News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by bsimpson on Friday September 08, 2023 @12:55AM (#37429503)
It's nice to see progress being made towards more rational drug policy, and also disappointing that this a "plant medicine = good" bill instead of a "criminalizing psychedelics is stupid" bill.

Chemically-derived ones like LSD and MDMA are not in-scope in Wiener's bill, even though (like mushrooms) they aren't the kinds of drugs that cause social problems.

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by somenameforme on Friday September 08, 2023 @01:31AM (#37429737)
I think it's relevant to point out that even Amsterdam eventually chose to ban magic mushrooms, though less potent magic truffles remain legal. This happened after a rapidly increasing number of incidents of people having psychotic episodes while tripping and injuring or killing themselves, usually while trying to fly.

I don't really see how legalization could work, let alone in an area with extremely high numbers of people with mental illness. Shrooms + mental illness go together like ammonia and bleach. And how many 'flying deaths', particularly of otherwise healthy young people, will society accept before backtracking? One can already easily envision the commercials for the inevitable proposition over it.

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by ShellfishMeme on Friday September 08, 2023 @01:47AM (#37429855)
Is there any proof that people trying to fly and jumping off a building is actually real? I always assumed it's some sort of anti drug meme that had been around since forever.
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by Fezzik on Friday September 08, 2023 @02:18AM (#37430080)
That does seem… odd. I’ve been enjoying mushrooms multiple times a year for 22 years. I’ve been around a lot of other people doing mushrooms. On fire lookouts. Rooftops. High in the mountains of Oregon, Washington, and Colorado. And I have never, ever seen anybody try to fly.
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by abletonlive on Friday September 08, 2023 @02:32AM (#37430184)
You haven't been around enough people doing psychedelics then. Psychotic breaks are not uncommon. Once you're at a music festival where n=thousands you realize this. Flying and drowning in lakes is not unheard of.

Everybody thinks they are immune to psychotic breaks until they do enough psychedelics and have one. This could be you some day.

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by Fezzik on Friday September 08, 2023 @02:41AM (#37430267)
Oh, I’m aware it can happen. I’ve been around people who OD or go super deep in K Holes, and been to more than enough festivals for one lifetime, but those extreme side effects don’t seem to be all that common with mushrooms. I don’t even know anyone who knows anyone who knows anyone that has had a psychotic break tripping. The dearth of information online leads me to believe it really is extremely uncommon.
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by abletonlive on Friday September 08, 2023 @02:45AM (#37430300)
> I don’t even know anyone who knows anyone who knows anyone that has had a psychotic break tripping.

It's not that uncommon. If you don't believe me, volunteer for a medical tent for any music festival where psychedelic use is rampant. You'll get psychotic breaks all night.

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by RoyalHenOil on Friday September 08, 2023 @03:49AM (#37430749)
I feel like you two are talking past one another.

One of you is saying "mushrooms" and the other is saying "psychedelics".

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by abletonlive on Friday September 08, 2023 @03:52AM (#37430774)
I'm saying all psychedelics commonly cause psychotic breaks. I've had to assist people on mushroom induced psychotic breaks before. I love mushrooms as much as any other hippie and think they should be legalized but don't agree with the whitewashing that is happening in the psychedelic activist circles. Let's not swing the pendulum too far in the other direction - they should be taken seriously just like any other mind altering drug.
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by pmoriarty on Friday September 08, 2023 @08:26AM (#37432629)
What do you mean by "psychotic break" exactly?
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by abletonlive on Friday September 08, 2023 @08:56PM (#37441137)
It means psychosis. I'm confused about what you do not understand about this. It's losing touch with reality, knowing that you're in a situation or place which you are not - losing the ability to determine what is real or what is not real. Once you are out of this state you realize that you could not have been trusted to make any decisions about reality (whether you were where you thought you were, whether what you were doing was safe, whether what you believe was true). It's basically sleepwalking while on psychedelics. Once you're done with the psychosis you might not remember most of it.

If you get caught in this state at a music festival and restrained (sometimes restrained to a gurney if you are caught in a camping festival like Electric Forest and they determine an ambulance is not necessary) you get sent off via an ambulance where they will feed you benzodiazepines/antipsychotics and hold you at a hospital until you are back to reality, incurring a pretty hefty ER bill. This is not just a bad trip that someone can talk you down from. This is literally losing control of your entire being. It's like having someone else at the wheels. Short term psychosis.

