News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by mk_stjames on Friday August 04, 2023 @10:01AM (#37000187)
This is obviously a quickly produced paper to get the finding out but.... I find there to be so much missing and so many things poorly worded or posed about their process that would have taken zero time to expound upon, it's infuriating.

"All the reactions are carried out under 10^-2 Pa"

OK, I know they mean 10^-2 of vacuum. But why not say that? "10^-2 Pa" isn't enough. Was this a full vacuum oven? Done in sealed quartz vials? Was there a purge, like argon, or just air?

If you look at the oven temperature profiles, you can see the ramp up time (0-2hr, 0-2hr, and 0-4hrs respectively), and the hold time, but the ramp down time isn't specified! There is no cooling rate, it just shows... a line drop off, with no end time. No label. This can be very critical. Were these just pulled straight out and air quenched? And were they kept under vacuum until at room temp or not?

Like, adding extra experimental setup details would take no time whatsoever to include in a paper and yet these researchers just don't do it. It's either pure fucking laziness or some sorta holier-than-thou gatekeeping that comes from theoreticians, or a combination, and it is the reason that replication is so hard in science right now. I would hope that no journal would accept this shit.

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by dmix on Friday August 04, 2023 @10:39AM (#37000696)
What personal benefit does this gain someone to publish it so quickly? Is it just social media attention?
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by jacquesm on Friday August 04, 2023 @10:55AM (#37000896)
There are no prizes for being second in science.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by smallnix on Friday August 04, 2023 @12:16PM (#37002031)
Except, most likely, in exactly this story with the second paper from the original Korean authors (if things can be proven to be true).
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by podiki on Friday August 04, 2023 @02:57PM (#37004274)
There's a long standing joke (but also true) that many things are named after the last person to find them.

See, for instance, Stigler's Law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stigler%27s_law_of_eponymy (for the concept an example itself)

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by rvba on Saturday August 05, 2023 @05:54PM (#37016637)
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by xpe on Friday August 04, 2023 @11:48PM (#37008815)
>> What personal benefit does this gain someone to publish it so quickly? Is it just social media attention?

> There are no prizes for being second in science.

The reply (second quote above) fits in context, but there is more to it.

1. Publishing early at the expense of quality has a way of catching up to one's reputation. (Hopefully.)

2. History has many examples of scientists who were "too early" or not "in the right place at the right time" to get recognition.

3. A result may get little attention in one field but a lot in another. One example that comes to mind are string-matching algorithms. Sometimes they seem a dime-a-dozen in CS. But the "right" ones have transformed DNA sequencing.

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by shortrounddev2 on Friday August 04, 2023 @10:58AM (#37000923)
There is intense pressure to publish as many papers as possible at Chinese universities. This has led to a big problem of faked or just bad research papers coming out of China, so people are generally skeptical of them
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by Al-Khwarizmi on Friday August 04, 2023 @11:08AM (#37001067)
This is a quite biased view.

As a non-Chinese scientist, I can attest that there is intense pressure to publish as many papers as possible pretty much everywhere, and this leads to a problem of bad research across the world.

China may be among the worst offenders in this respect, but the particular thing the OP is asking about doesn't strike me as a Chinese-specific thing at all. I see non-Chinese scientists rushing half-baked results to arXiv all the time.

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by light_hue_1 on Friday August 04, 2023 @11:18AM (#37001215)
It's not biased, it's a fact. I see it all the time as PC/AC/reviwer/etc.

There is deluge of terrible papers from China that are just a mess, below any imaginable standard. Ones that labs in the EU/US/Russia/Japan/etc. don't put out. Yes, everyone has to publish, and there are bad papers out there, but the volume and low quality from China is unmatched.

