I would understand perhaps semaphore because anyone can wave their arms about and communicate long distances.
But since radio requires equipment anyway, you might as well use modern digital equipment - with the benefit that in the same amount of time, power and bandwidth that a morse signal would use, you can send 10,000x more data.
Morse is the ultimate narrowband mode. The cleaner your oscillator and the narrower your output the better. On the receive side, you can make your receiver as narrow at the transmitters oscillator.
The only comparable digital mode is on-off keying which is used by cheap, low data rate devices. Even 'narrow' digital modes are wideband compared to morse code.
"On the receive side, you can make your receiver as narrow at the transmitters oscillator". Completely wrong, and shows a fundamental misunderstanding.
Morse is a wonderful mode, but suffers from the lack of error correction which had made modes like PSK31 and FT8 so much more effective, especially in bandwidth usage.
Clrly yu hve never usd this on the bands.
Yes, the error correction is between the operator ears. It is not a mode that can easily automated.
CW is wonderful, but is has long since been superseded by more modern digital modes.
You can easily use a transmitter with Gaussian keying to reduce the sidebands to zero.
The sidebands in CW ARE the information.
> When the key is down there is no modulation whatsoever.
No, but you can't keep the key down forever. The information is in the transition from Key-down to Key-up (and Vice/versa). Which is why the modulation envelope has to be tailored to the keying speed, else you get excessive key clicks.
> You can easily use a transmitter with Gaussian keying to reduce the sidebands to zero.
Gausian keying requires a Raised-Cosine envelope. It is this which contains the sidebands and the information, and causes the B/W to be widened.
The hobby already struggles with gatekeeping/driving off people who don't "ham right" and so making the hobby more accessible is a big positive in my book.
As long as you are Part 97 compliant, what exactly is your problem?
I mean the most basic CQ is dah dit dah dit - dah dah dit dah. You don't heard the dots or the dashes, you hear the rhythm. You don't see the CQ either, you know the concept from the rhythm as part of the conversation.
Btw, original American Morse had extra symbols!
To understand this further, let's consider a more advanced modulation scheme. Instead of just having two states (high and low) to represent binary bits, imagine we have four distinct states: high, medium-high, medium-low, and low. These states can represent combinations of bits as follows: high = 11, medium-high = 10, medium-low = 01, and low = 00.
In this scenario, each state transition represents a symbol, and since each symbol can represent two bits, the symbol rate (or baud rate) is half of the bit rate. If you know the symbol rate and want to determine the bit rate, you'd multiply the symbol rate by the number of bits per symbol. In this example, you'd multiply the baud rate by two.
Most signals rely on techniques beyond simple voltage differences though to transfer information, and that's when you delve into the world of RF theory. Instead of a discrete voltage, a sine wave is used at a particular frequency. The amplitude of the sine wave can be adjusted just like we adjusted the voltage on that line. If we want even more symbols, maybe 0000 to 1111 or bigger, we can introduce another variation to the sine wave called phase. Phase of a sine wave is just shifting it left or right, but could be visualized as two people on a race track. If they start a race from the same line and run at the same speed in the same direction, they're in phase. If one of them starts a quarter of the way ahead from the other and they both run at the same speed in the same direction, then he's a quarter phase shifted from the other.
That adjustment of phase and amplitude falls into a broad category of RF modulation called QAM, and it's used in more than RF between two radios. It can also be used over Ethernet or PCIe busses.
I could go on rambling for a long time on all this, but hopefully this helps answer your question.
The FCC set the rules, not a bunch of old farts upset that the morse code test was eliminated. But because the FCC doesn’t pay much attention to the Part 97 service, it has taken them this long to get around to updating the rules.
This change was proffered as far back as 2008 at a Dayton TAPR session.
The baud rate dates back to 1980. To be pedantic, the decoupling of symbol and baud rate was understood by some at least partially since at least the 1800s. The harmonic multiplex telegraph -- a kind of frequency multiplexing -- was an early invention, predating electronics. Matched resonators. Electromechanical resonators, much in the style of tuning forks, which only cause a strong resonance in tuning forks with certain related frequencies.
Such an arrangement is conceptually very similar to how a traditional radio transmitter/receiver pair are tuned with matched resonant circuits. Multiple carriers in parallel. OFDM had been thought up by at least the late 1940s.
The limit was always computational complexity. Measuring and comparing values at many different frequencies, and comparing against the predicted values, that a signal would have if it were indeed there. I am still surprised consumer hardware can now churn through those calculations, not only for 3 kHz of audio spectrum but, these days, tens of MHz of spectrum with an SDR.
However, amateur radio has some natural conservatism to it, like Morse code requirements (since retired) to gatekeep the hobby. Getting rid of this baud rate limit is long overdue as analog transmissions are laughably archaic for anything outside amateur radio.