News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by justinpombrio on Sunday October 29, 2023 @12:29PM (#38060140)
> Very few engineers want to maintain relationships with customers, interview users to identify potential features, manage leadership, play politics for resource allocation, and so on

Ah, so that's what a product manager is supposed to do. When product managers were introduced at a company I worked at, they did very little of any of that. They certainly weren't speaking to customers. They weren't technical, so they weren't managing our Jira tickets. And "managing leadership" fell mostly on our managers' plates. I think the PMs mostly had meetings, talked to leadership, talked to engineers, wrote documents, and presided over the (now very long) sprint planning meetings.

I can imagine product managers that did your list of things being a lot more valuable.

Re:The product manager role is a mistake by jpatt on Sunday October 29, 2023 @12:37PM (#38060224)
Sounds a lot more like a project or program manager than a product manager.
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by moandcompany on Sunday October 29, 2023 @12:56PM (#38060415)
And ironically it seem like the things you'd positively attribute here to a product manager used to be/are actually part of the scope of what was traditionally a "project manager" or "program manager."

For example, look at the scope and definition of a "program manager" from Microsoft or the US DoD in the 1980s, 1990s+, as well as literature describing the role of a program manager and the discipline from that time.

Re:The product manager role is a mistake by lukevp on Sunday October 29, 2023 @01:46PM (#38060906)
Why’s that ironic? There didn’t used to be frontend / backend / full stack devs either. As software engineering has matured and grown in scale, more subdivision of responsibilities is a natural outcome of that. We’re not all just directly writing code on mainframes and our customers aren’t just < 1k of users who directly call us on the phone if something goes wrong anymore, it’s millions of people using services 24x7 now. MS wasn’t making real-time collaboration systems and cloud sync in the 80s and 90s. They were making a stand-alone offline machine that barely could install device drivers and didn’t know what the internet was. Completely different products, and much simpler.
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by pseudalopex on Sunday October 29, 2023 @04:55PM (#38062691)
What subdivision of responsibilities? Clients and servers were divided for as long as clients and servers existed. Full stack is aggregation of responsibilities. DevOps too. Dedicated QA is rare now.

Most companies with product managers have fewer customers and less complex products than 1990s Microsoft.

Re:The product manager role is a mistake by ajkjk on Sunday October 29, 2023 @12:56PM (#38060424)
Nevertheless it is the role called "product manager" at many companies.
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by sanderjd on Sunday October 29, 2023 @01:03PM (#38060501)
Yep, a common pitfall is to not understand how product managers are supposed to do, and thus they just do project management, which often has neutral or negative value.
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by marcosdumay on Sunday October 29, 2023 @01:39PM (#38060846)
I've seen competent project managers work very hard to achieve that neutral-value proposition. I haven't yet seen any one succeed.

In my experience, as soon as you decide your projects will be formal and managed, you are already doomed to that negative value.

Re:The product manager role is a mistake by midasuni on Sunday October 29, 2023 @02:08PM (#38061080)
Sometimes you need a formal project. We’re kitting out a new office over the next couple of years, it’s a major programme of multiple projects, all which interact. At the end of it though we have a building fit for purposes following the plans currently set. I’m sure those plans will adjust a little, but the end date is January 2025, or July, or something - I’m sure the date will slip.

You can’t build a £20m facility with a series of sprints.

Re:The product manager role is a mistake by marcosdumay on Sunday October 29, 2023 @02:54PM (#38061467)
Well, the Empire State Building was famously built as a series of sprints...

You need a formal design. This doesn't mean you need a formal project. Some amount of planning ahead very obviously helps, but how much is debatable, and when you have people whose sole specialization is "planning ahead", you are certainly past the point where it's too much.

Anyway, the most valuable people are the ones "planning behind", looking for what was left broken and could be done better from now on. Project management defines those people out of existence.

Re:The product manager role is a mistake by trog on Sunday October 29, 2023 @04:31PM (#38062452)
Think of the "formal project" is the API by which executing the design can be understood by all stakeholders.

It is a high level abstraction that allows all parties to understand what they need to do and when they need to do it. For large projects it is simply essential - you need your external vendors to plan their availability, months or sometimes years in ahead, so that they can commit to the timeline.

If you're lucky enough to work on large software projects where there are no managers or other stakeholders asking "and how long will this take, exactly?" then maybe the design is enough.