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by OO000oo on Friday August 04, 2023 @12:01PM (#37001809)
Unmatched doesn’t make it qualitatively unique. It’s a problem everywhere.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by cinntaile on Friday August 04, 2023 @12:07PM (#37001904)
If the problem is much bigger from certain countries then I would say that qualifies as qualitatively unique.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by tough on Friday August 04, 2023 @01:17PM (#37002911)
If those certain countries have a very big population I'd say is more of a quantitative issue. If china had 10 scientists they couldn't pump as many papers, fake or good or not as if they're 1million scientists
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by dylan604 on Friday August 04, 2023 @01:20PM (#37002959)
Isn't the population of China much bigger as well? Laws of percentages and what not can go along way. Has anyone displayed a percentage of rushed/inaccurate studies between countries to see if the lines normalize?
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by nyolfen on Friday August 04, 2023 @01:43PM (#37003288)
i saw such a chart a few days ago, specifically for withdrawn papers -- forgive me if i can't dig it up again but china made up something like 50% of the total number

e: recollection was slightly off but it is actually much worse! https://sci-hub.ru/10.1007/s11948-017-9939-6

china is truly in a league of its own with this stuff, by literal orders of magnitude

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by michaelmrose on Friday August 04, 2023 @03:22PM (#37004610)
Population of researchers != Population it's more than 4x as large in terms of population but only has ~25% more researchers while having around 50x the retractions.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by jldugger on Friday August 04, 2023 @05:24PM (#37006096)
> Isn't the population of China much bigger as well?

Yes, but official government stats have also been overstating the population a bit. I think it mostly affects the younger generation at present though.

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by SZJX on Sunday August 06, 2023 @12:33AM (#37018999)
lol I don’t know where you got this impression but during the one-child policy phase it’s widely known that people would underreport their kids to avoid fines. Why would the population be overstated?
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by jldugger on Sunday August 06, 2023 @05:11PM (#37026820)
> lol I don’t know where you got this impression but during the one-child policy phase it’s widely known that people would underreport their kids to avoid fines.

The news mostly. But also this guy[1], who I guess is using the leaked data. But even the official data shows a huge drop in the 0-4 bucket.

> Why would the population be overstated?

As I understand it[2], the local governments are reliant on two sources for income: land sales and money from the central government. Both are influenced by demographic change, so there's incentives to adjust the numbers upwards to keep revenue coming in.

[1]: https://zeihan.com/new-chinese-demographic-data-population-c... [2]: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-03-13/china-s-p...

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by sheepscreek on Friday August 04, 2023 @02:34PM (#37003957)
> It's not biased, it's a fact. I see it all the time as PC/AC/reviwer/etc.

Let's agree this is anecdotal at best, and move on. Facts need data to back them up. There's no data or links to research in this post.

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by ImPostingOnHN on Friday August 04, 2023 @02:48PM (#37004150)
I'm confident that poster's experiences are based on the data they saw

if you're doubting the veracity of the poster's claims, just say so directly

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by macintux on Friday August 04, 2023 @03:22PM (#37004619)
Data linked from another comment.

https://sci-hub.ru/10.1007/s11948-017-9939-6

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by PicassoCTs on Saturday August 05, 2023 @06:17AM (#37010630)
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by d0gbread on Saturday August 05, 2023 @09:33AM (#37011854)
Seems like a wild generalization.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by hotdogscout on Saturday August 05, 2023 @10:40AM (#37012460)
It is not wild, if you can't disagree with the majority I'm skeptical of your ability to discover truths.

I anecdotally feel religious or leftist western circles very much fall under the definition of face culture though.

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by throwaway2037 on Saturday August 05, 2023 @11:32AM (#37013015)
That is crazy talk. I don't believe it. Korea and Japan both have crazy levels of "face" in their culture (and Taiwan to somewhat less extent), and they all produce huge amounts of high quality scientific papers.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by happytiger on Friday August 04, 2023 @04:30PM (#37005464)
China publishes more science research with fabricated peer-review than everyone else put together

https://qz.com/978037/china-publishes-more-science-research-...

