News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by geraldwhen on Monday October 23, 2023 @06:25PM (#37992436)
A nonstandard interview process like this is illegal in some jurisdictions. It may run afoul of US law too, depending on the outcomes.

It is safer and easier to use a one size fits all interview.

Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by ygjb on Monday October 23, 2023 @06:30PM (#37992490)
Genuinely curious, which jurisdictions is it actually illegal?
Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by paulryanrogers on Monday October 23, 2023 @07:58PM (#37993257)
In practice GH or FOSS criteria often exclude people of color. They often don't grow up with -- or have in adulthood -- enough money and free time to log meaningful GitHub activity or stars.
Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by arp242 on Monday October 23, 2023 @11:27PM (#37994581)
No one is talking about having it as a "criteria", but simply about using it if it's there.
Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by hallway_monitor on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @02:59AM (#37995598)
Interview with coding and design is nonstandard and possibly illegal? We must be living in different timelines.
Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by eschneider on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @09:51AM (#37999181)
Except it's pretty much standard. If there isn't a github link, I'm still going to tailor the programming questions to a context that I infer from the past experience on their resume (as in, they said they did X, so they should know about Y) but with a bit less accuracy.

Most of the interview is getting the candidate to show me that they know _something_ in depth and I'm not super concerned with exactly what it is. (If they've learned something in depth, I expect they can also learn the details of what we do. :) So the exact same questions to every candidate serves no one's interests.

Re:The GitHub Black Market That Helps Coders Cheat the Popul... by blindhippo on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @11:49AM (#38000865)
I think the nuance here is if you tailor ALL interviews for a specific job based on each candidate to the point where the interviews are no longer directly comparable, that could constitute a hiring practice that would run afoul of some laws in various places.

However, what you're describing sounds reasonable to me - you're offering the same overall interview structure, just tailoring the question to delve more into someone's bespoke experience. That's a hell of a lot more work than a one size fits all (ala leetcoding style) question - kudos to you.