News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by jvm___ on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @07:31AM (#37234311)
Scott Manly has a video on why he thinks the last one failed. It sounds like their landing software didn't have "oh crap, we're way off course, just land wherever". It only had the happy path of "fly to here and land", so when it switched to the landing phase it tried valiently (including flying upside down) to try to fly back to the landing zone, but the landing zone was much further than fuel supplies allowed.

Hopefully they have upgraded software to just gracefully attempt a landing, and hopefully they won't be off course.

Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by raverbashing on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @07:47AM (#37234418)
This applies to general software development but is especially true in this case

While we think "this cannot ever happen" in a lot of cases it can, in ways you did not consider. Both for good and bad

Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by rob74 on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:12AM (#37234659)
In general software development it's usually not a problem if your program crashes, then you can fix the bug and run it again. If the thing that crashes is a lunar lander however, you should put a bit more effort into covering all the eventualities...
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by pjmorris on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:46AM (#37234981)
I really ought to dig up a reference for this, but there are strong echoes from the past here. Margaret Hamilton (who coined the term 'software engineering' and can be seen standing next to a tall pile of green bar printouts of the Apollo software) brought her daughter to work one weekend during the Apollo program and she (daughter) fiddled with the buttons and caused an error condition. Hamilton, based on this, argued that the software should account for the possibility of mistakes. Management's view was that the highly-trained astronauts wouldn't make mistakes. In time, Hamilton prevailed, and was proven correct.
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by monitron on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @10:27AM (#37236495)
If you find a reference (or anyone does), please share. This is too good a story not to be told widely.
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by stuaxo on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:41PM (#37243769)
Having seen what happens when you let a toddler start randomly pressing stuff on an Android tablet she was spot on, and if anything every environment should be out through this.
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by extraduder_ire on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @09:47AM (#37235794)
The recent japanese lander had something like this happen a while back. The altitude radar noticed a sudden 2km drop in ground-level, and the system assumed it was broken and stopped using that data.

Turns out it just flew over a cliff edge that actually does that. Completely by accident.

Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by jvm___ on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @10:22AM (#37236403)
They picked a new landing site late in the program and didn't get the topography near that site, or run enough combinations through the software in test.
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by oaktowner on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @05:22PM (#37242026)
While I worked at Google I once searched for "//this should never happen" in the code base.

It was in there.

A lot.

Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by gora_mohanty on Thursday August 24, 2023 @01:21AM (#37245316)
That might still be OK if that path literally should never happen in normal operation, but us used, e.g., to handle an error, or at least log it, if the impossible happens because the software is deployed in some unexpected configuration
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by oaktowner on Monday August 28, 2023 @05:53PM (#37300875)
Yes! Totally agreed.
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by The_Colonel on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @07:55AM (#37234519)
Not considering such a basic error condition seems like a gross omission.

This can't even come from the software engineering, but must be some kind of managerial failure (e.g. we're short on time, but have to report great progress to my boss, so skip this scenario).

Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by delta_p_delta_x on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:10AM (#37234638)
> seems like such a gross omission.

Almost all space mission code only ever has the so-called 'happy path'. We rely on extremely tight mechanical and aerospace engineering tolerances to achieve that happy path.

The Hubble Space Telescope's primary mirror grinding was off by a matter of micrometres, and resulted in blurry images.

Consider all the Mars rovers. Imagine some wind gust threw the descending module off course, or a retro-rocket failed because of vibrations.

Writing code for space missions isn't like writing a CRUD app. Developers can't just teleport to a space probe millions to billions of kilometres away to rectify errors and debug running code on the fly.

For the record, the 'failure path' for Apollo 11 was to get the US President to announce to the world that the two astronauts would likely be marooned on the Moon. Apollo 13 very nearly failed, too.

Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by The_Colonel on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:21AM (#37234751)
When saying "we", do you mean you write code for the space missions?

Writing only happy path code as a standard practice in the space sector seems quite absurd. You won't ever achieve absolute precision and errors do happen, yet it seems like systems recover most of the time.

