News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The right to use adblockers by izzydata on Thursday December 21, 2023 @04:20PM (#38727121)
If something is not sustainable without ads that seems to imply that people are not willing to pay for it. If people aren't willing to pay for it then I'm not sure it is a good business model.

Regardless of the consequences I'd rather see an ad free internet. If that means Youtube can't exist and Facebook can't exist and Google can't exist then so be it.

Re:The right to use adblockers by sbarre on Thursday December 21, 2023 @04:34PM (#38727298)
Yeah like I hate to say this, but do we need _that many_ sites about cameras, gadgets, games, cars, or <insert topic>?

Do all those sites need to be commercial enterprises with sales teams and large editorial teams? Or could they go back to being hobby passion projects?

Or maybe there's just a handful of them and they are subscription-based for people who _really_ want that kind of news, and the best writers and creators gravitate to those sites and they build a sustainable business that way?

The ad-supported business model has allowed perhaps _too many_ people per topic area to try their hand at garnering eyeball in exchange for what is ultimately the same repackaged content, because they don't need their users to pay for the content, they just need to draw them in to support the sales of ads or tracking data.

This incentivizes all kinds of user-hostile behaviours in the quest for profit (or even just sustainability).

Re:The right to use adblockers by ryandrake on Thursday December 21, 2023 @04:48PM (#38727500)
You shouldn't hate to say it--it's absolutely true. We don't need yet another listicle site choked with ads competing in a zero sum slugfest for some top organic search result spot. Nobody needs it. The only thing these sites serve is the greed of whoever is producing them. The Internet is worse off the more of these that exist. This shouldn't be a controversial opinion.
Re:The right to use adblockers by sbarre on Friday December 22, 2023 @10:30AM (#38735051)
I guess I have a slightly more charitable take on this, in the sense that the Internet has an amazingly low barrier to entry for putting your content online and reaching an audience, and I think overall that's actually a great thing.

So I don't begrudge people trying to build an audience by publishing online about things they know or love, but one of the downsides is that the Internet's "content is free" tradition - that comes from hobbyists working out of passion - has led to a whole industry of "how do we make money off people without taking money from them" and that's ads and tracking.

And then the game becomes "how many people can I draw in to my site by any means necessary" instead of "how can I create engaging content".

Re:The right to use adblockers by dageshi on Thursday December 21, 2023 @04:48PM (#38727497)
I think you're about 5ish years out of date.

Most of the sites on cameras, gadgets, games, cars e.t.c. are dead or dying and have been replaced by youtube channels, many of them run by hobbyists.

Re:The right to use adblockers by whstl on Thursday December 21, 2023 @06:27PM (#38728605)
This is an interesting point in the SEO conversation.

SEO, content farms and content marketing are killing the open web and Google is enabling it, perhaps because they're ok with the web being replaced by 4 or 5 websites, Youtube being the biggest of them.

Re:The right to use adblockers by sbarre on Thursday December 21, 2023 @05:23PM (#38727932)
Ehh sure, that's a take.

There's still plenty (too many?) commercial websites - most that include their own YouTube channel - trying to compete for eyeballs by repackaging the same preview/review/press materials that companies send out..

They're no longer the only game in town though, that's for sure. I don't disagree that many hobbyists (definition up for debate) can compete on merit for the audience, which is awesome of course.

Re:The right to use adblockers by jjulius on Thursday December 21, 2023 @05:13PM (#38727791)
The same rhetorical question still applies for hobbyist YT channels, IMO. Especially since many of them lock the more useful content behind subscription walls.
Re:The right to use adblockers by johnnyanmac on Friday December 22, 2023 @05:01AM (#38732712)
>Especially since many of them lock the more useful content behind subscription walls.

useful content? which ones? average youtuber incentives (be it through YT or Patreon) tend to just be a community private server on Discord to talk to the creator with. Or cut content that they couldn't air on youtube anyway (e.g. extended commentary on a video that would be de-monitized otherwise. There's way too much competition to lock out signifigant part of a Youtube's channel's content.

Re:The right to use adblockers by mewse on Thursday December 21, 2023 @05:59PM (#38728306)
Hobbyists who are sponsored by NordVPN. ;)
Re:The right to use adblockers by JohnFen on Thursday December 21, 2023 @06:29PM (#38728630)
They represent a small fraction of the hobbyists on the web. The majority that I see aren't wanting or accepting sponsors of any sort.
Re:The right to use adblockers by AlbertCory on Thursday December 21, 2023 @05:42PM (#38728136)
do we "need" 50 brands of soda, or 300 varieties of cheese?