That's how ALL big music festivals in the US handle psychotic breaks. They won't let you just go around the festival endangering yourself and being a menace to the rest of the patrons.

Not a great place to be in, but I've seen it enough times to know it's not uncommon.

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by washadjeffmad on Saturday September 09, 2023 @06:38AM (#37443901)
Just weighing in, but sampling for these events isn't necessarily applicable to the general population.

Whether that's because people whose brains are more likely to experience psychosis are more drawn to music festivals, whether it's a supply-trust or dosage issue (lower purity or higher potency compounds, goers don't know what they took or how much), or that prior exposure to cultural lore like "drugs makes people want to fly" is influencing them, I don't know.

Age is also a known factor - schizophrenia is more likely to emerge around the age of maturity, often associated with stress and drug use (again, may be wet roads causing rain - people self-medicate even if they don't realize it), even though, statistically, "college" would be just as likely, and it often happens as a psychotic break, the way you described. I worked with young musicians for many years and saw it happen regularly enough - no psychedelics required.

So the fact that everything you mention happens is evidence, but of what? That's a harder question to answer.

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by danielbln on Friday September 08, 2023 @04:12AM (#37430921)
I'm also curious if OP talks about actual medical psychotic breaks or "bad trips", which may overlap but don't have to.
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by abletonlive on Friday September 08, 2023 @05:27AM (#37431457)
I'm talking about medical psychotic breaks.
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by pmoriarty on Friday September 08, 2023 @08:26AM (#37432634)
Please define that.
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by plugin-baby on Friday September 08, 2023 @04:07AM (#37430889)
> I don’t even know anyone who knows anyone who knows anyone that has had a psychotic break tripping.

I’ve witnessed it. There might have been weed and/or alcohol involved as well.

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by amanaplanacanal on Friday September 08, 2023 @08:50AM (#37432837)
In my experience weed with psychedelics is a horrible combination. I know a lot of people do it, but yuck.
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by saberience on Friday September 08, 2023 @02:37AM (#37430218)
You haven't been around enough people drinking booze then. Psychotic breaks are not uncommon. Once you're basically anwywhere with people drinking you realize this. Flying and drowning in lakes, murdering your wife, or dying in a fiery crash on the freeway are not unheard of.

Everybody thinks they are immune to psychotic breaks until they do enough booze and have one. This could be you some day.

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by abletonlive on Friday September 08, 2023 @02:41AM (#37430264)
I'm not sure why you're responding in this manner. I never said alcohol was any better. I was addressing a comment that they were surprised psychotic breaks and deaths happen on psychedelics. This has nothing to do with alcohol.

Seems quite petty of a response.

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by krisoft on Friday September 08, 2023 @03:43AM (#37430705)
> I was addressing a comment that they were surprised psychotic breaks and deaths happen on psychedelics.

They were specificaly asking about people wanting to fly.

“And I have never, ever seen anybody try to fly.” was the direct quote. Doesn’t say anything about psychotic breaks or deaths.

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by AllegedAlec on Friday September 08, 2023 @03:42AM (#37430701)
\>thing A is bad, but so is thing B, so we can't criminalize thing A

Better decriminalize murder in that case.

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by saberience on Friday September 08, 2023 @09:05AM (#37432962)
Honest question: How many people do you think avoid murdering others because there is a law against it? Or another way of putting it, do you think that the reason more people don't go around murdering others is because the government wrote down somewhere "this is illegal"?
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by AllegedAlec on Saturday September 09, 2023 @02:43AM (#37442855)
No clue, but I also don't see how it's relevant to my tongue in cheek dismissive answer to OP
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by fsckboy on Tuesday September 12, 2023 @03:48AM (#37477964)
> How many people do you think avoid murdering others because there is a law against it?

if murder were legalized, the murder rate would jump, a lot.

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by fullspectrumdev on Friday September 08, 2023 @04:08AM (#37430896)
Most of the times I’ve seen someone have a mental health episode while on drugs, it’s been caused by either overdose, poly drug consumption (taking a bunch of shit), or the drug they took not being the drug they thought they were taking.