But pretending planning ahead on large projects that is something that will just happen by osmosis or people "just doing it" simply won't work. Good project managers who do what they're supposed to are worth their weight in gold (just like good product managers).

Re:The product manager role is a mistake by marcosdumay on Sunday October 29, 2023 @07:15PM (#38063821)
> If you're lucky enough to work on large software projects where there are no managers or other stakeholders asking "and how long will this take, exactly?" then maybe the design is enough.

How well can your project managers answer how long will this take? Because on my experience, 10000% delays are all but routine (ok, on construction it's usually bounded to something around 1000%). And how much value do people that can give you an estimate between 1% and 10000% of the target?

> But pretending planning ahead on large projects that is something that will just happen by osmosis

I'm telling you that planning ahead has a small value, following up with the plan has a high negative value, and the thing with a high positive value that is reexamining the plan is fought against by the practitioners.

Re:The product manager role is a mistake by trog on Monday October 30, 2023 @12:43AM (#38065764)
If they are good project managers, they plan for non-routine delays and account for them in the project schedule. Before people are allowed to commit to schedule, the project managers make sure that these people have properly scoped and estimated their part of the work, by asking pointed questions, using their domain expertise and general experience to figure out if they're being bullshitted or not.

If things start to slip, they find out where and why and apply what pressure they can to get them on track. If they cannot get them on track, they then liaise with everyone downstream to make them aware of the slippage, adjust the entire schedule, and get everyone reorganised.

It's not just putting things in the calendar and forgetting about them - it's a constant, ongoing herding of cats to get them all going the same way.

It sounds like you just might not have been lucky enough to work with really great project managers!

Re:The product manager role is a mistake by glimshe on Sunday October 29, 2023 @01:11PM (#38060581)
It sounds like you had a project manager, not a product manager. A good product manager is very valuable.
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by elicksaur on Sunday October 29, 2023 @01:38PM (#38060832)
It seems like whoever named these titles did a poor job. They’re so close, can you blame people for not seeing a difference?

What is a product but a large project anyways?

Re:The product manager role is a mistake by alonsonic on Sunday October 29, 2023 @01:48PM (#38060920)
A product manager is expected to view things from a business point of view. To identify features for the product and help it succeed in the market.

A project manager is in charge of planing, execution and governance of a project. They don’t define any of the goals or vision.

Saying product is a large project is a big over simplification. If we go that route anything could be called a “large project”.

Re:The product manager role is a mistake by TeMPOraL on Sunday October 29, 2023 @04:17PM (#38062298)
> Saying product is a large project is a big over simplification. If we go that route anything could be called a “large project”.

Yes. That's precisely the point. What's the difference between "X manager" and a "project manager" when the X itself is obviously a project?

Re:The product manager role is a mistake by kaibee on Sunday October 29, 2023 @04:53PM (#38062673)
> in charge of planing, execution and governance of a project. They don’t define any of the goals or vision.

This sounds like if you were trying to hire a race-car driver instead hired two people, and put one of them in charge of steering to the left and the other in charge of steering to the right.

Re:The product manager role is a mistake by lazystar on Sunday October 29, 2023 @05:57PM (#38063245)
this is exactly why back-to-office initiatives have value - it's easier to coordinate when the steerers are next to each other
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by IanCal on Sunday October 29, 2023 @09:00PM (#38064508)
Navigating and driving the car are two very obviously distinct tasks that regular people and rally drivers split up.
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by stcroixx on Sunday October 29, 2023 @09:16PM (#38064609)
The product manager decides which direction the car should be turned and the project manager turns the wheel.
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by tcmb on Sunday October 29, 2023 @01:52PM (#38060962)
A project has a planned end date, a product typically doesn't.
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by almostnormal on Sunday October 29, 2023 @02:40PM (#38061352)
[delayed]
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by JCharante on Sunday October 29, 2023 @04:03PM (#38062152)
Development phase is the project. Maintenance phase before sunsetting is I guess another project.
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by TeMPOraL on Sunday October 29, 2023 @04:18PM (#38062309)
Isn't it the other way around? Projects tend to never end. Products eventually get released.
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by gardenhedge on Sunday October 29, 2023 @04:54PM (#38062678)
A released product is not the end of the product. See: Google, Facebook, WhatsApp, X, Gmail, Dropbox, Firefox, etc.
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by johannes1234321 on Sunday October 29, 2023 @06:21PM (#38063434)
A release ist ksut the begining of a product. After that you have to collect customer feedbackand figure out what to prioritize for the next release.
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by midasuni on Sunday October 29, 2023 @01:58PM (#38061003)
My company had project managers and product owners to avoid that verbal confusion.

