What you're talking about is illustration, which will indeed have a difficult time in the future.
I encourage you to check out the work at museums and galleries in whichever city you live in. It should be immediately obvious that these aren’t really skills that transfer to Photoshop and blog post images.
Maybe in your circle, but that's certainly not the case generally.
I've never heard these terms used like you are using them.
See also: Art Forum. ArtNews. MoMa. The Met. Etc.
I didn’t invent the term.
Great, now that's solved, let's agree on a definition of 'punk' next
a lot of art isn't always so much about the technique but the content. ai might make the gap from beginner and crap to pleasing to look at in a technical sense, but that doesn't mean the art it self will be interesting or meaningful.
if you really think art as a whole is at risk of being destroyed by ai you should go to your nearest high quality museum and really think if ai would make that. i know like half the posters are in the bay area lol, go to sf moma this weekend and think about this.
So you just need to pair DallE with an axidraw?
idk how a computer would deal with the unpredictability of a medium like water color. axidraw looks more like a printer thats using a pencil instead of ink.
skip to 36min in here, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OokWxQPU5kw
Does a new form of “art” evolve that makes use of these seemingly omnipotent brushes?
It’s simply a new tool for artists to create art with. It will change art but I doubt it will destroy art. Like you said, a new form of art will evolve from it.
I'm becoming more and more redpilled on the generative art stuff. The risk-benefit analysis checks out in favour of LLMs, but maybe art is something we can keep our Markov chains off of.
Is that true? Are there fewer live music shows, plays, live comedy, etc... than there were before cinema and television?
To me, it does feel like there's a value hierarchy. Watching television is the lowest level. I'll have the TV on while I do other things. Going to the cinema is more special and not something I do all that often compared to how often I watch television. Going to see live music or theater is a big deal.
Those spirals got backlash for being "too easy to do", but others have done more creative things with the same technology: https://www.reddit.com/r/StableDiffusion/comments/15wdoqa/be...
That's the importance of accessibility, and has happened all the time in art history (e.g. photography did not kill painting on a canvas)
For instance the emergence of extremely good reproductions didn't affect the price of the original paintings. Same way the evolution of photoshop doesn't have much effect on the price of picture prints.
Now stock photography could be impacted. But otherwise generative AI only opens the door to more picture production, and won't be put in competition to the traditional painting/prints market/direct artist support market.
> What does a world without art look like.
As an aside I always find it funny when 'art' is used as short form for 'pictures', especially in the world's context.
I think, given the context being an generative AI for images it should be fairly obvious what I’m talking about.
I’m sure it’s only a matter of time before they do it for music, dancing, fighting and whatever else you care to tag with the term.
For example, Flag by Jasper Johns sold for $110M in 2010 [1]. The fact that almost anyone could make something like this (the subject matter is public domain, and the technique is within reach of anyone who has taken an art class) doesn't seem to have diminished its value.
And as for all of the art you see in the everyday world, being able to design it more easily would lead to more of it, not less. Instead of seeing the same 20 things that they carry at IKEA over and over, you'd have custom artwork everywhere.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flag_(painting)
EDIT: Added the last paragraph while you were replying.
Nope. I mean the visual art we see all around us. If it’s trivial to generate it’ll be everywhere and nobody will value it. It will become a annoyance to people - so what fills that space then? Bare walls? Or will things go to a new level. Was kind of my line of thinking.
I also think the output isn’t yet good enough to be usable without some human intervention (fixing hands, spot treatments, etc.)
And Chinese wages are rising, so it'll eventually be too low-level for them.
It would be a terrible outcome if authorship and illustration are mostly reduced to editing and touching up errors in AI-generated statistically likely art.
(Although oddly, for programming, I'm really looking forward to that outcome).
Software developers have been having technology completely eat their work out from under them since the dawn of the industry. But jobs aren’t being lost over it; there’s more demand for software developers than ever. When software advancements reduce the work needed to produce output, the world has moved on by taking that as the new baseline which software developers build upon and demanding more software to be built with bigger and better features.
Back when I first started working, it was somebody’s entire job to take pages and pages of content and transcribe them into HTML manually so that they could be published on a website. People used to do that all day, every day. Then CMSs came along and completely eliminated that work. Now sure, if a developer decided that all they wanted to do was write static HTML and refused to adapt their skills, they would be out of a job. But we all used the new technology to build more dynamic websites that provided more value. The new technology didn’t take away our jobs, it provided an opportunity to do a better job.