Or massive sleep deprivation powered by stimulant abuse over a protracted period of time.

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by mschuster91 on Friday September 08, 2023 @04:31AM (#37431054)
The worst compounding factor is that many people do not have "trip sitters": sober people that take care no one gets up to too dumb shit, get injured, or that rude external people don't barge in and ruin the vibe.
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by Rebelgecko on Friday September 08, 2023 @02:24AM (#37430126)
If you Google around it seems like there's plenty of anecdotal cases of it happening, although some of them are a bit tabloidy and sensationalized, and some of the people had multiple substances going on

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/asia/bali-death-ong...

https://www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/news/greater-manches...

https://www.irishtimes.com/news/man-jumped-from-balcony-afte...

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by orangepurple on Friday September 08, 2023 @02:43AM (#37430277)
My friend experienced a situation where she took something 10 years ago that was speedy and trippy that was sold as LSD but was clearly NOT and there was definitely a feeling of invulnerability to damage at altitude and a heightened perception of strength.
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by greyface- on Friday September 08, 2023 @03:00AM (#37430405)
If it weren't illegal, we'd have better supply chain transparency, and your friend would have been less likely to have been sold a dangerously mislabeled substance.
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by Gibbon1 on Friday September 08, 2023 @04:31AM (#37431053)
I remember that as a meme of sorts in the late 1960's. And there is a film with a scene where a hippie tries to fly out a window.

This is the scene, no idea what movie though.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G29gdfcsgio

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by Cthulhu_ on Friday September 08, 2023 @09:56AM (#37433552)
It's real, but highly uncommon (that is, every incident will be in the news); compare that to e.g. instances of drunken rages, alcohol poisoning, Korsakoff and drunk drivers which... is still reported on, but a lot of it goes by silently.
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by supercheetah on Friday September 08, 2023 @02:00AM (#37429950)
This isn't legalization. It's just decriminalization. There's a big difference. People can still be fined for their use if there isn't a medical reason, but they won't go to jail or prison.
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by todd3834 on Friday September 08, 2023 @02:33AM (#37430192)
I’ve been around a lot of people on mushrooms. I will say that the experiences I’ve observed never made anyone think they could fly off a building. Maybe they were just lucky or the shrooms were always weak.

However, I have very real concerns about the effects on those who might have dormant mental illness. I have no proof but the idea that many kinds of drugs could amplify or accelerate a mental illness scares me in a mass consumption setting.

If there is no evidence for this then I’d like to know. If there is evidence for this then we need to really make it clear and educate people of the risk.

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by Gud on Friday September 08, 2023 @02:56AM (#37430375)
I suspect we will never really know until mass consumption becomes legal. There is so much FUD regarding drugs the truth is hard to tell.

My 2 cents, out of all the psychedelics, Mescaline seem to be the most gentle on the human psyche.

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by tudorw on Friday September 08, 2023 @05:02AM (#37431252)
Let's make it clear, if by gentle you mean an intense 18 hour journey in a mind roller coaster you cannot control or stop, then yes, that's what a friend told me.
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by Gud on Friday September 08, 2023 @09:26AM (#37433182)
It depends on the dosage. Start by slowly taking incremental 50mg steps, once a month. Less if you have a low body weight .

But less is more. Mescaline is very potent.

It’s not something you want to be doing too much of anyway, it’s exhausting.

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by bsimpson on Friday September 08, 2023 @02:34PM (#37437543)
Incidentally mescaline tends to be one of the exceptions from the "legalize all plant medicine" crowd. Apparently it's a lot of effort to cultivate peyote; there isn't much of it, and it's associated with tribal practices. People advocating for legalization tend to leave out peyote because they don't want people competing with tribal shaman for access to it.

I believe there's another source (S. Pedro cactus?) that doesn't have the tribal history, and is thus considered a reasonable alternative for legalization.

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by mythhabit on Friday September 08, 2023 @03:08AM (#37430462)
The research is old and in its infancy, but I believe there is a pretty clear evidence that link underlying predisposition to certain mental illnesses and a psychotic episode when using psychedelics. I believe it remains to be determined what exactly this means, and how to go about it.