A project has a defined start and end. You know when it’s done, and you should know that before it even starts.

A product is ongoing. It reacts to business changes.

Re:The product manager role is a mistake by esafak on Sunday October 29, 2023 @02:46PM (#38061401)
Project managers co-ordinate the teams and stakeholders associated with a project. It only applies to bigger companies. In smaller projects senior engineers and engineering managers do the same job.
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by isbvhodnvemrwvn on Sunday October 29, 2023 @05:20PM (#38062934)
There's sometimes also program managers who organize relevant projects across the company (for example with GDPR compliance a program manager might coordinate between legal and various products, identify risks and report progress to C-level, and each product will have a project kick off to get it into compliance (depending on the effort, the person overlooking this project and working with program might be a dedicated project manager, engineering manager, some engineer etc).
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by starky on Sunday October 29, 2023 @01:32PM (#38060773)
Last time I saw one of these types of articles on here it quickly became apparent that a lot of companies don't know the difference and call their project managers by the wrong name.
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by koonsolo on Sunday October 29, 2023 @02:07PM (#38061068)
People using "PM" is adding to the confusion.
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by wombatpm on Sunday October 29, 2023 @02:57PM (#38061503)
That’s why I use PMP for Product Management Professional. Much clearer
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by starky on Sunday October 29, 2023 @03:09PM (#38061614)
This adds to the confusion since Project Management Professional is a certification for a Project Manager that specifically uses that acronym and not all project managers have the certification.
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by namdnay on Sunday October 29, 2023 @03:25PM (#38061743)
I think it was a joke
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by Terr_ on Sunday October 29, 2023 @06:11PM (#38063364)
Alas, the joke is "Too Real" and on all of us.
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by Loughla on Sunday October 29, 2023 @05:18PM (#38062916)
For what it's worth, I enjoyed that joke. I work in education and the number of redundant acronyms and initialisms (if that's a word) is astounding.

BIT meeting on my calendar. Is it behavioral intervention team or something about the bachelor of information technology or Business Information technology or bachelor of industrial technology or are we talking about income taxes or what?

Re:The product manager role is a mistake by starky on Sunday October 29, 2023 @03:04PM (#38061564)
Agreed, PjM and PdM are what I use when referring to them.
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by naravara on Sunday October 29, 2023 @03:00PM (#38061529)
A lot of teams with poor business operations seem to treat project, product, and program management as a generic blob of “help us be organized please” duties instead of specific jobs with specific operational missions.
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by TeMPOraL on Sunday October 29, 2023 @04:15PM (#38062284)
What is the difference then, between a project manager, product manager, a project owner and a product owner? Always thought they're approximately the same thing. Isn't any product you're working on a project too?
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by zappb on Sunday October 29, 2023 @04:59PM (#38062731)
The main difference is between a product and a project. The gist is that projects are short term specific plans while products are a bit more open-ended ideas with continual feedback. Here’s a decent overview: https://martinfowler.com/articles/products-over-projects.htm...
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by IanCal on Sunday October 29, 2023 @08:57PM (#38064487)
Imo projects are company details, products are what your users see.

The split between project manager and product owner seems clearest.

A project manager is running the team. Who does what and when? How do we plan the work?

A product owner is kind of like the representative stakeholder. What should this do? How important is launching now Vs fixing these bugs?

How Vs what.

Good people in these roles are incredible. I've been fortunate to work with some.

Re:The product manager role is a mistake by starky on Sunday October 29, 2023 @10:03PM (#38064909)
Product Manager: They are essentially the voice of the customer and upper management. They work on the product roadmap and determine the requirements for the product based on the needs that are determined by conversations with the stakeholders as well as other market research. In addition to this they also work on things like product pricing, release strategy, etc.

Project Manager: They ensure that all the tasks for a project get done on time. They make the gantt charts, work with teams to break it down into sections, keep track of budgets, manage risks, report on progress to stakeholders, etc.

