News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by paxys on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @03:47PM (#38859670)
I know it is inevitable, but I'm dreading the day when 100% of devices have fast broadband-level connectivity everywhere on the planet and there's truly nowhere you can go to just disconnect. Already in the last few years with satellite internet getting affordable you see people in remote RV camps or backcountry hikes or on boats in the middle of the ocean texting and video calling away, streaming the latest news and catching up on work emails. It's just going to keep getting worse.
Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @03:55PM (#38859776)
> you see people in remote RV camps or backcountry hikes or on boats in the middle of the ocean texting and video calling away, streaming the latest news and catching up on work emails

They want to text and call and stream and email. You don't. They can. You don't have to. I get what you're saying. But lamenting advances on account of some folks' poor impulse control is neither here nor there.

Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by paxys on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @04:15PM (#38860040)
You don't exist in a vacuum. If people around you are connected then you are as well. You can still hear their cell phone pings. You can see that strangers gathering by your campfire and having conversations is more and more infrequent. And "sorry I didn't have network" is no longer a convenient excuse when you are on these trips. It's never as simple as "oh just let them do their thing" when talking about a broad cultural change.
Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @04:24PM (#38860143)
> You can still hear their cell phone pings

This is valid. That said, if you're close enough to hear a cell phone ping, you've chosen proximity. You're close enough to hear a lot of other sounds. You retain the option to move away.

> "sorry I didn't have network" is no longer a convenient excuse when you are on these trips

To whom are you giving this excuse? Because if you were previously saying you were going somewhere without connectivity, you can still say you're going to reject connectivity.

Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by nickpp on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @04:18PM (#38860077)
I miss spending time in the evenings as a child with my grandparents at candle light, before electricity got brought to their remote village. They told us stories, we watched the flame flicker and we sang. It was a simpler, smaller world. But our modern world is an undeniable better one - they were the first to acknowledge, when they were still alive.
Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by lewdev on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @04:51PM (#38860401)
I don't get it. These things are all still possible to do. It's just the less preferred thing to do.
Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by secstate on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @07:32PM (#38861666)
I found out recently Switzerland doesn't use European SIM cards. Had WiFi in the rental, but as soon as we started walking around Luzern we were text message only. The experience was kind of like turning off the TV that's on all the time. Everything got quiet and I became more aware of the people I was with. I guess I can just turn my phone off, or turn data off, but so long as I have to WANT to do it, I wont. And that's maybe as human a conclusion I can draw. Candle light and wood smoke still exist, but unless we're kinda forced towards them, we'll always go towards the bright lights and warmer rooms.
Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by nickpp on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @05:27PM (#38860724)
Of course. They're not around anymore though, so...
Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by r00fus on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @04:49PM (#38860384)
> But ours is an undeniable better one.

Is it? Honestly, global trade/capitalism has ravaged our planet - we have a fire season nearly everywhere now, ocean acidification/plastic gyre. The same engine that can give us global wireless broadband has polluted our planet beyond restoration.

Yes, medicine and technology is arguably better for most but increasing income inequality is making everything less available to all.

I would urge you to confirm your priors on whether the concept of "ongoing progress" is a state of nature, or a belief system.

Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by Dalewyn on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @04:50PM (#38860395)
Stop consuming the news so much and you'll realize the world is not anywhere as bad as the pundits would want you to believe.
Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by sgu999 on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @05:36PM (#38860794)
I don't think that's fair, it's entirely dependant on where the person you're replying to lives.

Life quality in cities is still improving, assuming one can afford it. In more rural areas, often simultaneously subject to all kinds of attacks on nature and a lack of opportunities and essential services, I'm not so convinced...

Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by nickpp on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @05:31PM (#38860760)
Never in our civilisation history have we had so much available to so many.

Yes, nature and the planet are in a worse state but the humanity is in a much better one. And I am confident with time and technology we will improve them both. The engine of progress has already solved much harder problems than the current ones.

Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by sgu999 on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @05:40PM (#38860824)
> The engine of progress has already solved much harder problems than the current ones.

I suspect the harder problems you're thinking of are all technological. The current ones we are facing are social and political more than anything, so I don't share your optimism...

Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by nickpp on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @05:49PM (#38860905)
Yes, there is a danger there, and it wasn't always an easy path, but anti-tech movements were always around. Call them luddites, de-growth, doomers, anti-tech, anti-nuclear greens, anti-development (or their e economic equivalent: anti-capitalists, marxists and communists) - historically they always lost to progress.

Humanity is huge and diverse - if a group of people decides to stop evolving and stagnate, another will gladly steal their place.

Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by sgu999 on Thursday January 04, 2024 @05:18PM (#38873084)
> historically they always lost to progress

What you call "progress" is what led us here. Remains to be seen if "here" is a trap. You seem to think that everything is fine since everything will be fine, but that opinion doesn't have a consensus right now. I prefer to remain more doubtful.

Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by Turing_Machine on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @07:05PM (#38861488)
> If people around you are connected then you are as well.

If there are other people around you at all, you're not really in the backcountry.

Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by ygjb on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @04:17PM (#38860059)
I agree with you, with one proviso. I hope there is a proliferation of camp grounds and sites with rules forbidding things like projectors and speakers over a certain volume level.

The number of projectors I have seen in use at campgrounds in the last couple of years is just profoundly irritating.

Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @04:25PM (#38860145)
> camp grounds and sites with rules forbidding things like projectors and speakers over a certain volume level

100% agree.

Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by pmontra on Monday January 08, 2024 @03:37AM (#38909502)
I missed this projectors thing but I've not been camping for the last 4 years. What I hated last time was the needlessly super bright flashlights campers started to use to walk around the campsites. I understand the psychological and commercial call for brighter is better, but they are really harsh to the eyes to the other people. Any 1000 lumen light is more than enough to see where you're walking and its maybe more than what people use at home to lit their rooms. I used one of these lights to bike at night in the woods. My flashlights are less bright than that. I see lights with 3000 lumens on sale on Amazon now.
Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by panarky on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @04:08PM (#38859942)
I live in the middle of a modern and densely populated city. I'm perfectly capable of disconnecting without leaving my sofa.
Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by hutzlibu on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @04:12PM (#38860005)
"You don't have to"

If something becomes the norm, it creates social pressure to do the same. Sometimes you can opt out, but not always and usually with a cost.

Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by Dalewyn on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @04:19PM (#38860090)
Wise people tell social pressure to sincerely fuck off.

One of the biggest lessons in life is learning that you don't have to care what the fuck others think about you.

Your life is short, and less than 1% of 1% of all the people you would ever meet will be of any consequence to you, let alone the rest of humanity whom you will never even know existed.

So if you want to disconnect: Go for it. Pedal to the metal. Afterburners blazing. Who the fuck cares? It's your life, not their's. They can leave a voicemail and wait for you to get back at your leisure.

Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by hutzlibu on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @04:36PM (#38860254)
"you don't have to care what the fuck others think about you."

No, but there are still consequences.

"and catching up on work emails"

If everyone is doing this, there will be a expectation of you to do it. And if you don't - you will have to really shine somewhere else, to not get serious disadvantages.

Also I already had various big drama in my life for not being reachable (I still have a phone where I can put out the battery) - so yes, I know how to disconnect and I do. But there is an increasing pressure to be always reachable and when you don't live totally on your own - it is a real struggle to get away from it.

Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @05:19PM (#38860651)
> If everyone is doing this, there will be a expectation of you to do it

Most people don't go to low- and no-connectivity areas to recreate. If you're bucking the trend by doing that now, it isn't much different to turn your phone off (or leave it at home).

Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by hutzlibu on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @05:32PM (#38860767)
"Most people don't go to low- and no-connectivity areas to recreate."

Well, those who do, are unfortunately often those who do it, so they don't catch Corona via the 5G waves ...

But my point was more that right now, it is still an acceptible excuse (in some areas) to not be reachable, to say you just had no reception. That is going away soon - and then it seems I will have to defend every time I turn off my phone and someone wanted to reach me with something "important". So yes, the problem is not the technology in my eyes, but the social expection. The result is still the same.

Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by rad_gruchalski on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @04:52PM (#38860412)
> No, but there are still consequences.

Can you name them?

Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by Espressosaurus on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @05:31PM (#38860762)
Getting poorer reviews. Not being seen as a team player.

Seriously? Have you ever worked where the expectation is you'll be on-call, even on your vacation?

If we're talking just socially, that will impact how the people you interact with perceive you. It's the same thing, as work, but with different stakes in terms of your ability to move among social groups that use texting constantly.

Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by Dalewyn on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @09:02PM (#38862221)
>Getting poorer reviews. Not being seen as a team player.

>If we're talking just socially, that will impact how the people you interact with perceive you.

I reiterate for emphasis: Stop caring what the fuck others think about you.

>Have you ever worked where the expectation is you'll be on-call, even on your vacation?

You are working at your choice of employment out of your own free will; you chose to work that job that demands you be on call even on vacation. If you don't like it, you have a right to quit and find other arrangements better suited to your lifestyle.

Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by hutzlibu on Thursday January 04, 2024 @03:15AM (#38864479)
"If you don't like it, you have a right to quit and find other arrangements better suited to your lifestyle."

I suppose you do not have a family or other ties? When you are young and unbound, the possibilities are a big bigger, than when you are settled down and don't want to uproot everyone to get a new job.

Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by averageRoyalty on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @07:27PM (#38945663)
> Seriously? Have you ever worked where the expectation is you'll be on-call, even on your vacation?

