News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fake chips, I got stung by cglace on Thursday December 07, 2023 @10:34AM (#38557489)
I once interviewed a candidate who had previously worked for the DoD as an engineer that validated components. I was blown away by how far they went to ensure the components they received were genuine and 100% matched the specs in their contract.
Re:Fake chips, I got stung by baz00 on Thursday December 07, 2023 @10:38AM (#38557543)
Yeah I did 6 months on a goods in line. We measured every single part and did full sampled testing. This was on defence grade parts as well from big vendors. They were rebagged, kept in stores ready for use so there were no surprises.
Re:Fake chips, I got stung by H8crilA on Thursday December 07, 2023 @11:07AM (#38557969)
Why is the defence industry so much more intense when it comes to checking parts? Is it mostly because it may be years or decades between purchase and usage?
Re:Fake chips, I got stung by awjlogan on Thursday December 07, 2023 @11:31AM (#38558370)
Money, time, and perceived/realised risk of failure (to both the end user, and the supplier). Any time you have enough of those, the scrutiny will increase.

If you're making a chicken feeder IoT device, the amount of marginal QA cost you can tolerate is low (in fact, you're probably tempted to use the counterfeits...) and the only adverse outcome is a slightly hungry chicken. Medical devices have a much higher risk, but not as much money or time as military (a bottomless pit of both), so the QA level is higher there, but probably not as much as defence.

Re:Fake chips, I got stung by QuadmasterXLII on Thursday December 07, 2023 @11:16AM (#38558110)
Probably because the brass knows what they’re doing to the other guys’ parts, and doesn’t want it done back
Re:Fake chips, I got stung by Turing_Machine on Thursday December 07, 2023 @11:28AM (#38558321)
Some good answers here, but at the end of the day it's this:

If the components don't work in a military situation, people might very well die. Sometimes a lot of people.

A counterfeit microprocessor in a dollar store Furby clone probably isn't going to kill anyone if it fails. The same microprocessor in a surface-to-air missile? Well...

Re:Fake chips, I got stung by toast0 on Thursday December 07, 2023 @11:54AM (#38558705)
> If the components don't work in a military situation, people might very well die. Sometimes a lot of people.

Sure, but if the components do work, people might very well die. Sometimes a lot of people. Probably different people.

Military (and aviation) want uniform, reliable parts and to be able to do post mortem investigation of failures where they lessons learned can be applied to the installed base and future production.

You can't do that very well when you don't even know who made your ICs to ask them what happened during production or to improve their processes.

Re:Fake chips, I got stung by polishdude20 on Thursday December 07, 2023 @11:31AM (#38558363)
>The same microprocessor

I knew Furbies had the same killing brains of missiles! It's in the eyes.

Re:Fake chips, I got stung by sterlind on Thursday December 07, 2023 @11:54AM (#38558694)
that's the plot of Home Alone 2 if memory serves (except with an RC car instead of a Furbie.)
Re:Fake chips, I got stung by lawlessone on Thursday December 07, 2023 @01:12PM (#38559705)
No Home Alone 2 is kid is lost in New York and a forced cameo with Trump.

You are thinking of Home Alone 3 which is a cynical money grabbing shadow of the original two films.

Personally small soldiers is my favorite missile chip in toy genre movie.

Re:Fake chips, I got stung by kemotep on Thursday December 07, 2023 @01:14PM (#38559735)
Home Alone 2 is set in New York. You are thinking of one of the later sequels that didn’t have Macauley Culkin.
Re:Fake chips, I got stung by userbinator on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:09AM (#38565931)
Ironically, related to this article, the original Furby has a 6502-derived core. Its source code was released a few years ago:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17751599

Re:Fake chips, I got stung by hkgjjgjfjfjfjf on Thursday December 07, 2023 @12:43PM (#38559355)
> If the components don't work in a military situation, people might very well die. Sometimes a lot of people.

TBF, that's also true if they do work.

Re:Fake chips, I got stung by samus on Friday December 08, 2023 @04:46AM (#38567117)
In the best case, the threat of using them is enough to get the job done. But for the threat to be genuine, they have to work reliably. This is definitely the case for nuclear and other "strategic" weapons.
Re:Fake chips, I got stung by petsfed on Thursday December 07, 2023 @07:30PM (#38563842)
Whether or not the thing keeps soldiers alive is actually pretty far down the list of reasons to control the supply chain (see, for instance, the various reviews of the M249, or the specific small-p political decisions around the M16 design. I've heard first hand accounts of Afghan National Army/Police answering calls while the US Army operated cell phone jammers a few feet away). The main thing is consistency.

If you can depend on depend on your machine gun to jam if you fire it for more than 3 seconds, then you just don't fire it for that long. But if you have no way of knowing how many rounds you'll get out of it (if any) before it jams, you'll just stop using the thing.