I respectfully submit that you may be providing an anecdotal experience.

It’s so bad that China’s courts have called for the death penalty for scientific fraud.

https://www.statnews.com/2017/06/23/china-death-penalty-rese...

Goodness me.

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by danielheath on Friday August 04, 2023 @06:13PM (#37006564)
“More than everyone else together” is meaningless without considering the relevant population sizes (in this case, the relevant population is “number of researchers producing papers”).

If China has half the worlds academics-writing-papers, one would _expect_ them to be responsible for half the fabricated ones.

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by bloppe on Friday August 04, 2023 @07:22PM (#37007153)
Chinese researchers [1] publish fewer total articles in Nature than American ones [2]. It's just one journal, with an admittedly western-leaning audience, but that's what the QZ article focuses on. It does include the caveat that it's possible that translation problems played a bigger role in the Chinese retractions than they did for other countries' retractions, although it would be surprising if that were the only cause of such a widespread problem.

[1]: https://www.nature.com/nature-index/country-outputs/China [2]: https://www.nature.com/nature-index/country-outputs/United%2...

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by janalsncm on Friday August 04, 2023 @07:43PM (#37007323)
Nice to see a government that takes science seriously. In the US if you fake data you can become president of Stanford (for a while).
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by mensetmanusman on Friday August 04, 2023 @10:09PM (#37008283)
It’s not taking science seriously when you have to threaten scientists with death. A healthy system wouldn’t need such threats.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by thucydides on Saturday August 05, 2023 @09:39AM (#37011907)
> In the US if you fake data you can become president of Stanford (for a while).

True. And then you can be humiliated by an 18 year old on the student newspaper and forced to resign in disgrace

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by biofunsf on Friday August 04, 2023 @08:02PM (#37007456)
> It’s so bad that China’s courts have called for the death penalty for scientific fraud.

To add some context, the death penalty is used much more widely in China than a Westerner might realize, so to them this idea is not quite as radical as it might seem. The PRC government is a bit tight lipped about exact policies, but it's known the death penalty gets employed for things like corruption and even major economic crimes like fraud or money counterfeiting. And of course drug offenses and the violent crimes.

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by mensetmanusman on Friday August 04, 2023 @10:07PM (#37008272)
And for speaking out against the power structure. The death penalty for bad action is only if you are on the wrong side politically. Xi’s family is among the wealthiest in the world due to corruption.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by SZJX on Sunday August 06, 2023 @12:35AM (#37019006)
This is quite a off-topic comment. Also, does the Biden family get showered with money left and right exactly because they’re hardworking?

The “death penalty” under discussion is for faking drug results and causing deaths of patients, which sounds reasonable.

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by andrewshadura on Sunday August 06, 2023 @06:08PM (#37027398)
Please refrain from whataboutism. We're not discussing Biden or the US. We're discussing the corrupt Chinese elites and the authoritarian regime of the PRC.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by dontmobile on Friday August 04, 2023 @10:41PM (#37008455)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Replication_crisis

Replication is just a nice term for it. It can just as well be a crisis of fraud with the failure of replicating fraudulent results as the consequence.

Scientific fraud and garbage results is a huge problem Everywhere. It's actually big enough to nearly invalidate the entire field of psychology.

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by dcow on Saturday August 05, 2023 @11:15AM (#37012812)
> The move, as Nature explained, groups clinical trial data fraud with counterfeiting so that “if the approved drug causes health problems, it can result in a 10-year prison term or the death penalty, in the case of severe or fatal consequences.”

To be fair, according to TFA the death penalty is only for clinical trials where the drug or procedure, due to faked or doctored data, causes severe or fatal consequences.

It actually seems pretty reasonable to me. You develop a drug that actually kills people but fake your data to show it saves lives. Then you make money while people start dying, essentially killing people because your career was more important than reality. I’d call that murder.

