News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by badcppdev on Friday September 15, 2023 @10:25AM (#37523470)
This is such a good idea. I know that everyone in the Western World is told that they eat too much but people need to be able to buy food and eat it. And if the same packaging this week has 90% of what it had last week then then consumers are going to suffer.

In the UK many people rely on Food banks and parents skip meals to feed their children. Cutting the amount of food in a package in a manner that is not even visible without carefully examination is a morally dubious practice.

Corporate profits are high. This is one of the reasons why.

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by BlueTemplar on Friday September 15, 2023 @10:39AM (#37523724)
Well, you can (and should!) check the (mandatory) price/mass or price/volume, but of course there are very smart people being paid a lot to design the packaging so that it's sufficiently compelling for you to still put a higher value on the product...
Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by rhaway84773 on Friday September 15, 2023 @10:44AM (#37523827)
The price per unit in US groceries is ridiculous.

You will literally have 3 packages of soda all of the same size listing the price per unit in completely different units. Some in ml, some in oz, some in pts.

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by flaviut on Friday September 15, 2023 @10:53AM (#37523985)
I've made a userscript for this! https://greasyfork.org/en/scripts/429539-unit-prices-on-krog...

Kroger doesn't publish unit prices on their websites, but they do publish quantities. They'll sometimes mix the units up (L, floz, see mapUnit() https://greasyfork.org/en/scripts/429539-unit-prices-on-krog...), but generally they're OK.

The script will normalize everything to a specific metric unit & present a unit price on the page.

Why stores have this horrible setup? Probably weaponized incompetence. Would be nice to have the FTC step in with some regulation.

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by thfuran on Friday September 15, 2023 @10:46AM (#37523861)
We don't even have standardization on the nutrition labels. The serving size is different for everything.
Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by cobbzilla on Friday September 15, 2023 @11:02AM (#37524138)
I had a bag of salad croutons that measured a serving as “2 Tablespoons” — are they expecting me to crush the croutons to measure a serving? Or just “eyeball” it to convert rectangular things into hemispherical things?
Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by hansvm on Friday September 15, 2023 @12:23PM (#37525503)
It's worse than that. The serving size changes the resulting label. A lot of the high-protein breads have the same composition and are sliced slightly thicker to hit the 3.5g mark so they can round up to 4g per slice and appear to be more protein rich in composition.
Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by thfuran on Friday September 15, 2023 @12:48PM (#37525884)
I've seen oil with zero calories and tiny serving size.
Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by nebula8804 on Friday September 15, 2023 @11:46AM (#37524829)
Just be happy they haven't switched over to butts (yet):

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Butt_(unit)

Maybe we'll be going back to hogsheads (or more likely a rundlet) though:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hogshead

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by stilley2 on Friday September 15, 2023 @10:45AM (#37523839)
But as a consumer I don't want to have to check the price/mass in every product everything I shop, especially if I'm buying the same brand every week.
Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by hedora on Friday September 15, 2023 @10:46AM (#37523847)
Expecting people to memorize the per-unit price of everything they buy and compare week to week is unrealistic.

Also, at least in the US, the price/weight for the same type of item is often in different units. ($/oz for brand A; $/lb for brand B, etc)

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by nebula8804 on Friday September 15, 2023 @11:42AM (#37524753)
Sounds like a great opportunity for an AR app that can compute and overlay differences in your field of view. It would be cool to run this on the Apple Goggles. (I am not ready to see people walking around wearing those things in real life).
Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by dustincoates on Friday September 15, 2023 @11:37AM (#37524670)
This isn't my experience, so I went looking and found this:

> Uniform Unit Pricing Regulations apply only when stores voluntarily provide unit pricing information. The unit of measure chosen must be consistent across like items within the category.

So if a store offers unit pricing it must be consistent within a category.

https://www.nist.gov/pml/owm/laws-and-regulations/us-retail-...

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by hedora on Friday September 15, 2023 @03:09PM (#37527800)
Strange. I've never seen a store in California (which they list as requiring such things) that uses consistent units of measure.

Too bad there's not an obvious way to report violations.

