I want to predict behavior and Google has always been a little too hermetic and occult for my taste.
There is no payoff for using a Google product versus one of the competitors, so a rational person would not accept the risk that Google pulls the plug on a product, or some contractor gets banned by Google and gets your whole account frozen, etc. There's no upside. It's not even gambling because there's no "win" possible - it's more like shooting an arrow straight up into the air and hoping it doesn't land on your head.
The linked article is literally about how Google is better than its competitor though! Obviously some people disagree.
If you want to write a nuanced take about risk and benefit, I'm there for it[1]. It's the stunningly absolutist take on something as clearly-not-a-big-deal as a cloud service provider, by people who would otherwise be willing to bet their careers on a job with a good vibe, that seems "deeply weird" to me.
[1] Actually I'm not. That's stuff's boring. But I respect that people do it.
Likewise, as a GCP customer, I've always had a real account rep and support I could talk to.
All of what you say is pretty accurate for free-tier Gmail/etc. No customer service, risk of an account getting blocked and nothing you can do, new apps not finding success and getting cancelled.
But none of it is the case with GCP. Customer service is great and you can reach real people easily, paid accounts aren't getting shut down without recourse unless you really are being abusive, and Google's not cancelling the services companies are paying for. (The same goes for the paid tier of Google Workspace.) It's a normal paid B2B relationship with all that usually entails.
It's unfortunate that people take their experiences and the stories they hear about the free consumer side, and extrapolate them to assume they're also true about the paid business side. It's understandable, but it's just not the case.
And neither GCP nor AWS is getting shut down. Even using the numbers you give, the answer is that the risk of either shutting down is zero for all intents and purposes. There's no reason to split hairs over which of two infinitesimally unlikely events is more likely, or use that as a justification for choosing one or the other.
I would also say that this is a byproduct of how google treats its customers, even on paid platforms. I used to manage Google Workspace few years ago (2016 -> 2020) and GCP (2018-2019) and I remember the difficulty I faced when attempting to reach a human. Even if I were to able to reach someone, I got someone who clearly was a tier 1 support, who wanted me to troubleshoot things by "turnings things off and back on again".
I've also seen blog posts (some even on hacker news) mirroring my experiences, so I know it's not just a "me thing".
Google is reaping what it sowed.
But I am not a Google customer. I am a Google user. I use all sorts of Google properties, but i dont give them any money.
What most Gmail users call "customer support" is really "user support". Your free account has the durability of what you pay - zero.
So should we judge customer support based on user support? Technically no. Do we? Of course we do. We absolutely judge the unseen experience on other things we can see.
Quite literally, we judge a book by its cover.
Google has a reputation for bad support. It has earned this reputation from endless free users. It may not be fair, it may not be true, but it exists.
Equally it has a reputation for shutting down services. Popular services. Gmail is likely safe. GCP is likely safe. Am I gonna bet my business existence on "likely"?
Not likely.
Dunno, they've still taken the time to implement all this crazy auto-management software for their free tier, so I'm fairly confident they'll deploy it from time to time on their paid stuff.
I'm curious how recent your experience was with GCP support? Sadly several contacts of mine were not long ago laid off from working there. Many of them had 10+ years industry experience. Presumably their roles were off-shored but from my experiences with other companies who have off-shored technical support, I don't imagine you'd get the same customer experience as you did before.
Ones I have personal experience with include Stadia (paid), and app maker (business).
https://killedbygoogle.com/ doesn't struggle to find content.
That's what I thought for a long time about google domains. Yet here we are.
I looked it up now to reconfirm, and it turns out a few days later it came out that Google Cloud Domains was also being shut down? [1]
WTF. OK, well that's idiotic. Maybe I have to take back my parent comment then. That's one of the dumbest corporate own-goals I've ever heard of.
That's not something I can even begin to explain or understand at all.
[1] https://cloud.google.com/domains/docs/deprecations/feature-d...
Selling to another company != shut down in my book. Although I'm already in the process of moving domains to another registrar...
Also if they're still keeping the original Google system then it's believable that they are indeed just selling Google Domains, but the fact that all domains must be migrated into Squarespace's system tells a different story.
Sure, in any other contexts, selling Stadia customers to Microsoft or Nvidia (for example) would be a voluntary decision, however they are barred from just shutting down this one. They can even shut down Gmail or YouTube with no legal repercussions (sure their reputation will suffer but legally it's in the clear), but Domains is in a different legal standing.
