News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“Web Environment Integrity” is an all-out attack on the f... by emilsedgh on Friday July 28, 2023 @02:07PM (#36910830)
What is all these negative nonsense about "people don't give a shit" on every thread about this. We don't need every single person in the street to give a shit. We only need enough influence within the industry and regulatory to give a shit. And they are. We are all upset by this and upvoting it and companies and organizations are writing about it. Keep that up and push for other companies to reject it or for regulation to stop it.

You know what Google fears most? Being broken down. If they push for this, we can organize calls to our representatives and raise our concerns and call for regulations and/or breakdown of Google's anti competitive behavior.

Re:“Web Environment Integrity” is an all-out attack on the f... by amelius on Friday July 28, 2023 @02:23PM (#36911052)
Here's an idea: websites should show an annoying window when the user agent supports this crap, regardless of whether it's relevant to the website.

Activism isn't restricted to the real world, or to "regular" people.

Re:“Web Environment Integrity” is an all-out attack on the f... by arsome on Friday July 28, 2023 @02:41PM (#36911299)
Hah, I like this idea, "It appears your browser passes web environment integrity, please come back when it fails"... I'd love to see a similar thing for SafetyNet on Android.
Re:“Web Environment Integrity” is an all-out attack on the f... by timeon on Friday July 28, 2023 @04:39PM (#36912997)
Why not. There are countless job positions for UX-designer unicorns while almost every page will give you anti-UX pop-up. One more banner will not going to harm the page.
Re:“Web Environment Integrity” is an all-out attack on the f... by pessimizer on Friday July 28, 2023 @05:36PM (#36913695)
I don't know that protest by mass suicide has ever changed anything.
Re:“Web Environment Integrity” is an all-out attack on the f... by amelius on Friday July 28, 2023 @06:23PM (#36914174)
Most protesting has some negative consequences for the person(s) doing it. Suicide is a bit strong, to say the least.
Re:“Web Environment Integrity” is an all-out attack on the f... by lern_too_spel on Friday July 28, 2023 @11:12PM (#36916490)
What are iOS users to do? They have no choice but to use a browser with PAT support.
Re:“Web Environment Integrity” is an all-out attack on the f... by GoblinSlayer on Friday July 28, 2023 @03:05PM (#36911665)
>What is all these negative nonsense about "people don't give a shit" on every thread about this.

When a company wants to promote an idea, it hires influencers (a.k.a. shills), who promote this idea around the web. This is called astroturfing.

Re:“Web Environment Integrity” is an all-out attack on the f... by meepmorp on Friday July 28, 2023 @03:35PM (#36912119)
Please don't do that. People with different ideas aren't shills - sometimes people disagree with you, see things that you don't or just understand the situation differently.

It's a bullshit way to dismiss people's opinions.

Re:“Web Environment Integrity” is an all-out attack on the f... by Given_47 on Friday July 28, 2023 @03:49PM (#36912322)
I’m pretty sure they’re referring to people that promote an idea/say something solely in exchange for money
Re:“Web Environment Integrity” is an all-out attack on the f... by CaptainFever on Friday July 28, 2023 @03:58PM (#36912463)
At the same time, astroturfing exists. It’s also incredibly frustrating how every time there’s a movement, people try to dampen its momentum by drawing attention to general apathy, a complete red herring for reasons explained in the GGP comment.
Re:“Web Environment Integrity” is an all-out attack on the f... by pessimizer on Friday July 28, 2023 @05:31PM (#36913633)
> We only need enough influence within the industry and regulatory to give a shit.

What exactly is this supposed to mean? All we have to do is control the government and the industry that we're complaining about, and we can win? They already have that. Doesn't that mean they already won?

> Keep that up and push for other companies to reject it or for regulation to stop it.

They are being paid to push in the opposite direction. You are paying to try to defeat them. Each of their victories brings them more money and influence, each of yours means you have to reset and construct an entirely new argument to defeat the same thing again, differently worded. The outcome is obvious.

And in this special case, Google needs no approval to take the web, because they bought Firefox and cooperate with Apple. There is no pressure that you can bring to a politician that will counteract the campaign funding, or access, or future employment, these awful companies can offer.

edit: This is a "why didn't the slaves all get together and end slavery" type argument. It's not cynical to resent the suggestion of the same tactics that have failed before so many times. Our problem is government, not any particular company.

Re:“Web Environment Integrity” is an all-out attack on the f... by AnthonyMouse on Friday July 28, 2023 @07:12PM (#36914653)
> All we have to do is control the government and the industry that we're complaining about, and we can win? They already have that.

Nobody controls all of the industry or all of the government. Half the people on this site work in the industry, often in prominent companies in a position of influence. Many of them own a major stake in a prominent startup, or operate a community with a large number of users.

Legislators care about whatever they think voters care about, and use voters calling them as a proxy for this. Don't pretend this doesn't matter.

> They are being paid to push in the opposite direction. You are paying to try to defeat them. Each of their victories brings them more money and influence, each of yours means you have to reset and construct an entirely new argument to defeat the same thing again, differently worded. The outcome is obvious.

Every time they do something like this, another person gets pissed off enough to extricate the perpetrator's services from their life even if it means re-implementing some of them themselves, and then post what they used to do it on Github. Which makes it easier for the next person to do it.

Some of them even find a way to make a business out of it and make money. I know it's not a popular belief, but it's actually possible to build a sustainable business by giving customers what they want for a fair price and not screwing them over -- businesses may find that customers even prefer this.

We're not all connecting to AOL using AT&T Unix(R) on Itanium. Why not? Those companies had real power. How did they lose?

> This is a "why didn't the slaves all get together and end slavery" type argument.

Your argument is what, that no one should make any attempt to end slavery because the slavers have too much power?

No, you keep fighting until you win. Be creative, coordinate with like-minded people. This is not a community of powerless victims. There are people who hate this who have money and skill in surplus. It's not illegal to do something which is net negative for you but net positive for society purely out of altruism, or anger, because it's your life and you get to choose what you do.

Reallocate the time you spend advocating defeatism to building something which is a threat to the people attacking you.