News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by kevincox on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @08:22AM (#37145944)
I have to say that I hate that Nintendo makes great games, because the company is awful. They are very controlling (ex: you can only play on their hardware), very litigious, create trouble with legal things like emulation and overall aren't pleasant.

I no longer give them my money. I would rethink this if they made the games available for PC or something less open. But the more I hear the less likely I am to start buying anything they produce.

Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by WhyNotHugo on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @08:55AM (#37146332)
Yeah, Nintendo is an awful company. Unlike some other awful game companies, at least they create pretty good games.

But they really love trying to squeeze every cent and milking their customers to a point where it's disgusting.

My partner purchased a the latest Zelda and I can't even play it on my account on the same device: I need to buy another copy of the game (which obviously will never happen).

Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by kmeisthax on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @09:13AM (#37146559)
Your partner needs to change the home console on their account to the one you play on. Then you'll be able to play with different accounts.

Usually most people only have one Switch so this never is a problem. However, if you've switched consoles and you didn't do System Transfer, you need to manually switch over the home console in order to get your offline play rights back.

Alternatively your partner may have explicitly set their home account to someone else's system. There's a mildly pirate-y[0] thing you can do with a friend where you log into your account on their system and they log into your system with their account, and then you have a shared game pool. In order to be able to play on your own account you need to swap the home console associations around so your friend's Switch is your home console and vice versa. But if you do this you can never play your own games on other accounts, since your friend's the one who took that half of the license.

[0] As in, it bends the rules of the DRM in ways Nintendo probably does not intend and thus probably violates a license agreement somewhere

Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by semiquaver on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @09:08AM (#37146492)
I don’t disagree with the sentiment but you’re straight wrong on the need to buy multiple copies of a game to play on different profiles on a single switch.
Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by alexilliamson on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @08:59AM (#37146384)
That's odd... My partner bought the game and I can play it on the same device with my profile.
Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by bluefirebrand on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @09:01AM (#37146419)
Digital copies are linked to one account, physical copies can be shared freely.

Don't buy digital, it's never worth it.

Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by alexilliamson on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @09:02AM (#37146423)
She bought digital and I can play it though.
Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by astura on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @09:06AM (#37146463)
They can be downloaded to a switch and once they are on the switch any account playing that switch can play any digital games on the switch.
Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by bluefirebrand on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @10:32AM (#37147654)
I think this is only true if they are local Switch profiles.

If they are linked to a different Nintendo online account they need to buy their own copy of the game?

Maybe I'm wrong about that...

Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by astura on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @10:39AM (#37147776)
You're wrong about that.
Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by bluefirebrand on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @11:33AM (#37148674)
Interesting. I spent a bit of time reading Nintendo's FAQ on this topic and it seems you're right.

They are a lot more permissive with their digital copies than I expected, honestly.

Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by circuit10 on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @11:54AM (#37149003)
Buying digital is worth it to me because I’m very disorganised and I will lose the cartridges
Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by ygjb on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @12:48PM (#37149822)
My kids are both actively playing TOTK on their profiles on my switch with a single digital purchase.

There have been other games where this has been problematic (Animal crossing I think limited some features per device instead of per account).

Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by WhyNotHugo on Friday August 18, 2023 @06:56AM (#37173916)
Some games simply have no stock of digital copies (at least not in the Netherlands). And haven’t had in months.
Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by astura on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @09:02AM (#37146429)
This is wrong - Nintendo allows people who are using the same switch to play each other's games that are downloaded to the switch. It's not even labeled anywhere which account that game belongs to. My husband an I pay each other's digital purchases all the time.
Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by Taylor_OD on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @12:24PM (#37149459)
Well you have some odd settings. My nieces and nephews can download and play games on their switch hundreds of miles away from me using my profile. Whenever I get a new game they are excited because now they have that game as well as long as they use my profile on their account.

Nintendo does a lot of stupid shit but this is one of the few things I think they have been really good about.

Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by sleepybrett on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @06:57PM (#37154987)
all companies are awful once they get big enough to hire awful lawyers.
Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by Daz1 on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @10:19PM (#37156380)
Every console does that. PS5, Xbox, whatever. Purchases are account-linked.
Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by hospitalJail on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @10:08AM (#37147258)
Nintendo doesnt make great games. There is a phrase 'Graded on the Nintendo Curve'

Nintendo games are rated highly by other Nintendo gamers, but people from the outside see things significantly more clear.

Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by spacemadness on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @10:50AM (#37147971)
Yeah, ok.
Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by TillE on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @11:04AM (#37148201)
"Nintendo gamers" aren't really a thing, unless you're a kid with only one console.

Everyone I know who loves games has a Switch in addition to at least a PS5/Xbox if not a gaming PC, and they play everything. Nintendo games are unique. They're a legitimate reason to still buy a six year old console, and millions of people do.

Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by brightlancer on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @06:08PM (#37154536)
> Everyone I know who loves games has a Switch in addition to at least a PS5/Xbox if not a gaming PC, and they play everything.

2021 was the first year that _half_ of households own at least one game console -- how many of those households owned just the one?

There is something special to folks on HN who don't realize the bubble they live in.

https://www.cta.tech/Resources/Newsroom/Media-Releases/2021/...

Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by mcphage on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @11:17AM (#37148408)
> people from the outside see things significantly more clear

Somebody isn't seeing things clearly, that's for sure.

Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by brightlancer on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @06:02PM (#37154482)
Nintendo games are a (meta)genre and not everyone likes that, but it doesn't mean they're Objectively Bad™. It's a matter of preference.
Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by hospitalJail on Thursday August 17, 2023 @07:04AM (#37159828)
Maybe not Objectively 'Bad'. But they are not 10/10s in 2023, objectively.
Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by hombre_fatal on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @06:23PM (#37154682)
"Nintendo games actually suck, you are just too much a {dummy,shill,fanboi} to realize it!"

Funny how these gaming faction war posts haven't changed one bit from 15+ years ago when I was a preteen arguing about Xbox vs PS2 vs Gamecube on NeoGAF forums.

I just hope anyone continuing the tradition on HN are no older than that.

Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by hospitalJail on Thursday August 17, 2023 @07:03AM (#37159819)
Nintendo markets to children before they are too young to realize what is happening.

All of those claims are extremely valid.

Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by saagarjha on Saturday August 19, 2023 @06:52AM (#37187445)
Many Nintendo fans are adults.
Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by NickC25 on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @10:48AM (#37147930)
They do make great games and have a very controlling ecosystem, which honestly I have no problem with - it's their IP and they can do what they want with it. Much like Apple, their integration with hardware is quite tight and their first-party content is usually really well done. Miles better than the first-party outputs from Sony or Nintendo.

Apparently, though, their corporate culture is VERY Japanese and kind of crappy. I know someone who negotiated with them directly and although the gentleman was and remains a massive fan of Nintendo, the experience put a bad taste in his mouth.

Wish Nintendo would also listen to fans and give some of their lesser IP a fresh coat of paint. Can't believe it's been nearly 20 years since a new F-Zero, and probably over a decade since we've had a decent Star Fox. Kid Icarus, Donkey Kong, Metroid and Earthbound could all use some love, too.

Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by zagrebian on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @11:04AM (#37148195)
So what video games do you play?
Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by matt_s on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @11:07AM (#37148250)
Great games, maybe. Repetitive use of same IP over 30+ years, 100%. Its like Fast N Furious or other movie franchises that just publish a slightly different version on some cadence. If you really like it, then yes those would be great games for you.

I recently fired up the original NES Zelda game and it was fun. I also got a switch and BoTW and the original is more fun. There is so much filler and repetitive game mechanics that don't add to the game at all in BoTW. Game companies keep adding stuff to lengthen game play loops and this ends up in tedious, repetitive gaming sessions which after some point I don't find enjoyable.

Its art though so to each their own and in my opinion you shouldn't be allowed to patent art.

Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by larrik on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @11:30AM (#37148616)
I disagree with everything you said, lol. Besides the original NEW Zelda being fun.

Nintendo is very sparing in how often they make mainline games in their IP (besides Pokemon). Mario has had one main 3d game in a decade. Zelda had 6 years between BoTW and ToTK, and 5 years between BoTW and it's predecessor. Everyone of those (Mario and Zelda) until ToTK was completely different, with a different feel and different mechanics.

Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by larrik on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @04:47PM (#37153561)
too late to edit, but I meant "NES" Zelda, not "NEW" Zelda
Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by pfannkuchen on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @06:31PM (#37154761)
I think a lot of what makes the games special is the level of polish vs other studios. Polish takes a lot of time, which is why most studios don’t do it to the degree Nintendo seems to.
Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by larrik on Friday August 18, 2023 @02:46PM (#37180294)
I think that helps a ton, but they also focus obssessively on gameplay. Story, graphics, cinematics, etc. take a backseat. Multiplayer rarely exists at all.
Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by PsylentKnight on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @11:43AM (#37148848)
You say the games don't change significantly, then you say the games have changed in a way you don't like.