I've never worked with a Product Owner since I understand it is mostly a software related position and that is not my area. From what I understand, they are an intermediary that sits between PdM and PjM.

Re:The product manager role is a mistake by ragestorm on Sunday October 29, 2023 @01:12PM (#38060595)
Agree. Similar to a developer vs. SWE.
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by willsmith72 on Sunday October 29, 2023 @01:20PM (#38060674)
Disagree. Project manager is extremely different to product. Dev vs SWE is completely arbitrary
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by elicksaur on Sunday October 29, 2023 @01:37PM (#38060814)
What do you see as the difference between a developer and a SWE?
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by ipaddr on Sunday October 29, 2023 @02:03PM (#38061046)
One is DevOps and one is a programmer
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by _rutinerad on Sunday October 29, 2023 @04:21PM (#38062337)
They’re both programmers and you can’t “be devops”.
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by 59nadir on Monday October 30, 2023 @04:12AM (#38066815)
The vast majority of my colleagues would say "that person is a devops" instead of "that person does devops", which I don't get at all. I've assumed it's some deeply rooted misunderstanding of language (my colleagues are eastern european) that has taken hold across the entire local industry.
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by elicksaur on Sunday October 29, 2023 @10:26PM (#38065041)
That didn’t really clarify for me, which is which? What is DevOps to you? (Seems to be different for everyone)

The wiki for “programmer” has “software developer, a software engineer, a programmer or a coder” as interchangeable terms in the first sentence.

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Programmer

Re:The product manager role is a mistake by boredtofears on Sunday October 29, 2023 @01:19PM (#38060654)
there is no difference between a developer and an SWE except a fancy title
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by jefftk on Sunday October 29, 2023 @01:52PM (#38060956)
Which one is fancier?
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by JCharante on Sunday October 29, 2023 @04:04PM (#38062162)
Software Development Engineer is the one title to rule them all
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by fnordpiglet on Sunday October 29, 2023 @02:10PM (#38061100)
Most companies don’t understand what a product manager does, and they are busy eliminating project management roles in favor of an “agile” workflow, so they just repurpose the project managers to be product managers because it’s only two letters different. With predictable results.
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by esafak on Sunday October 29, 2023 @03:43PM (#38061940)
Project management was the role Larry Page once axed in 2001: https://medium.com/illumination/google-once-fired-all-manage...
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by gardenhedge on Sunday October 29, 2023 @04:50PM (#38062651)
Sounds like he fired a type of project manager - one who controlled the team. A project manager can manager the team by supporting them and unblocking them while doing non-implementation type work such as managing and reporting the project's budget, managing and reporting progress and delivery aims.
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by singron on Sunday October 29, 2023 @08:34PM (#38064337)
Google currently has program managers (and technical program managers). I could not tell you the difference between them and product or project managers.
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by jack_h on Sunday October 29, 2023 @02:54PM (#38061471)
It changes between companies. At my company the Product Owner is the one who maintains the relationship with customers. Product Managers are there for prioritizing the feature requests. We also have Project Managers for inter-project dependency tracking and Engineering Managers for resource allocation and work output.
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by haizhung on Sunday October 29, 2023 @03:36PM (#38061861)
I think that’s the challenging part. A product manager is supposed to stuff holes in your team that no one else currently does. Do you have a strong TL with a good product sense? Then the PM should probably spend their time talking to customers, and not interfere with the engineering team so much.

Do you have a good UX team, but the engineering team is just a bit too big to be comfortable? Then the PM should work with the team to streamline communications and processes.

The hard part about this is that on the one hand, you need a PM that is experienced enough that they can set up processes and be disciplined enough to make sure they are followed. On the other hand, you need a PM that is able to embrace the chaos on aspects of the teams organization where it is beneficial for the team. Oh, and also they should be a domain expert, if possible. Know SQL. Know how to talk to management. Etc.

I think if you have a good one, it is a strong force multiplier for the team. If you have a bad one, it is a force subtractor.

And it is extremely difficult to tell beforehand (or even while they are actually working in that team!) which kind of PM you have. It’s one of those roles that, if it’s done perfectly, people won’t be sure whether you have done anything at all.

But I agree with the premise that there are probably too many bad ones in circulation right now.

Re:The product manager role is a mistake by bruce511 on Sunday October 29, 2023 @03:54PM (#38062062)
There are certainly more bad managers than good ones. (Just like programmers.)

