News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by eternityforest on Thursday August 17, 2023 @09:25PM (#37170456)
Why did they have to use a micro HDMI port? Couldn't they have done dual USB-C and made one the DisplayPort output? MicroHDMI is not a very nice connector, it's a lot of pins under mechanical stress from the heavy, rigid HDMI people generally attach to it.
Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by paxys on Thursday August 17, 2023 @09:40PM (#37170549)
And it already has dual USB-C, just without video out support. Pretty disappointing.
Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by lelanthran on Friday August 18, 2023 @12:26AM (#37171399)
I also scrolled down to look for this (in the market for a low-power long-lasting laptop that will be 99% docked).

I might get one anyway, if they ship to SA. At least micro HMDI is still dockable.

(Just out of curiosity - does anyone know of any other option to use an external display with this tablet? Are wireless displays a thing?)

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by chx on Friday August 18, 2023 @02:01AM (#37171816)
It has DP alt mode support you need to click the big + on https://us.starlabs.systems/pages/starlite-specification next to connectivity
Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by jauntywundrkind on Thursday August 17, 2023 @09:31PM (#37170493)
DisplayPort has the huge advantage of being incredibly easy to passively convert into the ultra-legacy-weird-difficult HDMI, where-as the legacy-centric-pita-gross HDMI requires active absurd adapters to turn into DisplayPort.

100% more usb-c please, with alt modes. USB4 mandates every port be able to do DisplayPort output.

I really hope we start to see phones and tablets which have >1 USB port. Lenovo has an absurd beast phone, a Legion phone, with both dual batteries and dual USB-c (USB3) ports. If we get to 2030 and phones can't plug in to GPUs something is f-ed and the system is broken, tech has ossified grossly. Hopefully happens sooner, and hopefully we see dual ports emerge midway to then too. Would be such a great capability set.

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by afavour on Thursday August 17, 2023 @11:25PM (#37171112)
> If we get to 2030 and phones can't plug in to GPUs something is f-ed and the system is broken, tech has ossified grossly.

Why? That’s an incredibly minor use case. If you’re expecting something this niche to become the norm then you’re destined to be disappointed.

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by mcny on Thursday August 17, 2023 @11:45PM (#37171194)
We had USB 3 with the Samsung Galaxy Note 3 in September 2013. It is now almost a decade. If rumors are true, Samsung will announce a USB 4 (thunderbolt 3) phone before the end of 2024. I agree with the grandparent. While most people don't care too much for eGPU (?), I'm sure if we let people innovate, good things will come.

My dream is much smaller. I just want whatever hardware circuitry is required to accomplish the scenario where a phone that is plugged in to a good power source runs directly from the wall, shutting off battery charge completely, not trickle charging all day and night.

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by eternityforest on Friday August 18, 2023 @01:05AM (#37171546)
Pretty sure most any phone already has the hardware for software defined charging. Android just doesn't have an API call for it, unless they do and I just haven't heard yet.

Maybe we should be filing feature requests for it;

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by RF_Savage on Friday August 18, 2023 @01:18AM (#37171611)
One of the tragedies of USB-C is how it can be anything from dumb charging only to one's capable of 40GB/s data transfer among everything else.
Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by LoganDark on Friday August 18, 2023 @02:09AM (#37171880)
This. People can get away with implementing really, really bad USB-C ports and you're just supposed to expect that no two USB-C ports are born equal.
Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by hgomersall on Friday August 18, 2023 @03:31AM (#37172371)
It makes working out which hole to plug something in to rather tricky. Especially when the little lightning bolt or other graphics have rubbed off.
Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by lproven on Friday August 18, 2023 @06:30AM (#37173738)
Seconded.

And even before then.

I have an M1 Macbook Air which will only output video over one of its 2 USB-C ports, not the other. There is nothing visible on the case or in the OS to indicate this.

I have had an Arm and an AMD Thinkpad which both have only dual USB-C, and both unpredictably switch between one or the other being bootable, with no discenable pattern.

