News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Radiation Spikes at Chernobyl: A Mystery Few Seem Interes... by dylan604 on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:07PM (#37183297)
Being from the West, it is very difficult to think that information black out can be achieved at such a level that younger generations would know nothing of a disaster on the level of Chernobyl.
Re:Radiation Spikes at Chernobyl: A Mystery Few Seem Interes... by cafard on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:30PM (#37183529)
How many Americans, younger or not, would raise an eyebrow if invited to go camping around Hanford? The Russian soldiers might have heard about Chernobyl, but had no idea a) that they were there or b) how far the contaminated zones extended.
Re:Radiation Spikes at Chernobyl: A Mystery Few Seem Interes... by eindiran on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:40PM (#37183622)
I tend to agree with your overall point, but the comparison is not a particularly good one; you are comparing knowledge of a black site decommissioned in the 1960s to one of the most famous events in human history.
Re:Radiation Spikes at Chernobyl: A Mystery Few Seem Interes... by jychang on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:51PM (#37183726)
I think "most famous events in human history" is probably overstating it, and even then it wouldn't be well known anyways.

Outside of the HN bubble, the average 18 year old person (even in america, as opposed to russians) would not be very informed about Chernobyl. I'd say Chernobyl is a lot less famous than WWII or 9/11 or events of that sort.

And even for big historical events... if you go to a Taylor Swift concert and asked the people there about it, 50% would probably have no clue about most historical events. For example, my 24 year old younger sister doesn't know what a floppy disk is, or what the Berlin wall is. I'd bet you can take any regiment of fresh 18 year old US Marines and tell them they're doing military exercises in Pripyat and they'll mostly ask if there's going to be air conditioning or if there are hot girls around.

Re:Radiation Spikes at Chernobyl: A Mystery Few Seem Interes... by sbierwagen on Friday August 18, 2023 @09:09PM (#37184357)
Around the time the Shuttle program was ending, I made a casual reference to Soyuz to a Russian national. "Huh? «Union?»" No man. Soyuz, the space rocket. Literally the only way to get to the ISS right now. Your country's manned space program. That Soyuz? "If you say so."

Amazing they even kept it going! We've over here twisting ourselves in knots in embarrassment that we let our only spaceflight system sunset and are reduced to begging rides from Putin, but his citizens don't even notice.

Re:Radiation Spikes at Chernobyl: A Mystery Few Seem Interes... by dylan604 on Friday August 18, 2023 @09:58PM (#37184694)
Would they know who Yuri Gagarin was? I would assume they would teach that a Russian was the first person in space while at the same time ignoring embarrassing things like Chernobyl in the classes. Just like I'd assume that they teach defeating Hitler, but ignoring the things Stalin did.
Re:Radiation Spikes at Chernobyl: A Mystery Few Seem Interes... by yakshaving_jgt on Saturday August 19, 2023 @12:43AM (#37185588)
Yes, they definitely know who Gagarin was, but that’s because that knowledge is a useful tool to further entrench a deep sense of chauvinism in russia.
Re:Radiation Spikes at Chernobyl: A Mystery Few Seem Interes... by mmasu on Friday August 18, 2023 @09:45PM (#37184616)
I think what you say is overall plausible, however in western Europe many more people would know what happened in Chernobyl. To be frank I am not sure that would be the case in Russia tho, and even more so in the cohorts of young soldiers that camped close by.
Re:Radiation Spikes at Chernobyl: A Mystery Few Seem Interes... by drewcoo on Friday August 18, 2023 @09:23PM (#37184457)
> a black site decommissioned in the 1960s

That's a bit dismissive for possibly the most radioactively contaminated area in the western hemisphere.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanford_Site

https://thatoregonlife.com/2021/10/hanford-washington-nuclea...

Re:Radiation Spikes at Chernobyl: A Mystery Few Seem Interes... by genocidicbunny on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:44PM (#37183654)
A lot of the soldiers are also just barely in their 20's. Many come from very impoverished areas of Russia where access to independent sources of information is very limited (no independent local media, western media hard to access without decent access to the internet) and education has long been eviscerated to serve the needs of the state. Their parents are also not likely to be good sources of information as they are similarly little-informed.

They might literally have never heard of Chernobyl even as a place until they were deployed there.

Much could be said about things that Russia is bad at, but disinformation, propaganda and revisionism are not those things. They're really good at those. And they've been good at those things for a really long time -- multiple generations.

Re:Radiation Spikes at Chernobyl: A Mystery Few Seem Interes... by basementcat on Friday August 18, 2023 @09:26PM (#37184495)
The US National Park Service hosts free tours to the B Reactor at Hanford! https://manhattanprojectbreactor.hanford.gov/
Re:Radiation Spikes at Chernobyl: A Mystery Few Seem Interes... by cf141q5325 on Friday August 18, 2023 @10:01PM (#37184717)
You could(/can?) also travel the exclusion zone as a tourist. Including to one of the excavator claws where the adventurous couch warriors are able to test their meter and make selfies.

