> Either way, it should be up to the user to decide what they want to do with their messages and how much security they attach to them.
So you agree, it's wildly unethical to use Beeper because it doesn't give all the users in the convo the right to choose the security of their messages.
It's only as unethical as someone not running the latest iOS version, not having a strong passcode on their device and a strong Apple ID password and observing proper security practices on their main computer to ensure it isn't compromised either.
Whether you consider that unethical is up to you. Most people don't know or care and everything works out anyway.
Either way, it should be up to the user to decide what they want to do with their messages and how much security they attach to them. After all, even in case of a fully bulletproof solution that would even prevent screenshots, the user is still free to read their messages out loud in a public place or in reach of a recording device.
Also, again, Beeper Mini (different from Beeper Cloud, which is not E2E compatible) operates entirely on-device - no message data transits through Beeper's infrastructure. There's an optional cloud component to enable real-time push notifications but even in that case I believe their server merely relays data and doesn't have the decryption keys.