News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by btilly on Friday November 03, 2023 @10:16AM (#38129105)
English is what you got when Anglo-Saxon peasants were forced to serve French speaking nobles. Which is why basic grammar and simple words are Germanic in origin, while words for food, laws, and various complex things have Romance origins. And then went on to become traders who borrow words from everywhere.

Add to that constantly shifting pronunciation rules. To pick an example that is only mostly complete, "wear" and "where" are now homonyms for most people. But a century ago they mostly were not. The spelling captures the historical pronunciation, not the current one.

But it could be worse. At least we've dropped the insanity of gender from the language. Old English had 5 genders, that generally didn't match what French had.

But still if you want a flavor of what English might have sounded like without being mangled by French, read Uncleftish Beholding: https://www.ling.upenn.edu/~beatrice/110/docs/uncleftish_beh.... It explains basic atomic theory using only Germanic based words (eg Beholding) and made up words with Germanic roots. So, for example, atoms can't be split or cleft, and so are uncleft is an atom. And Ymir has a mythological role parallel to Uranus, so uranium became ymirstuff.

It is surprisingly readable, but sounds quite different than English usually does.

Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by HPsquared on Friday November 03, 2023 @10:31AM (#38129368)
This feels like reading German.
Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by OnlyMortal on Friday November 03, 2023 @12:43PM (#38131290)
Well yes. My dialect is somewhere towards German (more so Dutch).

I write, “learnt” rather than “learned”. Past perfect and past imperfect from a Germanic view.

“I learnt” and “I have learned”. “I learned” sounds wrong.

Source: Yorkshuh.

Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by stevekemp on Friday November 03, 2023 @03:48PM (#38134061)
Only this evening I was trying to explain to my child that "telt" was the same as "told", with extra emphasis and implied overtones..

Source Yorkshuh and Scottishland!

Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by OnlyMortal on Friday November 03, 2023 @05:09PM (#38135039)
It’ll be old Saxon.

Admittedly, I’d not use “telt” though I understand why it is used.

My Yorkshuh is (now) soft Wetherby. It wasn’t as a lad but I had to learn English, as a second language, when I lived abroad (NL/BE/US).

It was embarrassing to have someone translate my English to an American boss.

Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by psunavy03 on Friday November 03, 2023 @12:47PM (#38131368)
English is a Germanic language, closely related to Dutch and German, which was later influenced by French and Latin.
Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by hinkley on Friday November 03, 2023 @02:12PM (#38132663)
As a native English speaker, it can be distracting to hear someone speaking Dutch in a movie. Your brain keeps trying to make it into accented English, because it sounds almost like it due to pacing and common syllables. The brain latches onto a handful of borrowed words and tries to interpolate the rest.
Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by foobarian on Friday November 03, 2023 @02:41PM (#38133062)
Same thing with many Slavic languages that aren't mutually intelligible, like Polish or Slovene and Croat. I wonder if there is a concept of Hamming distance for languages.
Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by jandrewrogers on Friday November 03, 2023 @02:33PM (#38132964)
Same. Dutch sounds like unintelligible English to me, which is useful for identifying it as Dutch (once I realize it is, in fact, actually unintelligible).
Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by Sylamore on Saturday November 04, 2023 @12:32AM (#38138148)
I've experienced this in real life, I was on a committee that rotated meetings between the US and The Netherlands.

During a policy session in Zaandam with some Dutch, UK, Spanish and US peers we had a moment when our Dutch hosts had an excited conversation in Dutch but since it was a tech conversation both myself and the UK member blurted out at the same time that our Dutch must be getting better because we understood most of what they just said and didn't need them to translate it for us.

Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by pbhjpbhj on Friday November 03, 2023 @09:10PM (#38137062)
Later?

Latin was the first official language in the UK, back when Celtic and Brythonic language was widespread.

The Normans were in the UK, viking there way up our rivers and establishing the Danegeld before Normandy was Normandy and, well, before French was French.

Old French was Gallo-Romance and Middle French, AIUI, emerged with the Norse influence as the Scandinavians moved down past Britain and into Europe. Modern French, ie French, came long after the English court took on the language of the Normans (1066, and all that).

Out of this melange English was born, the next official language of England famously legislated as such by the Welsh-speaking Henry Tudor in the late C.15th.

Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by tivert on Friday November 03, 2023 @11:17AM (#38130081)
> Add to that constantly shifting pronunciation rules. To pick an example that is only mostly complete, "wear" and "where" are now homonyms for most people. But a century ago they mostly were not. The spelling captures the historical pronunciation, not the current one.

It's worth noting that's not unique to English: it's a phenomenon that's universally happens across all languages. It's how language diverge into new ones and how linguists can reconstruct old languages that have no written records.

Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by wongarsu on Friday November 03, 2023 @01:06PM (#38131686)
Pronunciation drifts in all languages. But usually languages take some effort to have either a clear mapping from spelling to pronunciation (when you read it you can pronounce it) or from pronunciation to spelling (when you can pronounce it you can spell it); or some compromise that tries to achieve both. Hence when pronunciation drifts too far that eventually causes the word to be spelt differently too.

Meanwhile English seems to have spelling set mostly in stone hundreds of years ago, and any shifts in pronunciation since then are just ignored (barring minor reforms like the ou->o thing that part of the world adopted)

Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by monknomo on Friday November 03, 2023 @02:46PM (#38133159)
People are very resistant to spelling reform, and it doesn't help that english has enough accents/regions where it is spoken, that no unified spelling is going to be sensible for all english speakers.

I mean, look at Carnegie's attempt: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simplified_Spelling_Board

some wins, but didn't go anywhere, really

Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by gingerrr on Friday November 03, 2023 @03:27PM (#38133839)
How does mapping spelling to sound work in languages like English that have homophones?

"wear", "where", "were-" (as in werewolf), "weir" (in some regional dialects) can all be pronounced identically in modern English. If we map them all to a single spelling, is that an improvement to readability and understanding?

Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by wongarsu on Friday November 03, 2023 @03:47PM (#38134037)
English has plenty of words that have different meanings but are are spelled and pronounced the same. An arm is either a limb or a weapon. A break is either a pause or a physical defect. A trunk can be a piece of clothing, a part of a tree, a cloth-covered chest, or the rear compartment of an automobile. A bat can be an animal or a stick. And while some of these words are related, some have completely different origins and just happen to be spelled and pronounced the same in contemporary English. The stick "bat" is from Old English batt, derived from Welsh and Celtic, the mammal from Middle English bakke, derived from Old Swedisch/Danish/Norse.

If you "cleaned up" English spelling, the same would happen with wear, where and were-. If the distinction were important for understanding, it would be equally important in spoken language and the pronunciations wouldn't have converged.

Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by Gibbon1 on Friday November 03, 2023 @04:45PM (#38134768)
The other thing is English speaking world hasn't had a government with enough authoritarian power to rationalize spelling and pronunciation. So pronunciation and spelling is all historical convention. Which it used to also be in most places until the government rationalized the language. This is the same reason people in the US still use English units. The government isn't willing to force the issue.

One advantage of the disconnect between spoken and written is old English literature since the great vowel shift is still readily accessible. Go back 500 years and the spoken language would be difficult but written would be easy.

Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by btilly on Friday November 03, 2023 @05:32PM (#38135261)
The spoken language might be easier than you'd guess.

Watch https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gPlpphT7n9s to see what our best understanding of Shakespeare actually sounded like. It is surprisingly easy to understand.

They also found that he had some bawdy jokes that rhymed for his audience which no longer do rhyme. :-)

Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by dragonwriter on Friday November 03, 2023 @04:48PM (#38134803)
> This is the same reason people in the US still use English units.

US customary units aren't English (or Imperial) units; even the ones that share names sometimes aren't the same, and not just because of the minor adjustments when the US customary system was redefined in metric terms.

Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by Balgair on Friday November 03, 2023 @02:06PM (#38132587)
English is drifting as we speak, literally.

Look at the shifts going on right now in the great lakes area. Lots of vowels are changing around.

Charlie Berens is a comedian that focuses on great lakes and midwestern life. His accent, though suped up for views, is somewhat representative of the state of the vowel changes going on right now:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PKFReM16N4Q

Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by kitd on Friday November 03, 2023 @03:47PM (#38134038)
English is drifting as we speak, literally.

Ha, nice :)

Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by Symmetry on Friday November 03, 2023 @04:01PM (#38134222)
English's two most common other intensifiers, "really" and "very" (verily), got their start the same way.
Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by msrenee on Friday November 03, 2023 @07:27PM (#38136385)
Did they? I'd love an article about that if you have one handy.
Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by Symmetry on Friday November 03, 2023 @03:59PM (#38134193)
It's not but the Great Vowel Shift happened after spellings were standardized and was a pretty big change.