While chump change to the likes of Google, it demonstrates Squarespace views this business as highly profitable. Migrating an acquired business into your systems makes a lot of sense.
Unless you have some evidence it would have been just simply shut down otherwise, I think you're inferring things that do not exist. Few if any of the other "shut down by google" operations could have sold for anywhere near this amount, as they almost universally lost money and/or were niche.
[1] https://www.theregister.com/2023/06/18/google_domains_shutti....
If the onion released an article that states "Google sells it's domain business, who needs domains in 2023 anyway" this would be a great joke.
First, selling it to another company is just shutting it down but doing you the courtesy of migrating the data to another vendor. It still results in all of the management UIs, integrations, and APIs that you rely on going offline. It just avoids creating an immediate outage (but it will create one eventually, unless you start interacting with this other vendor).
Second, the point has repeatedly been made that GCP is fundamentally different from Google's other offerings and essentially immune from being shut down (even in the responses to this article). That may be true for GCP as a whole, but this proves that it's not true of the individual sub-components of GCP, even ones that seem extremely core.
I actually agree with the article that GCP is just good in ways that competitors aren't but... Running on their platform does continue to be a bit nerve-wracking.
Google is selling Domains to Squarespace. Yes, many techies will migrate their domains, but majority of the people on Google Domains probably wont. That's why Squarespace thought it was worth paying anything for, after all.
Personally, I'm moving my domains already. But, saying Google Domains was shut down is inaccurate - it was sold, as business units/subsidiaries tend to be...
Sure, in any other contexts, selling Stadia customers to Microsoft or Nvidia (for example) would be a voluntary decision, however they are barred from just shutting down this one. They can even shut down Gmail or YouTube with no legal repercussions (sure their reputation will suffer but legally it's in the clear), but Domains is in a different legal standing.
Of course they’re likely to not outright get rid of them thanks to ICANN. They could have however just given them away rather than selling them off. I feel like there’s some precedent there too? Maybe from Wordpress?
In any case, they weren’t forced to sell them. They had other options including _not_ shutting down. But even if they did merely give them to another company or sell them, people would have the chance to move their domain to another provider.
Really I just don’t get what point is trying to be made. Google shut down domains in every good faith interpretation of the phrase “shut down”. All the ICANN argument does is try to conflate “shut down” with “going against ICANN rules” but no one was ever suggesting that.
Fine, sure, but this is a cop-out. Clearly they really want to clear the thing: if it was to be a GCP-only option with no more consumer-focused Domains, they have temporarily set a transition period with no renewals and new domains and then bow out of consumer space, but even the enterprise version is being shu- sorry, I'll be using Google's term here, deprecated (https://cloud.google.com/domains/docs/deprecations/feature-d...). The Squarespace buyout is irrelevant here because unlike GCP Domains there are no automation features in the Squarespace's system (and have no plans to implement one), so you are required to migrate to another provider like DNSimple or AWS. This is a clear sign that they really want to dispose of it as soon as feasible.
> Really I just don’t get what point is trying to be made. Google shut down domains in every good faith interpretation of the phrase “shut down”. All the ICANN argument does is try to conflate “shut down” with “going against ICANN rules” but no one was ever suggesting that.
It's a reasonable assumption when you're talking about their first time in closing down things, but there is a clear trend, even solely in the enterprise space. (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38020254) At this point, it is clear that Google does shut down things when they feel it.
One year later, Google Graveyard.
Parent did point to Workspace where they also didn't get customer service.
To lay it first: GCP has excelent support if you're in the right bucket. For instance startup support programs will have dedicated engineers, sometimes on site, ready to meet and answer questions.
You'll also get that at the higher tiers (around where you start to negociate rebates in echange for usage volumes) with recurring slots with a support engineer to discuss your issues and growth inside the services.
But outside of the blessed situations, if you're just a mere paying user/business there will probably close to nothing for you.
And yes, education/corporate targeted products also get killed. Last month Jamboard's name was etched into its tombstone, along with Google Domains and so many others.
Even within GCP many products will get merged with more or less changes to adapt to. Stardriver becoming a different service with an unsearchable name comes to mind. Or the GA4 transition with the breaking changes.
I don't think GCP is going to shut down as a whole, but that doesn't mean I'd trust Google to keep any specific service I might depend on up and running.
