News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:12VO power standard appears to be gaining steam, will red... by Arnavion on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @01:54PM (#38774700)
I'm not too worried about the complexity. What I *am* worried about is that your number of SATA power ports on your motherboard will become the limiting factor for how many SATA drives you can connect. The number of SATA *data* ports on the motherboard was not as much of a limiting factor because you can add data ports through M.2 / PCIe adapters.

For example, the "MSI Pro H610M 12VO" hyperlinked in the article has a manual that shows it as having two SATA power ports, and an image shows one such port connecting to a single drive. Now I imagine this is a simplified illustration and maybe each port will have enough power to supply 3-to-4 HDDs (depending on current rating of the HDDs of course), but that's still a max of 8 HDDs. Meanwhile the non-12VO PSU I use has four ports available that can each connect to 3-to-4 HDDs each, so a max of 16 HDDs, and it definitely has enough spare power to support them because I sized the PSU for that need.

Re:12VO power standard appears to be gaining steam, will red... by marcosdumay on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @01:59PM (#38774761)
Why not get a SATA PSU just like you are adding a dara adapter?
Re:12VO power standard appears to be gaining steam, will red... by Arnavion on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @02:04PM (#38774818)
So two PSUs / power bricks? I'll just stick with non-12VO PSUs and boards as long as I can, and if enough people think like me then mobo manufacturers will continue stalling on 12VO.
Re:12VO power standard appears to be gaining steam, will red... by namibj on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @05:59PM (#38777026)
No, an active converter from a PCIe power connector or such to SATA power. Perhaps integrated in many sata cards.
Re:12VO power standard appears to be gaining steam, will red... by marcosdumay on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @06:03PM (#38777046)
Does the power brick come exclusively with the motherboard connector? I'm pretty sure you will be able to get one with extra connectors for power-hungry peripherals.

Your adapter board that will need an extra pair of switching power supplies. I doubt you'll even need an extra board.

(Not that I expect anybody to actually adopt the standard. People will continue to drag their feet, mostly because there aren't enough gains to switch.)

Re:12VO power standard appears to be gaining steam, will red... by RecycledEle on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @06:19PM (#38788073)
A second PSU causes huge issues with currents leaking where they should not go.

An adapter from 12VO to SATA power can work, or it can be a $5 board that does $2,000,000 of damage.

Re:12VO power standard appears to be gaining steam, will red... by doublespanner on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @04:43PM (#38776396)
I suspect that you will have to get add in cards or drive caddies that also do power conversion, but these already exist (although expensive). More than 2-4 drives is starting to hit a point where you should start thinking about a different platform anyway.
Re:12VO power standard appears to be gaining steam, will red... by dwattttt on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @05:18PM (#38776706)
In the post PATA days the available data connectors all map to disks 1:1, it knows how many power connectors would be needed for them. Expansion cards could probably supply power as well as data? I suppose other uses for those connectors would need to provide shims, much like the molex shims they use now.
Re:12VO power standard appears to be gaining steam, will red... by jdboyd on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @06:08PM (#38777075)
A 12VO PSU can still choose to provide SATA power ports, and I imagine that at some point there will be PCI-E to SATA power adapters for PSUs that support 2x GPUS and users who want 1x GPU and a lot of SATA.