> The ad-supported business model has allowed perhaps _too many_ people per topic area

"Too many" according to whom? You?

If no one "needs" them, then they won't get viewers and thus eventually won't get ads, either.

Re:The right to use adblockers by ghodith on Thursday December 21, 2023 @05:52PM (#38728228)
> If no one "needs" them, then they won't get viewers and thus eventually won't get ads, either.

Demonstrably untrue; there are plenty of spam sites that hide themselves and play the SEO game well enough to (temporarily) get my eyeballs. These sites only satisfy a "need" insofar as my grandparents have a "need" to respond to emails from Nigerian scammers.

Re:The right to use adblockers by AlbertCory on Thursday December 21, 2023 @06:36PM (#38728723)
> (temporarily) get my eyeballs

train your eyeballs better, then. Or theirs.

Re:The right to use adblockers by thecrash on Thursday December 21, 2023 @07:46PM (#38729385)
Why do the villagers keep complaining about the widespread bandit problem when they could simply improve their swordfighting or hire bodyguards?
Re:The right to use adblockers by AlbertCory on Thursday December 21, 2023 @08:10PM (#38729616)
Someone's been watching The Seven Samurai.
Re:The right to use adblockers by johnnyanmac on Friday December 22, 2023 @05:03AM (#38732726)
I'm sure villagers wish they could adblock or PiHole the bandits. would be a win-win situation.
Re:The right to use adblockers by sbarre on Thursday December 21, 2023 @07:14PM (#38729066)
Ok.. This feels needlessly confrontational?

Sure, yes, according to me. That was implied when I posted my opinion on here, a discussion forum where we share opinions.

My opinion is that the ad-supported model itself, which doesn't rely on having paying readers/users, but rather on attracting said users to then be paid for showing them ads or collecting their data, has perhaps unintentionally created too low of a bar for entry (in hindsight) and as a result, the fierce competition for profit has led to user-hostile incentives in order to stay alive in such a crowded landscape.

I think the low barrier to entry for putting up websites or creating content online are a net positive, for the record. I love that anyone can just put their content online and compete for an audience on merit (more or less), rather than needing some large monetary investment up front.

But I also think the ad-supported monetize-the-shit-out-of-users model is a bad thing, and benefits from the same low barrier to entry.

But you take the good with the bad I suppose.

Re:The right to use adblockers by AlbertCory on Thursday December 21, 2023 @07:45PM (#38729379)
> This feels needlessly confrontational

if you make an assertion about there being "too many" of something, it begs for someone to ask how you know this. Almost anyone on HN might ask that. However, you've now added some nuance to it.

I think in general a low barrier to entry is a good thing: most of the music on Bandcamp wouldn't have even been available to the public 50 years ago.

Most of the self-published books out there now also would never make it past the Mean Girl "agents" who populate literary agencies. Most of those books are crap, but then so are the books from major publishers in airport bookstores.

Re:The right to use adblockers by sbarre on Saturday December 23, 2023 @10:11AM (#38744739)
> if you make an assertion about there being "too many" of something, it begs for someone to ask how you know this.

Ah yes, the old "must challenge every statement" gambit. You must be fun at parties.

Re:The right to use adblockers by eli on Thursday December 21, 2023 @05:14PM (#38727817)
What's stopping people from creating these hobbyists sites now? Or you from using them?
Re:The right to use adblockers by bshacklett on Thursday December 21, 2023 @05:29PM (#38727997)
Discoverability is a problem. The average hobbyist website has no chance of making it to the top of the pile of search-engine-optimized trash websites that are returned by search engines. For example: Quora often takes up half of my results these days.

…and if the hobbyists know that their sites aren’t going to get any visitors, there’s little reason to make them in the first place.

Re:The right to use adblockers by struant on Thursday December 21, 2023 @07:04PM (#38728971)
If we just ban all advertising then there are no more SEO optimized sites trying to get that ad-revenue. So hobbyists should have no trouble with popularity if the ad-supported internet goes away.
Re:The right to use adblockers by johnnyanmac on Friday December 22, 2023 @05:08AM (#38732746)
hobbyists who may one day want to have a lifestyle out of this wouldn't benefit. And those would be the sites that have a reliable stream of content instead of maybe a burst of content for 2 months before getting bored or burned out and maybe making a piece of content every 5 months afterwards.

