News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by trauco on Monday October 02, 2023 @06:24AM (#37736282)
A good reminder that academic institutions often fail to recognize the best in their ranks. From this NYTimes article: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/04/08/health/coronavirus-mrna-k...

About Dr. Kariko:

"But for many years her career at the University of Pennsylvania was fragile. She migrated from lab to lab, relying on one senior scientist after another to take her in. She never made more than $60,000 a year"

Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by elashri on Monday October 02, 2023 @06:39AM (#37736417)
To be honest and in this context. Nobel prize committees doesn't do any better and have history of failing in recognizing great scientific achievements until long time passes (and sometimes scientists die before that which disqualify them from the prize)
Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by ramraj07 on Monday October 02, 2023 @06:47AM (#37736488)
In that vein what institution in the history of mankind ever been fair and objective more than this?
Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by empath-nirvana on Monday October 02, 2023 @09:45AM (#37738021)
They only give one per year and there's probably more than one nobel prize worthy achievement every year on average, so they end up with a backlog. Unless something huge happens in a given year like the Higgs, they're probably going to reach back as far as they can for a worthy award to make sure people get the awards before they die.
Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by Ekaros on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @01:52AM (#37748385)
Also Higgs probably falls in that category too. His original research was almost 50 years old... Only receiving award after it was confirmed with testing.
Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by kevmo on Monday October 02, 2023 @06:35AM (#37736378)
And her daughter won 2 Olympic gold medals! That family must be intense!
Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by xattt on Monday October 02, 2023 @07:11AM (#37736661)
The perspective from the inside is pretty different from the outside. High-functioning families see their achievements as “normal” while the rest of the community looks around in awe.
Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by sdfghswe on Monday October 02, 2023 @08:28AM (#37737235)
Yes. That's because "high-functioning families" compare themselves with those who are better, not those who are worse. They go "sure I got 2 olympic medals, but bob and suse also got 2 each. It's not a big deal". They never dwell in thoughts like "I got 2 olympic medals, and look at the billions of people who got zero."

It's just a culture of self-improvement.

Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by DaedPsyker on Monday October 02, 2023 @08:45AM (#37737382)
And misery if done wrong. I have to temper my perfectionist temperament to avoid the self flagellation that comes with small failings.
Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by funnym0nk3y on Monday October 02, 2023 @11:20AM (#37739289)
I'm not sure about that. Being in a state of constant fear of failure doesn't enable one to do great stuff.
Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by somenameforme on Monday October 02, 2023 @11:42AM (#37739589)
Absolutely. Becoming world class at anything, especially anything competitive, also involves failing about a million times on the way up. In coaching chess one of the first things one tends to ask is what the student wants to achieve. And the typical response has something to do with winning. But they don't need you for that. If they just want to win, then they but need to never play anybody better than themselves!

Improving involves blood, sweat, tears, and defeat. Only to come back ever stronger.

Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by funnym0nk3y on Monday October 02, 2023 @12:52PM (#37740882)
That's maybe the essence of a growth mindset. I want to play. Winning is secondary.
Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by cm2012 on Monday October 02, 2023 @05:40PM (#37744824)
Building a business is the same way. Just constant punches in the face you have to persevere through.
Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by darkwater on Monday October 02, 2023 @11:43AM (#37739593)
You can fail or have success on many dimensions. There is probably some skill you are good innately, or better than a large chunk of population. On that dimension you will have probably have built a pretty good self-esteem over the years, but you know that you can still improve (hence comparing yourself with who got 4 medals if you have 2) but fear of failing will not completely block you, only stress you more to raise the bar. On the other hand, in domains where you are not so good by default, if you are a perfectionist you can totally risk being paralyzed until you think you are "good enough for it".
Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by funnym0nk3y on Monday October 02, 2023 @12:51PM (#37740853)
I don't think there is a "good by default" dimension. Maybe a "learning easier" dimension. I'd argue that in such advanced spheres comparison becomes secondary. First an foremost it's about the activity. Like friends competing in a game of cards. It's about having fun with friends. Winning is for having a purpose to play.
Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by anonporridge on Monday October 02, 2023 @12:34PM (#37740575)
It's just what happens whenever you rise in the ranks of any domain.