Further, a lot of the procurement rules devolve down to "is this supply chain a strategic weak point?" We don't buy our HMMWV tires from Russia not out of quality concerns, but to deny them that weapon. So the testing is done to verify provenance, rather than quality.

Re:Fake chips, I got stung by gosub100 on Thursday December 07, 2023 @11:13AM (#38558083)
Because you could defeat your enemy if you sabotaged their components! Say you were selling op-amps or oscillators you knew were going to be used in warfare. You could burn in an "easter egg" where they shut down if they received a particular RF pulse (or drifted wildly if they didn't receive some covert 'keep working' message). It would be a disaster.
Re:Fake chips, I got stung by barelyauser on Thursday December 07, 2023 @11:13AM (#38558084)
Because when you under deliver on a government contract they can throw your ass into jail faster than you can say "Quidditch".
Re:Fake chips, I got stung by AnimalMuppet on Thursday December 07, 2023 @11:13AM (#38558082)
Partly that. Also they tend to push parts farther - temperature range, probably also radiation hardness, maybe some other things. When you need a part with a milspec temperature range, you really want to get a part with that range, not a part with a smaller range with a forged label.
Re:Fake chips, I got stung by doikor on Thursday December 07, 2023 @11:32AM (#38558385)
A lot of the environment stuff is more about actually testing that the part can take that.

A civilian part might be very close (or the exact same part with a different model number) and even better in some cases but as it was never tested you don’t know.

Re:Fake chips, I got stung by JohnFen on Thursday December 07, 2023 @06:51PM (#38563477)
Exactly this. In my day job, I program industrial equipment that operates in very unfriendly environments (lots of heat, vibration, humidity, etc.) We pay extra for parts that are certified to be able to take the abuse.

Many of the parts aren't really any different than what you'd find inside consumer goods. They cost more because they've been tested and certified.

Re:Fake chips, I got stung by _factor on Thursday December 07, 2023 @01:21PM (#38559809)
Welcome to the world of supply chain poisoning. Go deep enough and you uncover local stores near defense companies and military bases which are targeted to contain modified inventory in the off chance someone buys it from said location. You might have some unused phone home chips in your coffee machine and not even know it.
Re:Fake chips, I got stung by RajT88 on Thursday December 07, 2023 @01:59PM (#38560311)
I've heard some similarly wild shit on the other side - the market for illicit product designs.

There are these boutique one-man contracting shops, which are closed most of the time in places like Shanghai and Shenzhen. They are contracted to do R&D for manufacturers, and deliver on firmware, product design, software, etc. but again are one-man shops which are closed much of the time.

I am told this is how the pipeline of information works between state sponsored cyber attacks on big tech companies, and their Chinese competitors.

Talking about Defense contractors, I've heard stories from govvies I know about asian dudes following them around the DC area, constantly catching them looking over their shoulders at coffee shops.

Re:Fake chips, I got stung by JohnFen on Thursday December 07, 2023 @04:04PM (#38561809)
> There are these boutique one-man contracting shops, which are closed most of the time in places like Shanghai and Shenzhen.

That's not just a China thing, nor is it suspicious all by itself. I made a good living in the US doing exactly the same thing for years.

The specific shops you're talking about may have been nefarious (I don't know), but the mere existence of private contractors is not inherently suspicious. They're pretty common.

Re:Fake chips, I got stung by RajT88 on Thursday December 07, 2023 @04:13PM (#38561884)
Maybe I did not say it plainly enough.

These one man shops deliver to Chinese firms (Like Huawei) hardware designs, firmware source and also other misc. software. All in one go, on contract under the auspice of "outsourcing R&D". Wayyyy too much for one person to deliver on, especially for a small office which is mostly closed.

I am not sure if I am mixing up anecdotes, but my source has mentioned that the materials provided often contain the same firmware bugs as a similar competitor's product does.

Re:Fake chips, I got stung by dkjaudyeqooe on Thursday December 07, 2023 @01:30PM (#38559922)
Because they build things that kill people, and you want the right people to die.
Re:Fake chips, I got stung by fsckboy on Thursday December 07, 2023 @08:49PM (#38564413)
>Why is the defence industry so much more intense when it comes to checking parts?

mil-spec parts need to meet specific standards, and since there are equivalent parts that don't have to meet these standards, the possibility and incentive for mislabelling parts is quite high.

Re:Fake chips, I got stung by Mtinie on Thursday December 07, 2023 @11:20AM (#38558170)
Sidebar question for you:

What educational background and/or practical experience route would someone have to get into the field? Is this a “requires electrical||mechanical engineering degree” role or can it be learned via apprenticeship?

Re:Fake chips, I got stung by cglace on Thursday December 07, 2023 @11:27AM (#38558308)
The person I interviewed had an MSc in EE.
Re:Fake chips, I got stung by nomel on Thursday December 07, 2023 @03:21PM (#38561340)
Maybe you can't say, but is it safe to assume it's fairly easy to "fingerprint" apart? Or, do the counterfeits "get it right" enough where deep functional testing is required?