For me the worst part is that my last name, Clough, was originally spelled that way to indicate it used English's guttural sound before that sound got dropped from the language and all the words with that sound got their own new pronunciations. E.g., "Though through rough boughs I push my way."

Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by Xorakios on Saturday November 04, 2023 @04:40AM (#38139176)
Nice!
Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by CoastalCoder on Friday November 03, 2023 @12:24PM (#38131004)
> Old English had 5 genders, ...

Would you mind elaborating on this?

I know almost nothing about the topic, but IIUC from Wikipedia, Olde English only had 3 genders: [0].

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Old_English_grammar#Gender

Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by z500 on Friday November 03, 2023 @12:40PM (#38131236)
[delayed]
Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by btilly on Friday November 03, 2023 @12:57PM (#38131550)
The way I learned about it, in addition to masculine, neuter, and feminine, there was also a distinction between weak and strong. So a man would be strong masculine, a body weak masculine, a girl weak feminine, and a woman strong feminine. Add in neuter and you get 5 genders.

But reading https://oldenglish.info/wam2.html, there were also 2 weak neuter nouns, eage and eare. Which are now eye and ear. Not sure how that fits with what I was taught.

Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by hinkley on Friday November 03, 2023 @02:02PM (#38132549)
I never quite got used to the added layer of polite verb conjugation in French, but I hear Japanese is far worse.

As a native speaker it might not be so bad. But as a second language it means that at some point you're taking a class that consists largely of learning to beg your betters for favors. Which I don't think is ever going to sit well with students of quasi-democratic nations. Doubly so for more stereotypically cantankerous ones.

Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by pomian on Friday November 03, 2023 @03:09PM (#38133581)
Formality in discussion with others, seems to be very common in other languages, and is very hard for a native North American speaker to use correctly. The whole concept sounds like contrite begging for us. Please sir, sir I could I sir ask you sir, to possibly pass the cheese, sir. So, of course we over correct and throw in more sirs(or ma'ams) willy nilly.
Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by dragonwriter on Friday November 03, 2023 @03:50PM (#38134088)
> Formality in discussion with others, seems to be very common in other languages, and is very hard for a native North American speaker to use correctly. The whole concept sounds like contrite begging for us.

Kind of ironic, in that English lost the ability to make formality distinctions because its speakers were so consistently formal to each other that the language lost its informal second person singular pronoun and associated conjugations.

Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by dkjaudyeqooe on Friday November 03, 2023 @07:41PM (#38136478)
Living proof of this is the that when translating from English to my local Slavic language Google Translate strips out all instances of "please". I felt like it sounded rude but it actually stops me from sounding overly pleading and a little pathetic.
Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by pomian on Friday November 03, 2023 @08:35PM (#38136830)
My solution for good interaction, since I'm fluent, is to state to the person i'm talking to, is right up front and say; I'm not a native, so forgive me if I sound informal. Usually that's enough for the person to be forgiving, and possibly impressed, sometimes I just get a confused or rude look.
Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by vharuck on Friday November 03, 2023 @03:12PM (#38133662)
>I never quite got used to the added layer of polite verb conjugation in French, but I hear Japanese is far worse.

I've only passed the N4 exam so far (about the skill of a Japanese elementary school student), but I fear the polite speech rules I've already learned. It's easy to conjugate verbs a little politely (-masu at the end, or desu for "to be"). Being more polite is a beast. There are different verbs to tack on depending on the basic verb, your relation to the person you're speaking to or speaking about, and whether it's a request, offer, or statement.

Then there are polite pronouns, polite particles (those are like prepositions), and it's usually polite to refer to things obliquely.

All that, and I'm sure I'm missing or misunderstanding a huge portion of the style.

Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by Angostura on Friday November 03, 2023 @01:03PM (#38131636)
> English is what you got when Anglo-Saxon peasants were forced to serve French speaking nobles.

And when the spelling was largely fixed by William Caxton, who pronounced the words with a 15th century Kentish accent

Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by hinkley on Friday November 03, 2023 @02:05PM (#38132581)
The rumor is that after the Revolutionary war, English nobility affected an accent change to distance themselves from those Americans, and that a historically accurate miniseries about the American Revolution should feature British Officers with something approaching a southern drawl, rather than the modern posh British accent.