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by Symbiote on Friday September 15, 2023 @10:57AM (#37524050)
The EU does have some rules about this [1], "The unit price shall refer to a quantity declared in accordance with national and Community provisions", but I've still seen similar products priced per 100g and a different brand priced per "item".

[1] https://commission.europa.eu/law/law-topic/consumer-protecti...

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by iteria on Friday September 15, 2023 @11:00AM (#37524107)
I don't think I've ever seen the price per unit unit not be the across brands of the same packaging type. Now this does get dicy for individual wrapped things, but outside of that everything uses the same unit in the same range.

Even still, this is not a reasonable approach to tracking shrinkflation because I know I don't keep a running log of prices from week to week. I do sometimes notice package shrinking, but only because I buy weekly. If I wad a bulk buyer I'm not sure I'd notice as fast

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by kvdveer on Friday September 15, 2023 @11:03AM (#37524153)
Here in the Netherlands, all units are metric (g, ml, g, kg). Liquid products are advertised by volume, but is they're watery (ie. most products), you can just assume litres are kilograms.

Fatty or very sugary liquid products (e.g. cream, syrup) are the only things that can't easily be compared to kg price. I've only seen those advertised by volume, so they can still be compared to their peers.

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by flir on Friday September 15, 2023 @10:56AM (#37524035)
Same in the UK, except 10g/100g/1000g so it's a bit easier to work out. Still an antipattern though.
Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by malfist on Friday September 15, 2023 @11:02AM (#37524132)
It's even worse when the products you are trying to compare unit prices for when one of them shares a volume unit price and the other a weight unit price and another is in counts.

These things should really be standardized.

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by darrylb42 on Friday September 15, 2023 @01:31PM (#37526463)
Or in Canada, BC. Things like meat can be priced in $/lb or $/100g in the same cabinet. Makes the mental math tricky and you can think something is cheap when it is not.
Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by BlueTemplar on Friday September 15, 2023 @06:26PM (#37529842)
Well, after a while I do roughly memorize it for the things I buy the most, don't you roughly remember the non-per-unit price if that is what you are looking at ?

But that was not my point, the price per unit is to compare similar products with each other in the span of a minute or so.

Because if they are ALL going up (or down), then there are clearly external factors to that price change. At worst it's the fault of the supermarket (and here remembering the rough price/unit comes handy, for comparisons in others), or an issue with a monopoly/cartel collusion, in which case hopefully consumer associations are going to start whistleblowing, leading to government handing out punishments.

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by badcppdev on Friday September 15, 2023 @11:47AM (#37524861)
And then I find myself checking the packaging of a frozen pizza (please don't judge me). There is a small plastic window on the front and I can tell that there is a pizza inside and from tipping it I can tell that the pizza is smaller than the box. The label says that the pizza is 500g (20 oz) which is totally useless to me because I can't remember if the box said 500, 550, or 600g when I bought it 3 months ago.
Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by oh_sigh on Friday September 15, 2023 @12:00PM (#37525082)
It seems extremely burdensome to do that every time you go shopping. Also, it requires people to remember the unit price of the same product across multiple trips - whereas most people who do check the unit price do so in a side by side comparison with a different brand of the same type of product.
Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by mytailorisrich on Friday September 15, 2023 @10:47AM (#37523881)
This is a cynical move because, as the article mentions right at the top, this is just to apply pressure on suppliers before contracts renegotiations.

> In the UK many people rely on Food banks and parents skip meals to feed their children.

A small minority, not 'many'...

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by tyingq on Friday September 15, 2023 @10:51AM (#37523948)
If this[1] is correct, one part stands out to me:

"2.1 million people in the UK lived in household which had used a food bank in the previous 12 months, a rate of 3%. This includes 6% of children, 3% of working-age adults, and around 0% of pensioners."

6% of children feels not great, though other stats say the US is much worse, with 6+% of all households, not just children...and I've seen higher estimates.

[1] https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cbp-...

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by mytailorisrich on Friday September 15, 2023 @12:46PM (#37525859)
That's a small minority that has used a food bank at least once in 12 months. The number of people 'relying' on them has to be even lower. We also can't discount that some people could have bought food but chose the food bank instead because it is free.

