News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by Boogie_Man on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @08:38PM (#38636750)
Can you speak briefly on the economics of you purchasing at a bulk store?
Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by FredPret on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @08:45PM (#38636808)
Try and stop me. I LOVE Costco.

Basically, when I buy something at a regular store, I'm shocked at the recent inflation.

But at Costco, most things have barely budged at all in the past few years. And that's starting at a lower base as well - at the moment it's simply nuts how much cheaper things are there.

In fact, if you look at their financial statements, their entire profit equals their membership fee income - this means you're buying things at cost price on average. And Costco is known to be brutal to their suppliers, using their market position to force lower prices and larger pack sizes onto the manufacturers.

They don't sell everything though - there are some items you have to buy on Amazon or a regular grocery store. But almost (not entirely) every time that Costco sells something, it's the best deal you can get.

Another downside is you have to buy a LOT of what you're buying. So it only makes sense if you're planning ahead somewhat, and if you have room in your fridge/freezer/garage.

EDIT: actually the main drawback is the hugeness and remoteness of the store, and the immense number of other shoppers. But again, this plays into going every couple of weeks and buying ahead. These things are inherent in their model and I accept it. I actually spend less total time shopping now because I do all of it in 60-80 minutes every two weeks.

Another edit: none of this means that the quality is any lower. Somehow, they're delivering excellent meat, produce, and more at a fraction of the cost.

Maybe I should buy shares in this company. They barely have a profit margin though.

Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by tcbawo on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @08:52PM (#38636843)
Product curation at Costco is another key aspect. If Costco sells it then it’s a decent product, they stand behind it, and the product is a good value. I trust them not to pass off bad merchandise on me.
Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by kgermino on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @09:03PM (#38636915)
This is the biggest reason I love Costco. If you need something they're selling you'll only have a couple options, all will be at least decent, and it's usually obvious which one's for you.

E.g. I needed a shredder. There were two, a smaller one and a bigger one. I got the smaller one without needing to think or comparison shop because I know it will work for me (absolutely no issues in 6 years) and it's a decent to great price.

On the very rare occasion I get a dud, they happily take returns. Last winter I returned a two year old fridge and they didn't even ask for evidence of my issue

Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by rahimnathwani on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:34PM (#38637817)
"if you look at their financial statements ... you're buying things at cost price on average"

Not quite.

Costco's gross margin is ~12% of revenue. That means their average markup (including revenue from membership fees) is over 10%. If membership fees are about 2% of revenue, and other income (e.g. commission from the vendors near the exit), then Costco's markup is in the 8% to 9% range.

If we were buying things at cost price on average, then Costco would not have enough money to pay for rent, staff etc.

Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by FredPret on Thursday December 14, 2023 @12:25AM (#38638112)
I mean true cost, not just COGS. If we all had to buy straight from the vendors, we’d have to pay the COGS as well as replicate the functions you mention.
Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by rahimnathwani on Thursday December 14, 2023 @01:06AM (#38638324)
It sounds like you're saying that it's preferable to buy from a retailer whose net profit (as a % of sales) is as low as possible. Because that means the price you pay is as low as possible (relative to what you call 'true cost').

If that's the case, then you could do even better: don't shop at profitable retailers. Only shop at places with really low net income. Better still, shop at places that are so badly run that, even though they have high gross margins, waste so much money on overheads that they lose money overall.

(I'm not suggesting Costco is poorly run, or is a bad place to shop. Just trying to illustrate why focusing on total costs instead of COGS can lead to absurd conclusions.)

Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by lotsofpulp on Thursday December 14, 2023 @01:24AM (#38638426)
> If that's the case, then you could do even better: don't shop at profitable retailers. Only shop at places with really low net income.

What does low net income have to do with anything? Profit margin tells you how much the middleman is keeping. The lower the profit margin, the lower the prices, for something as fungible as retailing consumer goods.

A business needs at least a minimal profit margin to survive a little volatility. That is why Walmart/Costco/Kroger have 2% profit margins. If anyone could deliver those goods for cheaper, they would, but they probably cannot as evidenced by competitors going out of business.

>Better still, shop at places that are so badly run that, even though they have high gross margins, waste so much money on overheads that they lose money overall.

Businesses that lose money tend to get shut down by the owners, since people generally do not like to lose money.

Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by rahimnathwani on Thursday December 14, 2023 @01:34AM (#38638470)
"What does low net income have to do with anything?"

Please read the comment to which I was replying. My whole comment was written to explain why we shouldn't focus on net income, and instead focus on COGS. You're making the same point I was.

Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by IAmGraydon on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @09:12PM (#38636978)
I buy literally everything I can at Costco. All my groceries, paper products, detergents, batteries, light bulbs, tires, appliances, and even many electronics. I even booked a vacation to Saint Lucia through Costco Travel and it was flawless. I have an executive membership, which is $120/year, but also gives me 2% back on all purchases. I spend enough there every year that it completely covers the cost of membership.

