So no matter what, conversations in your native speech would have to be delayed before translation.
I'm reminded of Mark Twain complaining about verbs arriving at the very end of sentencess in German (among a myriad of other complaints)
"The Awful German Language* -Mark Twain https://faculty.georgetown.edu/jod/texts/twain.german.html
Pretty sure there is nothing universal there though as you say.
I have a pair and have only asked it that so far...
Kind of like having an expert next to you all the time.
By keeping creating speaker specific tonal ranges and profiles you maintain the better cohesion on the final product.
I grew up bilingual outside the US, and speak English with a hybrid British/Indian/Middle Eastern accent (with some of my personal quirks, and mixing increasing amounts of various American accents over time). I can understand English in nearly any accent (Singaporean, Chinese, Vietnamese, Indian, Nigerian, eastern European) as long as the words involved are globally used and the grammar is passably queen's. Especially after hearing it for about an hour. And people who natively speak English with these various accents usually can understand my English better than they can an average American accent. Yet in this country, my accent is belittled, despite being perfectly understood and more versatile. Even by others who don't speak with the American accent!
This is the problem of the "default accent" anywhere being referred to as "no accent", and therefore anything deviating is considered "having an accent". This makes "accent" a negative trait, scaling from 0-bad to heavy-bad. But if the vernacular were such that we said "American accent" instead of "no accent", then noone's accent is bad, just not used to.
Most of my non-American peers who were raised on English have a better command of the language than my American ones, yet they are mocked for their accents as if they don't know the language, when in reality it's the Americans lack of familiarity with the language (as its used globally) preventing them from comprehending the language.
So yes, put in more work, the world is shrinking and English is the global language (for better or worse). What you're saying is spoken from a position of privilege because the culture allows you to mock others' accents and imply your version of it is the correct one that everyone else should put in work to provide you with, rather than the other way around.
Every time you hear English with an accent other than British, American or Australian, remember that it usually means the speaker knows at least one entire other language as well, probably one that you would sound like an idiot if you tried to speak it. Don't be rude or dismissive of their command of English.
In fact, you were so close — you called it a "no accent am-english", when you could have just called it what it is — "an american accent".
> What you're saying is spoken from a position of privilege because the culture allows you to mock others' accents and imply your version of it is the correct one that everyone else should put in work to provide you with, rather than the other way around.
> Every time you hear English with an accent other than British, American or Australian, remember that it usually means the speaker knows at least one entire other language as well, probably one that you would sound like an idiot if you tried to speak it. Don't be rude or dismissive of their command of English.
This is so uncharitable an interpretation of GP that it makes me wonder if it's Poe's Law at play and you're actually trolling. Nevertheless, I will assume you are being serious and address your comments as such.
You clearly have some deeply held frustrations (at a minimum), but unless you have a history with GP and therefore a lot more context on them than I do from just reading these comments, or unless GP edited their post in between my writing this and reading yours, then you are majorly projecting upon them based purely upon a negative stereotypes that you harbor against Americans. If I've missed the mocking or rude dismissiveness you refer to, then please point it out with a direct quote so I can further examine what you are referring to.
There definitely are people (and definitely some Americans, though it's certainly not monopolized by them. I was once ridiculed by locals in Mexico City for my terrible Spanish) who "mock" accents and are generally assholes who don't appreciate the difficulty of speaking a non-native language, and many of them would deserve the criticism you've levelled at GP, but to unload those accusations and chastisement at a person without cause, I don't think you're behaving any better than the people you would criticize who.
There was not desire for identity erasure or homogenization, leave whoever's voice the way it is online, give me an option to translate it. I added more about my issue downthread.
Diverse accents across the country. - absolutely! which is why I said 'no accent am-english.' (for me, as I can't learn well outside that) - and assuming if this tech exists it could help me, and perhaps be tweaked to change to other accents for other people.. also mentioned in downthread reply.
I could of been more specific, but my request for the tech to vary, I think would lead to specific options for different people.
And actually to be even more.. not sure the word.. I want 'the Chicago accent' I think it's called, or midwest / no accent. Personally as much as I enjoy some entertainment from Jersy / NY accents, I would not volunteer to watch tutorials on tech taught by the Sopranos cast - as funny as that might be (and I get if you are from the NE, you may be learning just fine being taught with such a language style).