My point was that writing 'many' suggests something common and widespread like if there were breadlines everywhere. It is not (but The Guardian likes to dramatise on this).

In fact, I suspect that poorer people in the UK have a much higher chance of being obese than of being actually hungry.

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by mholm on Friday September 15, 2023 @10:49AM (#37523917)
A small minority of the UK can still be hundreds of thousands, even millions of people. Don't underestimate volume just because the % is low.
Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by mytailorisrich on Friday September 15, 2023 @12:33PM (#37525666)
A small minority is a small minority whatever the absolute number.

Also, using a food bank at least once and 'relying' on them are not the same thing.

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by bearmode on Friday September 15, 2023 @10:56AM (#37524027)
3 million people used them between last year and this year. About 4.5% of the population. That's a lot of people.
Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by WalterBright on Friday September 15, 2023 @10:53AM (#37523988)
> Corporate profits are high.

Inflation increases profits, too (but not in real dollars).

> This is one of the reasons why.

The reason why is inflation.

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by lesuorac on Friday September 15, 2023 @11:09AM (#37524249)
Inflation is a disease not a virus.

Inflation does nothing on its own; it does not have agency. It's just a description of a symptom (increase in price). Whether that set of symptoms (Disease) is caused by price gauging or labor price increases or resource prioritization is not known just from inflation.

Although if you see that profits are way up then you know its not due to labor price increases as that company's revenue and expenses would both be up and not just revenue.

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by WalterBright on Friday September 15, 2023 @11:27AM (#37524508)
If inflation is 10% and profits go up 10%, most likely that's inflation's effect.
Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by lesuorac on Friday September 15, 2023 @01:31PM (#37526470)
I don't think you get it yet.

If I pour water into a cup and the line says 100 ML there's 100 ML of water. That measurement of 100 ML is a descriptor of how much water that is.

Inflation is a descriptor of how much prices have increased.

If we measure the line a second time and it says 120 ML then the water level has increased (i.e. inflation occurred). But why inflation occurred is not know _just_ by measuring the water level.

If firms increase their prices by 10% then the firm is causing inflation (prices have increased). If said firm also gets a 10% increase in their profits then we people would say inflation is entirely driven by profits (although probably strictly inaccurate). However at no point does "inflation" cause something. Inflation is _just_ a measurement.

--

Sticking with the incorrect math, if your prices go up 10% and your profits go up 10% you are the cause of inflation.

If your suppliers increased their prices by 10% so you increased your prices 10% then your profit goes up 0% and if your suppliers profit went up 10% then they're the cause of inflation.

This second example is why people are getting upset. Companies are all complaining they need to raise prices "due to inflation" but since their profit margins are just getting better people are suspicious of how much of the price increase is dictated by their supplier's price increases versus greed (value pricing).

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by WalterBright on Friday September 15, 2023 @04:46PM (#37528911)
> I don't think you get it yet.

Au contraire. Inflation comes from too much money chasing too few goods and services. How does too much money come about? The government prints money to deficit spend. Why does this cause inflation? The Law of Supply and Demand. Too much money means the money is worth less.

Individual companies cannot cause inflation, because they cannot increase the money supply.

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by lesuorac on Friday September 15, 2023 @05:08PM (#37529147)
> Individual companies cannot cause inflation, because they cannot increase the money supply.

No, you really don't know what the word inflation means in the economic sense.

>> https://www.google.com/search?q=define+inflation

>> ECONOMICS

>> a general increase in prices and fall in the purchasing value of money.

Also companies can 100% increase their prices and if a singular company such as Exxon does it then pretty much every company will also increase their prices because their cost of revenue went up.

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by WalterBright on Friday September 15, 2023 @05:28PM (#37529343)
Where does the extra money come from, lesuorac?

> companies can 100% increase their prices

Only if the consumers have the money, and are willing to pay it and not their competitor.

Where do they get the extra money?

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by lesuorac on Monday September 18, 2023 @07:11AM (#37554687)
I see you've moved past trying to argue what the definition of inflation is so I can only assume you've agreed me with.