It’s the same with this. These aren’t tools to replace artists – these are tools artists can use to do more and better work. These aren’t tools that will reduce demand – when everybody can get on-demand, totally custom artwork, people will want more of it, not less.
The reverse doesn't hold -- there are no tools that allow an artist with no training or study to be an effective developer. I'd say the CMS example is more of a data entry job than a development job now, it's two different things.
Most of the advancements in tech still need trained developers to utilize them. GPT-4 cannot create non-trivial programs itself and does not seem particularly close to doing so, it's mainly used for scaffolding and bug fixing and guiding, all of which still need a trained developer at the wheel.
I'm worried for the future of artists.
Right, but it used to be a development job, which is the point. The CMS took a development job and turned it into a data entry job -- exactly what DALL-E does to some limited forms of artistry.
But development didn't disappear, and neither will artistry.
Basically, there is no circumstance under which automation reduces demand for labor. It's like if you got a pay raise and started worrying it might make you poorer.
I mean sure yeah, in the past I would pay for logos from artists and now I just make them with AI for my projects instead.
Have web builders totally replaced developers? No, not at all. It’s definitely cut out the lowest end of the market, but that’s because your local restaurant really doesn’t need more than a squarespace template.
But warping a website builder to do something more complex is complicated. To the point where you need to hire someone trained in using that builder tool. Then that person finds the edges of the customizability of that tool and reaches for just writing HTML/CSS/JS.
I could totally see a similar trajectory here. We’ll have prompt engineers, and they’ll realize sometimes photoshop is just easier to tweak the output, then maybe they’ll realize it’s easier to prompt for components of an image, and composite them manually… and then we’ve reached a point where it’s just a tool that makes art easier.
Though… it still does feel somehow different from web development. Will just have to see how things shake out.
Ever stopped at one of those self-checkout registers at the grocery store that didn't exist in your childhood and wondered what happened to the cashier who used to be there?
A lot of people mumble something about "jobs not worth doing", but I'm not sure if web front-end development (how many unique, differentiated, worthwhile websites exist? how much of that code is glue and boilerplate, and people solving the same problem in parallel every day?) fares much better in that gauntlet.
Software developers right now are, for the first time in their lives, experiencing a little backlash to their privilege -- for hundreds of millions, they've been riding that rollercoaster all their lives.
They're still there, they're restocking shelves.
Similarly, the invention of ATM machines increased the number of bank tellers.
- will be more artwork be bought (probably)
- will the increase in the quantity of artwork being bought (assuming there is one) compensate the decrease in price for each piece of art?
Clearly for software, _so far_, the increase in productivity / decrease in price has led to such a big increase in demand for software that some programmers are better off - I say _some_ because many jobs within the software industry stopped existing.
Yet if we look at something like agriculture, there has been some increase in demand in food products(e.g. much more meat is being sold), but one can only eat so much - so most of the increase in productivity has led to way fewer people working as farmers, and not much increase in farmers income.
No "these are tools to replace farmers - these are tools farmers can use to do more and better work".
Basically people are making statements about the elasticity of demand with respect to prices for prices & quantities no one has ever observed. If making a piece of art is now 1/2 (random number) the cost thanks to AI, will people buy 50% more? 100% more? 1000% more? I have no idea and I am not sure why people think they do.
Automation does not always increase demand for the jobs being automated. Tractors didn't create more demand for oxen than ever.
Farm automation allowed a single man to plow many fields in the time one field would have taken.
Automation allows one person to accomplish more with less.
Tractors didn’t reduce the demand for product, but increased it many fold.
Automation increases demand; every time.
Sure, automation increased demand for food, but demand did not increase enough to not destroy 5/6th of farmers jobs.
Now this may not be a bad thing at all, that's not the point, but I am not sure "hey demand for art will increase but 5 out of 6 artist jobs will no longer exist!" is a super hopeful statement to artists.
[0] https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/number-of-people-employed...
Yours is a different definition of demand than the economics definition, which is basically the amount customers will buy as a function of price.
Automation increases supply, which increases the volume of art consumed, mainly because it is available at a lower price. That is shifting to a different point on the same demand curve, and doesn't mean that demand has increased.