For all the negatives, a consistent stream is one of the biggest benefits from professional content creators, be it traditional news, Youtubers, streamers, or even bloggers.

Re:The right to use adblockers by sbarre on Thursday December 21, 2023 @05:21PM (#38727906)
Nothing! And I do use a lot of them personally. I pay for several creators on Patreon and subscribe to a few creator-owned website publications to encourage work I care about most...

These are not mutually exclusive things, sorry if I implied that.

My point was more about the race to the bottom with commercial content sites/networks/publications in what seems like a borderless space, with increasingly bad incentives to draw in users.

Re:The right to use adblockers by awiejtlaijwr on Thursday December 21, 2023 @06:13PM (#38728438)
Well, ads are the business model. Ads make it possible to sell things that people don't want to pay for. Newspapers and magazines wouldn't be possible without ads. It's been that way for literally centuries. But internet ads are definitely a new level of crazy. I'm conflicted about Youtube in particular because when you filter out all the social viral crap, Youtube is one of the greatest educational resources ever created by human beings. I can go search youtube for any subject imaginable and get broad and deep video instruction on the subject from dozens of different perspectives. In grad school when a professor did a terrible job of explaining a niche technical subject, I could go on Youtube and watch lectures from a variety of other professors. I can go to Youtube to learn how to cook, how to dance, how to build a wooden canoe with hand tools, so many amazing things. It's a shame we can't find a better way to fund and maintain the educational portions of it. I don't know of a better way.
Re:The right to use adblockers by paulddraper on Thursday December 21, 2023 @04:33PM (#38727285)
Or, some people are willing to pay for it, and some are willing to pay for it indirectly (via ads).

Hulu

I wouldn't characterize it as a "bad" business.

Re:The right to use adblockers by neuralRiot on Thursday December 21, 2023 @05:04PM (#38727687)
If past experience serves me right, usually it would rther be: Some people are willing to pay for it indirectly by ads and some are willing to pay and still get ads later.
Re:The right to use adblockers by bediger4000 on Thursday December 21, 2023 @05:06PM (#38727713)
Ads are creeping in to paud-for Hulu. That's the nature of ads (or maybe advertisers): they corrupt the medium they support.
Re:The right to use adblockers by paulryanrogers on Thursday December 21, 2023 @06:27PM (#38728607)
Some of us want an ad supported internet. And the ad / no ad Internets are not mutually exclusive. They can coexist.

You can chose to only frequent ad-free sites and services. You wouldn't even have a use for an ad blocker.

Re:The right to use adblockers by bee_rider on Thursday December 21, 2023 @07:24PM (#38729181)
There are too many low-effort ad supported sites currently. I don’t think we should make ads illegal, but it would be preferable if all ad-supported sites would identify themselves as such and then link aggregators, search engines, or even web browsers could have an easy “don’t show links to ad supported sites” button.

It really seems like a win-win.

Re:The right to use adblockers by jefftk on Thursday December 21, 2023 @09:47PM (#38730357)
It would be very easy for link aggregators and search engines categorize sites as ad-supported or not: load the page in a browser (which these sites often already do) with an ad blocker extension and see if it identifies anything. But my guess is they're not interested in doing this, since it rules out a lot of valuable pages. For example, HN is ad-supported.
Re:The right to use adblockers by dageshi on Thursday December 21, 2023 @04:43PM (#38727434)
It's a well understood part of human nature that it's very difficult to charge for something you previously gave away for free.

The vast majority of the web has been given away for free by being ad supported, that's never going to roll back, the expectation has been set.

Thankfully, the wider public might find ads irritating but they'd still prefer them over paying so ads aren't going away anytime soon.

Re:The right to use adblockers by izzydata on Thursday December 21, 2023 @05:00PM (#38727649)
I know it will never happen. At least not anytime in the near future.

There is usually a group of people advocating that using an adblocker is like stealing or killing businesses. My counter argument is that I'm fine with that. Don't offer something for free when I have complete control over how it is displayed on my end if you can't stay in business if I block some part of it. Everyone on the planet should use ad blockers for their own protection and to actively change the internet to a non-ad business model.

I will never stop using ad blockers and I don't feel bad about it in the slightest.

Re:The right to use adblockers by crazygringo on Thursday December 21, 2023 @04:59PM (#38727634)
> that seems to imply that people are not willing to pay for it.