Did you first try to understand what Pixel Pass was? No, it wasn't supposed to "pay off" with a phone upgrade. To get a new phone, users would have had to renew their Pixel Pass subscription. It wasn't - pay monthly for 2 years and get 2 phones: one at the start and end of the 2 years.
* Google Domains
* Google Cloud IoT Core
* Jamboard
Also they increased Google Maps pricing by like 10x at one point, and they increased Cloud Storage prices pretty substantially last year too. Price increases can be just as impactful as killing a product. I don't think AWS has ever increased any prices or shut down any service (though quite a few are essentially zombies - SimpleDB, OpsWorks).
Then on the consumer side, Google have killed quite a few paid products. One that bit me was they shut down Google Cloud Print which killed the ability for me to print to my (cheap) printer from my phone. Besides that, there was Nest Secure, Stadia, etc. etc.
Google's reputation problem isn't just coming from their free consumer apps.
https://www.allthingsdistributed.com/2023/09/farewell-ec2-cl...
That doesn't put my mind at ease. Under who's definition? Do I even get told what I did wrong? You try to draw a distinction between the free and paid products but that doesn't address the perception people have of the company in general. If I was a small startup I wouldn't want to risk it.
Potentially apocryphal, but it rings true enough that you have no idea what might anger the Google automation.
What's worse is that their loss-leading free products kill competing products before they finally abandon it themselves, leaving the space much worse than if they had ever entered it.
No chance I'll ever vender lock myself to GCP.
What possible end could that serve? I am baffled by the idea that succeeding via open access to their infrastructure is not a serious long-term goal for Google.
For a company who ostensibly is existentially interested in developing at least one meaningful complement to it advertising business, of all the things https://killedbygoogle.com/ over the years, why the domain registrar? The cost to developer trust vs. the cost of ongoing operations – did they not even have that conversation?
Now I imagine how I would've felt to have my registration transferred to – I can't even recall who bought their customers – and I try to imagine putting faith in trusting GCP products with a startup idea, where ostensibly their second-mover advantage could let me move faster in greenfield development ... and I throw my hands up. This is a company acting like it places no value on goodwill, not even from a bare bean counter perspective.
I guess I'll stick to AWS (and more bespoke cloud offerings).
We couldn’t get hold of any actual person at Google, and were told by our Google reseller to buy a fairly expensive support package to have our issue expedited after raising multiple appeals/objections. Suffice it to say, we run out of AWS now. I’ve heard GCP support (in terms of reaching an actual human support person/engineer has only gotten worse since then, and our experience occurred a good few years back).
Again, I'm willing to be wrong about recent reality, but GCP does not have a good reputation with its customers.
We onboarded a new client who had many different locations serving different brands. We set up these accounts, set up Google accounts for the locations to own/access the AdWords accounts, etc.
Out of about a dozen accounts, one got suspended.
There is no general Google Support for that. So I contacted AdWords support. They put in a ticket for me with the accounts team. They also told me it's unlikely I'd ever hear back about it and advised me that my best course of action was just to register a new account and hope that wasn't suspended too.
Three years later when I left that company, I was still getting occasional emails to remind me that my ticket was still open but there were no updates to provide.
Meanwhile, in AWS land...
With my personal AWS account (~$3k/yr spend) I've never had an issue getting in touch with support that can resolve any issue I raise. I accidentally bought a bunch of reservations under the wrong account and put a ticket in and they swapped them to the intended account right away. I raised a ticket about trying to use a new product and running into some issues that appeared to be on their end and a day later got an email from the lead engineer for the product.
At a company spending ~$250k/yr, not only could I access _the exact same support_, but we also had an account rep that would swing by the office once a month just to check in. We had his direct email and phone. He was actually empowered to do things. We had an AWS key leak and ran up over $100k in additional costs before we caught it and our payment didn't go through. Sent him an email and almost immediately got back to not worry about it--he'd put a note on the account that no action was to be taken without his approval. Shot off a ticket to support about the spend due to a security breach, and they asked us some basic questions to demonstrate that we knew how to prevent this happening again and then cancelled over $100k in charges. (Current company I'm at spends ~$360k/yr on GCP and we have no contact at Google.)
This isn't "conflating google's free product support with their B2B support". This is "google's culture does not leave room for providing proper product support".