I currently spend the same there every month as I did 5 years ago. Inflation has barely touched it except for a few items like beef and fish, which have recently come back down in price.

I don’t understand the complaint some people have that it’s hard to shop there because quantities are too large. I use everything before expiration and end up throwing away very little. For short expiration item like meat, just use your freezer.

Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by kredd on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @08:56PM (#38636870)
Having a Costco downtown and 15 minute walk from me is the best experience a human can get. I just stroll to get one item when I have nothing better to do.
Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by dylan604 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @09:08PM (#38636957)
This must be amazing. There is no Costco within 20 minutes in a car near me.
Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by kredd on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @09:11PM (#38636971)
Yeah, it’s always funny to explain it to outsiders, but I wish it was ubiquitous everywhere. Every time I think about moving away one of the things that pops up in my head is — “ah, but I will miss dt Costco!”.
Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by toomuchtodo on Friday December 15, 2023 @08:07PM (#38660809)
If only Costco built condo builds above them. A missed opportunity to sell condos at Costco!
Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by kgermino on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @09:04PM (#38636924)
Oh what I'd do for that. Even just in a decent biking distance would be amazing. Ours are all in the distant suburbs.

What city has one downtown?

Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by jfim on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @09:11PM (#38636974)
San Francisco has one close to the mission and SoMA area.
Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by kredd on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @09:09PM (#38636966)
Vancouver, Canada!
Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by doublerebel on Thursday December 14, 2023 @12:44AM (#38638217)
Seattle has one in Sodo. With a car wash.
Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by S_A_P on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @08:49PM (#38636830)
I have a relatively large family and the quantities required still don’t make sense for most items in my case. However the gas prices keep me a member.
Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by FredPret on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @08:53PM (#38636853)
They also sell fridges, freezers, and shelves ;)
Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by Paul-Craft on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @09:34PM (#38637103)
Do they sell space to put that stuff? When you're talking "relatively large family," I suspect that's actually the real bottleneck.
Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by flatline on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @08:58PM (#38636883)
Costco travel alone has saved me hundreds if not thousands of dollars in rental cars over the past year. Easily 40% cheaper than the competition.
Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by dylan604 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @09:10PM (#38636969)
tell me more. are you just getting a discount at the normal rental places, or do they have their own? i was not aware of the rental option.
Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by flatline on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @09:15PM (#38637001)
Just another third party booking service. Last month a rental from Budget through Costco travel for a six days in CA was around $340. The same thing on rentalcars.com was over $500.
Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by TylerE on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @09:25PM (#38637055)
Wonder how much of that is CostCo members generally being higher income/lower risk.
Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by dylan604 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @10:19PM (#38637396)
I mean, they let me in as a member. I can tell you I'm not doing anyone any favors in the lowering risk category
Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by taftster on Thursday December 14, 2023 @12:23AM (#38638098)
Hey, at least you're honest about it.
Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by TylerE on Thursday December 14, 2023 @05:49PM (#38648474)
I mean, you joke, but you've shown ability to get to the store, fill out an application, pay the $200 or whatever... that at the very least means you are probably not in, say, the 5% worst risk category. Damages that can be caused to something like a hotel room or rental car are essentially unlimited.. avoiding the worst risks is really good.

Below average is fine, you just want to avoid horrific.

Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by IAmGraydon on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @09:17PM (#38637005)
I shop there for only my wife and I and it’s perfect. I’m curious - what products come in quantities that don’t make sense?
Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by mcphage on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @09:34PM (#38637106)
I get that they sell a lot of things, but buying your wife there? That strains the bounds of credulity.
Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by taftster on Thursday December 14, 2023 @12:25AM (#38638105)
I mean, they have hosted weddings at Costco before. Next step, bride or groom ordering service? Wonder how they handle returns in this scenario. Probably 90 days like electronics.
Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by tomcam on Thursday December 14, 2023 @01:12AM (#38638355)
Obvious trolling, so I’ll spell it out for you. IAmGraydon and I live in the same neighborhood. Obviously, Costco only sells wives in packages of 8 (Kirkland brand). We went in with 6 other friends on this one.
Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by Boogie_Man on Thursday December 14, 2023 @09:10AM (#38641485)
I tried to rob a Costco, but my plan failed because I didn't bring eight guns.
Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by mcphage on Thursday December 14, 2023 @11:19AM (#38643018)
That does sound great for you, but I'm not in a polycule, and I don't think I've got room in my pantry for the spare wives. I guess it's just not for me.
Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by Scubabear68 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @08:55PM (#38636868)
Not everything at Costco is a win price-wise, but if you do even a small amount of research you can find a number of items that are huge wins.