It is, in my opinion, a very strong argument for not allowing unsupervised mass consumption. And to be fair, most people are not using psychedelics in a way that maximize their psychological healing, but rather just to trip. On the flipside, smoking and alcohol are legal, and that causes a lot of early deaths every single day, even to people not smoking or drinking.

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by amanaplanacanal on Friday September 08, 2023 @08:56AM (#37432877)
By “not allowing” do you mean putting people in jail, or something else? Because passing a law doesn’t make it just go away. Putting people in jail seems worse in every way.
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by mythhabit on Friday September 08, 2023 @09:46AM (#37433425)
You should never put people in jail for using any controlled substance. That is mostly an american thing. For people using it, just fine them and be done with it. Go after the people producing, distributing and selling.
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by datadeft on Friday September 08, 2023 @02:35AM (#37430212)
> number of incidents of people having psychotic episodes while tripping and injuring or killing themselves, usually while trying to fly

1 person died and she was 17 so could not legally purchase mushrooms.

> Sale to minors is prohibited, and an information leaflet should be given with the mushrooms (apparently, the French girl had not bought the mushrooms herself, but older friends).

I think we live in era when driving a car and dying is ok while taking mushrooms and dying is not ok.

The first has one or two orders of magnitude more deaths than the second case.

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by nec4b on Friday September 08, 2023 @03:51PM (#37438558)
I guess you don't drive to work if you somehow equate driving (something necessary to live) with taking mushrooms (unnecessary and risky pleasure)?
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by davidandgoliath on Friday September 08, 2023 @04:20PM (#37438891)
Driving is very optional. Guns are very optional. We have both, so, we should also consider responsible adults worthy of choosing to use/not use substances.
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by nec4b on Friday September 08, 2023 @05:19PM (#37439582)
Maybe for you driving is optional, though I wander how food gets to your store, but for a large number of people is a necessity.
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by datadeft on Monday September 11, 2023 @04:19AM (#37464402)
Can I also claim that taking LSD is a necessity for me to have my well being?

Who decides what is a necessity and what is not? I would say that the harm rate could be a good indicator what a society should tolerate and anything that is less harmful what is tolerated should be legal.

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by datadeft on Monday September 11, 2023 @04:18AM (#37464389)
I do sometimes, but more often I take public transportation or wfh.
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by caskstrength on Friday September 08, 2023 @04:10AM (#37430904)
> And how many 'flying deaths', particularly of otherwise healthy young people, will society accept before backtracking?

But it is fine to put those "otherwise healthy young people" to prison for having a pack of shrooms in their pocket, amiright?

And when they are out (probably not as healthy or as young anymore) let's ruin their lives further by preventing them for ever getting any reasonable job for having a criminal record...

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by pmoriarty on Friday September 08, 2023 @08:18AM (#37432557)
"Even Amsterdam"?

The Netherlands have been under the control of a conservative government for a long time now, and countless coffeshops have been forced to close under their rule. Banning magic mushrooms is just par for the course.

The Netherlands used to have a well-deserved reputation for tolerance, but that's been wearing away for decades now, with intolerance for everything from Muslim immigrants to drug users.

I say this with a heavy heart, as someone who absolutely loves the Netherlands for everything else it has to offer, and who used to be in awe of how tolerant and accepting they were.

There was a day when the Netherlands could be justly proud of leading the world in tolerance, but that time is over.

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by mensetmanusman on Friday September 08, 2023 @08:37AM (#37432714)
Can’t blame a conservative government. Their society tried something different and they found the approach lacking.
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by pmoriarty on Friday September 08, 2023 @08:38AM (#37432728)
The conservative government is a reflection of what the Dutch people want.

They just aren't as tolerant as a society as they used to be.

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by mensetmanusman on Friday September 08, 2023 @11:04AM (#37434439)
Exactly, government is a symptom of society.
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by electrondood on Friday September 08, 2023 @01:12AM (#37429623)
They were originally, from the article, this is a narrower version that removed ibogaine, LSD, MDMA. Which is silly, because LSD is comparable to mushrooms and MDMA is a powerfully therapeutic substance.
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by bsimpson on Friday September 08, 2023 @02:35PM (#37437568)
I didn't read the article because paywall.

My comments were from memory - I had heard about this bill earlier (but it was also only plant medicine then).

