News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by donatj on Saturday October 28, 2023 @04:09PM (#38052965)
I know next to nothing about radio, can someone tell me why a baud rate limit put in to begin with? Is there a technical reason for it like causing interference or something?
Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by gaze on Saturday October 28, 2023 @04:41PM (#38053180)
In nearly all cases, the lower the baud rate, the lower the bandwidth. You can come up with sufficiently pathological cases but indeed it’s the bandwidth that should be limited.
Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by Animats on Saturday October 28, 2023 @05:38PM (#38053635)
> In nearly all cases, the lower the baud rate, the lower the bandwidth. You can come up with sufficiently pathological cases but indeed it’s the bandwidth that should be limited.

This is not the case for classical frequency-shift amateur radioteletype. This sends two tones on single sideband, at 2125 Hz or 2295 Hz. So it uses up about 2.3KHz of bandwidth no matter how low the baud rate goes. 45.45 baud is classic mechanical Teletype speed, so the bandwidth is about 50x the data rate in that mode. You can do FSK up to maybe 600 baud; you need a few cycles to detect the tone frequency with classical filters. 300 is a traditional limit. Beyond that antique technology, you need a modulation scheme less than half a century old.

Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by Johnythree on Saturday October 28, 2023 @07:34PM (#38054482)
Your "2.3KHz of bandwidth" is caused by using a wide SSB filter to send a relatively narrow shift of 170Hz.

You equally could have used a narrower filter.

Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by Animats on Saturday October 28, 2023 @08:16PM (#38054719)
Pre-single-sideband suppressed carrier systems used an AM carrier, so there really were two audio tones. It's also possible to send FSK over FM, which was often done on VHF where there's more room.

Before everything went digital, this sort of thing tended to involve a chain of analog processing stages.

Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by Johnythree on Sunday October 29, 2023 @09:18AM (#38058333)
Hams sometimes used Audio Frequency Shift tones modulated on to an AM carrier as a temporary way of getting on air with an old style AM transmitter.

Which of course meant two sets of sidebands (eg four in total) and a excessively wide signal..

But any of the better quality transmitters (Ham, Commercial or military) used pure FSK directly.

Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by TedDoesntTalk on Saturday October 28, 2023 @04:20PM (#38053041)
I think to limit the amount of spectrum used by any one signal… prevent bandwidth hogs.
Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by ARandomerDude on Saturday October 28, 2023 @04:23PM (#38053057)
Uh oh. Looks like the Stack Overflow mods among us closed your question as off topic.
Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by donatj on Saturday October 28, 2023 @04:27PM (#38053075)
I reworded it to be more clear what I was asking and it turned around. It was fair.
Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by Steltek on Saturday October 28, 2023 @04:43PM (#38053196)
When the limit was put in place, we didn't know that symbol rate and baud rate could be different. A lot of these discoveries really came into their own during the 90's and enabled far more data transmission than previously imagined.

However, amateur radio has some natural conservatism to it, like Morse code requirements (since retired) to gatekeep the hobby. Getting rid of this baud rate limit is long overdue as analog transmissions are laughably archaic for anything outside amateur radio.

Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by selfhoster11 on Saturday October 28, 2023 @04:50PM (#38053236)
Morse sounds like a useful thing, really. There aren't many digital encodings that can be done by hand and still remain readable in high-noise conditions.
Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by londons_explore on Saturday October 28, 2023 @05:36PM (#38053615)
You still need equipment to transmit/receive radio...

I would understand perhaps semaphore because anyone can wave their arms about and communicate long distances.

But since radio requires equipment anyway, you might as well use modern digital equipment - with the benefit that in the same amount of time, power and bandwidth that a morse signal would use, you can send 10,000x more data.

Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by sidewndr46 on Saturday October 28, 2023 @06:43PM (#38054103)
What you're saying is very wrong.

Morse is the ultimate narrowband mode. The cleaner your oscillator and the narrower your output the better. On the receive side, you can make your receiver as narrow at the transmitters oscillator.

The only comparable digital mode is on-off keying which is used by cheap, low data rate devices. Even 'narrow' digital modes are wideband compared to morse code.

Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by Johnythree on Saturday October 28, 2023 @07:27PM (#38054455)
The bandwidth of a CW signal depends very much on the bandwidth of the modulation, eg the faster the keying speed, the wider the bandwidth.

"On the receive side, you can make your receiver as narrow at the transmitters oscillator". Completely wrong, and shows a fundamental misunderstanding.

Morse is a wonderful mode, but suffers from the lack of error correction which had made modes like PSK31 and FT8 so much more effective, especially in bandwidth usage.

Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by kmbfjr on Saturday October 28, 2023 @09:12PM (#38054988)
Lack of error correction?

Clrly yu hve never usd this on the bands.

Yes, the error correction is between the operator ears. It is not a mode that can easily automated.

Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by Johnythree on Sunday October 29, 2023 @10:00AM (#38058727)
Which is why PSK-31, WSPR, FT8, etc are so much more bandwidth efficient than CW.

CW is wonderful, but is has long since been superseded by more modern digital modes.

Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by sidewndr46 on Sunday October 29, 2023 @08:04AM (#38057738)
The sidebands of morse code carry no information and are incidental. When the key is down there is no modulation whatsoever.

You can easily use a transmitter with Gaussian keying to reduce the sidebands to zero.

Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by Johnythree on Sunday October 29, 2023 @09:04AM (#38058210)
> The sidebands of morse code carry no information and are incidental.

The sidebands in CW ARE the information.

> When the key is down there is no modulation whatsoever.

No, but you can't keep the key down forever. The information is in the transition from Key-down to Key-up (and Vice/versa). Which is why the modulation envelope has to be tailored to the keying speed, else you get excessive key clicks.

> You can easily use a transmitter with Gaussian keying to reduce the sidebands to zero.

Gausian keying requires a Raised-Cosine envelope. It is this which contains the sidebands and the information, and causes the B/W to be widened.

https://www.w8ji.com/cw_bandwidth_described.htm

Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by subhro on Saturday October 28, 2023 @05:30PM (#38053555)
Oh it’s crazy useful. You can communicate with a stupid lightbulb. It might save your life some day.
Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by kortilla on Saturday October 28, 2023 @05:56PM (#38053769)
Extremely unlikely. Learning to start a fire without matches or a lighter is far more likely to be life saving.
Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by carapace on Sunday October 29, 2023 @10:38PM (#38065115)
[delayed]
Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by lost_tourist on Saturday October 28, 2023 @06:29PM (#38053989)
What is a "stupid lightbulb" in this case? is that some kind of "ham operator" parlance, or are you only referring to using Morse code and a flashlight/light source?
Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by lebuffon on Saturday October 28, 2023 @06:40PM (#38054075)
It means you can transmit Morse code by blinking a light on and off in the correct manner.
Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by patmorgan23 on Saturday October 28, 2023 @11:15PM (#38055568)
Literally a light bulb
Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by vvanders on Saturday October 28, 2023 @05:00PM (#38053320)
Oh it's useful and if you want to use it that doesn't change. However a number of us are interested in the digital and experimental side of ham radio, for that morse code doesn't really offer anything and it's a non-trivial hurdle to cross.

The hobby already struggles with gatekeeping/driving off people who don't "ham right" and so making the hobby more accessible is a big positive in my book.

Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by lostapathy on Saturday October 28, 2023 @05:55PM (#38053756)
Exactly this. Current ham regs in the digital modes really, really limits what you can do, and keeps it in the dark ages compared to what goes on in 900mhz and 2.4ghz with unlicensed devices. We need to get back to where having a ham license means you can do cutting edge things!
Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by kmbfjr on Saturday October 28, 2023 @09:09PM (#38054979)
Give it a rest. No one holds you back in amateur radio and if the comments of old farts bothers you, perhaps you need to evaluate what prompts them to tell you that.

As long as you are Part 97 compliant, what exactly is your problem?

Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by vvanders on Saturday October 28, 2023 @10:14PM (#38055319)
Thanks for confirming that attitude still exists :)
Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by adgjlsfhk1 on Saturday October 28, 2023 @05:06PM (#38053378)
it has a number of pretty big downsides. for example, it's not a hamming code and isn't self synchronizing. it's not horrible, but it is missing a lot of the properties you would want from a modern digital code.
Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by baz00 on Saturday October 28, 2023 @06:27PM (#38053977)
That's a really bad way of looking at it. From a theoretical perspective yes but it's more useful if you think of it is a language. If you do it for a bit you'll get it and you tend to pick it up like another conversation method with different sounds that's all. It's not dots and dashes, it's musical phrases that you learn. And from that, like conversation, you fill in gaps and recognise words automatically.

I mean the most basic CQ is dah dit dah dit - dah dah dit dah. You don't heard the dots or the dashes, you hear the rhythm. You don't see the CQ either, you know the concept from the rhythm as part of the conversation.

Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by clbrmbr on Saturday October 28, 2023 @09:05PM (#38054951)
But you can hear the other “fist”. (If using a straight key or bug).

Btw, original American Morse had extra symbols!

Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by thrtythreeforty on Saturday October 28, 2023 @04:46PM (#38053213)
Do you mean bit rate and baud rate can be different? My understanding is that baud rate and symbol rate are the same thing.
Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by mal10c on Saturday October 28, 2023 @05:08PM (#38053394)
Baud rate and symbol rate often refer to the same thing, especially in the context of digital communications. However, they don't necessarily equate to the bit rate. In the digital realm, we're familiar with the concept of 1's and 0's, which represent binary states. When we transmit a single bit, it can be visualized as a digital line being high (for 1) or low (for 0). The rate at which this line transitions from one state to another is called the baud rate or symbol rate.

To understand this further, let's consider a more advanced modulation scheme. Instead of just having two states (high and low) to represent binary bits, imagine we have four distinct states: high, medium-high, medium-low, and low. These states can represent combinations of bits as follows: high = 11, medium-high = 10, medium-low = 01, and low = 00.

In this scenario, each state transition represents a symbol, and since each symbol can represent two bits, the symbol rate (or baud rate) is half of the bit rate. If you know the symbol rate and want to determine the bit rate, you'd multiply the symbol rate by the number of bits per symbol. In this example, you'd multiply the baud rate by two.

Most signals rely on techniques beyond simple voltage differences though to transfer information, and that's when you delve into the world of RF theory. Instead of a discrete voltage, a sine wave is used at a particular frequency. The amplitude of the sine wave can be adjusted just like we adjusted the voltage on that line. If we want even more symbols, maybe 0000 to 1111 or bigger, we can introduce another variation to the sine wave called phase. Phase of a sine wave is just shifting it left or right, but could be visualized as two people on a race track. If they start a race from the same line and run at the same speed in the same direction, they're in phase. If one of them starts a quarter of the way ahead from the other and they both run at the same speed in the same direction, then he's a quarter phase shifted from the other.

That adjustment of phase and amplitude falls into a broad category of RF modulation called QAM, and it's used in more than RF between two radios. It can also be used over Ethernet or PCIe busses.

I could go on rambling for a long time on all this, but hopefully this helps answer your question.

Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by Steltek on Saturday October 28, 2023 @04:57PM (#38053295)
Oops, yeah and it's not quite my domain of expertise. In fact, that's the big draw for me: Amateur radio has been amazing for filling in knowledge gaps of low level electrical engineering details. it takes things way past the simple CPU/system models from university CS class and the Arduino DC logic hobby projects. The educational potential is really top notch.
Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by fsckboy on Saturday October 28, 2023 @04:54PM (#38053266)
if there are two possible symbols in your communication medium that you switch between, bit rate is baud rate (with the two symbols being 0 and 1). If you have more symbols, then baud/symbol rate increases will correspond to greater bitrates increases by a factor.
Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by Steltek on Saturday October 28, 2023 @04:58PM (#38053307)
Okay, I was pretty sure I had it right the first time but my confidence is rather low since it's been a while since I read up on it.
Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by Crunchified on Saturday October 28, 2023 @06:00PM (#38053795)
Plenty of stories of old hams that became dysphagic following a stroke, but could still chat with fellow hams using Morse - whether using simple finger movements in the hospital or months later on-the-air.
Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by kmbfjr on Saturday October 28, 2023 @09:06PM (#38054954)
It has nothing to do with amateur radio operators being conservative. The rules were what they were, and amateurs experimented within those rules such as modifying fax modems for use on HF.