No, it's just often that the logistics make it too inconvenient.

For various impossible-coordination reasons, micropayments and monthly-subscription-to-all-news just haven't taken off, despite consumers being willing to pay.

Re:The right to use adblockers by johnnyanmac on Friday December 22, 2023 @05:13AM (#38732778)
sounds like enough people weren't willing to pay. It's very easy to espouse demand, but in reality not everyone will put their money where their mouth is.

Or in a worst case scenario, everyone who is willing to pay already is, and the business is indeed non-sustainable. But I doubt this.

Re:The right to use adblockers by crazygringo on Friday December 22, 2023 @11:24AM (#38735660)
No, I said precisely the opposite.

People can be willing to pay, but corporations are unable to coordinate amongst themselves to receive the payment or make it frictionless enough. This is not an uncommon situation in economics. It's not a fictional concept.

E.g. you can look at Spotify as a success story of coordination. That wasn't inevitable though. If record labels had chosen to launch fragmented independent music streaming services, that wouldn't have changed people's willingness to pay for all music for $10–12/mo., even if it weren't available.

Re:The right to use adblockers by johnnyanmac on Saturday December 23, 2023 @11:59AM (#38745699)
I imagine it comes down to costs either way. If it was quick and easy companies would have done it. And that willingless is partially based on if more buyers come in from it. They wouldn't do it for the most dedicated buyers nor for the ones who think it's too expensive.

>you can look at Spotify as a success story of coordination.

By basically giving the record labels all the money and make the actual artists not really make money on their craft. I guess nothing can be perfect.

But music is realtively cheap to produce (but not cheap at the top, of course). There is also a reason Netflix has been price hiking and still bleeding content and customers as everyone rolls their own. You simply want more control when each episode of content is 7 figures.

Re:The right to use adblockers by changoplatanero on Thursday December 21, 2023 @05:35PM (#38728076)
> If something is not sustainable without ads that seems to imply that people are not willing to pay for it. If people aren't willing to pay for it then I'm not sure it is a good business model.

Advertising can be a perfectly fine business model. Look at the radio, television, and newspaper industries. These have existed for decades and have brought much good to humanity even though they need advertising support to exist.

Re:The right to use adblockers by soraminazuki on Thursday December 21, 2023 @09:07PM (#38730061)
The crucial difference being that traditional advertising didn't enable mass surveillance.
Re:The right to use adblockers by arp242 on Thursday December 21, 2023 @05:23PM (#38727937)
Things like newspapers and comic books and whatnot have had ads for over a hundred years. These types of things partly being sponsored by ads is hardly a new concept.

Ads are not going away.

I would argue that the internet has gone rather overboard with it, but that's a different thing.

Re:The right to use adblockers by JohnFen on Thursday December 21, 2023 @05:55PM (#38728263)
For me, the problem that internet ads have that older media ads didn't is all the spying that comes with them. It's the spying that elevates them from being incredibly annoying to being just plain evil.
Re:The right to use adblockers by arp242 on Thursday December 21, 2023 @06:19PM (#38728496)
That's not an ad problem, that's a tracking problem. I think it's important not to conflate the two concepts. But other than that, yes, I agree.
Re:The right to use adblockers by JohnFen on Thursday December 21, 2023 @06:24PM (#38728570)
They are two different things, but you don't get ads without the spying. Often, you get the spying even if you block ads.
Re:The right to use adblockers by arp242 on Thursday December 21, 2023 @06:54PM (#38728888)
That's not true; there is nothing preventing anyone from serving ads without tracking, and I'm pretty sure there are solutions out there that do exactly that, even if they're not the most commonly used. Like I said, ads were viable in print, well before the internet.

Just <img href="/ad.png"> would work, and has no tracking and is essential the same as print media ads (or those YouTube sponsors for that matter). While this would probably net in less income than e.g. the Google ad stuff, it's completely viable and I'm sure there are people and companies doing something like that.

But uBlock will block that, because it's an adblocker and not a trackblocker, and that's clearly an ad. That's perfectly fine, but what I want is a trackblocker

Re:The right to use adblockers by JohnFen on Thursday December 21, 2023 @06:57PM (#38728913)
> there is nothing preventing anyone from serving ads without tracking

I'm not saying it's impossible, I'm saying it's not done.