Basically the American South did not get the memo about changing English accents.

Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by Angostura on Friday November 03, 2023 @03:04PM (#38133477)
I'll let you look at modern English spellings - Know, though, thought etc etc and decide for yourself whether that looks like a transcript of southern American english:)
Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by MrJohz on Friday November 03, 2023 @06:10PM (#38135695)
I'd love for you to correct me on this, but I believe this is nonsense. The only places that discuss this are very dubious articles from infotainment-style blogs, and I can't find anything to back this up on Wikipedia, let alone anything more reputable.

IIRC, the element of truth that begets the lie here is that the Southern accent does have some elements in common with older British accents. But it's not clear whether those elements are retained from those old British accents, or whether they've simply been added into the accent later. And even then, we're talking about very specific features - I think the rhotic R is one of them? - and not the accent as a whole.

Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by baq on Friday November 03, 2023 @01:30PM (#38132083)
I’d like to give the word ‘bass’ at least an honorable mention.
Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by hinkley on Friday November 03, 2023 @01:57PM (#38132472)
On the topic of food; livestock, which were raised by peasants, kept their Germanic names. Meat was expensive though and usually went to nobility, or people catering to them (learn the language of the occupier if you want to get ahead).

So you get ham from a pig, beef from a cow, and mutton from a sheep.

Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by kridsdale3 on Friday November 03, 2023 @04:26PM (#38134536)
I asked GPT4 to re-insert latin word-components to Uncleftish Beholding to "remangle" it. The result is perfectly fine modern English. It does a pretty good job of "uncleftish-ifying" any other text if you enjoy that style.

https://pastebin.com/FCAjrckG

Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by pcrh on Friday November 03, 2023 @07:13PM (#38136289)
That's fairly impressive to be honest. Correctly interpreting "uncleft" as "atom", for example.
Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by dreamcompiler on Friday November 03, 2023 @06:35PM (#38135968)
> At least we've dropped the insanity of gender from the language.

Except for ships, which are always feminine in English. It feels very weird to me because gendered noun categories are very unusual for English and ships are just about the only counterexample that remains.

Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by dkjaudyeqooe on Friday November 03, 2023 @06:50PM (#38136109)
That's a tradition, or possibly a convention, not a language rule. All inanimate objects are 'it'.
Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by Symbiote on Friday November 03, 2023 @07:50PM (#38136539)
I consider this sexist and will continue to use "it".
Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by pbhjpbhj on Friday November 03, 2023 @08:44PM (#38136882)
Why is it sexist, surely it is linguistic gender and has nothing to do with biological sex?

Of course, you can use "it", your choice.

Mind you I find the forced overlaying of sex onto language absurd, my late mother was chairman of many committees and always complained when people started calling her "chair"; I agree.

Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by Symbiote on Sunday November 05, 2023 @04:46PM (#38155974)
"sċip" is neuter in Old English.

The tradition refers to some sort of mother / goddess protection the sailors are hoping for.

Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by PaulDavisThe1st on Friday November 03, 2023 @07:55PM (#38136576)
> English is what you got when Anglo-Saxon peasants were forced to serve French speaking nobles.

Are you suggesting that England, the very definition of imperialist settler colonialism, is itself the product of imperialist settler colonialism?

Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by OJFord on Friday November 03, 2023 @08:24PM (#38136769)
Many, it's not even a lukewarm take I'm afraid. Different invaders for different times.

Also Jews were expelled for a few centuries, and made to wear particular clothing prior to that.

I'm sure you could find many other examples that we more readily associate to some other country (or in some other direction) today, and they may be different again in centuries to come.

Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by pard68 on Friday November 03, 2023 @08:20PM (#38136741)
Well it is. Celts are the original peoples and have been invaded at various times by Gaels, Scandinavians, French, and Romans. Probably others too.
Re:How to Pronounce the Trickiest English Words: Ask This Fr... by PaulDavisThe1st on Friday November 03, 2023 @08:35PM (#38136832)
There were non-Sapiens species on the islands. Later, after the last ice age, a neolithic culture apparently linked to Anatolia. Subsequently during the Bronze age, the Iberians ("Bell-Beaker people") arrived, preceding the Celts.

So any talk of "the original peoples" in the British Isles is just about as meaningless as it is anywhere outside of some parts of Africa.