This is not to say that this entitles anyone to do so without Apple’s consent, but the argument about resource usage is a straw man here, IMO. This is not about who pays for the servers. Even if Beeper would offer Apple an appropriate portion of their revenue (edit: and they actually do in TFA), Apple would not agree. For Apple, this is about keeping the garden wall up.
Which is the intent of running those email servers. These are the “public-use” servers. The iMessage servers are private.
On iMessage, all messages are stored on Apple’s servers (at least in-transit), even those that would be destined between two Android users communicating via iMessage.
At least with email it’s a bit easier to filter out spam, but iMessage is also E2E encrypted so automatic spam detection is much harder.
There are much better business arguments to make here then "oh no! The 3 trillion dollar company might have slightly more overhead managing text messaging!"
From a business perspective, I'm much more sympathetic to arguments that iMessage is a perk Apple wants to keep as incentive for more users to switch to Apple's ecosystem and, likely more important, lack of cross-platform interoperability raises the cost for existing Apple users to transition to Android.
Are you claiming Apple would have to pay fixed costs a second time because new users were added to the already existing service?
And are you claiming that 1 million dollars is a lot of money to Apple, a company worth over three million million dollars?
I was responding to someone who said the extra overhead for running a chat service that has more people use it would be notable for Apple. A business argument - not a legal one.
No 3rd party batteries in devices or 3rd party ink cartridges either
That's about the strength of it. Unless the protocol is open, paid or otherwise. iMessage is closed and undocumented.
I'm willing to buy all of your property for $1, but that doesn't give me the right to come use it all, just because in theory there is a price I would pay to have it all.
Sure, many atrocious acts are fantastic business decisions. Slavery? Great for business. Massive ROI. Incredibly evil.
Who is auditing Beeper's code for security issues? How big is their security team and their response SLA? How are they encrypting messages at rest? How much money are they prepared to spend on attorneys to defend these stances against various governments? What can their servers see, what do those servers retain? etc etc
Apple makes commitments about encryption and security, shown in-app via message colors, that Beeper has no right to subvert.
Those commitments are only as strong as the recipient's control of their Apple ID credentials. It should be up to them whether they want to entrust a third-party (whether Beeper, or someone with an actual Apple device) with their messages.
I don't see how Beeper makes that any worse - I've listed a myriad of ways a user can choose to compromise the security of any iMessages sent to them. These ways have been known for decades and Apple hasn't done anything (they could lock-out outdated and jailbreakable iOS versions).
Either way, it should be up to the user to decide what they want to do with their messages and how much security they attach to them. After all, even in case of a fully bulletproof solution that would even prevent screenshots, the user is still free to read their messages out loud in a public place or in reach of a recording device.
Also, again, Beeper Mini (different from Beeper Cloud, which is not E2E compatible) operates entirely on-device - no message data transits through Beeper's infrastructure. There's an optional cloud component to enable real-time push notifications but even in that case I believe their server merely relays data and doesn't have the decryption keys.
So you agree, it's wildly unethical to use Beeper because it doesn't give all the users in the convo the right to choose the security of their messages.
Whether you consider that unethical is up to you. Most people don't know or care and everything works out anyway.
It's also an abuse of their market position to discriminate against the competition, and they have done so very successfully.
There are far more subtle, less othering ways to indicate a participant in a conversation isn't capable of the same functionality as others.
Google is pushing RCS only because they are completely incapable of making their own protocol and lord you know they have tried (gchat, hangouts, allo, and now messenger)
And by the way, RCS is entirely carrier dependent. It’s awful. I wish my friends could also use iMessage but Apple is well within their rights to stop people from using their network against their terms of service.
You can. I've been using Beeper Cloud for a year on a Windows desktop. It's fantastic. I also use WhatsApp in that same application.
Before that I had all sorts of workarounds that mostly worked. Like having a Mac VM running in the background with an AirMessage server and then using their web client to access messaging from Windows. Beeper Cloud removed all this nonsense from my life.
You have MANY of them. SMS/MMS and Matrix spring to mind immediately. Mastodon qualifies. You can use RCS today if your carrier has an app like Verizon's Message+. If you want to go all retro, IRC.
That's ignoring the productized implementations all over the place - Signal, WhatsApp, Telegram, Messenger, Slack, Discord, and so on. MSN and ICQ are still running.
That is 100% accurate from the technical perspective.
As an iPhone mobile / windows desktop user I would love an interoperable protocol so I could respond to texts from my desktop
But from the business side Apple's decision is totally defensible and clear
The blue bubbles are a luxury item / luxury signal that let's apple differentiate their products
I assume an internal assessment of that "brand" value from blue bubbles is in the many billions of dollars