People in the 99th percentile aren't super happy and satisfied that they've outcompeted 99% of the participating population who looks at them with awe and envy. They're comparing themselves to the 99.9th percentile who leave them in awe and envy.

I think it's important for any high performer to occasionally step out of their narrow perception of the world and really grok how far ahead they are compared to everyone else. This is definitely something a lot of my high income tech friends could learn to appreciate when they get caught up feeling like a loser for only making $250k total comp.

Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by xattt on Monday October 02, 2023 @08:11PM (#37746236)
> I think it's important for any high performer to occasionally step out of their narrow perception of the world and really grok how far ahead they are compared to everyone else.

A (pre-Putin) Russian proverb goes it’s better to be first in the village, than it is to be last in the city.

Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by ChicagoBoy11 on Monday October 02, 2023 @09:43AM (#37737990)
I know a family of a nobel prize winner, and everyone in it is just insanely talented -- like, if you were to caricature the experience of a super genius family you'd actually probably get pretty close to them. And, your point is spot on. For them, the sheer creativity and output (in writing, science, and music) of the whole family was kind of seen as table stakes and something rather unremarkable. Whenever I was over for dinner I felt like a kid in class who hadn't done the reading haha (just in terms of how hard it was to keep up... they were all super gracious and I have many many cherished memories from the time we hung out)
Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by arbuge on Monday October 02, 2023 @07:35AM (#37736857)
The class of people who seem to do well in academia these days are those focused on grinding out masses of papers on incremental advances. Professors good at writing grant applications do well too, because with those grants they can afford to hire lots of graduate students to help with those incremental advances and masses of papers.

Individuals focused on real discovery and not publishing much until they really have something significant to say don't fit into this well.

Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by kiba on Monday October 02, 2023 @08:23AM (#37737190)
Maybe we should bring back the concept of the gentleman(gentleperson for the modern era) scientist, who are both independent and wealthy.

Charles Darwin, for example, was born into wealth and doesn't really need to work for a living.

Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by tetrep on Monday October 02, 2023 @08:31AM (#37737258)
According to this data, at least in the US, wealthy people are already "gentlepersoning" us in many elite fields: https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2014/03/18/289013884/who-...
Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by 2devnull on Monday October 02, 2023 @10:26AM (#37738560)
It’s international. The global elite are not constrained by borders.
Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by maven29 on Monday October 02, 2023 @11:51AM (#37739735)
There aren't a lot of places where going into academia has significant opportunity cost (like for example, losing out on the prospect of a yacht paid for by reactjs work).
Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by dkqmduems on Monday October 02, 2023 @08:26AM (#37737215)
While we're at it let's bring back the monarchy!
Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by badcppdev on Monday October 02, 2023 @09:59AM (#37738224)
Well at the moment the UK could really benefit from tax revenue from a certain prosperous former colony so that sounds good to me. Not sure about the benefit for the colony.
Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by graemep on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @09:58AM (#37752037)
Which of the UK's prosperous former colonies do you have in mind? There are several scattered around the world.

Even ones that are not all that prosperous per capita achieve things like moon landings.

You can have the monarchy without being a colony - several former colonies do.

Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by chpatrick on Monday October 02, 2023 @08:42AM (#37737353)
I think in obscure unprofitable fields that's already the case.
Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by AlexErrant on Monday October 02, 2023 @09:24AM (#37737747)
Musk and Bezos have their science/engineering experiments... and Gates through his investments. Hell, if we look at this broadly, many investments are being made in science - just through through (and to) institutions.

Basic science funding seems sparse though. Investments tend to favor commercial entities.

Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by heyoni on Monday October 02, 2023 @09:53AM (#37738126)
Yes but they mostly direct stuff and wouldn’t know how to calibrate a pipette if their life depended on it
Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by Kranar on Monday October 02, 2023 @09:52AM (#37738122)
Funny you bring up Charles Darwin, since Darwin was never an academic.
Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by edanm on Monday October 02, 2023 @10:05AM (#37738312)
There's no need to "bring it back" because we never "got rid of it". It's just a natural part of some people being wealthy - they have more time/resources to spend on various pursuits, including art and science.

This is still true, although to a lesser degree, because everyone is much better off. 500 years ago, you could only pursue some things if you were born rich. Today, the field has greatly expanded, to everyone's benefit.

Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by dekhn on Monday October 02, 2023 @10:43AM (#37738797)
There are several SROs ("Scientific Research Organizations") funded by extremely wealthy folks (typically made their billions in tech). They can offer scientists a number of nice things that universities can't- for example, Arc Institute, created by Patrick Collison among others, has plenty of lab space and computing for its members, compared to the space and computing available on campuses like UCSF and Stanford.
Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by f6v on Monday October 02, 2023 @11:29AM (#37739394)
Yes, I’m willing to accept donations to become multimillionaire and do science. Cash or check from you?
Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by esafak on Monday October 02, 2023 @06:08PM (#37745123)
Rich people today fund the people that do the work, rather than do it themselves. I'd say the new way is more productive.
Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by renewiltord on Monday October 02, 2023 @06:49PM (#37745517)
That never went away. We just have multiple avenues:

1. Government funded research

2. Private industrial research

3. Private personal research

Usually, those involved in #3 are made fun of constantly by the lumpenproles. Before someone in category #3 makes it they look like Bryan Johnson doing Blueprint. That's the defining characteristic, actually. If you were to look at Ms. Kariko before she was successful, the majority of HN users would have made fun of her.

Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by jjtheblunt on Monday October 02, 2023 @11:50AM (#37739710)
I wonder if there's a way to measure the proportions of impactful science coming from private companies versus universities. Perhaps measure by field, too, since the proprotions may differ in genomics vs electrical engineering, for example.

I don't have any idea how to calculate those proportions, but it's an awesome puzzle.

Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by wolverine876 on Monday October 02, 2023 @12:56PM (#37740938)
Private companies are interested in profitable science, not impactful science. In fact it can have negative impact: Discovering a way to extend intellectual property rights for an expiring patent, or a formulation that they can charge more for. Discovering a cheap cure for cancer wouldn't help profits.

And have their own internal politics - they want science that does not disrupt the VP/CEO's plans, or make the chief scientist look bad.

Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by lotsofpulp on Monday October 02, 2023 @05:13PM (#37744461)
> Discovering a cheap cure for cancer wouldn't help profits.

Hence patents. The new Hep C treatments are hundreds of thousands of dollars cheaper than older treatments, but we’re still researched and developed.

Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by mananaysiempre on Monday October 02, 2023 @02:13PM (#37742182)
Many companies, unfortunately, go out of their way to not produce meaningful science in the sense of publicly available (trade secrets) or publicly usable (patents) knowledge. Biotech especially.
Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by radus on Monday October 02, 2023 @05:39PM (#37744807)
How is that different from any profit seeking endeavor? You could write the same company about software companies that don't open source all of their code..
Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by mananaysiempre on Monday October 02, 2023 @06:09PM (#37745128)
Fundamentally, it isn‘t. Practically, some industries are more open about their work than others—computer graphics (both game and cinematic) come to mind as an example on the opposite end of the spectrum from the secretive worlds of biotech or (say) semiconductor manufacturing.

My point was only that (by the definition I think makes the most sense here) they are doing science to the exact extent they give up the intellectual-property monopoly, whatever that extent happens to be.

Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by MichaelZuo on Monday October 02, 2023 @08:05PM (#37746189)
So all the folks doing experiments on telescopes, astronomy, etc., without publicizing it during Medieval Europe were not doing science?
Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by mananaysiempre on Monday October 02, 2023 @09:05PM (#37746635)
I mean, there’s definitely a date in the past before which this definition is not useful. On the other hand, if a human learns something new, but nobody else does as a consequence of that, has human knowledge advanced? There are always edge cases—occasionally the mere awareness that something is possible has allowed others to rediscover the method—but generally I’d say no.

That does not mean that dissemination of new information has to work like it does now. The Republic of Letters was very different but quite successful. But if you have taken no effort to make your discovery available to others, I’d say you’re not advancing the cause of human learning; if you have taken effort to ensure it is not available, like what many patents aim for nowadays, I’d say you’re working against it.

Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by adrian_b on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @08:53AM (#37751191)
The folks doing experiments on telescopes, astronomy, etc., during Medieval Europe, almost always made great efforts to publicize their work.

On the other hand, those who at the same time were experts in, for instance, making shoes, made efforts to keep secret their techniques.

Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by wolverine876 on Monday October 02, 2023 @12:24PM (#37740365)
Just for context, what experience is that based on? What fields in academia? Do you work there or have friends there?
Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by quantum_magpie on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @01:03AM (#37748156)
I am in academia and I see the same thing among my colleagues. In physics and chemistry. I also see a lot of data manipulation, lies in methodology, omission of any flaws in the studies, just to get published. Because that is the only measure of your value ti the institution.

Fuck, even the head of the institution publicly announced that only quantity matters, not quality. Because the government funding for research also depends only on quantity.

Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by arbuge on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @01:08PM (#37754659)
>> what experience is that based on?

Graduate school, MS at Harvard & MIT, PhD at UIUC.

Both my MS and PhD supervisors were brilliant and strongly believed in publishing only when they had something real to talk about, which I respected a lot. But it was clear this wasn't what the top professors were doing. They were running paper mills.

>> What fields in academia?

Elec engineering & CS.

>> Do you work there or have friends there

I don't work there, although I was offered several positions. This culture is pretty much why I chose industry. In the real world, most customers care about real achievements.

Lots of friends, yes.

Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by eigenvalue on Monday October 02, 2023 @01:03PM (#37741066)
Yes, or in the social sciences, those who just make up fake data and come up with catchy, media-friendly summaries! See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37714898
Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by queuebert on Monday October 02, 2023 @01:19PM (#37741362)
This is especially true in U.S. health sciences, where to get money from the NIH, you must plan and describe the outcome of the next 3-5 yrs of research. It's not acceptable to say, "We're going to explore this area for 5 years and see what we find and hope for a surprise."

Obviously, you then only get very incremental, low-risk, low-reward research, but high-profile scientists who mainly serve on the committees at the NIH and dole out funding get to keep their small business (err, I mean lab) going with minimal disruption in funding.

Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by didntknowya on Monday October 02, 2023 @04:02PM (#37743683)
yeh unfortunately most of the best professors spend the majority of their time applying for grants for their students, going to conference, doing admin etc rather than work in a lab
Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by sambazi on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @04:31AM (#37749297)
> Individuals focused on real discovery and not publishing much until they really have something significant to say don't fit into this well.

https://www.theguardian.com/science/2013/dec/06/peter-higgs-...

Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by lost_tourist on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @09:57AM (#37752018)
They are more likely to be able to recognize talented grad students and build an army of them to pump out good (great?) papers and hit up the conference circuit.
Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by relativ575 on Monday October 02, 2023 @08:48AM (#37737403)
Survivor bias. This is what often mentioned in any thread about business success, yet nobody has mentioned it here.

Institutions also often don't recognize researches that end up going nowhere. What we can say is that finding a gem is hard because of abundance of noise.

Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by f6v on Monday October 02, 2023 @11:28AM (#37739379)
> A good reminder that academic

Unlike industry, where there’s no internal politics and everything is merit-based.

Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by specialist on Monday October 02, 2023 @11:41AM (#37739564)
> often fail to recognize the best in their ranks

I know it's a dumb cultural cite, but I keep thinking of the "12th man" scene from the movie (book too?) "World War Z". The Israeli is explaining that his job is to disagree with the consensus. Just in case. Who is then given charter and resources to plan accordingly. Just in case.

I hope there's buckets of research funds. With some percentage for long shots. And perhaps a smaller percentage for loonie tunes. Where by formalizing that model would preempt all the "omgherd golden fleece!?" reactions.

As a taxpayer, I'd be thrilled if researchers, artists, crazies got some kind of UBI, to do their work without starving. Considering the scale of all the usual waste and pork, genius grants wouldn't be more than a round-off error.

With a payout of 1:1000, it'd be a bargain for society. Smartest investments ever.

Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by wolverine876 on Monday October 02, 2023 @12:42PM (#37740730)
It seems more as a status issue to me:

Kariko had a PhD from Hungary, was a post-doc at Temple U. - not an elite pedigree. At Penn, an elite school:

"It was a low-level position, research assistant professor, and never meant to lead to a permanent tenured position."

and after that boss left,

"Dr. Kariko was left without a lab or financial support. She could stay at Penn only if she found another lab to take her on. “They expected I would quit,” she said.

Universities only support low-level Ph.D.s for a limited amount of time, Dr. Langer said: “If they don’t get a grant, they will let them go.” Dr. Kariko “was not a great grant writer,” ...

Kariko was slotted into the non-tenure / adjunct role, and it didn't matter what they did. It happens in private industry too. The problem is elitism overlooking talent and production. It's a brazen, obvious flaw.

The US long had the culture - imperfect, of course - of an active rejection of elitism, class, etc. 'All men are created equal', 'every man a king', meritocracy, hard work, you can accomplish anything if you work hard enough, the land of opportuity, the American Dream, etc. That equality, the respect for others, is the foundation of voting - you respect everyone's right to have input and its value.

The dominant fashion, a sort of neo-reactionaryism, is to reject that, deride it, rather than aggressively moving it forward. Many people look for ways to justify prejudice, to exclude, to embrace personal ego and greed and to mock public good. I think that's because if you embrace universal rights, opportunity, equality, etc., you can't avoid 'liberal' ideals too, and those are the target of reactionaryism.

Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by fatherzine on Monday October 02, 2023 @03:19PM (#37743063)
"active rejection of elitism". Not really. In US 'elite' means money wealth, whereas in historical Europe 'elite' means martial nobility. Anecdata: the very concept of 'legacy admission' is overtly classist, and simply does not exist in continental Europe. US is very much elitist, it's just that its manifestation of elitism is less obvious to the unsuspecting eye.
Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by inglor_cz on Monday October 02, 2023 @05:44PM (#37744885)
Is there any non-elitist country out there? Humans tend to socially stratify even in relatively modest conditions (such as tribal life).

What really matters is if the elite is closed or relatively permeable, and how it treats the non-elite.

What the founding generation of America rejected, was inheritance of elite status, but I don't think they were completely egalitarian either. After all, people like Jefferson and Washington were highly regarded by their peers.

Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by wolverine876 on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @01:45AM (#37748341)
> Is there any non-elitist country out there?

You could also ask, 'is there any elitist country out there?'. There is no perfectly elitst or non-elitist. The differences are matters of degree.

Some countries have castes and royalty that last forever. Others at least advocate social mobility and work at it.

> people like Jefferson and Washington were highly regarded by their peers

'Highly regarded' and elitist are very different.

Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by wolverine876 on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @01:43AM (#37748325)
Again, it's not at all perfect, but it has certainly been a widely held value and objective. Think of the overt humility of Washington, Lincoln, and most American leaders until around seven years ago.
Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by IOT_Apprentice on Monday October 02, 2023 @01:48PM (#37741821)
She was also demoted at U Penn. She is now working at a university in her homeland.
Re:Nobel Price in Medicine goes to development of mRNA vaccines by esafak on Monday October 02, 2023 @06:14PM (#37745182)