For example, the "MSI Pro H610M 12VO" hyperlinked in the article has a manual that shows it as having two SATA power ports, and an image shows one such port connecting to a single drive. Now I imagine this is a simplified illustration and maybe each port will have enough power to supply 3-to-4 HDDs (depending on current rating of the HDDs of course), but that's still a max of 8 HDDs. Meanwhile the non-12VO PSU I use has four ports available that can each connect to 3-to-4 HDDs each, so a max of 16 HDDs, and it definitely has enough spare power to support them because I sized the PSU for that need.
Your adapter board that will need an extra pair of switching power supplies. I doubt you'll even need an extra board.
(Not that I expect anybody to actually adopt the standard. People will continue to drag their feet, mostly because there aren't enough gains to switch.)
An adapter from 12VO to SATA power can work, or it can be a $5 board that does $2,000,000 of damage.
That timestamp is where they address this issue. It seems the argument is that in sleep mode (low power modes), the system will draw overall less power with ATX12VO vs today's standards.
Further, if you go directly to the specs: https://edc.intel.com/content/www/us/en/design/products-and-..., you can see they talk about ALPM (alternative low power mode) which seems to be the reasons for this design.
If it's so desperately vital that they have some "it's low-power, but still doing something like checking for notifications" mode, couldn't this be done with a mini-coprocessor with the specs of a RasPi 1 running on +5VSB?
I somewhat wished they’d gone to 48vdc instead of 12vdc, though to further reduce cabling, but I guess that would be a big change, the 12vo seems much simpler
components use 12v, 5v, or 3.3v in pcs currently. why do the step down from 48->12 instead of running 12v naturally? 12v is also what is used by the most power hungry components of a PC (GPU).
In fact the exact opposite is true, it is safer in practice. In a true fault condition into flesh the currents involved aren’t substantially less safe (4x microamps is still microamps). With protection circuitry and current limiting, the permitted currents are that much lower, which is easier to deal with.
which are cut because of costs.
It depends on the current. Your 48 V suppply won't supply microamps, but Amps.
There shouldn't be an intermediary step down to 12V. Google's been doing direct step down from 48V->~1V with GaN fets for half a decade, which is vastly more power efficient than the two step 277V->12->1V that many server systems go through.
It'd also be amazing to have usb-c extended power (48v) be something we could just add for free, essentially. (Alas this is complicated by needing to step down to lower voltages too, necessities some semiconductors in the delivery path to usb-c, which would have some voltage drop. This strongly implies to me something more like 52V or 54V would be ideal instead of 48V.)
For anything that typically runs under 100W, I agree that 48V is ridiculous. But I would love love love to see some motherboards for ThreadRipper that have GaN fet for direct conversion from 48V, or stuff like that. It'd be pretty niche. But it should be an option!
One of the big potential winners could be people with solar; being able to run your system directly off your solar bank would save double digits percent of power, versus inverting then converting back.
You're right that in the immediate term we'd see a lot of intermediary conversions. I'd love to have a better game plan, for not just motherboards but other components to expect either 48v or wider voltage inputs. Non-trivial to support 10-60V but if that was a market expectation & not a niche need we'd see very affordable solutions spring up practically overnight. There's already a range of usb-c focused power converters that are exceedingly cheap that could step in for this need!
Edit: seems like Google is using two stage conversion primarily, but not necessarily 4:1 48V:12V. Their fixed ratio converter seems to have a 6:1 mode (8V) target as well, or be configurable for even bigger ratio (they said up to 12:1 in their talk). As of 2019, a bit of change of tune from original 2016 ambitions. Good talk? https://youtu.be/aBkz2JR4UVs
The GPU voltage is also step down to 1-1.5v by graphics cards VRMs.
An additional issue is that the sweet spot for voltage conversion is around the 1:10 ratio. Going 120V -> 12V -> 1.2V makes a lot of sense, 120V -> 48V -> 1.2V less so.
I don't buy this at all. 48V and 96V are standard telecom DC voltages. Those parts already exist.
If anything, this would be a big boon as it would enable using both telecom and consumer parts interchangably (thus increasing volume on both).
You use a 100K resistor if you really need to keep things at 0402 for 100V. (P=V^2/R = 0.1 watt)
A 0.1uF 0402 ceramic cap rated at 100V is half a cent.
The biggest problem are your power transistors with max Vgs. That requires a bit of care at 24V; requires quite a bit more care at 48V; requires very specialized topologies at 96V.
So the solution is to.make 75 % or even 100 % of the mainboard, the PSU. /s
Its like a code refactoring
Mains power is dangerous and should be kept in a box separate from current limited lower voltage DC, which could be on the mainboard instead.
Nothing actually needs 12v, it all just converts locally to the desired voltage which is why the mainboard is already a psu
RAM doesn't have an interface voltage, it uses the voltage supplied, typically around 1.2V.
USB uses 3.3v signalling up through USBHS. (USBSS is 1V differential.) The higher voltages are for power delivery only.
And M.2 using 3.3V is kind of weird and limiting.
Though RAM does its own conversion now, starting with DDR5.
If you put most on 12v but you have a motherboard pulling more from 5v, you have a problem. Currently power supplies divide it based on average motherboard usage, but these slowly change, and your old power supply will stop having the optimum mix.
The solution is to output it all on one rail.
There was a time when the 5V and 3.3V rails on ATX power supplies weren't vestigial, but that era was shorter than the current era of all the major high-power components using a 12V supply.
Surely this will simply move part of the complexity from the PSU to the motherboard? Resulting in more efficient and simple PSUs, but more inefficient and complex motherboards? I've only ever had motherboards fail because of leaky capacitors or busted voltage regulators. The only PSU failure I've ever had was on account of a broken fan. Won't this lead to more motherboard failures?
The cynic in me thinks that Intel would be fine with that, because that way they can sell more motherboard components.