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by lloeki on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:06AM (#37174029)
> I have an M1 Macbook Air which will only output video over one of its 2 USB-C ports, not the other.

Weird, ever since I had USB-C based Mac Mini or MacBook (two Intel, two M1) they could reliably output video on any of the two, three, or four ports (as long as I don't go past the limit). They're essentially symmetric on all features.

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by jauntywundrkind on Saturday August 19, 2023 @12:21AM (#37185480)
USB4 mandates 40GBps. It mandates DisplayPort. These would be pretty helpful baselines to expect, reasons for consumers to want USB4: they know it will be fairly featureful.

PCIe transport ("Thunderbolt") and Power Delivery are both optional though, I think.

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by contrarian1234 on Friday August 18, 2023 @01:24AM (#37171635)
My Lenovo Y700 does passthrough power. It also has a mode where it only starts charging if the battery is below 40% and it'll stop at 60%

Unfortunately its not a phone. Its a mini tablet. But I find the size ideal for daily use - browsing,reading pdfs, small sketches . (no SIM slot though)

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by RetroTechie on Friday August 18, 2023 @04:18AM (#37172712)
> It also has a mode where it only starts charging if the battery is below 40% and it'll stop at 60%

Wish every battery powered device would have a setting for this.

As opposed to always charging when charger is plugged in, and always charging up to 100% (non-configurable).

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by jauntywundrkind on Saturday August 19, 2023 @12:17AM (#37185458)
My sample size isn't big, but on Linux every laptop I've seen has amazing battery reporting information galore. Oh sure battery level. And various assessments of wear. Things like realtime charge or discharge rates.

But more notably, I think around half also have charge control. It's just been on/off. But it would be a pretty basic bash script to make this happen.

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by contrarian1234 on Saturday August 19, 2023 @05:35AM (#37187050)
I have a Huawei Mate book 16 and under KDE (Ubuntu) I can set a charge limit in the energy settings

But it depends on the laptop. From what I understand not all laptops have the drivers for power control ie. the ability to from-software tell the laptop to stop charging

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by MikusR on Friday August 18, 2023 @02:05AM (#37171846)
And it was so bad they went back to microusb on 4
Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by ewoodrich on Friday August 18, 2023 @11:47AM (#37177295)
All Galaxy S models were Micro USB until they switched to USB-C on the S8 series.
Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by MikusR on Saturday August 19, 2023 @07:38AM (#37187741)
I was talking about Note 4. And Galaxy S5 had usb3
Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by jauntywundrkind on Friday August 18, 2023 @12:05AM (#37171291)
You may be onto something, as Lenovo shut down the super-badass ultra-phone. https://www.androidauthority.com/lenovo-legion-phone-shutdow...

But reciprocally, what's the new ultra-hot device? Gaming decks. Lenovo just announced theirs today. Steam, Asus, and dozen of others have amazing devices. And there are still gaming-centric phones galore.

This should be an easy ask. It should be a lock. Android alas is kind of a weird divergent hard to use OS that makes everything difficult. Apple hasn't supported anyone elses GPUs in a long long time. But in general, this should just be easy simple & doable, were it not for the sins of these ultra-bizarre weird not-PC but so close systems. ChromeOS finally found jesus & is now running on Wayland, because it was obviously the correct & only sensible choice all along, And has huge advantages, such as having a huge world of people optimizing & making the system better. I don't know how Android ever pivots (they just steal everything ChromeOS (which runs Android great) is doing), but it should, so that it can make ideas like this unimaginably easy & simple tasks, versus today where this sort of idea is a painstaking slow & awful endeavor to make happen.

So much of computing is a story of niche finding leverage & finding adherents. The early adopters are just those who see potential, and they continually have reshaped what computing is. Writing off "niche" as uninteresting & minor ignores how sensible & clear & obvious so many advancements are & should be.