As annoying some of the Cali style of language is, I can understand the words and meanings without squinting my ears and spending double the brain cycles trying to understand the words, while then interpreting the meaning, and then trying to put together concepts for understanding new ways of coding or using tech.
I've run into folks in Louisana that I could not understand at all and had to ask for an interpreter at a gas station. From Florida to Chicago to Seattle down to Miss and Ala - I can hear what people are saying and learn without spending lots of extra energy trying to understand.
With that being said, I understand there are parts around Miami where accents may be thicker (or not) - and with some folks even if using the rights words and grammar, I may need to slow down the speech to actually learn if they were teaching a class.
The slow down and speed up options already exist with youtube.
"So yes, put in more work"
- I do try a bit. I don't mind accents with some folks and media.For example I can listen to and enjoy Shankar sharing via the 'hidden brain' series, partially because his accent is limited but also because the media requires less thought intensity.
I have tried many youtubes, and bought a few courses taught from folks in India and other places where I just could not muster the energy. I literally squint with my ears and feel like my head gets hot trying to decipher what is being said, translate into what is meant, and how it should create new patterns of understanding in my brain.
I can only do that for so long and I am done. Now I just skip any learning video that has non-am English speakers. When I consider courses to sign up for or buy, I have to research the authors / speakers and find video of them to hear the audio, because I just can't learn well that way.
"other than British," - True story, a few years ago I had to call an ISP in Britain(?) and the person I got to to file an issue with, I could not understand them. I had ask 'what did you just say' many times. I laughed at myself for even thinking of saying 'can you slow down and speak clearer English please' - I mean, crazy... I was paying by the minute for the long distance at the time and it ended up being a 25 minute call that could of been 10 if I had a magic translate without accent device.
"a position of privilege because the culture allows you to mock others' accents"
- This is truly not about mocking accents, this is truly about my lack of ability to learn well.
Yes, I would defintely sound like an idiot trying to speak another language. Like I said, I do not learn as well as some others.
Truly not my intent to be rude. I apologize if the shortness came off that way, I was trying to be brief in the hope that there's a chance that some tech like this exists and someone here could point me to it. Before I posted, I DDG'ed it and found a couple of things attempting to be in that space with a 'speak to sales' type of 'you'll never afford this' button for info.
I will never be dismissive of anyone's command of English, or other spoken language, or computer language or anything like that. There is no way for me to know someone else's situation and circumstances led them to their current command of whatever language. If someone is trying to learn more at any age; I applaud and encourage them - being rude or dismissive does not encourage more learning.
"no accent am-english", when you could have just called it what it is — "an american accent". - Well maybe, but actually I meant to be more specific, as mentioned a bit above - I mean '"no accent" American accent' - because there are plenty 'American accent' types that I would want removed by a magic earpiece to make it easier for me to understand and learn.
There is no "no accent". An accent is a baseline feature of intelligible human speech, like a voice, or a volume, or a language. You can't say stuff without those features. When you say "the Chicago accent", or the "Midwest accent", that's an accent! Not "no accent".
I understand it's common usage to refer to the default "radio accent" as "no accent", but in a country like America, all kinds of people with all kinds of accents speak English. Reinforcing an expectation that a certain (usu. majority-white-spoken) one is the "default" by referring to it as "no accent", implicitly suggests all others are erroneous affectations, even if I trust that is not your personal intent.
All that said, I think your idea for a translation device capable of revocalizing what is said with an unfamiliar accent into one you are used to is not a bad one, and likely easier than translating between languages while retaining expressiveness.
Wow, you just keep digging in don’t you? When these Americans you deride say “no accent”, do you think they are referring to the “majority-white-spoken” Scottish accent?
No, of course not. Get that race baiting out of here.
I believe I had heard the term 'the chicago accent' as a term for radio broadcast that may have come more from 'the chicago market' or mid section of the US.. not meaning specific urban/city speak but the market segment for that part of the country as opposed to the east coast market, etc.