No, because that would be illegal in my country, as it is in many. One call to the relevant government department would launch an investigation and at minimum lead to hefty company fines and the practice stopping.

If that's normal to you, you should fix it or leave whatever country you live in. That would be laughable to most of us if it weren't so sad.

Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by janice1999 on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @04:05PM (#38859908)
I think the bigger problem will be omnipresent HD audio and video real time surveillance by governments both directly and also indirectly via commercial devices like smart glasses.
Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by kilolima on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @04:04PM (#38859890)
The worst outcome will be that urban Californians will be able to buy houses anywhere and work remotely, driving up local prices and making every where look like orange county.
Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by owenversteeg on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @04:21PM (#38860117)
Reposting a comment I made some time ago here:

When I was much younger I also felt a profound sense of loss when I found that the Iridium constellation covered the globe.

Thankfully our shared thought that you can't be away from everything is not true: caves, anything underwater or dense forests around the world are totally inaccessible for any satellite devices.

Also, not sure if you've used any satellite devices but even in most conditions you're still pretty away from things. You have to set up the device with a view of the open sky and wait several minutes for a text-only message of a handful of bytes. Using it in a Costa Rican rainforest was almost impossible.

For better or for worse, there are pretty large parts of the Earth where we will have no Internet for most likely our entire lifetimes.

Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by 0xbadcafebee on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @04:13PM (#38860018)
At Burning Man, I saw a woman getting accosted by a man for having her phone out, "ruining" the experience of the guy who came there to disconnect.

She was trying to talk to her relatives, because her house had caught on fire, while her kids and babysitter were home. She was freaking out and trying to find out if everyone was ok.

You don't like that other people are connected, when you want to disconnect. That's really a you problem, not a them problem.

Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by laweijfmvo on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @03:56PM (#38859794)
Nothing worse than someone on a Facetime call on their way up Half Dome, I agree...
Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @03:58PM (#38859823)
> Nothing worse than someone on a Facetime call on their way up Half Dome

Is it so different from two hikers conversing?

Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by puchatek on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @04:11PM (#38859988)
Yes. People focused on their phones are even more oblivious to their surroundings than two people having a conversation.
Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by the_third_wave on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @06:53PM (#38861397)
Not only that, the fact that the person on the other side of the conversation does not have any clues as to what is happening and as such is wont to keep on blathering while her conversation partner really needs to focus his attention on that slippery slope/crumbling ledge/onrushing traffic/deer jumping in front of the car/rushing river/person in distress/...(fill in the blanks)... makes telephone conversations much worse than those between two or more people in the same location.
Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by joe5150 on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @04:06PM (#38859920)
In the most material terms, they're probably more distracted than two people who are both present and chatting which isn't great for anybody's experience. People also tend to be shouting into the phone, worse if they're not using headphones so you get to hear the other person shouting back.

At a psychic level it also kind of sucks in ways that are harder to describe.

Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by firstime111 on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @04:06PM (#38859919)
Yes
Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by khaki54 on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @03:52PM (#38859732)
Time to take up spelunking!
Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by paxys on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @03:53PM (#38859741)
Haha zero chance of that. Watching videos of people trying to fit into those dark, tight spaces triggers way too many phobias for me.
Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by Scoundreller on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @05:05PM (#38860524)
keep watching the videos to continue your desensitization journey
Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by hammock on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @03:56PM (#38859781)
For anyone who wants to try it out, my favorite place ever is Craters of the Moon National Monument. So many lava tubes to explore.

And protip the people that actually do it as a hobby tend to call it caving not spelunking :)

Would love to hear HNer recs on caving spots

Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by khaki54 on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @09:48PM (#38862436)
Ha, yep but spelunking is a way better word!
Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by carabiner on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @04:11PM (#38859991)
Such a tryhard take. Look at me, I want everyone to know I'm not like other girls. Get over it. I probably spend 10x as much time outdoors as you but I can disconnect anywhere. Even here.
Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by Waterluvian on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @04:06PM (#38859921)
It’s an odd social issue. You can obviously regulate your own access. So the issue distils to it being regrettable that other people aren’t behaving in a way that’s necessary to satisfy one’s desired ambience. Ie. enforcing behaviour of others for our benefit.

I imagine there may eventually be sufficient demand for private locations that ban devices?

Is there something about this that makes it distinct from a “kids these days” kind of lament?

Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by onlyhumans on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @05:12PM (#38860578)
I’m not looking forward to cellular connected IoT devices. Like my tv watching me and I can’t just turn off its lte connection
Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by jtriangle on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @06:09PM (#38861065)
Your problem isn't that you can get broadband everywhere, it's that you want to regulate the lives of the people around you for some reason.