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by corethree on Friday September 08, 2023 @01:10AM (#37429605)
We need more progress on this. I don't see enough homeless people getting high on the streets of SF. Priorities.
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by Pxtl on Friday September 08, 2023 @02:17AM (#37430067)
Well obviously the homeless people are getting drugs just fine so since prohibition failed why not let law-abiding folks have a hit?
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by callalex on Friday September 08, 2023 @02:56AM (#37430378)
You are aware that different drugs have different effects right? Or do you take Tylenol for allergies and Benadryl for headaches?
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by valec on Friday September 08, 2023 @01:54AM (#37429905)
it's even sillier. LSD is derived from very small modifications to compounds produced by the ergot fungus. and certain synthetic psilocin analogues like 4-ho-met and 4-aco-dmt have few if any meaningful differences to psilocin itself (aka 4-ho-dmt)
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by sargun on Friday September 08, 2023 @02:01AM (#37429960)
Early versions of the bill had Ketamine in it. It was villified as a "date rape drug". I don't remember why MDMA got removed, but babysteps if my guess.
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by fluxem on Friday September 08, 2023 @02:36AM (#37430214)
Well, because it is
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by theptip on Friday September 08, 2023 @03:10AM (#37430484)
Alcohol too, if we are applying rigor equally. And yet not many bite the bullet and say “alcohol, the well-known date rape drug, should be banned and its users put in jail”.
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by rightbyte on Friday September 08, 2023 @03:30AM (#37430608)
Isn't the victim unaware of being drugged when you speak of these "date rape" drugs?

With alcohol you can maybe put more spirits in a drink than you claim. It is not tasteless.

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by baq on Friday September 08, 2023 @03:39AM (#37430683)
> It is not tasteless.

It definitely is harder to notice after the first couple normal alcohol content drinks.

I've played pranks on my friends like this in the past. They were surprised how wasted they'd been the night before.

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by WesolyKubeczek on Friday September 08, 2023 @04:38AM (#37431109)
Also because when this had been attempted in Prohibition and during Perestroika, it failed quite spectacularly both times.
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by theragra on Friday September 08, 2023 @03:37AM (#37430662)
Pretense to disallow self-meciating depression and paying instead?
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by Animats on Friday September 08, 2023 @02:37AM (#37430221)
> "plant medicine = good"

That's a problem. The other side of that is "natural = unstandardized doses" That's become a big problem with cannabis, which has had huge potency upgrades through both selective breeding and concentrates.[1][2]

The good thing about cannabis used to be that the effective dose and the hazardous dose were a long way apart, and it was hard to reach the hazardous dose. That's changed.

[1] https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2020/11/201116092241.h...

[2] https://www.nbcnews.com/health/kids-health/states-legalized-...

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by danielbln on Friday September 08, 2023 @04:09AM (#37430898)
You can thank the black market for that one. Same as you couldn't buy much beer and such during the prohibition, because hard liquor was more lucrative to smuggle.

And while psychosis occurrence might raise with increased doses, at least LD50 for THC in rodents (I know, but hard to ethically gauge it in humans) is 1250mg/kg orally. If we naively scale this up to humans, a 70kg human would have to consume 90g of pure THC, which is an incredibly outrageous, absolutely unattainable amount.

I would also argue that you need less cannabis to reach a desired state if it is of higher potency. Do people measure their intake in "joints" which are consumed no matter what the actual potency is?

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by saiya-jin on Friday September 08, 2023 @04:38AM (#37431103)
That argument indeed doesn't make much sense to me. If I smoke, its not "this amount regardless of potency or method" rather "to get this high". If I smoked joints which I don't do since I like my lungs it would just mean much more unhealthy hobby.

So yes strong stuff is a godsend, can get to desired state more effectively and cheaply too.

The only situation where it may make sense is some inexperienced users taking too much, which can easily happen with random illegal street stuff. But its like arguing to ban hard liquors since people can get shitfaced from few shots easier than from beer, and indeed getting wasted increases the chance to develop some bad mental issues, father of one of my ex gf ended up with schizophrenia just from excessive drinking at ripe age of 18.

Which is all true but response is - don't do stupid stuff, as it should be with other drugs. Legalizing and having easy available advice / guide is much better.