Just look at the dairy industry. Pre-automation sales numbers vs. post-automation sales numbers.
This is true for every industry on earth, and doesn't care about the pedantic definition of demand. Consumer demand = more purchases. More purchases = more revenue.
Clip art/stock photography though, you can do that with 0 artists if you have the actual art bit automated.
you could do that with zero artists for decades because it's already fully commoditized. Everyone who is cheap already just buys a subscription to some gigantic vault of stock imagery owned by some digital rights holder for pennies.
the mechanical reproduction of art did not start in 2020
Also, it would be nice if there was something akin to a watermark that was perhaps invisible but upon inspection using a certain tool will reveal if it was created using the Generative AI model (similar to how real currency can be inspected and differentiated from fake currency notes)
Making a living from art is something that the majority of artists even before GenAI did not reach.
I agree that it will change things a lot, but fearing the "exctinction of art" is a bit dramatic IMO.
Another example would be someone who loves to garden. If a gardening robot was invented those people would still garden themselves.
Generative AI allows people without mechanical skill to do art, by iteratively interacting until the AI gets it just right for them, so in that sense generative AI opens up art to many more people.
As for making money from art, I believe we're going to have to implement some sort of universal basic income. I currently don't have to work because I collect social security, so I pursue my hobbies the way most other people on UBI will do.
Sure, but will that have an effect on art? Most artists I know have day jobs completely unconnected to their art. Even the ones that draw stuff for a living don't consider that drawing their art. After spending all week working in the "drawing factory" they spend their weekends working on their 'real art'.
The only argument I can see is that fewer people will be willing to really learn the craft of drawing/illustration etc. if the chance of getting a day job doing that diminishes greatly.
I can easily imagine a future where a single dedicated individual or at least a very small independent team can make a full-length movie without leaving their apartment on a tribal budget that rivals a big Hollywood production costing hundreds of mullions to produce today.
Right now you've got the writers striking, worried that the studios are going to replace them with AI, I think this is totally backwards, it's the studios who should be worried because the barriers to entry that protect them today are about to come crashing down.
I am already seeing a few people make short films using these tools. Right now anything "AI generated" has a certain novelty factor, like back in the day when 3D CGI was new and we were all rendering chrome 3d spheres and shiny red cubes and cylinders on black and white checkerboards, this phase is going to pass soon enough. Perhaps that surreal Midjourney glow will be part of 20's nostalgia in the decades to come. There's a whole new set of skills a new generation of artists are going to master and do things largely unimaginable a year or two ago. They're going to make art that expresses their own perspectives and ideas and not just what's currently allowed by the current consensus, just as the artists before them did.
This is definitely exciting to contemplate, but it's still quite tricky for the economics: Right now, the fact that you need 4000 people to make a blockbuster movie limits the number of movies being made, giving each movie enough of an audience (potentially) to make their money back.
Better tools will enable more awesome creatives to make content alone - but will there be enough eyeballs to consume that content, even if it's cheap to make?
It is all just impetus to go and find the prior form of "art" we have had all along. Art need not be about the Artist and her Works, or about creating something for some kind of vague consumption. Art can be about collectivity and shared truths. Art used to be about speaking to God or whatever, and whoever actually placed the pieces of glass were very secondary. At my most optimistic, I feel like some turn like this (but probably more secular) is inevitable. People need to get stuff out, and if this pressure is not relieved by our current ideas of labor and such, it will find a way nonetheless like water through stone.
I think the market for affordable prints and copies will definitely suffer, because I can create prints of Midjourney art that looks as good as anything I see in our small local galleries and gift shops.
Years on, it's still a little hard to fully grasp the imminent, momentous impact this (has yet to have?) on commercial artists. I fear it will become pretty much impossible to make any sort of living off art in the next decade.
I mean: the outputs on the page are just awesome. Leagues ahead of the stuff we have now. And I'm already seeing old-gen generated AI images on corporate blog posts: everyone will jump on DALL-E 3.
Being in the profession right now must be very discouraging indeed. My heart goes out to those artists who will eventually be replaced by cheap, intuitive text prompts.
Commercialising art for corps was one of the last ways to exist as an artist in today's economy and get by. I fear the extinction of the profession will have a big impact on our cultural capital.