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by eternityforest on Friday August 18, 2023 @01:08AM (#37171556)
I wish Android and Linux would just merge. Give people access to a Linux userland that lets you install Nix packages(Most anything but Nix or similar would be a step backwards from Android's reliability during updates), and then Android could very easily be most people's only OS.

If people could plug in their phone and run Linux apps on a full size monitor they'd probably pay a lot more for the phone, knowing they didn't then also need a nice laptop.

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by pmontra on Friday August 18, 2023 @01:41AM (#37171710)
The general population only need to run a browser on their external monitor, with Office 365 or Google Docs and Gmail. There is no need for anything else. If one is not a software developer, which Linux apps do you feel are needed?

I used Samsung DEX a few times on my tablet. The mouse plus touchscreen combination works well. The keyboard is a little worse because there is no Esc key on Android and Ctrl [ is uncomfortable.

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by eternityforest on Sunday August 20, 2023 @02:11AM (#37196621)
Gimp/Krita, FreeCAD, more and more games, Inkscape, Ardour, Audacity, Calibre, Sound Converter, Converseen, PrusaSlicer, etc, plus all the other stuff that people would probably discover.

If one IS a software developer of course, then you probably need a lot of Linux apps, and it would be cool to have them alongside a platform that's way more reliable than Linux, so that your browser and email and calendar and music are always there and don't bog down.

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by silon42 on Friday August 18, 2023 @05:44AM (#37173329)
So, maybe AOSP should become another Linux desktop?
Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by pjerem on Friday August 18, 2023 @04:39AM (#37172845)
Because that’s what standards are for : a single base of universal rules that allows you to build what you want over it.

The point is not that phones should be connected to GPUs, that’s a silly idea.

But nevertheless for plenty of reasons including ecology and autonomy of people, it should be the case that any device should work with any other device as long as anyone is able to develop a driver. And there should be no permanent lock against custom drivers.

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by nimish on Friday August 18, 2023 @12:36AM (#37171441)
DP can only be passively converted to HDMI if the source uses DisplayPort++/Dual Mode, which is not supported by the DisplayPort Alt Mode over USB-C spec (Why? Who knows).

Every usb-c to HDMI adapter has to actively convert the signals which is why one end is usually much larger than the other.

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by eternityforest on Friday August 18, 2023 @01:12AM (#37171574)
Isn't there not enough pins for that? Plus, it would just be needless extra hassle, when their goal is to just not have HDMI at all eventually.
Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by yyyk on Friday August 18, 2023 @01:30AM (#37171665)
>I really hope we start to see phones and tablets which have >1 USB port

We're much more likely to get phones with 0 USB ports (justified by 'security', 'water proofness' or 'simplicity') where the only charging is wireless.

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by smcleod on Friday August 18, 2023 @12:21AM (#37171373)
I haven't seen one of those in many many years! I wish HDMI in general would die and let displayport take it place.
Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by karmakaze on Friday August 18, 2023 @12:41AM (#37171467)
What's the practical difference? With USB-C there's power delivery. DisplayPort has..?
Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by smcleod on Friday August 18, 2023 @12:48AM (#37171496)
USB-C is the connector / cable, DisplayPort is one protocol that can run within such a cable. HDMI (a proprietary licensed protocol) can also. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DisplayPort#Comparison_with_HD...
Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by chx on Friday August 18, 2023 @02:00AM (#37171809)
DisplayPort has MST.
Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by vladvasiliu on Friday August 18, 2023 @03:32AM (#37172386)
> DisplayPort has..?

Consistently good colors. Sometimes even PC monitors won't negotiate properly with the PC and start displaying washed out colors. IIRC this had to be forced on a Raspberry Pi on the PI side. Not all monitors can be adjusted.

Consistently no under/overscan. For some reason, the TVs we had in conference rooms figured it would be smart to cut the borders of the image and zoom in, so you get missing bits and whatever's left is a blurry mess.