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by loa_in_ on Friday September 08, 2023 @09:36AM (#37433312)
Someone who isn't me found cannabis intolerable because it was making them feel anxious. Asked whether they considered using a smaller dose or lower potency they said they already tried that. What happened was even though they acquired the least strong stuff it was still too much for them to benefit from it. They ended up with a process making edibles, very much diluting the weakest stuff and that proved useful to them.
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by danielbln on Friday September 08, 2023 @02:35PM (#37437566)
A benefit of legalization is that you can have 1mg THC mints or whatever. Good luck finding that in any illegal market.
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by dr_dshiv on Friday September 08, 2023 @03:02AM (#37430420)
I think all drugs should have licenses that can be obtained and taken away. I think it’s ok to require IDs and a certain level of test performance. Heck, I wish alcohol was the same (at least for 18-20 year olds).
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by sneak on Friday September 08, 2023 @03:51AM (#37430766)
Upon what reasonable moral authority can anyone claim to control what another person does to their own body that does not harm another person?

I claim an absolute, perpetual, inviolable, and inalienable moral right to my own person, and modifying it in any way I see fit: tattoos, scarification, branding, piercing, amputation, et cetera. I get to choose what medical procedures I will or will not accept. I get to choose when my life ends voluntarily. I alone choose what I will or will not eat, will or will not insert into my bloodstream.

The same moral authority that tells me I cannot put a specified substance into my bloodstream must also simultaneously claim the authority to tell me that I must swallow a certain substance or food, which is ridiculous. Does looking at it in that way reveal its absurdity to you?

If you don't have the moral basis to force me to eat a food I do not wish to eat, you do not have the moral basis to deny me the right to ingest a drug I do wish to ingest.

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by debatem1 on Friday September 08, 2023 @04:01AM (#37430846)
It turns out the state can restrict what you say, what you do with your body, what you ingest, and all the rest. This is demonstrably true to anyone with a passing familiarity with the criminal justice system.
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by sneak on Friday September 08, 2023 @04:33AM (#37431064)
Not in my experience. Nobody really agrees with the state here, and their restrictions are ignored by everyone (when it comes to their own body). The only people who support these restrictions support them when applied to the bodies of other people.

https://joycearthur.com/abortion/the-only-moral-abortion-is-...

My question was not what authorities the state claims - my question is about upon what moral or philosophical basis such claims would be morally justified.

I am aware the state claims such authority. I am also aware that they further claim the authority to enslave me, arm me, ship me across the earth, and execute me if I refuse to commit murder on their behalf. The state claiming an authority does not actually provide them with a moral basis to do so.

On what reasonable moral basis could anyone claim the authority to strip someone of their rights to final disposition over their own body?

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by dr_dshiv on Friday September 08, 2023 @08:09AM (#37432491)
Well, a murderer is just having an experience and moving their body, right? So obviously there are restrictions in the case where one’s internal experiences lead to actions that affect others. Even for actions like suicide there are negative externalities. Hence the need for regulation.
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by mensetmanusman on Friday September 08, 2023 @09:10AM (#37433009)
People disagree on the definition of harm, therefore there will be preferences for law.

On a societal scale, if there is a 1:N chance a drug or experience will nullify your health and you will require society to bear the burden if your existence, then people in society may decide to attempt to minimize such occurrences through law.

If N is 6 as in Russian Roulette, society might control what you might accidentally put in your body. If N is 1,000,000 like in driving, we might regulate the requirements of who can do that to minimize the chance of harming others and drive N higher.

If N is 10,000 (for certain drugs) in terms of the chance you might overdose and harm yourself sufficiently, society might say the benefit isn’t worth the risk and ‘control what you do with your body.’

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by Melting_Harps on Friday September 08, 2023 @03:36AM (#37430659)
> Chemically-derived ones like LSD and MDMA are not in-scope in Wiener's bill, even though (like mushrooms) they aren't the kinds of drugs that cause social problems.

I think that is a mistake; both have a long record of use and potential in clinical trials dting abck since the 60s in Harvard, with a litany of uses from depression, alcoholism, scitzoephrenia etc... We all know the work of T. LEary, but the research needs to be continued and implemented at a time when we seem to need it more than ever. Thus why this portion is perhaps the most notable take-away and not the decriminalization aspect (Oakland, like Denver, has been decriminalized for sometime):

The bill also would require the California Health and Human Services Agency to study the therapeutic use of psychedelics and submit a report with its findings and recommendations to the Legislature.

