You know what Google fears most? Being broken down. If they push for this, we can organize calls to our representatives and raise our concerns and call for regulations and/or breakdown of Google's anti competitive behavior.
Activism isn't restricted to the real world, or to "regular" people.
When a company wants to promote an idea, it hires influencers (a.k.a. shills), who promote this idea around the web. This is called astroturfing.
It's a bullshit way to dismiss people's opinions.
What exactly is this supposed to mean? All we have to do is control the government and the industry that we're complaining about, and we can win? They already have that. Doesn't that mean they already won?
> Keep that up and push for other companies to reject it or for regulation to stop it.
They are being paid to push in the opposite direction. You are paying to try to defeat them. Each of their victories brings them more money and influence, each of yours means you have to reset and construct an entirely new argument to defeat the same thing again, differently worded. The outcome is obvious.
And in this special case, Google needs no approval to take the web, because they bought Firefox and cooperate with Apple. There is no pressure that you can bring to a politician that will counteract the campaign funding, or access, or future employment, these awful companies can offer.
edit: This is a "why didn't the slaves all get together and end slavery" type argument. It's not cynical to resent the suggestion of the same tactics that have failed before so many times. Our problem is government, not any particular company.
Nobody controls all of the industry or all of the government. Half the people on this site work in the industry, often in prominent companies in a position of influence. Many of them own a major stake in a prominent startup, or operate a community with a large number of users.
Legislators care about whatever they think voters care about, and use voters calling them as a proxy for this. Don't pretend this doesn't matter.
> They are being paid to push in the opposite direction. You are paying to try to defeat them. Each of their victories brings them more money and influence, each of yours means you have to reset and construct an entirely new argument to defeat the same thing again, differently worded. The outcome is obvious.
Every time they do something like this, another person gets pissed off enough to extricate the perpetrator's services from their life even if it means re-implementing some of them themselves, and then post what they used to do it on Github. Which makes it easier for the next person to do it.
Some of them even find a way to make a business out of it and make money. I know it's not a popular belief, but it's actually possible to build a sustainable business by giving customers what they want for a fair price and not screwing them over -- businesses may find that customers even prefer this.
We're not all connecting to AOL using AT&T Unix(R) on Itanium. Why not? Those companies had real power. How did they lose?
> This is a "why didn't the slaves all get together and end slavery" type argument.
Your argument is what, that no one should make any attempt to end slavery because the slavers have too much power?
No, you keep fighting until you win. Be creative, coordinate with like-minded people. This is not a community of powerless victims. There are people who hate this who have money and skill in surplus. It's not illegal to do something which is net negative for you but net positive for society purely out of altruism, or anger, because it's your life and you get to choose what you do.
Reallocate the time you spend advocating defeatism to building something which is a threat to the people attacking you.
Google's address is 1600 Amphitheatre Parkway, Mountain View, CA 94043.
Which, hey, if you think that's worth it, it's a free country and I can't tell you not to. Maybe you'll convince a front desk receptionist to petition the temp agency she works for to change companies.
Google maintains a physical address because Googlers sometimes order packages and it's a legal requirement so they can be served formal court papers. That's it.
1. Contact antitrust authorities: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36880224
2. Use a template: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36881511
3. Provide Google's address to the authorities: 1600 Amphitheatre Parkway, Mountain View, CA 94043.
My question reading, assuming it’s main purpose is preventing as blocking, this is whether my pinhole dns blocker would be affected. If the new standard is dns blockers for everyone that’s an improvement in the landscape, at a small cost to the users.
There is little adoption or support of privacy tools when there is no need for it and we trust our systems to be free and open, everyone is a tinfoil hat wearer until they aren’t and the boundaries have shifted. People should generally have better understanding of personal data protections, control over their services and the like but we are lazy until there is no other option but to take back control.
People do care, but there are steps to creating public pressure. The public needs to become aware of the issue, to learn and understand the technical aspects of it, and to organize opposition. This is not necessarily a quick process.
They pivoted to cloud services and their server products still do robust business.
you are upset so.. empathy on that, first. Please consider that the pressure of the situation somehow escalates blame on exactly the people who are not doing this.
Consumer electronics users are not the ones who "vote" on the content. Closed-box computer systems with hierarchical, private and internal decision making, are arriving at decision points.
People DO-NOT-GIVE-A-SHIT. Because there are bigger problems, like "what the fuck am I going to pay the rent with tomorrow", and more entertaining spectacle, like watching a person pretend it's an NPC for 5 hours straight and give them money for it.
And I feel a lot of the people I have worked for are the same type of individual used to realizing they are getting screwed sideways, addicted to complaining but only as long as it's among a very select group of individual sharing common interests.
It's the most draining type or revolution. Nothing ever gets done, fucks are handed left and right: DNS, JS-fiasco, web neutrality, browserland... And we always just kick the buck and revisit the good 'ol days on another thread further down the line, once no other rights are left be destroyed...
And yet, what am I going to do? reject the PR?