So to move on to your new topic, there is a framing problem here. There does not need to be extra money during a period with inflation.

If I had $100 dollars and potatoes are $2 and a car is $50 I can get 25 potatoes and 1 car. If the costs of a car increases to $80 I can get 10 potatoes and 1 car. Inflation has occurred and I haven't done any changes to the money supply here.

And then of course, Inflation isn't a new word post-Bretton Woods; there was inflation when people used gold as currency.

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by malfist on Friday September 15, 2023 @11:00AM (#37524106)
> Inflation increases profits, too (but not in real dollars).

[Citation needed]

I find it hard to believe that corporate profits rise exactly proportional or less than the inflation rate.

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by myrmidon on Friday September 15, 2023 @11:26AM (#37524491)
Just compare corporate profits before and after Covid, see e.g.

https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/CA.PA/financials?p=CA.PA

Not much of a difference. Certainly nothing that looks outright malicious.

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by drawkward on Friday September 15, 2023 @12:16PM (#37525354)
That's Carrefour, not the product manufacturers. In fact, the evidence you present is completely consistent with Carrefour's assertion that they have been doing what they can to absorb the price increases taken by the product manufacturers.
Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by WalterBright on Friday September 15, 2023 @05:29PM (#37529353)
Profit margins stay roughly the same for the last century.
Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by effingwewt on Friday September 15, 2023 @11:01AM (#37524113)
No, the reason why is price gouging.

Or as companies like to call it 'not leaving money on the table'.

Prices have outpaced inflation. Everything has, except worker pay and minimum wage.

Profits are record-breaking while laying off workers. CEO compensation and bonuses are insane. Housing prices are out of control. Gas is still $5/gallon where I'm at.

It all boils down to one word: GREED.

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by mannerheim on Friday September 15, 2023 @11:04AM (#37524171)
Looks like we're in the 'blaming suppliers for being greedy' stage of inflation. Haven't seen that one before.
Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by yoyohello13 on Friday September 15, 2023 @11:12AM (#37524288)
It’s not irrational to be mad. All the poor see is that they are getting screwed and the rich are doing fine (sometime thriving) no platitudes about “economics” are going to make them feel better.
Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by mannerheim on Friday September 15, 2023 @11:15AM (#37524335)
That's all very fine. But it ends the same way every time.
Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by astrange on Friday September 15, 2023 @12:18PM (#37525395)
Wages by definition also increase with inflation. (Inflation is a general increase in prices and wages are a price.)

Also in the US, the lowest 10% of real wages has grown significantly since 2020, lowering income inequality vs the middle class.

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by effingwewt on Friday September 15, 2023 @12:49PM (#37525894)
I'll need some citations on those numbers.

In states like Texas minimum wage is still $7.25/hr and many places pay just that.

How do you reconcile your numbers with that?

Bills have outpaced wages to the point nearly a whole generation of young adults have given up on home ownership and have had to move back home.

Mortgages are increasing in years and rates, even new cars have.

Income inequality has never been higher and you're seriously saying it's gotten better since the greatest wealth transfer in history?!

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by astrange on Friday September 15, 2023 @01:24PM (#37526377)
> How do you reconcile your numbers with that?

https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w31010/w310...

It doesn't matter what the minimum wage is though, it matters what people are actually paid. Denmark doesn't have a minimum wage and they're doing okay.

> Bills have outpaced wages to the point nearly a whole generation of young adults have given up on home ownership and have had to move back home.

Not true, and Texas is fairly affordable. (It's blue states that aren't because they all refuse to build homes.)

https://www.redfin.com/news/gen-z-millennial-homeownership-r...

> Mortgages are increasing in years and rates, even new cars have.

Rate increases theoretically don't affect the total price of a new mortgage because you can negotiate the sale price down to make up for it. Supply and demand is what controls the total price. Higher rates do reduce new construction though.

Cars got more expensive because they stopped making cheap new cars, which is bad, but it's not 100% of CPI any more than rent is.

> Income inequality has never been higher and you're seriously saying it's gotten better since the greatest wealth transfer in history?!