For the TV situation, you usually don't have a full remote to adjust it, if it even supports that. You often don't have time to look up things in the TV's typically crappy menu system. I've usually found the option to disable over scan, but using full-range RGB seems less common.

Also, HDMI seems to lag DisplayPort capabilities when it comes to higher resolutions and refresh rates. When my 2013 MBP came out, it could drive a 4k@60 screen over DP. HDMI required the 2.0 version to do that, which, IIRC, came much later.

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by ThatPlayer on Friday August 18, 2023 @04:29AM (#37172775)
>Also, HDMI seems to lag DisplayPort capabilities when it comes to higher resolutions and refresh rates.

I think that one very much depends on when you chose to look at it. HDMI 2.1 has more bandwidth than DisplayPort 1.4, enough to do 4k@120 which DP1.4 wouldn't be able to do it without dropping color down to 4:2:0. DisplayPort 2.0 devices are starting to come out, but even Nvidia's RTX 4000 series still do not have DisplayPort 2.0 (but do have HDMI 2.1). While TV started supporting HDMI 2.1 around 2019, with the PS5 and Xbox Series X having HDMI 2.1 ports.

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by vladvasiliu on Friday August 18, 2023 @05:25AM (#37173183)
That's a fair point. I admit I was judging by the availability on the PC side (I don't follow the console market).

Although, if I'm not mistaken, my particular PC monitor initially didn't support HDMI 2.0, even though it's a 4k panel. There was a further revision which included it. I have that revision, but support is still somewhat wonky, in that it can't seem to switch on its own from 2.0 to 1.4b.

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by ThatPlayer on Friday August 18, 2023 @04:49PM (#37181917)
Display support is always last in this chicken-and-egg problem. As far as I know, there's still no DisplayPort 2.0 supporting displays, so any of the higher end monitors require display stream compression. I can't even get a DisplayPort 2.0 MST hub so I can chain multiple 1440p@144 monitors. Which is definitely something that HDMI can't do.
Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by karmakaze on Friday August 18, 2023 @09:29AM (#37175339)
Ok so that sounds like DP has better negotiation protocol spec and/or implementations.

I've only encountered overscan on TVs not monitors, but I don't give conference room presentations, which would be very annoying. On Macs there compensation for that.

I've had trouble with colors where it uses YPbPr rather than RGB, but that seems to be an Apple thing where it's done on purpose for non-Apple-approved displays and it happens for both HDMI and DP. Generating a custom EDID profile fixes that. Can't recall having trouble with color range, sometimes the display has a setting but the default always looked better to me.

I've used 4k@60 HDMI just fine (and 4k@30 on an early Apple adapter), but more often use 1080p anyway. I use USB-C with my 4k displays which likely runs DP on them.

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by vladvasiliu on Friday August 18, 2023 @09:47AM (#37175554)
> Ok so that sounds like DP has better negotiation protocol spec and/or implementations.

Right. So... DP is better than HDMI?

The color issue I had was not with a Mac but with an HP laptop on an HP monitor. My understanding is that there's something about "broadcast colors" or something, which is "regular" RGB only with a narrower range. I think the PC thought the monitor was a TV with a limited range, which the monitor was not.

With the TVs I plug into, it's usually harder to judge since their color rendition tends to be all over the place anyway and tend to have the reverse issue (too much contrast).

I remember the overscan control on the mac, but it still was a PITA to have to fiddle with that instead of, you know, just plugging the screen in and being in business.

While I've also had numerous positive experiences with HDMI where things seemingly "just worked", I've never had an issue with DP. It always worked. Hell, even my gaming GPU, which came out a while after HDMI 2, and supported it out of the box, connected to my monitor with full HDMI 2 support, still has weird colors compared to DP. No tweaking in the AMD drivers managed to get me the proper output, so I went and bought a cheap Chinese DP KVM instead. Which worked with no fuss.

All this makes me automatically pick DP if given the choice, and discount any computer or screen that only does HDMI. Which makes it pretty tough to buy a TV, so I just watch movies on my computer monitor.