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by davrosthedalek on Friday August 04, 2023 @12:04PM (#37001857)
Citations. The early papers will be cited more often. And citations are kind of a currency in science.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by zhynn on Friday August 04, 2023 @12:29PM (#37002242)
Some background on the drama (and the rush to publish): https://www.reddit.com/r/redscarepod/comments/15egs7i/avg_ru...

and

https://twitter.com/8teAPi/status/1685294623449874432

The papers were totally rushed.

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by fouc on Friday August 04, 2023 @02:00PM (#37003505)
8teAPi admitted they were essentially writing fiction generated from some of the known facts
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by salty_biscuits on Friday August 04, 2023 @06:37PM (#37006813)
It's just a preprint. I appreciate the fast update of progress on a new development. Just don't give it the same weight as a peer reviewed piece.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by Bombinator on Saturday August 05, 2023 @06:54AM (#37010822)
From what I understand it was discovered in 1999, hence LK99. Doesn't seem very quick to me in that case.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by eggy on Friday August 04, 2023 @11:07AM (#37001042)
I agree, it could use more of the easy details, however, I don't have much issue with 10^-2 Pa, since standard atmospheric pressure is 101,325 Pa, so 0.1 Pa (10^-2 Pa, or 1.45x10^-6 psi) is definitely understood as a vacuum, but you're correct, why not just add "vacuum" for thoroughness.

I know mercury gauges use to have a 0 to 30 scale sometimes (not 0 to -30), and that was confusing!

Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by wittenbunk on Friday August 04, 2023 @11:13AM (#37001150)
10^-2 is 0.01
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by wruza on Friday August 04, 2023 @12:20PM (#37002103)
Classical off by one when you wrap through zero (not sure if this one has a specific name).
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by zild3d on Friday August 04, 2023 @02:50PM (#37004182)
off by 1 (order of magnitude)
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by joseda-hg on Friday August 04, 2023 @05:38PM (#37006236)
Off by one floating point
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by asddubs on Saturday August 05, 2023 @10:45AM (#37012509)
off by one em
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by klysm on Monday August 07, 2023 @10:21AM (#37034835)
Wouldn’t it be 1ch
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by andy_ppp on Saturday August 05, 2023 @05:57AM (#37010549)
It’s actually also an example of cache invalidation being difficult if you think about it…
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by eggy on Friday August 04, 2023 @03:16PM (#37004526)
Yep, had that on my calc, and then skipped the zero when typing the post. Good catch. Even closer to a pure vacuum!
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by chiph on Friday August 04, 2023 @06:26PM (#37006723)
Or they are holding the details of their process close to their chest, in anticipation of a lucrative spin-off.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by hanniabu on Friday August 04, 2023 @07:10PM (#37007052)
A breakthrough of this kind should be illegal to patent
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by shaftoe on Friday August 04, 2023 @07:56PM (#37007414)
Why do you think so?
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by hanniabu on Saturday August 05, 2023 @09:58AM (#37012067)
Why do you not think so..... what if the internet was patented? What if copper was patented?
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by solrik on Sunday August 06, 2023 @04:57AM (#37020167)
Not comparable to copper at all.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by mikhailfranco on Monday August 07, 2023 @10:53AM (#37035293)
The formula and atomic structure should not be patentable (like gene sequence), but a novel and non-obvious industrial process to fabricate such material could be patented. There may be many different such patents.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by ngc6677 on Saturday August 05, 2023 @03:31AM (#37009838)
Your point is fair. It feels it also underlies the importance of "continuous teaching and learning", global (or assigned) peer reviewing. At moments in time where discoveries like this one happen, one could hope that beyond "open publishing" like Arxiv, comes a true "science in the open", with room for cooperation. Looking forward evolving further our current system.
Re:Successful room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic lev... by osigurdson on Saturday August 05, 2023 @10:36AM (#37012418)
Why isn't 10^-2 Pa enough? Clearly they mean absolute pressure. What would 10^-2 of vacuum mean?