No, income (wage) inequality peaked in 2014 and has been flat since, then decreased since 2019.

https://www.noahpinion.blog/p/inequality-might-be-going-down...

The real great wealth transfer in history was the 2020 CARES act giving a lot of money to the poor. We should do it again. (This is the one that a lot of people online like to say "we only got $600" about which is a straight up lie. It was up to $2400/month for an unemployed mother with children.)

The one that went up is wealth inequality, meaning value of unrealized assets like stock portfolios. But that's not nearly as real as cash. (Also, our top tech billionaires Gates/Bezos/Musk helped inequality out by losing half of their wealth by cheating on their wives or buying Twitter.)

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by yladiz on Friday September 15, 2023 @05:11PM (#37529180)
> Denmark doesn't have a minimum wage and they're doing okay.

It’s more complicated than that, and you know it, or you’re using that fact to further your point somewhat disingenuously. Yes, there in no minimum wage defined by law, but in practice it’s around €20 due to the collective bargaining agreements (read: unions) in most industries.

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by astrange on Friday September 15, 2023 @07:24PM (#37530280)
So it doesn't have a minimum wage.

There's nothing to hide here. Just look at the median wage in both places. Or in this case, the lowest 10% wage.

I prefer Australia's wage board system, but I think nobody knows how it works because they're Australian so they've given stupid names to everything. Try and guess what "award" and "casual loading" mean.

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by yladiz on Friday September 15, 2023 @07:44PM (#37530413)
It doesn’t have a de jure minimum wage, but it does have a de facto one, and just saying it doesn’t hides the subtlety of that.
Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by mannerheim on Friday September 15, 2023 @08:35PM (#37530791)
Plenty of Danes make less than that. Stages at Noma used to make absolutely no money at all.
Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by RugnirViking on Monday September 18, 2023 @06:20AM (#37554325)
I disagree. I live here and regularly see people exploited. It's not uncommon for students from romania/moldavia/bulgaria being paid a literal token fee per hour just so they can register enough hours to claim SU. Job listings advertising this fact brazenly, because its not even illegal... Similarly a whole bunch of workers here in nordjylland's factory farms get paid ridiculously low salaries per hour. We're talking 70kr per hour or less.
Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by mannerheim on Friday September 15, 2023 @01:06PM (#37526143)
https://equitablegrowth.org/u-s-income-and-wealth-inequality...

> In states like Texas minimum wage is still $7.25/hr and many places pay just that.

> How do you reconcile your numbers with that?

'Assistant Commissioner for Regional Operations Stanley W. Suchman noted that the 196,000 workers earning the federal minimum wage or less made up 3.1 percent of all hourly paid workers in the state. Nationwide, those earning the federal minimum or less accounted for 2.3 percent of the hourly paid workforce.'

And that's only those paid hourly, not salaried.

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by Dylan16807 on Friday September 15, 2023 @12:14PM (#37525328)
I don't see how "they have increased prices more than inflation" is blaming them for inflation.

Though that assumes the "everything" in the post is an exaggeration because I think the price of "everything" is inflation.

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by WalterBright on Friday September 15, 2023 @06:02PM (#37529630)
The way inflation is measured is debatable. It's in the government's best interests to measure it in such a way as to make the number as small as possible.
Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by WalterBright on Friday September 15, 2023 @04:48PM (#37528934)
> Prices have outpaced inflation.

Or, as many people suspect, the government calculation of inflation is deliberately under representing it. The government doesn't like to admit it is the cause of inflation, hence all the excuses for it coming from the government, like "Putin's Price Hike" and all that other economically illiterate nonsense.

Companies can raise their prices at any time. So why don't they? Why do they do it only after the government dumps trillions of newly printed money into the economy?

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by mitthrowaway2 on Friday September 15, 2023 @11:58AM (#37525056)
Inflation can allow corporations to be less price-competitive, because it gets harder for consumers to judge price competitiveness. For example, you sit down at your favourite burger restaurant and see on the menu the price is now $12 instead of $8. Are they just passing on increased costs? Or are they taking the opportunity to pad their profits? I can't really tell, not without seeing if prices have gone up comparably at similar restaurants, but I'm here now and I'm hungry.