Looking at the top 12 radio markets; New York, Los Angeles, Chicago, San Francisco, Dallas-Ft. Worth, Houston, Atlanta, Philadelphia, Washington, Boston, Detroit, Miami
If you pick any of those and think of broadcasting the base accent of that city to the rest of the country.. I could see most annoying the other cities.. maybe Philly being a close 2nd.. and I don't think anyone can determine what a base accent for DC is.. that would depend on which neighborhood or however to median that.. (and I have no idea what the accent / tone / language is of Frisco in general, never been, and maybe it was different 20 years ago vs today)
And I mean, yes, there are people who know they don’t sound like whatever ideal accent they have in mind, and there are people who will make fun of accents - but, and I can’t stress this enough, depending on the context literally any accent can be made fun of, sadly. I’ve had people mock my “American” accent while travelling, for example. It sucks, but it’s not easy to single out any accent as “default” unless it’s literally enforced by a government and taught that way in schools. Last I checked, the US is not one of those countries and English is not as centrally controlled as e.g. French can be.
What accent? Whose accent? Brits are as diverse accent wise as Americans, London, cockney, New England, Southern...
A lot of Indians that I know have a very "proper" British accent, one that maybe a bit aristocratic, its quite an irony for a former colony. https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20220915-what-the-queens-...
The context matters, but so does history.
There are many american accents. Your suggestion makes the sentence much less clear.
And by specifying "american" they're already making it clear there is no such thing as a universal base accent for english.
I’ve been in mixed language communities in which I wasn’t sure who spoke what, and I have found this to be quite effective when done right.
Good time to reference st:ng “darmok” episode and quotes like “darmok and jalad at tanagra”.
In my other languages that I am actually fluent in, it’s kinda the same — you use specific suffixes to soften or embolden your point and so on. Maybe add “exclamation making sounds in specific language” too. Eventually your nouns and verbs end up in different languages, with different suffixes where it “makes sense”, yet the person whom you’re talking to will “get it”.
Would be curious to try the new Seamless model on such speeches.
The only thing that doesn’t work is if you talk to people too young to remember Skype. Then you feel old.
Verbing a noun is pretty simple; French borrowing English nouns as loanwords then verbing them is another. I was expecting something intermixed and trilingual.
"The word “brunch” doesn’t exist in French": well not the official French language per the Académie Française, but functionally it does, once everyday French-speakers start using it [0] "Many were quick to point out, as Reuters reports, that French President Emmanuel Macron commonly uses English idioms, including “start-up nation” and “bottom-up.”". I'm guessing Québecois people are even more fluid about this, since they have to be functionally bilingual(/trilingual) in daily interactions, and France's Toubon law doesn't apply to them.
For example, it would be interesting to chart the ratio of the Académie-mandated 'courriel' vs 'email' in majority-French-language posts in various regions. [1]
[0]: ["How France Tries to Keep English Out of Public Life" (8/2019)](https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20730219)
[1]: [Should You Use "le Courriel" for "Email"? (2019)](https://www.thoughtco.com/le-courriel-vocabulary-1371793)
Ne smotra na fact that tomorrow bir o kadar da sunny diyildir, bilo bi horosho progulyatsa around the seawall.
(Despite the fact it's not really sunny tomorrow, it would be nice to go for a walk around the seawall)
It's very weird to type it out, as we only use it when we speak. At least, when I type, I tend to think in one language, so there's less organic mixing happening. Since it's speaking-only thing for me, I tend to add the usual filler words, suffixes for superlative forms and etc., but from all three languages. Apologies for using French/English, as that didn't convey my point properly.
It's not about loan words, it's exactly just mixing random languages together as they roll off your tongue. I know it sounds stupid, but I've been talking to my siblings that way my entire life, so it's very "natural" to me. Most of my university friends are at least bilingual as well, and from what I've been told, they do the same with their friends in their own languages.
I don’t know for cockney but verlan is very alive.
Question is, what will happen to the tribal / local languages? Will they survive?
This might be required to get full buy in for a unified language, which is a bit sad but makes some sense - if you ensure it's taking up more and more of media and culture more people know it from immersion, and other languages are reduced to being spoken at home / with friends and that's going to cut into how many people really are fluent in them.
I did several experiments recording from all the microphones I could on my iPhone and AirPods while out in the wild. My conclusion: it's impossible right now for that hardware given the microphones we have and what they pick up.
So much of what's spoken is at a combination of (a) high distance (b) low volume (c) background obscuration. Something that was clear as day to my ears would barely register on the mics. While context is of course an issue, the raw audio didn't have enough to even translate.