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by smcleod on Friday August 18, 2023 @09:43AM (#37175510)
Yeah totally agree - I’ve had quite a few situations where a monitor or tv looks blurry and washed out with HDMI and it’s immediately fixed with a DP cable.
Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by cirelli94 on Friday August 18, 2023 @06:09AM (#37173564)
I've read this article from HN about it: https://hackaday.com/2023/07/11/displayport-a-better-video-i... It's video done right!
Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by rollcat on Friday August 18, 2023 @10:22AM (#37176031)
> I wish HDMI in general would die and let displayport take it place.

That would be an interesting thing for the video production industry. Basically the entire market is divided between "professional" equipment, in which SDI continues to dominate (with some movement towards SMPTE 2110 aka IP), and "amateur" equipment which is all HDMI - with very few products on the boundary and supporting both connectors.

Consumer grade digital cameras have only recently (10 years, maybe less) started being able to output the live video feed over HDMI. Before that, believe me or not I've stumbled upon MANY camera models from 2013 or before that had an HDMI port, but all it was good for was displaying pictures from the memory card on a TV.

It would certainly make life easier in a lot of "small streamer" setups. Currently, if you don't want to torture your camera's battery, you need to get a silly (often third-party) "dummy battery" that you can (hopefully!) plug into an ordinary USB power supply; and on top of that, a separate mini/micro HDMI -> full HDMI cable to plug into a capture card. If you could reduce that to a single USB-C with PD and DP - trust me, every silly cable you can eliminate from your setup is an enormous win.

Even better, if these cameras could talk the regular USB "webcam" protocol in addition to DP, eliminating the capture card for the overwhelmingly common setup of "I just want to look very good on video calls".

But that opens a can of worms: in any non-trivial setup, a camera (one camera) is merely a small piece of a much more elaborate puzzle. Even seemingly simple setups end up converting the signal back&forth between some crazy stuff. On one job, we needed to run an SDI or HDMI cable between the floors, but couldn't do either because the building was untouchable; so we've used a couple of HDMI -> HDBaseT converters to run the signal over existing Ethernet cables. Turns out, it was no longer possible to convert the resulting HDMI signal again to SDI (we've tried many converters, all failed), which limited our choice of video mixers. Would the signal make it through if it originated as DP? Your guess is as good as mine.

Broadcast is a strange place. I still laugh whenever I think of Quad-SDI; only the broadcast industry could ever come up with that. Things need to work with one another and even if every single person in the world agreed that HDMI must die, starting today, I'm fairly certain we'd still see new equipment being made in 2033 that supports it.

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by Thews on Friday August 18, 2023 @03:36PM (#37180996)
I have spent the last few months doing a deep dive on broadcast / audio engineer standards. The lack of reliability and strange standards are interesting...

It seems like the last few standards started really robust and open because of the lack of compatibility, and then greed got involved and vendors just slipped in something to make it difficult cross connect. I assume so people would have to buy more of their stuff.

The focus on "realtime" makes the standards have worse quality in practice (bad handling of dropped or bad bits), and makes it much harder for the IP based standards to be routed (network congestion from high bitrate through uplinks). WebRTC by comparison can be quite nice.

I seriously don't have any hope for sanity in that market.

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by MichaelZuo on Friday August 18, 2023 @12:48AM (#37171492)
Probably due to cheapening out a few dollars on the BOM, not a great sign to be honest.
Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by chx on Friday August 18, 2023 @02:02AM (#37171825)
Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by askbookz1 on Friday August 18, 2023 @08:38AM (#37174822)
doesn't explain the mini hdmi port
Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by mike_hock on Friday August 18, 2023 @09:28AM (#37175321)
But not cheapening out on pixels that you can't even see with a magnifying glass. 1920p on 12.5 inches, lol.
Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by RF_Savage on Friday August 18, 2023 @01:12AM (#37171576)
USB-C DisplayPort altmode would have required one to two extra chips for the port supporting it and some extra routing on the PCB.

