parents (in a country with an absurdly high divorce rate)

interracial couples

physical disabilities

That's just kinda gross.

Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by theultdev on Friday January 05, 2024 @03:55PM (#38884821)
He never said he was offended by those things.

Just those things don't always need to be in all kid shows.

You can support those ideals and not want pandering in your show.

Crazy, I know.

Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by skyyler on Friday January 05, 2024 @04:04PM (#38884925)
Any inclusion is pandering to some people.
Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by theultdev on Friday January 05, 2024 @04:07PM (#38884954)
So the GP was happy with a show that was relevant to his family.

Yeah I think we're on the same page.

Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by skyyler on Friday January 05, 2024 @04:35PM (#38885298)
It's almost like people just want to be upset about how other people are living their lives for some reason.
Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by theultdev on Friday January 05, 2024 @04:40PM (#38885341)
Yup, just let people enjoy Bluey and live their own lives.

There's plenty of "woke" stuff to enjoy if you want to live life that way.

Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by skyyler on Friday January 05, 2024 @04:42PM (#38885365)
Oh, believe me, gay and trans furries love Bluey. It's pretty much our fav thing, it's so insanely popular with the LGBT+ crowd.
Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by theultdev on Friday January 05, 2024 @04:42PM (#38885370)
Ok? My Little Pony was in the same boat. Doesn't really change anything.
Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by skyyler on Friday January 05, 2024 @04:43PM (#38885375)
It's insanely popular and I certainly don't want to stop anyone from enjoying it :)

Was it pandering when My Little Pony had a lesbian couple?

Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by theultdev on Friday January 05, 2024 @04:50PM (#38885441)
Never watched it, my point was another group enjoying something doesn't really effect what another group gets out of it.

For me it depends on how it's presented. The characters shouldn't announce what they like to fuck. That's jarring, pandering, and very inappropriate.

No idea how it was portrayed so I can't say.

Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by skyyler on Friday January 05, 2024 @04:53PM (#38885469)
>The characters shouldn't announce what they like to fuck.

Has that happened in a kids show you've seen?

Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by theultdev on Friday January 05, 2024 @04:56PM (#38885502)
No. The shows I screen never say or portray anything sexual.

They will find out that out on their own, without the help of kid shows.

I have no idea what the character's sexual preferences are and I don't want to know.

Curiously, how was it presented that they were lesbian, and who was lesbian? One of the ponies? lol.

Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by skyyler on Friday January 05, 2024 @04:58PM (#38885530)
Wait, why did you bring up characters on children's show announcing their sexual proclivities then?

Are you just getting angry about a hypothetical? Help me understand where you're coming from please

Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by theultdev on Friday January 05, 2024 @05:00PM (#38885554)
I'm not angry? And I didn't bring it up, you brought up the lesbian in MLP.

How was it presented in the show?

Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by skyyler on Friday January 05, 2024 @05:21PM (#38885804)
Why did you bring up whether the characters want to fuck?
Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by theultdev on Friday January 05, 2024 @05:34PM (#38885942)
Because that's what your sexual preference essentially is.

Why is it relevant in a kid's show?

Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by skyyler on Friday January 05, 2024 @05:43PM (#38886052)
There's so much more to relationships and human connection and even romantic relationships than that.

Get your mind out of the gutter.

Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by theultdev on Friday January 05, 2024 @05:51PM (#38886142)
Connections can be made in kids show without referencing sexual preferences, that's my point.

I just fail to see why you need to make a pony a lesbian in a kids show.

Why bring that up at all?

Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by afavour on Friday January 05, 2024 @07:34PM (#38886990)
> Why bring that up at all?

So that it reflects the real world, perhaps? Same reason shows have families with moms and dads in them.

Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by skyyler on Friday January 05, 2024 @05:54PM (#38886168)
Why bring up couples at all?

Are the heterosexual couples going to tell the kids about the sex they're having?

Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by theultdev on Friday January 05, 2024 @05:55PM (#38886190)
That's why I said it's how it depends how it's presented, and you never explained so I don't know if it was appropriate or not.

Many kids shows I enjoyed never had any couples or parents in them, which avoids that altogether.

Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by skyyler on Friday January 05, 2024 @06:25PM (#38886484)
That's really great, good talk, buddy.
Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by theultdev on Friday January 05, 2024 @06:43PM (#38886637)
You too, pal.
Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by skyyler on Friday January 05, 2024 @06:58PM (#38886743)
Thanks :)
Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by dragonwriter on Saturday January 06, 2024 @02:21PM (#38894429)
So is any exclusion.
Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by sophacles on Friday January 05, 2024 @04:04PM (#38884924)
Is it pandering? None of those things are rare, and I'd be surprised to find out any significant portion of the population wouldn't encounter them in their own school. It's literally just a representation of the real world.

I guess preparing children for the world that exists is "woke" or something.

Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by theultdev on Friday January 05, 2024 @04:08PM (#38884967)
Bluey prepares kids more for the real world more than the corporate HR messages the US shows have.

It's not about checking diversity boxes, it's about handling your emotions.

And yes, we're all tired of "woke" shit, that's not the real world, but it tries to parade as it is.

Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by bcrosby95 on Friday January 05, 2024 @04:41PM (#38885348)
In my 8 year old's classroom there is:

A kid in a wheelchair. Another with mild autism. Another whose being raised by the grandparents because her mother is a drug addict. Another with pretty severe alopecia (this being her "best friend"). One of her other friends has been very sad because her aunt was killed in Israel.

This is all "real world". And it affects us despite it not happening to our family. At least not yet.

Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by theultdev on Friday January 05, 2024 @05:12PM (#38885710)
You teach morals to handle all situations.