Re:The right to use adblockers by arp242 on Thursday December 21, 2023 @07:15PM (#38729078)
How do you know? For starters there's a bunch of solutions out there that specifically market "non-tracking" as a feature. I assume they're being used.

Come to think of it, you're on a site with track-free ads right now: the ycombinator launches/hiring posts really are just ads.

And whatever the status-quo exactly is right now, what I responded to was "if something is not sustainable without ads then it's not a good business model", and tracking really doesn't come in to play in discussing to what degree the very concept of ads is or isn't desirable, as that's just an entirely separate issue.

Re:The right to use adblockers by Nextgrid on Thursday December 21, 2023 @07:51PM (#38729434)
> that specifically market "non-tracking" as a feature

Which ones? All the non-tracking, supposedly-GDPR-compliant ads/analytics out there just use a convoluted and overcomplicated interpretation of the GDPR to claim their solution complies while it ultimately doesn't, or stretch the "legitimate interest" definition quite a bit.

For example, if it's able to reidentify a user coming back to a website, then it doesn't matter if they hash the IP address 20 times which is salted with the outcome of a crystal ball and all under the supervision of a magic unicorn, it's still processing personal data for non-essential purposes and should require explicit consent.

Re:The right to use adblockers by arp242 on Thursday December 21, 2023 @08:42PM (#38729873)
What's the superlative of conflation? That's what bringing analytics into the discussion here is.
Re:The right to use adblockers by Nextgrid on Saturday December 23, 2023 @04:55PM (#38748644)
I'm just sharing the experience that most of these "privacy" products (whether ads or analytics - the latter seem very popular on HN) only make that claim because of an outlandish interpretation of the GDPR or whatever privacy law they're trying to work around.
Re:The right to use adblockers by JohnFen on Friday December 22, 2023 @10:55AM (#38735326)
OK, let me be very precise, then.

The vast majority of ads are supported by and come with tracking. Sure, there exist sites that do ads in a way that isn't so intrusive, but they're an extreme minority. It's also hard-to-impossible to tell if a site is tracking you or not.

So long as more than a tiny number of sites use ads that involve tracking, it's necessary to treat all sites as doing so.

Re:The right to use adblockers by tedunangst on Thursday December 21, 2023 @10:41PM (#38730707)
https://daringfireball.net/feeds/sponsors/

There is one "tracker" on DF, but it doesn't affect the ad you see. And if you read the RSS feed, you get the ad without the tracking.

Re:The right to use adblockers by johnnyanmac on Friday December 22, 2023 @05:16AM (#38732797)
it's not done as often =/= no one does it. And I feel it is a good distinction to make.
Re:The right to use adblockers by jefftk on Thursday December 21, 2023 @09:50PM (#38730383)
It's pretty hard to do online ads without tracking because of how easy fraud is online. With newspaper, TV, and radio we put a bunch of effort into measuring the size of the audience, but those methods are far easier to subvert online.

If I tell you jefftk.com has 10k daily active users so you should pay me $500 to put a banner on the top of my site, should you believe me?

Re:The right to use adblockers by tootie on Thursday December 21, 2023 @05:29PM (#38728001)
That would eliminate 99% of news. Including anyone on social media.
Re:The right to use adblockers by JoshTriplett on Thursday December 21, 2023 @07:00PM (#38728936)
No, it would eliminate most news sites, and little value would be lost. Frankly, net value might be created that way. People will still write about things that happen, and people will still read that, and money just won't change hands. Or people will read paid news, and the quality will almost certainly improve as a result.
Re:The right to use adblockers by tootie on Thursday December 21, 2023 @10:18PM (#38730574)
No, no they will not. News sites pay reporters. If news sites have no money reporters stop reporting. Journalism costs money.
Re:The right to use adblockers by JoshTriplett on Friday December 22, 2023 @02:44AM (#38731927)
I said "Or people will read paid news", by which I mean news sites supported by subscriptions rather than ads. I don't think that's a likely scenario, but it's another possible alternative world that could arise.
Re:The right to use adblockers by tootie on Saturday December 23, 2023 @09:17PM (#38750473)
Aside from industry news, nobody survives just on subscriptions.
Re:The right to use adblockers by krapp on Thursday December 21, 2023 @05:59PM (#38728305)
Good. 99% of news and almost everything on social media is garbage. Burn it all down.
Re:The right to use adblockers by johnnyanmac on Friday December 22, 2023 @05:18AM (#38732811)
ironically enough, it'd just mean that most news would end up being funded by the government where possible. Which is how the FSFE gets its funding.
Re:The right to use adblockers by tootie on Saturday December 23, 2023 @09:17PM (#38750470)
The only government funded news in the US is VOA. The CPB gives out grants but public media are all responsible for their own budgets and a lot of them (notably NPR and it's largest affiliates in NYC and LA) have been crushed by a drop in ad revenue and cutting back severely on content production.
Re:The right to use adblockers by kevindamm on Thursday December 21, 2023 @04:31PM (#38727261)
Some services would go the subscription route and survive, but then they're limited to the users that are able and willing to pay. I can't imagine offering a search product or wiki product where payment is required. Donations may be a viable option but may not provide enough starting runway.