What gets me is that AWS must have insane turnover with the Amazon stack ranking. The stability of that platform long term concerns me.
AWS is a utility at this point. Utilities are boring, conservative, and have people that know their systems and stay there for decades.
It seems like all the OP is saying is that the company evaluated alternatives (Azure & AWS) whose cloud products are "first class" citizens of the business whereas with Google the first class product is search, advertising, Android (a couple other things but you get the idea).
It doesn't seem too far out of left field that Google would flounder with all it's cloud products being phased out in favor of some other new product they've made or acquired.
It might adds negative credibility on HN.
That they’ve actually discussed shutting it down in the recent past lends plausibility to this risk. In 2019, they set 2023 as a deadline for moving into the #2 spot ahead of Azure. Obviously, they’ve not gotten anywhere near that.
[1] https://www.theinformation.com/articles/google-brass-set-202...
But I generally agree with what you’re saying
Google's cloud products are built around the needs of advertisers. A large and slow backend that's meant to churn ungodly amounts of data.
Amazon is a retail company their cloud products are build around this need. They have a highly segmented and mostly nimble backend that's mean to build unwieldy amounts of API.
Google probably should spin off GCP rather than killing it, but it's not a terrible idea to divest from a failing arm of a business. Google (like Intel) just does it too early.
So it's true that Ford US manufacturing have exited sedan production, Ford itself continues to build and sell sedans.
https://www.autotrader.com/archive/european-shoppers-also-so...
Ford China also isn't really launching new sedan models under the Ford brand. However, Ford is still making sedans worldwide under the Mustang brand.
There's no way that was under consideration. This "person with direct knowledge of the matter" must have somehow received bad information or not been honest.
AWS is basically the same infra Amazon runs their own business on, opened up for the world to use.
Azure is the backbone that Microsoft sells you all their cloudified Office/Outlook/etc suite of tools.
GCP is neither of those things to Google.
Spanner is used ubiquitously inside of Google, supporting services such as; Ads, Gmail and Photos. ... Spanner on the other hand processes 3 billion queries per second at peak, which is more than 20x higher [than DynamoDB], and has more than 12 exabytes of data under management. https://cloud.google.com/blog/products/databases/announcing-...
Google Colossus file system underpins all storage across Google services and GCP Cloud Storage. https://cloud.google.com/blog/products/storage-data-transfer...
Monarch: Google's Planet-Scale In-Memory Time Series Database, provides metrics for Google's own services and GCP Operation suite. https://research.google/pubs/pub50652/
Zanzibar: Google’s Consistent, Global Authorization System - underpins access control across Google's product and GCP IAM. https://research.google/pubs/pub48190/
https://www.cnbc.com/2021/06/04/google-is-moving-parts-of-yo...
With GCP I feel like you should stick to the core services to avoid any risks.
On GCP, not the same. The GCP console of around 2012 if memory serves me well, is barely recognizable. That just the UX and I'm sure APIs would have changed as well in the meantime.
The hip product management culture of Google is beyond me. Today's cloud console would be something else tomorrow and I'm sure some hip and smart PM is chalking that out on their Chromebook or something. Sorry for the stereotyping.
As of speaking to customers, I bet AWS (real people) directly, routinely reach out to even 2 person startups. I have experienced it myself. They really do care. Even I had multiple hour long calls with Azure representative for an account who's monthly spend was a joke.
On the other hand, good luck with getting anyone from Google on email let alone phone.
If anything, they have been too eager to talk when I had nothing to discuss with them.
But my complain about product stability and maturity remains and that's admittedly is subjective.
Even if it's just to assuage fears.
At best GCP is slightly better than AWS (debatable), which is not enough to offset the risk because of how much of a pain it is to switch cloud providers.
Even if GCP shutting down is one in a million, aws shutting down is 1 in ten million.
Also, I keep getting the feeling that Google keeps trying to automate their customer service through bots. I have use quite a few google services from youtube, to google workspaces (a paid service) - I have never talked to a Google representative. I have talked to AWS service reps multiple times, I have talked to Amazon reps multiple times. Amazon as a company has real people you can talk to.
I don't trust google to not shut down my gcp account because my gmail was connected to some project where I accidentally sent a bunch of spam emails to a test account. And if that did I happen, I feel like I would just get an automated message and a bunch of hoops to jump through before I could talk to a real person.