News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by siva7 on Monday October 23, 2023 @04:27PM (#37991112)
Is this really a thing or just some local phenomena? I can't remember that the github profile played a role in any hiring committee i've been part of (western europe) as people understood that most of the experienced software developers aren't active open source contributors.
Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by wizerdrobe on Monday October 23, 2023 @04:34PM (#37991204)
Here in a flyover type state in the US:

It never served a a cheat-code, or a skip-the-line or any such goodness. What it did was serve as a conversation starter, “I see project Y in strange language X. What is the story there?”

That’s your cue to sell yourself, your skills, your experience, etc.

I could never know, but perhaps having it also got me on the short-list for an interview to begin with?

I would say GitHub has featured in at about half of my interviews.

Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by eschneider on Monday October 23, 2023 @04:55PM (#37991464)
When I get a resume for someone I've been asked to interview, I'll certainly look at any github profiles, and if there's something relevant there, I'll often use their project as a basis for whatever coding exercise we do, such as extend this class to add X functionality. Or use it as a basis for design questions.
Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by geraldwhen on Monday October 23, 2023 @06:25PM (#37992436)
A nonstandard interview process like this is illegal in some jurisdictions. It may run afoul of US law too, depending on the outcomes.

It is safer and easier to use a one size fits all interview.

Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by ygjb on Monday October 23, 2023 @06:30PM (#37992490)
Genuinely curious, which jurisdictions is it actually illegal?
Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by paulryanrogers on Monday October 23, 2023 @07:58PM (#37993257)
In practice GH or FOSS criteria often exclude people of color. They often don't grow up with -- or have in adulthood -- enough money and free time to log meaningful GitHub activity or stars.
Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by arp242 on Monday October 23, 2023 @11:27PM (#37994581)
No one is talking about having it as a "criteria", but simply about using it if it's there.
Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by hallway_monitor on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @02:59AM (#37995598)
Interview with coding and design is nonstandard and possibly illegal? We must be living in different timelines.
Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by eschneider on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @09:51AM (#37999181)
Except it's pretty much standard. If there isn't a github link, I'm still going to tailor the programming questions to a context that I infer from the past experience on their resume (as in, they said they did X, so they should know about Y) but with a bit less accuracy.

Most of the interview is getting the candidate to show me that they know _something_ in depth and I'm not super concerned with exactly what it is. (If they've learned something in depth, I expect they can also learn the details of what we do. :) So the exact same questions to every candidate serves no one's interests.

Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by blindhippo on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @11:49AM (#38000865)
I think the nuance here is if you tailor ALL interviews for a specific job based on each candidate to the point where the interviews are no longer directly comparable, that could constitute a hiring practice that would run afoul of some laws in various places.

However, what you're describing sounds reasonable to me - you're offering the same overall interview structure, just tailoring the question to delve more into someone's bespoke experience. That's a hell of a lot more work than a one size fits all (ala leetcoding style) question - kudos to you.

Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by arghwhat on Monday October 23, 2023 @05:04PM (#37991563)
I can anecdotally attest to contact and employment happening solely based on Github profile - without it containing anything impressive - in Scandinavia, as well as a few cases where the profile was used as input in a regular interview process.

Do what you want with that info.

Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by ahoka on Monday October 23, 2023 @05:15PM (#37991705)
It’s just another site to scrape for dev profiles.
Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by jokethrowaway on Monday October 23, 2023 @07:05PM (#37992803)
Same, albeit they had no idea about its content.

Same as for linkedin

Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by arghwhat on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @07:23AM (#37997473)
In this case the code was actually reviewed, but I imagine existence itself is also used in some cases.
Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by tedivm on Monday October 23, 2023 @05:17PM (#37991725)
In my experience it's a positive sign to have an active Github profile or open source contributions, but it is not a negative sign if a candidate doesn't have one.

At higher levels (Principal, Distinguished) you often have to show external contributions to the industry, and some companies count open source towards this.