The price used to be $8 because they were in a tight battle with other burger joints, and that was as low as they could get it. Now they have to fight their suppliers, but not so much with their competition.

This is one of the reasons why high inflation creates unstable inflation, and why central banks like to keep inflation low.

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by WalterBright on Friday September 15, 2023 @05:27PM (#37529324)
That is called the "cost-push" theory of inflation, and its giant problem is it doesn't explain where the extra money comes from that is necessary for sustained price increases across the economy.

It's sibling is "demand-pull" where customer demand causes inflation, but it equally does not explain where the extra money comes from.

A theory that does explain it is the government dumping cash into the economy - inflation consistently picks up about a year after this is done.

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by mitthrowaway2 on Friday September 15, 2023 @05:47PM (#37529495)
(I'm sure you're aware of this, but price increases only require increased spending from customers if transaction volume is held constant. It's entirely possible for prices to rise to arbitrary heights even as the economy contracts and customers become poorer, either because supplies dry up, or because high-volume demand dries up and companies are forced to shift to a smaller but wealthier customer base with high spending power.)

More importantly, this is why I said that inflation becomes more unstable when it is higher. Dramatic price increases can happen as companies become less competitive, and then price collapses can happen as well as consumers tap out and companies are forced to compete for a shrinking pie. Economists generally prefer low inflation rather than high inflation, even if all else is equal in real terms, because higher inflation brings higher volatility.

Lastly, this isn't necessarily the driver that initiates inflation, but it is a feedback loop that can propel it to overshoot an increase in the volume of money.

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by WalterBright on Friday September 15, 2023 @07:48PM (#37530429)
> I'm sure you're aware of this, but price increases only require increased spending from customers if transaction volume is held constant

Reduced demand reduces prices. It's the Law of Supply & Demand at work.

The Law is always at work, even money is subjected to it. Increase the supply of money, and the value of a dollar drops accordingly. We see this effect as inflation.

In physics, we know that momentum is conserved. Any theory that deviates from that is wrong, even if we can't figure out why it is wrong.

Analogously, any economic theory that results in a "free lunch" is wrong. Any economic theory that denies the Law of Supply & Demand is also wrong. Bad government economic policies are nearly always the result of denying the existence of the Law of Supply & Demand, which is as doomed as denying the Law of Gravity.

Nothing stops the government from pretending that deficit spending is a free lunch, and they sell that notion at every opportunity. But the Law of S+D still applies.

The elephant in the room is the sheer size of the several trillions in deficit spending. There's just no way to ignore it and explain inflation away by suddenly every business is price gouging. It's not a compelling explanation at all.

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by mitthrowaway2 on Friday September 15, 2023 @08:27PM (#37530719)
> Reduced demand reduces prices. It's the Law of Supply & Demand at work.

You have to be careful when asserting this though, because demand does not mean what most people think it means. In particular, it does not refer to the number of people demanding a good, nor does it refer to a volume of goods purchased. A declining sales volume occurring together with rising prices does not violate the law of supply and demand.

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by WalterBright on Friday September 15, 2023 @09:47PM (#37531211)
Rising prices reduce demand. But there are competitors. That's why a company cannot just raise prices.
Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by mitthrowaway2 on Friday September 15, 2023 @10:30PM (#37531461)
Yes, rising prices reduce demand. But rising volumes also create economies of scale and allow low prices. There's a delicate balance and sometimes an equilibrium of large volume, low price can transition to a new equilibrium of low volume, high price, or vise-versa. For example, if you are a software company and you sell software to a small group of professionals, like a CAD program, your price is probably around $1000 ~ $5000 per seat, per year. And competition will not lower it, because your competitors face the same economic situation you do: it's a niche product, you have to amortize a high development cost over a small number of customers, and those customers have money and are willing to pay.

