News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I think GCP is better than AWS – by Fernando Villalba by Alupis on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @07:41PM (#38019799)
Google Domains is not being shut down - it's being sold to Squarespace. I would assume Cloud Domains either went with that package, or is being removed as part of the deal.

Selling to another company != shut down in my book. Although I'm already in the process of moving domains to another registrar...

Re:I think GCP is better than AWS – by Fernando Villalba by zinekeller on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @07:47PM (#38019848)
Google, and all other domain registrars, are obliged by ICANN to allow domain migrations in case that the original registrar is shutting down. Getting money from Squarespace is just icing on the cake. You're sounding that this is a decision that Google is doing voluntarily, but it's literally not an option here (for once).

Also if they're still keeping the original Google system then it's believable that they are indeed just selling Google Domains, but the fact that all domains must be migrated into Squarespace's system tells a different story.

Re:I think GCP is better than AWS – by Fernando Villalba by Alupis on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @07:49PM (#38019868)
What point are you trying to make? Because it has nothing to do with my comment as far as I can tell.
Re:I think GCP is better than AWS – by Fernando Villalba by zinekeller on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @07:51PM (#38019882)
They are forced to sell it by their contracts with ICANN - this is not a decision that they have done voluntarily. If they can legally shut down Domains they would have done it.

Sure, in any other contexts, selling Stadia customers to Microsoft or Nvidia (for example) would be a voluntary decision, however they are barred from just shutting down this one. They can even shut down Gmail or YouTube with no legal repercussions (sure their reputation will suffer but legally it's in the clear), but Domains is in a different legal standing.

Re:I think GCP is better than AWS – by Fernando Villalba by Alupis on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @07:54PM (#38019908)
They sold it for a reported $180 Million[1]

While chump change to the likes of Google, it demonstrates Squarespace views this business as highly profitable. Migrating an acquired business into your systems makes a lot of sense.

Unless you have some evidence it would have been just simply shut down otherwise, I think you're inferring things that do not exist. Few if any of the other "shut down by google" operations could have sold for anywhere near this amount, as they almost universally lost money and/or were niche.

[1] https://www.theregister.com/2023/06/18/google_domains_shutti....

Re:I think GCP is better than AWS – by Fernando Villalba by zinekeller on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @07:58PM (#38019946)
And they're also shutt- I mean deprecated their enterprise version? (https://cloud.google.com/domains/docs/deprecations/feature-d...) That doesn't sound like "oh, we're selling this because it's valuable money" but more of "we don't have the energy to maintain this".
Re:I think GCP is better than AWS – by Fernando Villalba by mixermachine on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @07:59PM (#38019952)
Isn't the goal to offer a good experience and a one platform rules it all approach? A massive downgrade for the GCP platform.

If the onion released an article that states "Google sells it's domain business, who needs domains in 2023 anyway" this would be a great joke.

Re:I think GCP is better than AWS – by Fernando Villalba by QuinnyPig on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @08:44PM (#38020267)
So when they get bored and sell their relational databases off to Oracle, what then?
Re:I think GCP is better than AWS – by Fernando Villalba by clhodapp on Thursday October 26, 2023 @12:59AM (#38021768)
I don't see the point of making this distinction.

First, selling it to another company is just shutting it down but doing you the courtesy of migrating the data to another vendor. It still results in all of the management UIs, integrations, and APIs that you rely on going offline. It just avoids creating an immediate outage (but it will create one eventually, unless you start interacting with this other vendor).

Second, the point has repeatedly been made that GCP is fundamentally different from Google's other offerings and essentially immune from being shut down (even in the responses to this article). That may be true for GCP as a whole, but this proves that it's not true of the individual sub-components of GCP, even ones that seem extremely core.

I actually agree with the article that GCP is just good in ways that competitors aren't but... Running on their platform does continue to be a bit nerve-wracking.