Maybe I've been drinking too much internet capitalism koolaid, but a completely ad-free internet would not have had the commercial lift we've enjoyed these past 20-plus years.

Re:The right to use adblockers by JohnFen on Thursday December 21, 2023 @05:56PM (#38728271)
> a completely ad-free internet would not have had the commercial lift we've enjoyed these past 20-plus years.

Would that be a bad thing?

Re:The right to use adblockers by sethhochberg on Thursday December 21, 2023 @06:21PM (#38728528)
I’d wager a significant number of people posting here owe their careers to that commercialization - I hate listicles, too, but not so much that I would wish them away and gamble that I ended up with the same standard of living on an Internet reserved mostly for nerds (nerds said lovingly, of course)
Re:The right to use adblockers by JohnFen on Thursday December 21, 2023 @06:26PM (#38728601)
> I’d wager a significant number of people posting here owe their careers to that commercialization

I'm sure that's true, and it would be a bad thing for those people. But for the world at large? It's not clear to me at all that it would be bad.

Re:The right to use adblockers by kevindamm on Friday December 22, 2023 @12:58AM (#38731385)
I'd wager that the pandemic would have gone a bit different too if we hadn't had the internet growth preceding it.

I recognize the double-edgedness of that, too, though.

Re:The right to use adblockers by margalabargala on Thursday December 21, 2023 @04:53PM (#38727555)
> Maybe I've been drinking too much internet capitalism koolaid, but a completely ad-free internet would not have had the commercial lift we've enjoyed these past 20-plus years.

I completely agree that an ad-free internet would not have seen numbers get big as quickly as what we've experienced, but it doesn't necessarily follow that an internet that makes numbers get big quickly is also the internet offering the best user experience.

Usually, user experience gets sacrificed to make the numbers get bigger, faster.

Re:The right to use adblockers by johnnyanmac on Friday December 22, 2023 @05:21AM (#38732827)
>imagine offering a search product or wiki product where payment is required.

I mean, we just called them Encyclopedias back in my day. They won't be as high quality, complete, nor peer reviewed, but there are plenty of fan wikis powered entirely by free labor. no money in nor out.

Search is much harder, but I've been keeing an eye on Unlimited Kagi which seems set to do this very thing. Hope it succeeds.

Re:The right to use adblockers by didntcheck on Friday December 22, 2023 @05:39AM (#38732922)
And most of those wikis are now on Wikia, sorry, "Fandom", which runs some of the most aggressive ads I've seen. The flippant response is to strawman then as evil and greedy, but the less satisfying reality is that web hosting can actually get quite expensive for popular sites, especially with media. And there's the additional cost of defending against abuse, of the DDoS, spambot, or malicious human types
Re:The right to use adblockers by johnnyanmac on Friday December 22, 2023 @11:27AM (#38735696)
Yeah, if the users don't care enough to move to ad-free sort of content, there's not much you can do as a passive viewer. Fortunately, Wikis are in theory easy to migrate should such a motivated user comes along.

That said, these days more and more guides and tribal knowledge is stored in discord servers. I don't know if that's better or worse. At least there's no ads.

Re:The right to use adblockers by giantrobot on Thursday December 21, 2023 @06:35PM (#38728721)
> If people aren't willing to pay for it then I'm not sure it is a good business model.

People literally can't pay a sane price for content. A blog post or warmed over press release isn't worth a penny let alone a dollar. Ads unfortunately are the only mechanism to pay the sub-cent value for content.

Even if you could reasonably conduct a penny transaction that's still an insane price to pay for a blog post or tweet.

So it's not about people being unwilling to pay it's about being unwilling to pay transactable amounts of money for content that's nowhere near worth those amounts.