However, there is also a stable equilibrium for a company to turn a similar profit shipping software of equal quality to a very large number of people for a very low price. Something like a spreadsheet or word-processing software. Now your software is cheap, or supported by ad revenue, and yet you can still remain highly profitable. If, however, your userbase started to shrink for whatever reason, you might have to charge the remaining users a large amount. Most will leave, but a few of those users may derive a lot of value from your software and are willing to pay, and you end up with the same economics as the CAD developer.

Software is of course an extreme example, where the marginal cost of production is approximately zero, but most industries outside of resource extraction have declining marginal costs with scale. That's why you can end up with high-quality cheap components (like cameras, etc) that are used in smartphones, where they have high-volume production, and very expensive specialty cameras for eg. microscopes, even though the specialty camera required much less investment of R&D to produce. It can only be sold at a high price because there is not enough demand to reach economies of scale that would allow a lower price.

So if for whatever reason, money was sucked out of the economy and the average person suddenly became very poor and could not afford a smartphone, it's possible that smartphone companies would compete hard to keep those customers and drop their prices. But if that doesn't make for a sustainable business, the smartphone makers have to drop production to sell only to a few wealthy buyers, the remaining phones will get much more expensive, because their components will be made in expensive fabs at smaller volumes. The total revenue will be lower, the GDP would be lower, but the average price of goods can still be higher. Especially when there's a large wealth disparity to make that high-price low-volume equilibrium stable.

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by WalterBright on Friday September 15, 2023 @11:26PM (#37531765)
Inflation isn't a price increase in one item. It's a price increase across the economy, including wages.

Your theory of inflation does not explain why it isn't continuous, and tends to follow periods of enormous deficit spending. That's a common factor to inflationary episodes, not some industry figuring out how to gouge.

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by mitthrowaway2 on Saturday September 16, 2023 @02:09PM (#37537140)
I'm not sure what theory of inflation you think I've presented, because I haven't presented a complete one -- I've only offered an explanation of how already-high inflation enables corporations to become less price-competitive, which makes inflation more volatile, and you will find the same explanation in mainstream economics and central bank publications. (I did explain why it isn't continuous). It doesn't make any attempt to explain what instigates the inflation to begin with, which could certainly be caused by a spike in deficit spending, or a natural disaster that reduces supply, or a trade embargo, or a war, etc.

Inflation isn't a price increase in one item, but the scenario I presented above does not create a tradeoff between one item and another; it can apply to any and all category of manufactured goods or services where efficiencies of scale apply. Macroeconomists usually assume only a single fungible good anyway (a "widget").

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by Cthulhu_ on Friday September 15, 2023 @11:00AM (#37524101)
I wish there was legislation in place that sets legal standard sizes; for one, it would allow for more uniform packaging, allowing reuse between brands and reducing trash. It would be more predictable box / pallet sizes, reducing transport costs. And it would give consumers more security, even with the mandatory price per liter / kilo notices which are often hard to read.

One example of shrinkflation / cost fuckery here is cheese. We buy a kilo of it every time, but they've changed it so you get e.g. 920 grams. Looks the same size, but it's slightly different, thus hard to make comparisons. Still up 30% since before the Ukraine thing though.

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by eru on Friday September 15, 2023 @11:06AM (#37524205)
You can already shop at Aldi if you like things to come in standardised sizes.

(I love Aldi! But I think such regulation would be pretty silly. But we already have such regulation in many parts of the world for many goods. Eg publ in the UK can't just sell you 500ml of beer, they need to give you a pint.)