So cost and complexity increase. MicroHDMI does suck, but despite that raspberry pi 4 has two of them.

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by eternityforest on Friday August 18, 2023 @01:15AM (#37171596)
The Pi also put a nasty old microUSB on the Pi Pico so I'm not surprised they used a crappy connector, when there's way less reason to still use MicroUSB.

They're a great company but MicroUSB? Really?

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by RF_Savage on Friday August 18, 2023 @01:28AM (#37171658)
At the time Pi Pico came out MicroUSB connectors were around ten times cheaper than USB-C. Now it has dropped to 2 - 4 times cheaper. In volume those differences do matter.
Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by chx on Friday August 18, 2023 @02:02AM (#37171824)
Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by ryantse on Friday August 18, 2023 @01:26AM (#37171646)
From <https://us.starlabs.systems/pages/starlite-specification>:

  Micro HDMI
  USB Type C 3.2 with Power Delivery 3.0
  USB Type C 3.2 with Power Delivery 3.0
  Micro SD Memory Card Reader
  3.5mm Headphone Jack
  HDMI version: 2.0
  USB-C Interface: Display Port (DP Alt Mode)
  USB version: 3.2 Gen 2 (up to 10 Gbps)
Maybe I am missing something, but it seems to have Display Port for their USB-C?
Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by eternityforest on Friday August 18, 2023 @02:15AM (#37171914)
Oh nice! That makes it a lot more interesting
Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by predictabl3 on Friday August 18, 2023 @05:31PM (#37182408)
It's very odd that their 12-port dock also shows a DP port in the image, but it's not listed in the specs.

But the 2x HDMI are visible + listed. :(

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by chx on Friday August 18, 2023 @02:02AM (#37171823)
Click the big plus on https://us.starlabs.systems/pages/starlite-specification next to connectivity to see

> USB-C Interface: Display Port (DP Alt Mode)

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by MichaelZuo on Friday August 18, 2023 @08:38AM (#37174821)
There's 2 USB-C ports but it's worded so that possibly only 1 port could support DP out. So even considering just the USB-C ports, there is a likelihood they cheaped out somewhat.

Did you assume it definitely will support DP out for both?

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by dheera on Friday August 18, 2023 @04:03AM (#37172605)
USB-C is equally bad. I really wish they would have the rubber housing of the USB-C go inside the case like an IEC power connector. I break about a USB-C cable every week. Broke one today just by putting it in my backpack while connected to a power brick.

Power bricks of the 1990s didn't have this problem. The barrel connectors were almost indestructible. You could drop bricks on VGA connectors and they'd still work.

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by lproven on Friday August 18, 2023 @06:32AM (#37173754)
Wow.

I have never yet broken a USB-C cable. Not one.

When I used an iPhone for a couple of years, I went through approximately a Lightning cable per month, sometimes more. At one point I took a carrier bag of broken Lightning cables to the electronics recycling.

You must treat equipment exceptionally roughly.

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by lloeki on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:10AM (#37174073)
I am full USB-C. I have a kid. Mine are treated very roughly. Not a single one ever broke. Comparatively, microusb has died on me quite a lot from regular usage, and always on the device side, which is so much worse.

(Now the cat chewing on cables in another matter xD)

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by kimbernator on Friday August 18, 2023 @10:43AM (#37176342)
Yeah, I've never once seen a USB-C cable break in that the physical connector itself was damaged. I've been through plenty that just seem to stop reliably connecting if they are in high-motion environments (the cable connecting my phone to my car's entertainment system, for instance)

I will say that I really wish they had managed to not have that middle section sticking up in the female connectors - cleaning out my phone's USB-C port is about 20x harder than cleaning out a lighting port because I feel like I'm going to break that little thing in the middle.

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by dheera on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:30PM (#37183531)
No, I treat equipment as any consumer would.