Yes, they use the same IP's for decades but they remain relevant because they do new things with those IP's. BoTW completely bucked the Zelda formula. ToTK was so successful because they didn't try to just ride off the success of its predecessor - they did a lot of new stuff.

A far better comparison to Fast N Furious would be Madden.

Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by matt_s on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @12:37PM (#37149666)
I get tired of the same story being repeated, maybe I could have worded it better - thats the part that they just recycle all the time. Yeah they aren’t releasing new games on a yearly basis but when they do its the same characters and nearly the same story lines. BoTW is about rescuing the princess, so is the orig Zelda. Yes there are different mini-boss fights, puzzles, etc. and they can be fun but its certainly not a new original story.

I like how with Batman and Joker movies different directors/actors have a different take on the characters or setting (gritty vs campy humor, etc.) and I don’t mind similar story elements being re-used. I don’t like that in most video games for some reason. Horizon Zero Dawn was awesome, same with Last of Us (game), haven’t looked at a sequels, they look like more of the same. Its okay for me to not like that in this art form and its okay for you (or others) to like it.

Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by mrguyorama on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @02:03PM (#37151082)
>I get tired of the same story being repeated,

But "Link, the hero of time saves Zelda from Ganon, the great evil" is the whole point of the story in the Zelda games, that these three fates are intertwined for eternity and meant to constantly dance their dance.

>I like how with Batman and Joker movies different directors/actors have a different take on the characters or setting

Zelda does this massively, there's multiple interpretations of these characters because they are different living beings in the same lineage or whatever. Consider the toon games, where "Zelda" is a pirate girl with zero "Royal" character attributes.

I don't know what you are expecting or asking for. Hell, BoTW is ALSO another re-interpretation of the story and characters

Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by matt_s on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @04:21PM (#37153181)
I’m not asking for anything, Nintendo is going to do whatever they want with their video game art form. I’m just commenting that I’ve found for most video games with story elements I don’t like repeat/rehashing a story. For whatever reason I’m ok with that sometimes in movies. I got through most of BoTW but just can’t pick it back up to finish, so I don’t.

Maybe the difference for me is with a movie, I’m just along for the ride and have no input into anything, but with a video game I’m playing the main character and when I’ve played that same exact main character with that same overall story arc I just don’t find it interesting. The other element I think is my age, I’m finding less consumable media (tv, movies, games, books, sports) enjoyable as I get older. There are things I still really enjoy but genres of them that I used to and now I don’t find interesting.

Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by ninedays on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @11:46AM (#37148877)
Couldn't disagree more with the first 2 paragraphs. It feels like saying Apple publishes a slightly different version of its iPhone every year. I think you will find plenty of differences - even major ones between the first iPhone and the latest one. Same thing with Nintendo games. IMHO, Nintendo is probably the best developer in the world and have proven this again and again. Completely agree with your last paragraph though.
Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by circuit10 on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @11:52AM (#37148979)
Honestly iPhones aren’t changing much any more, at least in a way that matters to most people
Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by m3kw9 on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @01:22PM (#37150374)
Every fps is just new graphics and few mechanic changes, no more different than sequels, at least Nintendo does it better than anyone
Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by _gabe_ on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @04:07PM (#37152961)
> Repetitive use of same IP over 30+ years, 100%. Its like Fast N Furious or other movie franchises that just publish a slightly different version on some cadence.

Go play the original Super Mario Bros, then Mario N64, then Mario Sunshine, then Paper Mario (wii edition), then Super Mario Galaxy, then Super Mario Odyssey. Sure all those games have Mario in it, but they’re only the same in the sense that the Mandalorian takes place in the same galaxy as Star Wars Ep 4. I would never compare this franchise (or Zelda) with Fast and Furious or even something like CoD. And I don’t know how you can call the IP repetitive when the only constant in all the games I listed is Mario. It’s not like FIFA that updates every year with a new roster and the exact same game.

The reason I love playing these game is because they do innovate and create completely new games even if it’s the same franchise.

Re:Nintendo Is Trying to Patent Some Broad Tears of the King... by m3kw9 on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @01:21PM (#37150354)
If you even hate Nintendo, then what company do you like?