Robotics is behind in making a 'human'.
Even AlphaGo had a human moving the pieces, and nobody would say that was evidence of any 'lack' in the AI.
It's just an interfacing issue, engineering will eventually solve.
If you have ever worked in a modern warehouse, it is very evident, the humans are just following instructions from the system. Now scale that up to a manufacturing facility, it is already happening.
Everybody with an ear-piece or 'phone' type device, following instructions.
> Workplace democracy, AKA unionization, AKA the thing Amazon has pulled out every dirty trick to prevent, is the difference between centaur utopia and reverse-centaur dystopia.
-- https://pluralistic.net/2021/02/17/reverse-centaur/#reverse-...
Also, we were talking about deep blue. Perhaps trying to not go OT would be beneficial to a productive discussion.
We're building tools to help us augment our intelligence, I don't see anyone getting "curb stomped"?
If intelligence leads to more violence, then I don't think it will be as useful as we'd have hoped.
Over time the original meaning may fade or be forgotten, and the residual symbol in the language becomes the thing itself. Etymology is full of examples.
But that much history has not yet passed since the introduction of the term "curbstomping" and so using it is still a choice that conveys some meta-meaning about content and style.
As mentioned further up in the thread it is unnecessarily violent for conveying the meaning in the comment.
No reason to make it an issue, people just like using those metaphors.
> [Hobbes] even, through sheer force of imagination, was able to outline the main psychological traits of the new type of man who would fit into such a society and its tyrannical body politic. He foresaw the necessary idolatry of power itself by this new human type, that he would be flattered at being called a power-thirsty animal, although actually society would force him to surrender all his natural forces, his virtues and his vices, and would make him the poor meek little fellow who has not even the right to rise against tyranny, and who, far from striving for power, submits to any existing government and does not stir even when his best friend falls an innocent victim to an incomprehensible raison d'etat.
-- Hannah Arendt
And that only applies to criticizing phrases like "killing it", without even demanding it to not be used -- but not to bringing out Nineteen-Eightyfour? And doublespeak? No, doublethink means holding two contradictory things to be true at the same time, doublespeak is the verbalization of that. You're thinking of wrongthink, and either way you are doing what you criticize. Instead of saying "this is horrible" you say "this is dystopian", it changes nothing.
More importantly, your reply contains nothing specifically applying to my comment. Maybe you missed the point, which is that people delude themselves to compensate their lack of agency, being restricted to partake in a rat race that will leave them empty-handed in the end -- all of which Hannah Arendt explains in the context, but I didn't want to post a wall of text. That they don't actually mean what they say, because what they mean (and do) would be to pitiful to say without such flourish, and that they aren't actually violent and powerful, but "poor meek little fellows", is precisely the point.
> beat Kasparov
So much violence everywhere
I have trouble articulating it, but I can see that LLMs and chess engines don't do the slightest hint of it.
I'll be concerned when machines show the slightest hint of it, but we're playing a ball game in a sphere they can't even touch yet.
I'm genuinely continually boggled that people are not seeing this difference and feeling threatened by machine "intelligence", although they are encroaching on something thought uniquely human, and I don't think the brain is doing some kind of information processing that can't be done in any other medium, but the number of connections and kind of processing in the human brain may make it hard with current technology. The number of connections in the brain is staggering, and we certainly can't simulate anything of its scale on the scale of computer we have now, so I don't know what it will take to get any bootstrap on the kind of intelligence computers aren't doing.
That was ~26 yeas ago. In the intervening 26 years humans have been curb-stomped so hard at chess that certain microwaves might be competitive against human grandmasters. Anyone who doesn't think that was an exciting moment for AI research has impossible standards, we're living in a tiny window of existence where humans were at the top of the intellectual food chain and are now dropping to also-ran status along with the rest of the meat-based animal kingdom.
All these moments are the real deal. The idea that somehow this particular step change is even unexpected is missing the forest for the trees. The trends that have been observed since the beginning of computers are chugging away so quickly the whole process may well happen in a single generation.