Like if my phone is low on battery I plug it into a portable battery and shove the phone and portable battery (connected by a USB-C cable) into my pocket, like any consumer would. I then go hiking, snowshoeing, biking, sleeping, like any consumer would. Cables have bent and broken in my pocket in these scenarios, among thousands of others.

My parent comment was yesterday; today's USB-C cable broke when it got stuck in an office chair's wheel caster, bending the sheet metal housing. Thi doesn't happen with ANY connector of the 1990s. BNC, RCA, DB-9, 1/8" headphone jacks, 5.5x2.5 barrel connectors, they ALL withstood office chair crushing and were all probably designed with consumer abuse like office chairs in mind.

I've even run over DB-9 and BNC connectors with heavy duty carts, they were fine.

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by eternityforest on Saturday August 19, 2023 @02:31PM (#37191664)
That sounds like a lot more active life than an average consumer. It would be nice if USB C could handle that kind of duty, but for most people, the 1/8 and RCA, or at least the cheap versions, might die of fatigue before the USB C has an issue. I remember non-pro audio cables as being insanely unreliable, like, you could break them in a week of light use.

USB C doesn't have that issue. There are high end cables and just kind of OK cables, but at least with the braided ones I normally buy, there aren't many terrible ones at any price. They decoupled reliability from craftsmanship and materials.

Pockets should be considered industrial duty environments.

Right next to a person is a much harsher environment than people think it is, stuff people carry tends to break and wear.

I'm not surprised the cables break in pockets in that kind of scenario, although I haven't experienced it myself with my admittedly much lighter and less varied lifestyle (lots of walking, occasional hiking, maintenance work sometimes including light carpentry, but no sports or biking).

There seems to be a very large variance in percieved reliability of cables and tech in general. Are you buying the same brand every time you need to replace something? Do more athletic people with more muscle have problems because their weight or level of force they commonly apply is more likely to break stuff? Probably just unrelated factors but it does seem like people who lift are more like to hate new tech. Is it about what clothes you wear? Is it the phone itself having something about the connector?

Obviously USB C has a problemwith a few specific environments, but I'm not exactly sure what those cases are.

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by kennydude on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:46AM (#37174371)
Barrel connectors I found always fail within 18 months for a lot of laptops I've known people buy (mostly from cheap brands such as Acer).

While not saying USB-C is a great choice instead. Personally I just wish everyone could have generic magnetic Magsafe style connectors.

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by jwells89 on Friday August 18, 2023 @09:13AM (#37175152)
Barrel connectors are easily one of my most disliked. Even if they don’t fail outright, they grow loose and finicky over time even if you’re trying to take care of them. On top of that, there’s numerous different sizes and pole configurations so even if an adapter is physically compatible, you have to look closely to make sure you’re not going to fry your device.

Just terrible overall.

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by dheera on Friday August 18, 2023 @07:31PM (#37183539)
So just agree on 5.5x2.5 and federally ban 5.5x2.1. The biggest source of finickiness is 5.5x2.5 plugged into a 5.5x2.1 socket.

Inventing a new standard with a weak sheet metal connector and 19 pins to deliver + and - isn't a solution to the above.

Re:New Linux Tablet from Star Labs by eternityforest on Saturday August 19, 2023 @01:55PM (#37191338)
Most new devices don't have enough space for 5.5x anything. And 2.1mm is the more common one from what I can see.

Regardless it's a crappy choice for consumer electronics because it's got no voltage negotiation. You can fry stuff with it, and chargers aren't universal.

2.1mm is a wonderful connector for switches, sensors, solar panels, and power you need to daisy chain, but PD is pretty much perfect for point to point medium power devices.

USBC seems to break far less often than anything else that's cheap and small. I don't see why 19 pins is an issue unless you just really like simplicity.

It absolutely looks like something that would fail all the time... But it doesn't. Somehow they made it so even the cheap knockoffs are durable.