You don't have to directly have brokenness, sex, rape, drugs, and murder in kids shows even if those things exist in the real world.

Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by sophacles on Friday January 05, 2024 @05:23PM (#38885826)
I find it easier to learn abstract things like morals when there are also examples presented along-side them. More so when those examples are practical and applicable to my life. I find this to be a common sentiment.

Are you really trying to say that showing brown people and kids with a single parent is equivalent to showing rape and drug use?

Perhaps you should pause and reflect on your own morals if you think these are equivalent.

Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by theultdev on Friday January 05, 2024 @06:03PM (#38886261)
First off, you brought up someone being killed as a real world struggle, so don't act like I pulled these real world events out of nowhere and tried to equate it to "brown people" (your words) alluding that I'm racist or something.

Second, my point was to show you that not everything in the real world needs to be depicted directly in kids shows. Not to make an equivalence of those listed things, but to test the consistency of the logic.

Learning morals you can learn how to handle those situations and ideals in the future without being introduced to inappropriate things too early in life.

Perhaps you shouldn't try to make an ad-hominem attack on my morals because you can't interpret it correctly. If you didn't understand, you could have asked for clarification.

Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by sophacles on Friday January 05, 2024 @07:00PM (#38886758)
I'd argue that encountering people that are slightly different than one's self is a normal daily reality for most people, and that using those people as characters in the protagonists' lives is just making the show relatable. I don't think it's a moral lesson any more than having parents who don't murder every episode is a moral lesson - sure it's an example of decent morals but it's not a lesson in morality.

That is to say, using same logic on "depicting brown people" and "depicting rape" is fundamentally flawed, it doesn't make sense to apply the same rules to "proximity to disabled people" and "murder" they aren't remotely in the same category. They are fundamentally different, and even if they were somehow similar enough to apply the same logic, they are not in any way similar in scope, its like claiming that showing a kid keeping a $100 bill they find on the street is somehow the same as showing a kid planning a multibillion dollar crypto heist... they involve different morals, different situations, and different consequences for every single person involved - that is they aren't the same.

Further, I never brought up someone being killed - that was a different person. You can tell because we have different usernames.

Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by ethanbond on Saturday January 06, 2024 @09:44AM (#38891793)
Isn’t the point of kids media to help prepare them for the real world?
Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by rglullis on Saturday January 06, 2024 @02:49PM (#38894715)
Not at all? How much "preparing for the real world" was there in Hanna Barbera cartoons, or GI Joe, Thundercats, Looney Toons, etc?

One could argue that cartoons of an era are descriptive of current culture, but to take them as prescriptive seems a terribly misguided idea.

Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by fredoliveira on Friday January 05, 2024 @01:58PM (#38883103)
> Owl doesn’t have a mother. Miscellena is from an interracial household. Crissy has a physical disability of some kind and cannot walk.

Oh man, god forbid a child being exposed to the vile, vile ideas of single parenthood, interracial love, or physical disability! How dare they, I say!

Sigh.

Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by evan_ on Friday January 05, 2024 @05:27PM (#38885882)
> Miscellena is from an interracial household

it's "Miss Elaina", you racist dipshit

Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by dragonwriter on Saturday January 06, 2024 @02:20PM (#38894412)
So the argument is no longer that presenting an intact heterosexual nuclear family is worthy of positive note, but that instead presenting exclusively intact monoracial nuclear families is worthy of positive note?

With the former, I would agree, except that its so common that while it may be positive its hardly noteworthy; with the latter... just no.

Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by geraldwhen on Saturday January 06, 2024 @05:18PM (#38896106)
You misunderstand. In the case of Daniel tiger, and Disney properties, these points of diversity are the point. They serve no greater story purpose.

Contrast this with the Korean drama “Moving”, where two kids raised by single parents find common ground. They’re both poor. Their households are broken in similar ways. This is why western media is trash. You can’t separate The Message from the media whatsoever.

Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by dragonwriter on Sunday January 07, 2024 @12:11PM (#38902971)
> You misunderstand.

No, I don't. A standard was set that the problem was the absence of media depicting intact nuclear families. Daniel Tiger depicts intact nuclear families, but was argued to not be a counterexample to the complaint because it also shows other families and because one of the intact nuclear families it shows is interracial.

This clearly shows that the problem is not the absence of depictions of intact nuclear families, but the presence of other families (and interracial families, even when they are intact nuclear families.)

And you’ve reinforced that with this post, complaining that there is insufficient story justification for these deviations from your preferred norm, which, again, demonstrates that your problem is not the absence of positive depictions of intact nuclear fanilies but the presence of other families (and interracial nuclear families) without sufficient justification for the departure from your preferred exclusive norm.

Re:Australia's 'Bluey' conquered childrens' entertainment by dang on Sunday January 07, 2024 @04:38PM (#38905402)
Can you please stop posting flamewar comments to HN? You've done it repeatedly, not just in this thread and not just on this topic, and you've repeatedly broken HN's guidelines. (e.g. like you did with the swipe at the end of https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38715161 - you went from making substantive points to a cheap putdown which was obvious flamebait.)

I'm sure you have substantive things to say, but when you toss in Molotov cocktails along the way, it becomes flamebait and you're breaking HN's rules—regardless of which position you're fighting for or against. You've been doing that repeatedly, it isn't cool, and it's also not in your interest because it makes your comments less persuasive. People will react to the provocations, lose your substantive points, and in the process the thread turns ugly. By doing this, you damage not only the thread but the community.

If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the site more to heart, we'd be grateful. Note these:

"Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive."

"Please don't use Hacker News for political or ideological battle. It tramples curiosity."