Re:The right to use adblockers by johnnyanmac on Friday December 22, 2023 @05:28AM (#38732869)
>Even if you could reasonably conduct a penny transaction that's still an insane price to pay for a blog post or tweet.

depends on the content TBH. some (relatively few in the grand scheme of things, but "some" when focusig on otherwise helpful feeds) blogs are worth their weight in gold. some feel like they should pay me to even read it. I do wish a micropayment sort of system was feasible in general so we could test such models. But I'm guessing that's a logistics issue with payment vendors; they probably don't like small, disparate transactions anymore than a GPU.

Still, I've tried the closest thing for a few comic websites back then where you buy "coins" in bulk and purchase new releases a la carte (e.g. say, 2000 coins for $10, and each new chapter is 10 coins. so roughly 5 cents). Doesn't feel too bad.

Re:The right to use adblockers by oh_sigh on Thursday December 21, 2023 @04:57PM (#38727611)
Except that users are willing to pay for it, since a vast majority of them look at the ads and some of them even click on the ads.
Re:The right to use adblockers by neuralRiot on Thursday December 21, 2023 @05:11PM (#38727774)
I wouldn’t have a problem with ads if they weren’t so intrusive and obnoxious. Imagine trying to read a magazine that would jump itself to the page with the “Axe” ad, you go back to the page you were reading and 10 seconds later it jumps to the “Chevy colorado” ad. Or asking the bookkeeper for “a book of holiday recipes” and on you way home in every corner a guy knocks your car window to sell you “holiday food”.
Re:The right to use adblockers by charcircuit on Thursday December 21, 2023 @04:24PM (#38727175)
Why not just ignore sites that use ads? If people find value in ad supported product they can use them and if they don't they can just avoid them and use an alternative without ads or nothing.
Re:The right to use adblockers by BobaFloutist on Thursday December 21, 2023 @05:49PM (#38728198)
If there were a way to filter sites that serve ads out of Google searches, that would be an interesting thought.

As of now, any given random website is far more likely to have ads than not, and many of the drawbacks of getting served ads (tracking, data collection, and performance issues) arise before the page is even loaded enough for you to know they exist.

Re:The right to use adblockers by midasuni on Thursday December 21, 2023 @06:50PM (#38728853)
I don’t use google but surely there is an extension to allow you to block a domain?
Re:The right to use adblockers by izzydata on Thursday December 21, 2023 @04:32PM (#38727281)
If there were no ads anywhere on the internet than everything would be on an even playing field. Currently a site that offers a paid service for something that someone else gives away for free is at a huge disadvantage.
Re:The right to use adblockers by drewcoo on Thursday December 21, 2023 @06:55PM (#38728896)
> If there were no ads anywhere on the internet than everything would be on an even playing field.

In one dimension. Maybe.

Influencers would still be a thing. So would SEO. The web would be like some medieval map with vast uncharted territories and "here be dragons" but also the few known sites where everyone in the known web lives.

Unless we dismantle media and tech monopolies, they will still dominate that web.

Re:The right to use adblockers by charcircuit on Thursday December 21, 2023 @05:16PM (#38727837)
Even if the web was on an even playing field it has to worry about being disrupted by other platforms that allow ads. That could take the form of Web2 which is the web + ad supported sites with backwards compatibility with the original web or it could take the form of mobile apps where users can get useful ad supported apps.
Re:The right to use adblockers by xboxnolifes on Thursday December 21, 2023 @10:03PM (#38730485)
> If something is not sustainable without ads that seems to imply that people are not willing to pay for it. If people aren't willing to pay for it then I'm not sure it is a good business model.

This only holds if you agree that humans are perfectly rational economic agents. I disagree with that and think that there are lots of little interactions where just introducing a financial transaction impacts how people interact.

Maybe If I tallied all of my internet usage, figured out how much I value my internet usage, and then gave each page visit a value I could find out that I value my hackernews usage at $0.02 per link click. But if clicking links directly led to me paying more, my usage pattern would change.

Re:The right to use adblockers by caskstrength on Friday December 22, 2023 @04:13AM (#38732419)
> Regardless of the consequences I'd rather see an ad free internet. If that means Youtube can't exist and Facebook can't exist and Google can't exist then so be it.

But you can already do that by not using Youtube and FB. You just want to deny opportunity to use them to other people who may like to have access to "free" (ad supported) internet services.