So it follows there will be more anecdotes about bad managers than good ones.

With respect, if you've never had a good, or great, manager then I understand it'll be hard to envision a good one.

I say this not to invalidate your anecdote but yo say that managers, like programmers, are not created equal and they cannot just be swapped like burgers at macdonalds.

Re:The product manager role is a mistake by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Sunday October 29, 2023 @04:03PM (#38062155)
My experience with product managers is that they wedge themselves between the business and the technical teams and then wield political power while doing very little.

I'm currently trying desperately to get two different PM's to talk to each other so we can be consistent with permissions sets across two different projects. Both projects use the same set of API's.

One of the PM's is basically incognito, the other has actively been trying to avoid doing any of the work.

But the technical teams will get blamed for this, I know because I've watched these same PM's blame the technical teams for their own failings on other projects.

I'm with the article, fuck Product Managers, grab a senior developer and let him or her spend part of their time interfacing with business while also teaching the younger developers the skills necessary to do it.

The problem isn't that their responsibilities aren't useful, it's that there shouldn't be a role dedicated to their responsibilities, it immediately draws moats around everything and suddenly the need for communication and collaboration jumps through the roof because the people in that role don't understand the technology the way a senior developer would.

There's a segment of the developer population that wants to put their head in the sand, do their job, and clock out. These developers are low value and will never be able to take on the role described above.

Re:The product manager role is a mistake by FireBeyond on Sunday October 29, 2023 @06:07PM (#38063324)
> My experience with product managers is that they wedge themselves between the business and the technical teams and then wield political power while doing very little.

There's a large number of companies where the company is the one wedging the PMs there.

My view is that a PMs job should include (but not be limited to) diplomacy, negotiation and facilitation. But if your heart isn't in that (and it can be easy to become disheartened), then it easily becomes "politics", and the worst parts of politics, at that.

Re:The product manager role is a mistake by foota on Sunday October 29, 2023 @06:10PM (#38063351)
I wonder if part of the gap here is about whether a company is B2B or B2C. In my experience at a largely B2B company, the product managers are people that aren't necessarily technical, but have experience in the relevant domain and meet with customers to find out what they need and coordinate launches etc., with them.

I don't know if the same role makes as much sense at a B2C company, so maybe people are B2Bs see their value and people at B2C companies don't as much?

Re:The product manager role is a mistake by steveBK123 on Sunday October 29, 2023 @06:39PM (#38063566)
I've seen shops hire product managers for INTERNAL customer facing apps, and then have the PMs basically not talk to those customers. They did instead talk extensively to product & tech management as well as the c-suite.

So tech people (even IC non-leads) end up on weekly calls with various internal stakeholders that the PM can't make (literally this is your job dude) and take the brunt of all the feedback/relationship management/etc with the trickier ones.

The worst was when he said he would take the weekly calls with Asia users but wanted to pre-meet with me first and ask I ride along with the weekly user call for a while. So we would pre-meet and then he would ghost on the user call so I end up having two calls instead of one.

Just cargo cult CTOs reading too many books and not actually looking at the evidence in front of their eyes.

Re:The product manager role is a mistake by braza on Sunday October 29, 2023 @06:59PM (#38063709)
Same experience, but I have one hypothesis: in B2C the “client” after some point become some abstract entity where people ship code/product to. A great PM can talk with those masses and extract exactly what needs to be done. This is a very hard skill.

In B2C the customer is way clearer and the relationship is everything and it’s quite hard a bad professional hide for long.

Re:The product manager role is a mistake by j45 on Sunday October 29, 2023 @11:07PM (#38065250)
The issue too often is business analysts wanting to be product managers when technical analysts may enable to learn the role better.

TA’s will devour the BA’s because tech folks can learn business easier than the other way around.

Still, BA’s can learn the details and get more fluent in working with them.

Re:The product manager role is a mistake by plorkyeran on Sunday October 29, 2023 @11:33PM (#38065391)
My experience with B2B PMs is that exactly one that I've worked with was amazing and the rest were just an awful intermediary that added a day of latency to any communication with our contact at customers and often managed to mangle things too.
Re:The product manager role is a mistake by alexchantavy on Sunday October 29, 2023 @06:16PM (#38063395)
I feel like that list of responsibilities describes a staff engineer too