Oregon was supposed to lead the way in this respect but has effectively stalled out in the process despite having first mover advantage [0] , so I hope CA takes over in it's place. Colorado doesn't seem to have any interest in anything other than decriminalization, either.

0: https://www.opb.org/article/2023/08/23/psilocybin-mushroom-t...

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by wil421 on Friday September 08, 2023 @08:14AM (#37432532)
I’ve met people who were addicted to both LSD and MDMA. One guy took LSD for a year straight. Decriminalization is a step in the right direction but where’s the support structure? California probably has the most drug problems in the states and mushrooms are not going to cause anymore problems. The other piece for support and therapy needs to improve. Alcohol is included as well as legal marijuana.
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by alienicecream on Friday September 08, 2023 @08:42AM (#37432764)
This is the opposite of rational. They are decriminalizing it based on a fashion that drugs are good and when it comes to drugs people should be able to do whatever they want without regard to consequences. Compare this with the fanaticism against smoking you see from the same quarters, that should be enough to tell you this is nothing more than hippy fashion.
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by amanaplanacanal on Friday September 08, 2023 @08:58AM (#37432902)
I don’t see anybody trying to make tobacco illegal.
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by alienicecream on Friday September 08, 2023 @01:03PM (#37436264)
Then I would say you're not looking closely enough. The impetus is there, but so far there is enough resistance to it to prevent it. That wasn't the point anyway, the point is the contradiction in the antipathy towards tobacco on the basis of health vs the libertine attitude towards drugs. The kinds of people who tend to be pro drugs, pro prostitution, etc are the same people who will scold others for smoking.
Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by bsimpson on Friday September 08, 2023 @02:26PM (#37437411)
A lot of people believe in the freedom to do what you like if you don't harm others.

People doing MDMA or LSD generally don't harm others.

People smoking do. Bartenders, card dealers, etc have their workplaces polluted by cigarettes.

I'm sure there are plenty of libertarians who are against social restrictions on smoking. There are others who tolerate the restrictions because they personally find it to be a nicer experience to not have ambient smoke out in the world. Nevertheless, nobody thinks you should be thrown in jail for carrying cigarettes.

Taxing cigarettes and decriminalizing psychedelics are not the same conversation. Your attempt to conflate them is a fallacy.

-----

Moreover, that aspect of the conversation is just about the "should"s - should someone be free to alter their minds/bodies in the privacy of their own homes/if they aren't causing undue harm to others?

The strongest argument for legalization is to defund the cartels. Countless dollars are being funneled to violent mobs because of the remnants of Richard Nixon's paranoia. The world would be a better place if the cartels were less powerful, and the drug problem would be much less of a problem if drugs weren't adulterated.

The cartels and fentanyl poisoning are causing trauma for way too many families. There aren't enough pros to Nixon's line of thinking to justify that.

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by alienicecream on Friday September 08, 2023 @03:03PM (#37437923)
The solution to second hand smoke is simple, if you don't want to be around it, then don't put yourself near it. That goes for most things. Nobody is forcing people to become waiters in restaurants where there is smoking. It is the converse, they want to ban the possibility. Nobody is going to jail for smoking...yet. But they have been pushed out of every public place where they used to be accommodated and punitively taxed. The intention is clear.

The argument is not important, the motivation is what matters, because that tells you where things are going to go. People that want drug legalization want to do drugs, not defund their supply, that is just a convenient argument.

Re:California moves to decriminalize use of magic mushrooms,... by LinuxBender on Saturday September 09, 2023 @09:05AM (#37444900)
"plant medicine = good"

That's risky. I and millions and others have natural hallucinogens growing in the fields in North America and much of Europe. Henbane is pretty hard to completely eradicate, is likely one of the most naturally powerful hallucinogens and is also one of the most dangerous to use as a recreational drug safely as potency varies wildly in each plant. Every part of the plant is a drug and every part of the plant is deadly. It can be and has been used in the medical field but has been replaced with chemicals that are safer to measure.