The even dumber are getting smuggled in for illegal tours. Meaning you get somebody who knows the area and run past the patrols and sleep in the ruins. Quite stupid but there is youtube. They are also coming after the people who stole all the scrap metal.

Chernobyl is also not the only place, people also visit abandoned cold war bunkers which can look quite amazing. But are also often heavily contaminated and off limits to the public.

Some examples are at @ExploringtheUnbeatenPath (NATO command bunker) and @shiey (Chernobyl) on youtube. Legal options are already quite nice and dont give you too much cancer. In Russia you will also go to Prison for a very long time when caught climbing a derelict antenna, let alone visiting bunkers. If i recall they got very annoyed when Russian teens climbed all the Stalin towers.

Re:Radiation Spikes at Chernobyl: A Mystery Few Seem Interes... by rewmie on Saturday August 19, 2023 @08:38AM (#37188161)
> How many Americans, younger or not, would raise an eyebrow if invited to go camping around Hanford?

You're grossly misrepresenting the facts. The Russians who were digging trenches in Chernobyl were a part of a full blown invasion force directly organized by Russia's regime from the very top. Russia's plan to invade Ukraine and dig in and around Chernobyl was specified from the very top of the chain of command, and enforced throughout the whole chain of command way down into individual orders sent to the Russian grunts in the ground.

These were no average randos who just felt compelled to dig a hole in a camp site.

It's entirely absurd to pretend that Russia's top echelons were oblivious to Chernobyl, and it's outright stupid to misrepresent a full blown invasion force executing battle plans as random people camping somewhere who just felt like digging a hole.

Re:Radiation Spikes at Chernobyl: A Mystery Few Seem Interes... by failuser on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:23PM (#37183447)
Between Stalker and Call of Duty they probably know at least something. And documentaries about Chernobyl were common on Russian TV.
[dead]
Re:Radiation Spikes at Chernobyl: A Mystery Few Seem Interes... by dylan604 on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:20PM (#37183418)
It's funny, my comment originally went in more depth specifically calling out how nobody in the US younger generations would know about 3 Mile Island, but decided to edit it back. To me, to even equate 3 Mile Island to Chernobyl isn't even in the realm of sane. What's the exclusion zone around 3 Mile Island? Exactly.

My bet would be future generations in Japan will be very aware of Fukushima. Stipulating that Russians knowing about things in Ukraine is totally different than the Japanese knowing about things in their backyard.

Re:Radiation Spikes at Chernobyl: A Mystery Few Seem Interes... by vkou on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:12PM (#37183346)
3 mile island was a nothingburger, though.
Re:Radiation Spikes at Chernobyl: A Mystery Few Seem Interes... by failuser on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:21PM (#37183428)
Core meltdown is never a nothing burger. The containment vessel worked though, so at least the engineering was sound.
Re:Radiation Spikes at Chernobyl: A Mystery Few Seem Interes... by KerrAvon on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:23PM (#37183449)
Revisionist bullshit. It was bad enough to cause the reactor to be removed from service permanently.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_Mile_Island_accident

Re:Radiation Spikes at Chernobyl: A Mystery Few Seem Interes... by hnaccount141 on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:24PM (#37183459)
Perhaps Castle Bravo would be a closer comparison? I think the point stands.
Re:Radiation Spikes at Chernobyl: A Mystery Few Seem Interes... by cf141q5325 on Friday August 18, 2023 @08:09PM (#37183914)
You dont really need a blackout. How many people can actually tell you the size and location of the contamination? Even the official limits of the exclusion zone are nonsense dating back to Soviet Bureaucracy. Wind meant there are contaminated areas outside and harmless areas inside. Also like the article stated, they are unlikely to have experienced any negative impact themselves.

Also, the Greenpeace statement mentions fires, which are a far far better explanation for a spike in measurements. https://www.greenpeace.org/international/press-release/54762...

They also have pictures and mention the Russian camp was at "Stantzaya Yanov" which i cant find a reference to outside of the Greenpeace report. But i would suspect that wouldnt be directly in front of the very visible sarcophagus.

edit: Maps in the report https://www.greenpeace.de/publikationen/20220718-greenpeace-... Page 6 says the camp was 26km from the plant.

edit1: Estimates from https://essd.copernicus.org/articles/10/339/2018/

https://essd.copernicus.org/articles/10/339/2018/essd-10-339... with longitude and latitude and Greenpeace puts the camp at 51.1663, 29.9645 SSW of the reactor. Which would put it in a safe area. Meaning they were right to be not worried if the trenches were at the camp.