The FCC set the rules, not a bunch of old farts upset that the morse code test was eliminated. But because the FCC doesn’t pay much attention to the Part 97 service, it has taken them this long to get around to updating the rules.

This change was proffered as far back as 2008 at a Dayton TAPR session.

Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by retrac on Sunday October 29, 2023 @05:39AM (#38057022)
> When the limit was put in place, we didn't know that symbol rate and baud rate could be different.

The baud rate dates back to 1980. To be pedantic, the decoupling of symbol and baud rate was understood by some at least partially since at least the 1800s. The harmonic multiplex telegraph -- a kind of frequency multiplexing -- was an early invention, predating electronics. Matched resonators. Electromechanical resonators, much in the style of tuning forks, which only cause a strong resonance in tuning forks with certain related frequencies.

Such an arrangement is conceptually very similar to how a traditional radio transmitter/receiver pair are tuned with matched resonant circuits. Multiple carriers in parallel. OFDM had been thought up by at least the late 1940s.

The limit was always computational complexity. Measuring and comparing values at many different frequencies, and comparing against the predicted values, that a signal would have if it were indeed there. I am still surprised consumer hardware can now churn through those calculations, not only for 3 kHz of audio spectrum but, these days, tens of MHz of spectrum with an SDR.

Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by kmbfjr on Saturday October 28, 2023 @09:01PM (#38054929)
Two reasons, avoid interference because the benchmark was a generously wide single-sideband transmission, and to avoid creating the opportunity for competition with commercial services.

When these rules were adopted, a phone call to Europe was $3 per minute and a Telex as $10 for thirty words.

Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by myth2018 on Saturday October 28, 2023 @10:01PM (#38055259)
The spectrum is a limited resource. Rate limits restrict the amount of spectrum one occupies, leaving more of it for use by other operators.

There are other restrictions like this. For instance, in my country, only clubs are allowed to transmit analog TV continously. Individuals can only make short transmissions.

Some people argue that increasing the bandwidth would incentivize digital modes. I can understand the point, but I would rather experiment with low-bandwidth modes than to take larger portions of the spectrum with faster, potentially wasteful modes.

Re:FCC will vote on plan to remove outdated amateur radio te... by ryukoposting on Saturday October 28, 2023 @10:56PM (#38055498)
> Is there a technical reason for it like causing interference or something?

That's correct, more or less.

There's this thing called "frequency shift keying" (FSK) which was the de facto standard digital modulation technique at the time the regulations were created. With FSK, you transmit data by toggling back and forth between two frequencies. That abrupt jumping back-and-forth creates hellish interference for people trying to use nearby frequencies.

Today, the obvious solution is to limit bandwidth so that there's a healthy amount of space for people to avoid that interference. However, in a (1970s/1980s) world where FSK is the only widespread modulation scheme, that wasn't really the mindset. The way they saw it was simpler: "higher baudrates demand more bandwidth, and more bandwidth creates more interference." Thus, they regulated baudrate as a means of regulating bandwidth.

The impetus for the rule change is simple: we have better modulation techniques nowadays. In case I haven't bored you to death, the simplest one to explain is probably GFSK. It's similar to FSK, but instead of abruptly jumping between the two frequencies, you gradually slide back and forth between them (the "G" stands for Gaussian). GFSK requires more precise electronics, but it doesn't cause as much trouble for people trying to operate at nearby frequencies. There are countless other modulation techniques as well. Bluetooth is probably the most notable implementation of GFSK (though modern Bluetooth actually uses something else).

For completeness: FSK is very useful and it's still widely used today. Your garage door opener uses it, among other things.