A pint of pure vanilla extract for $9.99. Dog treats at about half the price of pet smart or online stores. Kirkland brand Flonase is about 75% less than you can get at a pharmacy. Kirkland brand Claritin is ridiculously cheap, 365 tablets for under $20.

You very rapidly get back your yearly fee.

Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by 4death4 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @08:41PM (#38636770)
I’m not even sure the economics make sense. Like if I buy toilet paper, I just want to buy as much as possible and not have to worry about it. Same with other staples. Costco delivers bulk goods with excellent quality at a good price. I’m not even sure I’m saving money honestly.
Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by talldatethrow on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @08:48PM (#38636825)
As a Costco/Price Club member since 89.. it's never been the cheapest really. But it's always been the best value.
Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by pottertheotter on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @08:58PM (#38636889)
I still regularly call it Price Club.
Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by yumraj on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @09:11PM (#38636972)
One of the primary reason I love Costco is fewer SKUs.

I don’t have to decide between 20 items of same kind, say white bread. There’s usually 1 or 2 of a kind, generally of great quality. You buy it and move on.

We rely on Costco buyers to do the quality due diligence for us.

Also, even if their price is not the best for an item, I trust it’s good enough. Couple that with their return policy, most purchases become a simpler exercise.

Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by ryandrake on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @09:52PM (#38637231)
Yea this is great. It sucks going into a supermarket and having to choose between nine different brands of tortilla chips. I mean, come on, store. Just sell the best (least expensive balanced by quality) one and don’t stock the rest! I know. First World Problem.
Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by cpburns2009 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @09:14PM (#38636993)
The bulk goods tend to be cheaper at Costco than my local stores whenever I've price shopped them. Bounty Paper Towels are about 5-15% cheaper. Kirkland butter is 10-20% cheaper than my local white-label. Kirkland unsalted nuts is 30% cheaper than white-label. I'm sure not everything has that much of an effective discount. Fresh fruit is roughly the same price. It can make sense to purchase bulk nonperishable products and food items you know you'll use before they go bad.
Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by FredPret on Thursday December 14, 2023 @12:29AM (#38638133)
There’s very little margin in fruit, so you would expect similar deals most places.

Take Fresh Del Monte - I know they do more than just fruit, but their margins are tiny. [https://valustox.com/FDP]

Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by armchairhacker on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @08:58PM (#38636890)
Things are cheaper when you buy in bulk. I’m lucky to have a fridge and freezer.

Ironically the bulk store brands also tend to be higher quality. The downside is there’s less variety.

Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by dylan604 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @09:12PM (#38636977)
Would it be less of a downside if you knew that a lot of the variety and options available at other stores are the same product just reskinned?
Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by enjoylife on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @09:21PM (#38637035)
For most non-perishables it’s the most time efficient in minimizing the number of trips. Also given how often I go, ~once a month, each time I get the same sort of novelty as a Trader Joe's for they will have swapped out many items.
Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by radicaldreamer on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @08:57PM (#38636873)
Costco has barely any markup on the items they sell (sometimes absolutely 0 markup). They make up for it in membership fees.
Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by rahimnathwani on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @09:18PM (#38637011)
Costco's median gross profit margin is about 12%. (Walmart's is about double that.)

Annual inventory turns: about 12x. (1.5x as fast as Walmart.)

Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by lotsofpulp on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @09:32PM (#38637092)
Why is gross profit margin relevant here? Are the other expenses at Costco not related to their business?

Their profit margin is 2.5% or less for 15+ years. Seems more accurate to use that number, which is also nearly equal their membership cost * number of memberships.

Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by rahimnathwani on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @09:41PM (#38637159)
"Why is gross profit margin relevant here?"

I replied to a comment that said Costco has "barely any markup".

Markup and gross profit measure exactly the same thing. If you know one, you can calculate the other.

A gross profit margin of 12% means Costco's markup is over 10%. (Or 8% to 9% if you don't count membership fees.)

This is low, but it's not nothing.

Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by xethos on Thursday December 14, 2023 @12:29AM (#38638137)
I still don't see the relevance - couldn't the higher gross profit margin be accounted for by having a markup of only slightly above zero, but supplemented by membership fees?
Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by IAmGraydon on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @09:22PM (#38637039)
Not sure why this is getting downvoted. It’s 100% true. Their profits primarily come from membership fees. I believe their markup is capped at a maximum of 15%.
Re:The average store size in the US is the smallest it's bee... by rahimnathwani on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @09:49PM (#38637210)
"Their profits primarily come from membership fees."

I've seen this quoted repeated but it's not a useful lens.

While Costco's annual revenue from membership fees is approximately equal to Costco's annual net profit, memberships are only valuable because of the additional services and products Costco offers, which also incur costs and contribute to their overall profits.

So it makes no sense to consider Costco memberships a product with close to 100% gross margin, which is what people normally mean when they say profits primarily come from membership fees.