The one caveat is that there might be low-level (i.e., Apple-only) access to headphone microphones that capture the environment to do noise cancellation. I'm not sure though---I couldn't find them on any API.
For cases where you do have clear audio, existing apps (e.g., Google Translate) are so close to achieving this, but don't let you specify audio outputs with enough fine grained control. By default, it will start screaming out of your phone what you were attempting to silently translate.
That is, they are able to translate (in all directions) novel languages that were not previously heard[0]. It is an open question, with likely a negative answers, that there is a universal grammar even among humans[1] (the definition itself is vague but even the most abstract version is suspect and highly likely to not be universal across species). I think no one will be surprised if it is always impossible to interpret an entire language based on only a few words (let alone do it in real time)
This isn't a knock down, because even a trained device is insanely useful, it's just a note about limitations and triage. This is awesome stuff and I can't wait for the day we have transnational headphones. It's an incredibly complex problem that I'm sure is not short of surprises.
[0] There are a few exceptions such as Star Trek TNG's episode Darmok, S5E2, where the Tamarians' language is unable to be translated due to its reliance on cultural references (the literal words are translated but the semantic meanings are not). It's a well known episode and if you hear anyone saying "Shaka, when the walls fell" (translates to "Failure") they are referencing this episode (often not using the language accurately but who cares (nerds. The answer is nerds)).
> The Babel fish is small, yellow and leech-like, and probably the oddest thing in the Universe. It feeds on brainwave energy received not from its own carrier but from those around it. It absorbs all unconscious mental frequencies from this brainwave energy to nourish itself with. It then excretes into the mind of its carrier a telepathic matrix formed by combining the conscious thought frequencies with the nerve signals picked up from the speech centres of the brain which has supplied them. The practical upshot of all this is that if you stick a Babel fish in your ear you can instantly understand anything said to you in any form of language. The speech patterns you actually hear decode the brainwave matrix which has been fed into your mind by your Babel fish.
“The argument goes something like this: ‘I refuse to prove that I exist,’ says God, ‘for proof denies faith, and without faith I am nothing.’
“‘But,’ says Man, ‘the Babel fish is a dead giveaway, isn’t it? It could not have evolved by chance. It proves you exist, and so therefore, by your own arguments, you don’t. QED.’
“‘Oh dear,’ says God, ‘I hadn’t thought of that,’ and promptly vanishes in a puff of logic.
“‘Oh, that was easy,’ says Man, and for an encore goes on to prove that black is white and gets himself killed on the next zebra crossing.
“Most leading theologians claim that this argument is a load of dingo’s kidneys, but that didn’t stop Oolon Colluphid making a small fortune when he used it as the central theme of his best-selling book, Well That about Wraps It Up for God.
“Meanwhile, the poor Babel fish, by effectively removing all barriers to communication between different races and cultures, has caused more and bloodier wars than anything else in the history of creation.”
That said, given the Heart of Gold improbability drive, I don't think information theoretic violations are your biggest problems.
"Can you stand up?" would be translated differently into Japanese depending on whether you're implying you need them to move their butt off your cell phone versus directly inquiring as to the function of their legs after a car accident. If you speak English and hear it as a background without the rest of the context being picked up, your brain instinctively knows it can interpret it either way, no problem.
But if you're Japanese and the AI picks a specific way to translate it, then you are completely unaware of the ambiguity because the AI resolved it with a 50% chance of being wrong.
nitpicky, but is it though? not really. and it's as much 'difference depending on what you're implying' as there would be in english comparing just saying 'can you stand up' or specifying 'from the seat/at all'.
Google: "A bit sticky, things are pretty sticky down there."
I think it's totally doable but you'd need many more microphones in order to deal with real world noise. As MEMS microphone quality improves, this should eventually be possible with a combination of smartphone/headphone/some other device like something around your neck.
The "universal translator" which was part of Star Trek and a lot of other Sci-Fi I was exposed to as a kid was something I was really fascinated with. My Dad worked as a simultaneous French->English translator and sadly spent long hours away from home and, as a kid, I started trying to build a translator so that it could do his work and he could be home more.
Translation is important work and one that could help a lot of people. It's my hope that we get to the point where these models work entirely on locally carried resources.