Re:Radiation Spikes at Chernobyl: A Mystery Few Seem Interes... by ClumsyPilot on Friday August 18, 2023 @08:54PM (#37184242)
exactly, I know the pyramids exist, but would you actually fund them on google maps without using the search bar?
Re:Radiation Spikes at Chernobyl: A Mystery Few Seem Interes... by grogenaut on Friday August 18, 2023 @09:16PM (#37184401)
https://www.google.com/maps/@29.9717687,31.1322225,620m/data...

I knew they were outside of cairo, which means close to the river generally. and was just going to walk the nile but "sphinx cafe" showed up when I got close. You can seem the ok from sattelite view no the top right half.

I was just going to look for giza but I found them before I saw giza pop up. I didn't search I scrolled from north america.

Re:Radiation Spikes at Chernobyl: A Mystery Few Seem Interes... by dylan604 on Friday August 18, 2023 @09:52PM (#37184657)
it's not they are small and hiding from you either. i would have suggested similar to your approach to follow the river. as you approach, you will see them.
Re:Radiation Spikes at Chernobyl: A Mystery Few Seem Interes... by grogenaut on Saturday August 19, 2023 @02:05PM (#37191425)
I wonder if just street viewing down the river would lead you to them
Re:Radiation Spikes at Chernobyl: A Mystery Few Seem Interes... by cf141q5325 on Friday August 18, 2023 @09:01PM (#37184302)
You can tell by the signs.

The point is the camp site was fine from a health and safety perspective. There are more heavily contaminated areas outside and it saw little impact due to the weather back then.

Which leaves either damage to roads that might not have seen much use before (doubtful, they have police driving around to catch real life Stalkers), lost Russians or the fires Greenpeace mentioned.

Some context for the heightened readings would be nice. Especially in comparison to the fires in March and 2020. They seem to be an obvious cause.

edit: Vehicle impact sounds quite likely https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/unprotected-russian-sol...

Maybe dont drive tanks through the red forest.

Re:Radiation Spikes at Chernobyl: A Mystery Few Seem Interes... by arcticbull on Saturday August 19, 2023 @01:07AM (#37185710)
How about Semipalatinsk in Kazakhstan? Atomic Lake? Hundreds of nuclear weapons tested all over the steppe - and open to the public. If you were an American soldier deployed there would you have a single clue you shouldn’t be digging near Opytnoe Pole? Or avoid catching fish from Lake Chagan?

Or a Russian soldier deployed at the Nevada test site?

I think not knowing is quite plausible.

Re:Radiation Spikes at Chernobyl: A Mystery Few Seem Interes... by oceanplexian on Friday August 18, 2023 @10:06PM (#37184756)
If you’re posting here, you probably have some degree of bias.

Of course the millennial crowd interested in engineering is going to know about Chernobyl. But if you ask the average Gen Z not associated with tech or engineering, I bet they’d have no idea.

Re:Radiation Spikes at Chernobyl: A Mystery Few Seem Interes... by DoreenMichele on Friday August 18, 2023 @10:27PM (#37184886)
How much do you know about The Red Scare in the US? I'm American and barely know anything about it.

It's just not really talked about and not, as far as I know, due to fear of being imprisoned for it.

Ugly history is often "forgotten" even when there is no compulsion to "forget" it.

Re:Radiation Spikes at Chernobyl: A Mystery Few Seem Interes... by craftkiller on Saturday August 19, 2023 @02:23AM (#37186102)
I'm also American and The Red Scare was taught in my high school. That being said, the Battle of Blair Mountain, the Tulsa Race Massacre, and the MOVE bombing were left out of my curriculum.
Re:Radiation Spikes at Chernobyl: A Mystery Few Seem Interes... by DoreenMichele on Saturday August 19, 2023 @04:01AM (#37186599)
And there can be other distracting factors. The biggest massacre of Native Americans in what eventually became the Continental US is largely forgotten by the modern US in part because it occurred during the Civil War at a time when there was no TV, internet, etc.

The date: 29 January 1863.

It gets remembered by various names and various sources give different counts for how many died. Wikipedia says 250 Natives were killed. Other sources say closer to 500.

https://boaogoi.org/

Re:Radiation Spikes at Chernobyl: A Mystery Few Seem Interes... by Moldoteck on Saturday August 19, 2023 @01:09AM (#37185718)
You are too optimistic about Russian education system in poor regions.

Even ignoring tons of corruption and the fact that many teenagers are skipping school to do house/agriculture/other work, consider the fact that those schools are severely underfunded and good teachers migrated long time ago for a better life to bigger cities and even if they have internet, that doesn't meen the information they consume is educational type. I've seen some similar regions when I've visited Russia when I was in school and it looked depressing and I've only visited a bit of west part. The eastern russia is has much bigger problems in this regard, aside mybe from big cities.

And that's just abt education, other comments abt how soldiers maybe didn't know where they are or were thinking that all Chernobyl is a thing of past may be also true