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by somsak2 on Friday September 15, 2023 @11:12AM (#37524296)
As sibling comment said, I think this is bound to cause unintended side-effects. I think it would be simpler to require per-unit pricing alongside overall cost, and regulate that amount. Nothing more frustrating than seeing a per ml or oz cost on one item and a per-count cost on one right next to it.
Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by bombela on Friday September 15, 2023 @11:47AM (#37524853)
In France, there is always the price per unit. And since the units are not in grain of barley nor a game of guess work (is this ounce dry or wet today?), it's obviously much easier to compare.
Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by kergonath on Friday September 15, 2023 @12:11PM (#37525279)
Isn’t this a European regulation? In any case, it is obviously a good thing for consumers and it is difficult to argue against this.
Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by eru on Monday September 18, 2023 @06:37AM (#37554441)
Not sure if it's EU-level regulation, but many EU countries seem to have it.
Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by JuanPosadas on Friday September 15, 2023 @10:41PM (#37531524)
At my Kroger, almost half the times I try to compare unit price bergen two products, the units are different (e.g. $/oz or $/lb or $/g). And these are always products right next to each other on the shelf.
Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by eru on Monday September 18, 2023 @06:38AM (#37554446)
I noticed that at Tesco in the UK as well (but that was ten years ago), they also mixed GBP/piece into the mix.
Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by ochoseis on Friday September 15, 2023 @11:08AM (#37524230)
If you regulate packaging sizes it’ll just cause unintended side effects, like weird fillers in your food.
Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by MAGZine on Friday September 15, 2023 @11:18AM (#37524374)
what, like all of the palm oil that's now in chocolate?
Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by kergonath on Friday September 15, 2023 @12:13PM (#37525303)
Even with unregulated sizes, Amazon’s boxes contain mostly filler. (I wrote Amazon, but it is common for other online stores as well).
Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by RunSet on Friday September 15, 2023 @11:44AM (#37524795)
> I wish there was legislation in place that sets legal standard sizes;

Those extracting profit from deceptive packaging would do better to extract a moral lesson from the provenance of the baker's dozen.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vantage_loaf

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by usrusr on Friday September 15, 2023 @11:47AM (#37524846)
Germany used to have that legislation, removed in 2009. Legal packaging sizes were e.g. 100g, 250g, 500g, 750g, 1000g.

Removed because it was, unsurprisingly, not the lowest common denominator EU wide. It's almost universally considered a tragic loss, I guess the only exception are those whose job description includes getting creative with packaging size.

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by eru on Monday September 18, 2023 @06:35AM (#37554422)
They still have legislation that you have to prominently display the 'Euro per 100g' price? I consider that good enough, and packaging size should be left to the customer.

(The old rule had lots of exceptions and loophole anyway. I remember that fresh yeast almost always came in little cubes of something like 42g, because that's a convenient amount for baking. And no one had any problems with that.

Do you really want bureaucrats or politicians to decide on arguments about what odd sizes are convenient enough to warrant granting such exceptions?)

However, I do remember shopping in Britain, where Tesco would give you the mandated unit price for one kind of apple per piece and the next box over with a different variety of apple would give you the unit price per kg. British supermarkets were a bit customer hostile like that. (I noticed them get a lot better when Aldi and Lidl really took hold in the UK. Especially those confusing '5-for-3' deals etc got much rarer.)

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by mitthrowaway2 on Friday September 15, 2023 @11:52AM (#37524949)
I've been saying this for ages. There are so many second-order benefits. For example in Japan, books are virtually all a standard size, and so bookshelves are built to match. Lets you fit more books in a small home.

When packages are random sizes and always varying, it's impossible for anyone in adjacent industries to develop synergies.

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by eru on Monday September 18, 2023 @06:36AM (#37554434)
As a customer you can already refuse to buy books that do not come in your preferred standard size.
Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by mytailorisrich on Friday September 15, 2023 @01:00PM (#37526060)
Enforcing legal standard weights/sizes for everything that businesses cannot deviate from would be ridiculous... and that wouldn't reduce inflation, either.

List the price per litre or per kg, for instance, for every item in addition to the item's price and people can then compare between different brands on the shelf. This is already done in many cases though I do not know if there is a legal obligation.

People are not stupid by the way, they notice when an item they are used to buy shrinks.

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by eru on Monday September 18, 2023 @06:36AM (#37554428)
> This is already done in many cases though I do not know if there is a legal obligation.

Many countries have such legal obligations. Details obviously depend on jurisdiction.

Re:Carrefour puts ‘shrinkflation’ price warnings on food to ... by erulabs on Friday September 15, 2023 @01:08PM (#37526162)
Be wary of engineering society as you would a machine. You don’t know which efficiency you’re destroying in favor of whatever efficiency you may or may not be getting.

A grocery story where all the isles are filled with identically sized boxes full of standardized products sounds pretty depressing, for one thing.