Recently, the antenna of Voyager 2 got misaligned, but it is expected to recover from that. That was only the last problem it encountered over its very long mission - and it managed to recover from all of those so far!

Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by jvm___ on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:36AM (#37234915)
Voyager 2 is already recovered, they waited until it was at the best possible (but still wrong orientation) and just yelled at it so that it heard, even with it being misaligned.
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by jacobwilliamroy on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @11:57AM (#37238036)
Wow I can't believe I didn't hear about this. It was all over the news when they broke it, so I figured it would be just as widely reported when they fixed it. It's been almost 3 weeks.
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by SamBam on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @01:01PM (#37238963)
There was definitely a prominent NYTimes story when it was fixed, that's how I heard about it.
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by stall84 on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:30PM (#37243708)
Voyager's programming just brings joy to me to think about.. I mean it's the system as a whole (of course) .. but the fact that they've been capable of flying through the environments they have been, using points of light to align themselves, among other things.. for decades .. and recover from incidents.. is just something I marvel at.
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by abecedarius on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @09:24AM (#37235504)
There was a NASA project to start developing flight software that's smarter in this kind of way, the Remote Agent. It got an award after flying, but if they continued that line of research I haven't heard about it. https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20000116204/downloads/20...
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by numpad0 on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @10:45AM (#37236824)
Trying to hand roll a super robust AI software usually backfires. Emergency mode triggers right in the middle of the happy path and ruins your uh, a day if you're lucky. They know that, even I kinda know that.
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by taneq on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:46AM (#37234983)
That can't still be the case these days, can it? Extremely tight mechanical and engineering tolerances are very expensive compared with merely 'very very' tight tolerances, and I'd imagine the difference between the two can be bridged with more intelligent software in place of "gyroscope + clock + maybe PID loop"?
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by fidotron on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @09:02AM (#37235195)
Yeah, this reads like two people defining happy path subtly differently: one is saying the happy path is anything within acceptable strictly defined mission parameters and tolerances, the other thinks it is the sequence of steps that is expected to successfully execute the mission without ever encountering an exceptional situation (which is the conventional software view of the term), but there are exceptional situations which may be covered in the specification of the mission and so “on the happy path”.

In the case the system strays outside mission success parameters then aborting could make sense. The question there looks to be if the success parameters were defined too narrowly - it sounds like an error in specification that prioritizes landing in the required area over the possibility of landing at all.

Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by bregma on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @01:53PM (#37239710)
The classic hardware engineering response of "we'll just fix it in software". Turns out fixing things in software is even more expensive because it's just so easy to make changes that a combinatoric number of changes sneak in.
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by taneq on Thursday August 24, 2023 @09:58AM (#37248856)
Ohhhh yes. I've been on the receiving end of this one. Designing a system which can accommodate higher tolerances on some hardware components through software controls is one thing. Being handed a poorly performing piece of hardware and told to "just fix it in software" is quite another.
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by astrange on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @07:31PM (#37243303)
If you write the failure path, then you also have to ensure it doesn't fire when there wasn't really a failure and do unnecessary heroics.

Same reason you can't program a self driving car to save a person by sacrificing a squirrel. It's just going to run over the squirrel when it didn't need to.

Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by ianburrell on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @07:32PM (#37243311)
Apollo 1 landed on the "failure path". Neil Armstrong noticed that the target was a boulder field, took manual control, discovered his new spot had a crater, and finally found level ground. They had low fuel but not dangerously low.

If Apollo 11 had followed the "happy path", they would have crashed and died.

Hubble was also the "failure path". The main mirror was flawed and had to be corrected.

Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by dotnet00 on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:13AM (#37234665)
That's probably why they haven't officially straight-up announced the issue.

This wouldn't be the first time that a mission failed due to embarrassing failures in basic software practices (eg Starliner's initial software bugs emerging from a lack of integrated testing).

Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by lenkite on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @11:27AM (#37237560)
> That's probably why they haven't officially straight-up announced the issue.

What do you mean by "they haven't officially straight-up announced the issue." ? They did so - several times actually.

Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by dotnet00 on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @11:52AM (#37237923)
Edit:nvm, I'm wrong, see below

They've given out vague explanations such as a software glitch, while holding the detailed post-mortem back claiming the obviously absurd excuse of national security concerns.

This is counter to how they typically operate as well as how most other agencies/companies around the world operate these days, where they at least explain what went wrong. eg Hakuto-R's team explaining that their flight software thought the radar altimeter was malfunctioning when it wasn't, causing it to rely on the IMU and thus it thought the surface was much higher than it actually was.

Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by lenkite on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @12:04PM (#37238148)
Might want to update your general knowledge. The ISRO Chief explained this in an interview. It wasn't just passed off as "software glitch" with no explanation.

Chairman S Somanath has given three main reasons that led to the crash-landing of the Vikram lander on September 6, 2019 just minutes before the touchdown.

The ISRO chairman said, “The primary issues were: One, we had five engines which were used to reduce the velocity (called retardation). These engines developed higher thrust. When such a higher thrust was happening, the errors on account of this differential were accumulated over some period. All the errors accumulated, which was slightly higher than what we expected.

When it (lander) started to turn very fast, its ability to turn was limited by the software because we never expected such high rates to come. This was the second issue.

The third reason for failure was the small site of 500m x 500m for landing of the lander.”

Rectifying those mistakes this time, the Isro chairman said, “This time we have kept an area of 4.2 km (along the track) x 2.5 km (width) for the landing site. So, it can land anywhere, so it doesn’t limit you to target a specific point.”

Somanath said “instead of a success-based design, Isro has this time opted for a failure-based design” and focused on what all can fail and how to protect it and ensure a successful landing.

“We looked at sensor failure, engine failure, algorithm failure, calculation failure. So, there are different failure scenarios calculated and programmed inside. We did new test beds for simulation, which was not there last time. This was to look at various failure scenarios,” he explained.

The ISRO chief said the Vikram now has additional solar panels on other surfaces to ensure that it generates power no matter how it lands.

Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by dotnet00 on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @12:28PM (#37238495)
Huh, I missed that, thanks for the info!
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by 8thcross on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @06:57PM (#37242995)
There was a JWST doc on netflix; that explained a NASA technique for Points of failure strategy. ISRO may be using similar.
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by xwdv on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:02AM (#37234582)
It probably wasn’t even the error. It could have been an accumulation of error % on some unbounded input.
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by subtra3t on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:45AM (#37234968)
Writing code for something that flies into space is not nearly as easy as you think it is. Perhaps the next time you write a comment you could first develop the software which you're complaining about first. I'm sure it would be a trivial task for someone of your stature :)
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by The_Colonel on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:52AM (#37235061)
I'm not saying it is easy to handle. But this mode of failure could be expected and prepared for. It's not that uncommon that the spacecraft finds itself in a position which was not calculated.

Or, are you saying that it's expected that the mission did not count with this scenario, and that future missions don't need to account for that either?

Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by MPSimmons on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:49AM (#37235017)
Out of curiosity, how many space programs have you been involved with?
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by throwaway4220 on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @09:21AM (#37235467)
No that’s a bit unfair. ISRO, Israel, and Japan all had reasons for their failures that were mainly technical
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by sph on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @09:44AM (#37235730)
This is the software engineering version of "I am very badass", passing judgement on software at the cutting edge of science, while sitting at home writing React code.
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by AlbertCory on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @11:21AM (#37237452)
In football journalism they call that Monday Morning Quarterbacking.
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by RajT88 on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @12:35PM (#37238605)
In any kind of aggressive manly kind of story, especially involving the military, they're "Keyboard Cowboys".

Or some new ones I've heard kicked around:

- Gravy Seals - 101st Chairborn - Chair Force pilots

...And so on...

Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by silisili on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @06:28PM (#37242703)
You're mixing up terms here. Gravy seals is an insult term, used for typically out of shape people who are heavy into gun/militia/i-am-very-badass type culture.

The latter two are just ribbing jokes about the Air Force, from the other branches usually. My old (Army) boss used to tell me to 'take off your air force gloves' if he ever saw me with my hands in my pockets.

Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by AlbertCory on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @06:33PM (#37242743)
Not having served (but I did help out on Operation Code for a couple years):

"Chair Force" does sound like something they would say about armchair generals. No?

Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by silisili on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @06:48PM (#37242901)
Absolutely. Just pointing out that one is strictly a pejorative, while the others would likely be viewed as 'someone in the airforce.' I think OP was wanting things more of the former, like gravy seals, meal team six, y'all queda, etc.
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by AlbertCory on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:55PM (#37243865)
I like y'all queda!
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by icemelt8 on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @01:32PM (#37239401)
I am a React developer and I am in this picture and I don't like it
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by antran22 on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @12:13PM (#37238267)
You are saying "gross omission" like this is some Python script, like they are skipping the else clause for a condition. Imagine trying to land a plane that is flying at Mach 2, with no direct control, only a video feed with 4 seconds resolution, a bunch of sensors and a tank of fuel for retrograde burn to slow you down. Can you even fathom the number of scenarios that can happen. Your application may have 1 happy path and 2 sad path. Here you get only 1 happy path, a few not so happy path where your probe land sideway or just roll down a crater; and the rest of them are every other combinations of your probe's orientation and speed vector and collision location.

Hell, you can run a few thousand simulators for every scenario you can think of during descent, including lost of burner, propellant leak, etc, and then during the actual descent a chip get burnt because of a stray cosmic ray. There will still be somebody on HN call you out for cutting corner.

Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by hoseja on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:11AM (#37234652)
Incredibly Kerbal vibe. I think something like that happened to me when using MechJeb. (it even has a "land whenever" feature, which it was too late to use at that point)
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by dotancohen on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:36AM (#37234917)
That is just a testament to the incredible work of the Squad team. The Indian landing is not similar to Kerbal, rather, Kerbal is very very similar to the real experience. Amazing.
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by franky47 on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:23AM (#37234765)
So in Scott's words, a "fly safe" subroutine?
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by m0llusk on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:35AM (#37234897)
If anything they seem to have overcorrected for this. This landing path stopped with a near hover at around 800m, then a prolonged hover at 150m while the lander scoped the situation, then an extremely slow descent that allowed for corrections the whole way down. Very impressive.
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by hoseja on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:51AM (#37235034)
Also incredibly inefficient.
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by user_7832 on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:52AM (#37235046)
A lot of things in the world trade inefficiencies for safety.
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by hoseja on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:54AM (#37235090)
I was surprised they had the propulsion budget for it.
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by devnonymous on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @09:07AM (#37235258)
Not only was the Chandrayaan 3 budget lesser than that of Chandrayaan 2, as a meme doing the rounds point out, it was lesser than the budgets of some Hollywood blockbusters like Interstellar. So yeah, safe to say they could have had the budget for more if necessary.
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by dotnet00 on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @09:21AM (#37235469)
I don't think they're referring to literal money, but rather that the lander had enough fuel.
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by Sharlin on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @11:13AM (#37237304)
"Fuel budget", "mass budget", "payload budget", even "delta-v budget" are common terms in spaceflight and refer to how much of a valuable thing a spacecraft can carry given some pesky laws of physics [1], nothing to do with money (except insofar as more money would let you build a bigger spacecraft…)

[1] https://www.kallmorris.com/columns/tyranny-of-the-rocket-equ...

Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by ansible on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @09:00AM (#37235169)
It helps a lot that the Moon's gravity is about 1/6th of Earth's.
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by Zigurd on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @10:46AM (#37236857)
This is one reason why low cost and efficiency are just a nice-to-have when it comes to to space exploration. Moreso the farther you go. A unique mission like a lunar polar landing should be conservatively engineered, where that is possible, on the first try. Early optimization and space exploration don't mix.
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by layer8 on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @11:02AM (#37237135)
First make it work, then make it right, last make it efficient.
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by bagels on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @11:45AM (#37237818)
It's a lot more efficient than having to send a fourth rocket.
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by tshaddox on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @12:14PM (#37238289)
What numerator and denominator are you using to calculate the efficiency of an unmanned lunar soft landing mission?
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by hoseja on Thursday August 24, 2023 @07:04AM (#37247427)
The most efficient landing - high impulse reverse gravity turn suicide burn vs. what they did - hovering mid-space two or three times, slowly inching toward ground while fighting gravity.
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by ansible on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:59AM (#37235156)
Yes, it was a very conservative landing trajectory. But it is very, very difficult to get a hoverslam right the first time, or the second, or the third...

