I think there's a small market for a browser (or browser plugin) that's all about client control. Querying mouse position, hijacking keypresses and showing popup windows and modal dialogs should be activated with a "This site tried to... Allow/Deny".
NoScript gets part of the way there, but I think you could go even further. Pages should display as soon as the HTML starts downloading, before CSS is loaded, before JS is all there, whatever. I don't care if this causes the page to jump a few times, or if it breaks a few scripts because it's not standards compliant, I just want to read my content on a slow connection.
I probably want to disable webfonts. They're a vanity thing, mostly, and the more I consider it the more I think I should be picking the fonts I read.
Maybe you could go even further - for specific sites with really atrocious interfaces you could have custom-written interfaces that almost completely remodel them (a'la Readability, I guess). I'm sure it would annoy web developers to have their pages render "incorrectly" on your screen, but screw them. My browser, my rules.
But track how often that link is clicked, and if it really is a lot more than 1% of people, then you know it's a behaviour worth accounting for and can code in your preference tracking thing accordingly. If not, no time wasted.
That is NOT working for me on a Mac.
"It looks like you're looking for Github brand image resources. - Have you tried right-clicking on the Github logo?"
And here I was thinking about adding cookies and saving client-state. :)
Advantages:
* Shows context menu immediately, allowing for edge cases
* Shows lightbox
* Always consistent, no clearing cookies or preferences to get it back
* Unobtrusive; "don't make me think"
* Simple to implement (just allow the event to propagate)
* Robust, context menu works if lightbox breaks
The lightbox that opens up asks, "Looking for the GitHub logo?"
But it doesn't let you answer no. It just presumes that your answer is yes, and supplies you with what it thinks you actually want (or, more cynically, what it wants you to want).
I would suggest adding a "No thanks -- just let me right-click" link at the bottom. That link would close the lightbox and prevent it from reopening for the rest of the session, which would be in contrast to its current behavior, where the lightbox pops up no matter how many times you right-click.