You, yourself, are free to live more or less however you please. You are not free, in any way, to regulate the lives of people around you. If your happiness depends on the people around you behaving according to your rules/values/etc, then you'll be profoundly unhappy regardless of them checking their instagram.

Which is funny, because you can't manage to regulate yourself, but, you desire to regulate other people, as though you are at all qualified to do so. The reality is, you're only qualified to make people as miserable as you are.

And while I don't disagree that, people being overly connected is a huge problem, and a general cancer that's eating humanity itself, I understand that it's not my job to save the world, only myself, and once that's sorted out, I might be able to save a few people around me that I hold dear. Anything broader than that has one outcome, and that's failure, not just for myself, but also the people I care about the most.

What you need to do is disconnect-in-place, you don't need a forest or a mountain or an ocean to do that, you can do it right now, spin yourself down, feel yourself breathe, clear your head. You'll suck at it at first, as you have sucked at many things you're now good at, embrace the suck, and get to it, stop basing your wellbeing on things rightfully outside of your control.

Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by briffle on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @07:03PM (#38861478)
Oh man, those crazy people on boats in the middle of the ocean. I mean why would you want to be connected to things like PredictWind [0] and other tools to make your trip safer, or be able to communicate with the manufacturer of your water maker, engine, or other systems if there is a problem, etc. PredictWind have had Irridium Go [1] support for years, but now that starlink is available, most are switching to get more than 2 times a day updates.

[0] https://www.predictwind.com/?lang=en [1] https://www.predictwind.com/iridium-go

Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by x-complexity on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @08:08PM (#38861904)
...I deeply abhor your take.

The fact that you see other people getting on with their lives as something that needs to be wrenched away from them lest they ruin your naturalist fantasy, deeply irks me to no end.

Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by codersfocus on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @08:45PM (#38862120)
There are places that have rules like No Smoking Allowed, No Photography Allowed, No Idling Allowed, No Phones Allowed, etc.

It’s perfectly reasonable for nature parks to have a no devices policy.

Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by lijok on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @09:11PM (#38862268)
How will you contact for help if devices are banned?
Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by crtasm on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @10:36PM (#38862685)
Radio? How else was it done before mobile phones?
Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by lijok on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @10:39PM (#38862700)
I was under impression radio fell into the “devices” category
Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by crtasm on Thursday January 04, 2024 @12:54PM (#38870098)
I think we both know what GP means.
Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by lijok on Thursday January 04, 2024 @02:24PM (#38871129)
So what are we saying here? Nature parks should reject people who can't afford a radio, even if they have a phone which can be used for calling for help?
Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by crtasm on Thursday January 04, 2024 @03:26PM (#38871826)
Packing a phone for use in emergencies sounds fine to me.
Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by relativ575 on Friday January 05, 2024 @06:13AM (#38877888)
Why do they need to pack an extra phone instead of using their primary one?
Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by crtasm on Friday January 05, 2024 @02:48PM (#38883867)
...
Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by deepfriedchokes on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @08:17PM (#38861970)
Nothing is worse than portable bluetooth speakers on hikes.

If anyone has any connections with the REI Board of Directors please ask them to stop selling that crap.

Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by lxgr on Friday January 05, 2024 @08:53AM (#38879025)
I'm afraid not only REI sells these...

But you raise a good point: A hike being quiet or noisy depends much more on the social norms of your fellow hikers than their and your ubiquitous reachability.

I've been annoyed by large groups on narrow trails talking at the top of their lungs in order to be able to lead one big conversation, and at the same time I would not even notice somebody texting a few meters away from me as long as they have their phone on silent.

Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by lijok on Wednesday January 03, 2024 @09:17PM (#38862296)
You are describing one of the most impactful achievements that humanity is making strides towards. 100% of devices having fast connectivity anywhere on the planet is a literal superpower.

We need to fix our browsing habits. Saying you dread the day when anyone anywhere can call for help because your poor impulse control might interrupt your disconnect is just ridiculous.

Re:Starlink launches "cellphone towers in space" for use wit... by wmoser on Thursday January 04, 2024 @09:20PM (#38874942)
As someone that works on a boat in the middle of the ocean, I welcome more accessibility. Being able to talk to my wife and kids while at work is so much better than being cut off. Also the better availability of weather information or technical information if there is a problem can literally be life saving. I also sometimes miss the days when I would go to work and literally have email every few weeks. Things were simpler then but I was young, single without any real responsibilities. Unfortunately time has moved on and even checking my bank account has become impossible without being able to receive 2FA messages. [There was a period of time where I could get enough service to load the app/web site but they insisted on a text l or email which was loading so slowly it would take more than half an hour that the 2FA was good for.] During COVID I had a coworker from Mississippi whose wife had to drive to the school to get photo copies of school work because they didn’t even have internet at their house with cell phones. Modern government and society has made internet connection mandatory to participate. Some people don’t have a choice of being somewhere remote.