I did like seeing the live images captured during descent, I also hope those get made into a video and posted online.

Looking forward to the rover deployment too.

Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by rst on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @05:13PM (#37241913)
This doesn't seem to have been a hoverslam, though -- the probe was hovering at, I think, 150 meters for quite some time, and then maintained a steady and slow rate of descent while still under power.
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by ansible on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @06:15PM (#37242568)
Yes, Chandrayaan-3 definitely did not performance a hoverslam, the landing was much more conservative than that. With a hoverslam, everything has to go exactly right. A valve that is slightly sticky can be enough to wreak everything.
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by morepork on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @06:04PM (#37242457)
If they have the fuel available, may as well be very conservative. Either burn the fuel on descent or have it sit in the tank forever on the lunar surface.
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by 8bitsrule on Thursday August 24, 2023 @03:24AM (#37246020)
Possibly the lander had a choice to be more careful/picky if the remaining fuel permitted. (Just as Armstrong did.)
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by seatac76 on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:53AM (#37235062)
They also had an issue with the thrust gradient it could only do it increments in 20% which was too much of a change this one was finer which allowed for better control authority.
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by ansible on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:53AM (#37235078)
Link to the Scott Manley video - The Real Reason Why Chandrayaan 2 Crashed on the Moon: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2ngVl6iO94c
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by Rygian on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @09:51AM (#37235855)
That's an example of failing to follow the "Aviate, Navigate, Communicate" rule of thumb.
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by goku12 on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @10:30AM (#37236554)
Could you elaborate how that applies here? Communication is out of the question - there's nothing the people on the ground can correct. And the lander apparently failed because it tried to navigate its way back to the designated landing site.
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by vikingerik on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @11:05AM (#37237183)
Communicate wasn't the important part, but you got it in your last sentence. It was trying to navigate over aviate - trying to get to its designated landing spot too hard so that it neglected/failed to stay airborne (spaceborne).
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by goku12 on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @11:10AM (#37237267)
That's much clearer. Aviate > Navigate. Thanks!
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by dadadad100 on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @12:30PM (#37238524)
If you crashed trying to ensure your antenna was optimally oriented then you chose “communicate” over “aviate”. It’s a stretch, but the point is to clearly define your priorities and stick to them, even in a panic
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by sumodm on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @10:57AM (#37237051)
Yes, this seems to be one of the issues. Here is a talk by ISRO Chairman S Somanath at Indian Institute of Science (IISc) about the same and what they added. He goes into details of what went wrong. These are based on my limited understanding. One of the thrusters had an issue and got activated for longer (or may be activation profile of thrusters at its extreme's were different from modeled). They had a narrow landing region selected as final position (even one possible point). So now their control system tried to correct this but the algorithm had a bug and that caused it to be further delayed. At this point the correction required, i.e; thrusters to be activated, was outside the tolerance levels. So finally ended up with 50m/s vertical speed. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fZ2sNRP1opY&t=1440s

With new one, they did couple of things. Larger area to be selected for landing based on camera input. Escape sequence to more achievable points, if something like this happens again. They increased the tolerance from 10 degrees to 25 degrees and guessing fixed the bug in code. They also did some smoothening of the trajectory for different phases to make it more continuous. I think they also made other changes in engines among other things and a whole host of testing.

Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by publicola1990 on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @12:33PM (#37238571)
Also did they use image processing to guide the landing this time? American and Chinese probes seems to use it to do the final phase of soft landing.
Re:Live telecast of Chandrayaan-3 Soft-landing by perryizgr8 on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @01:18PM (#37239187)
They have to, don't they? There's no other way.