I can honestly say that my profile has been a huge benefit to my career, but that's more due to 20 years of open source contributions and a very customized (and automated) profile page.

https://github.com/tedivm/

Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by catlover76 on Monday October 23, 2023 @06:31PM (#37992503)
I am infinitely less qualified/smart than you, but I will steal your format for my own shitty and lame accolades and accomplishments nonetheless
Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by constantly on Monday October 23, 2023 @07:14PM (#37992880)
Yeah, when your GitHub profile looks like _that_! I would take that into account as well as a hiring manager. I do regularly click through candidates’ GH profiles and they’re usually not noteworthy so don’t count them for or against them. If they looked like yours though I would definitely read more deeply.
Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by flir on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @07:10PM (#38006957)
Yeah, that's not a github profile that's a landing page for a one-man consultancy. Very impressive.
Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by Lucretia9 on Monday October 23, 2023 @07:31PM (#37993037)
An Ada image with zero use of Ada.
Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by tedivm on Thursday October 26, 2023 @09:06AM (#38024985)
What Ada image?
Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by bonestamp2 on Monday October 23, 2023 @05:25PM (#37991817)
I had a friend working with a well known startup founder. The founder was interested in me from what my friend told him, all he wanted to see was my github profile. All of my github projects are private. That was the end of that, even after he already knew that my experience was perfect for their company. So ya, some people definitely put too much emphasis on the github profile.
Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by Grimburger on Monday October 23, 2023 @06:05PM (#37992225)
You can share private repos? Granting access for a week isn't hard.
Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by siva7 on Monday October 23, 2023 @06:18PM (#37992363)
Why should parent bother if the startup ceo can't be bothered to interview on the signal of a personal referal?
Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by Grimburger on Saturday October 28, 2023 @12:46AM (#38047222)
Because they want a job and need to pay for the goods and services they desire to utilise?
Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by blindhippo on Monday October 23, 2023 @06:22PM (#37992410)
I would presume they are organizational/protected repos which cannot be shared due to a contractual obligation, not private and personal repos.
Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by withinboredom on Monday October 23, 2023 @07:31PM (#37993035)
If you were to share your current job's private repos with me, I wouldn't hire you since that's a signal that you would do the exact same when you leave my company.
Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by zuzu89 on Monday October 23, 2023 @06:11PM (#37992288)
this is a perfectly reasonable decision when hiring for a startup, why waste hours, that you don't have, on interviews testing the candidate when you can lookup their past work
Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by siva7 on Monday October 23, 2023 @06:21PM (#37992401)
That's in no way reasonable and would show pretty weak hiring skills in a ceo obvious to people who have hired many engineers in the past.
Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by zdragnar on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:10PM (#37993350)
Considering how important networking is to startup businesses, you'd think a startup founder would put a little more weight on an employee referral than only considering their GitHub profile.
Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by chinchilla2020 on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:54PM (#37993698)
Almost 100% of my work (in midsize to big tech) is confidential. I cannot go sharing my work due to 10,000 confidentiality agreements.

I can share my random side projects... but what is the use of that? They aren't that impressive compared to my actual work.

My fear is that I will have to put lots of advertising into myself for things that don't describe what I actually do.

Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by zuzu89 on Monday October 23, 2023 @06:02PM (#37992186)
> (western europe) as people understood that most of the experienced software developers aren't active open source contributors.

that's probably true for western europe. compared to the US there is significant less open source projects,businesses and developers.

Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by bdw5204 on Monday October 23, 2023 @09:28PM (#37993908)
Most experienced software developers in the US also aren't active open source contributors. Most experienced developers who have contributed to open source probably did so as part of their job whether because they worked for an open source business or because they fixed an issue with an open source project that was important to their employer's business.

I personally have contributions to an open source project because I was employed by it for around 3 years but I generally spend my free time on hobbies other than writing code.

Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by paulgb on Monday October 23, 2023 @06:08PM (#37992260)
I doubt many people cheat stars to get hired, it’s just not a major signal there. But with stars being a signal of traction for open source startups, I definitely think there are some companies out there buying them.

Particularly in crypto where people want to quantify “community” and star count is a crude but very available way to do that.

Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by ethanbond on Monday October 23, 2023 @06:34PM (#37992532)
+1 seems like a much "better"/more valuable signal to game for startups built on OSS than for individuals.
Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by da768 on Monday October 23, 2023 @07:08PM (#37992826)
Don't know, but you can definitely find GitHub profiles built on reattributing other people's PRs to OSS projects, and they end up working for Google.
Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by plugin-baby on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:26PM (#37993476)
Any examples? How do you reattribute other peoples’ PRs?
Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by herpdyderp on Monday October 23, 2023 @07:18PM (#37992920)
What bugs me is when an applicant prominently includes a link to their GitHub profile in their resume and then that profile has zero activity. All I can gather from that is that they aren't paying attention to what they're doing: they created a profile solely because some seminar said to put it on a resume. If you don't have anything to show, simply don't include the link!
Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by surge on Monday October 23, 2023 @07:29PM (#37993016)
I've seen it more in the context of security, if you want developers to use a malicious library or extension, you can buy stars to give it a fake reputation boost making people more likely to use it.