News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by bell-cot on Sunday July 23, 2023 @02:05PM (#36837947)
That article's subtitle: "In principal, but probably not in practice, fresh water can be extracted from our oceans for no expenditure of energy" [Italics mine]

Also - 231 meters deep is where, in theory, you'll just start getting fresh water coming through your membrane. Which is 231m deep. Fresh water that you'll spend plenty of $energy to pump up to the ocean surface.

(For reference - Hoover Dam, when brim-full, has a slightly lesser drop from the water surface in the reservoir to the output of the hydroelectric turbines. You'll be pumping $energy in, to lift each ounce of your "free" fresh water up to where it is useful.)

[Edit - from some quick calculations, and the density of sea water relative to fresh water...it looks like the "don't need to pay to pump the fresh water back up" version of this scheme will need to run its osmotic membranes at the bottom of the Challenger Deep (~11,000m), or something pretty close to that.]

Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by basseed on Sunday July 23, 2023 @02:13PM (#36838039)
*principle
Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by eslaught on Sunday July 23, 2023 @04:55PM (#36839745)
If I built an ocean base 231 meters below the surface, does that mean I'd get free fresh water by sticking a membrane on the outside of my base? (Ignoring the impracticality of building an underwater base, of course.)

Sounds like a cool sci-fi premise.

Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by brilee on Sunday July 23, 2023 @05:05PM (#36839839)
Almost. You would have to maintain your underwater base at 1atm and you would indeed get free freshwater. The catch is that the internal volume of your underwater base would decrease and you would eventually have to eject wastewater by pushing against the deep sea pressure. Nothing's free in physics!
Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by nonethewiser on Sunday July 23, 2023 @05:24PM (#36839988)
But what would take more energy? Pushing that wastewater out or desalinating?
Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by hwillis on Sunday July 23, 2023 @05:57PM (#36840278)
Pressure (N/m^2) times volumetric flow (m^3/s) equals power (N-m/s). At 231 meters the pressure is ~340 psi or ~6.3 MPa. 1 liter would take ~6.3 kJ to pump.
Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by jl6 on Sunday July 23, 2023 @05:06PM (#36839844)
Also depends on the energy/materials needed to make and maintain that membrane, I guess.
Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by thaumasiotes on Sunday July 23, 2023 @05:27PM (#36840020)
Adding an open window to your suboceanic base sounds like an awful idea, frankly. It's not difficult to see the obvious problem.
Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by idontwantthis on Sunday July 23, 2023 @06:54PM (#36840816)
Delightfully close to “a screen-door on a submarine”.
Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by geysersam on Sunday July 23, 2023 @05:11PM (#36839883)
Still, pumping water from 230 m is not that expensive energy wise compared to other approaches.

Best case scenario, pumping 1 kg of water 230 meters costs 2.3kJ.

Elsewhere in this thread it was mentioned that typical desalination approaches need 10-15kJ/kg.

Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by chongli on Sunday July 23, 2023 @06:02PM (#36840330)
I think you’re still going to get killed on maintenance costs. When the membrane gets clogged, how do you replace it cheaply? How do you repair/replace damaged/worn out pumps? What about sections of pipe and the fittings?

All of these sorts of repairs are also required for land-based water treatment facilities, of course, but now you have to perform them all at 230m underwater. That’s gotta be mega-expensive. Furthermore, all of your equipment needs to be able to survive at those depths, with saltwater attacking exposed surfaces and seals, requiring much more expensive materials and tighter tolerances.

It really doesn’t seem very economical to me!

Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by stereo on Sunday July 23, 2023 @06:13PM (#36840414)
When your straw gets clogged with ice cream, do you dip your fingers into your milkshake to unclog it?

You add your osmosis filter at the end of a long flexible hose. For maintenance, you reel it back in.

Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by chongli on Sunday July 23, 2023 @06:20PM (#36840493)
Straws don’t work beyond 10 metres. You need all your pumping equipment either at the bottom or distributed along the pipe. Either way, that’s going to put a ton of strain on your “flexible hose” when you try to reel it back in. And what if it breaks? Oops!
Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by Enginerrrd on Sunday July 23, 2023 @06:30PM (#36840605)
I mean, we do it with oil. ...At least sort of. Usually the wells are pressurized so pumping isn't a concern, but there's a surprising amount of infrastructure involved down at depth and the maintenance of that infrastructure is significant but largely a solved problem. Obviously economics probably favor it when oil is $75/barrel compared to ~$3 maybe for the fresh water, but still.
Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by chongli on Sunday July 23, 2023 @06:49PM (#36840778)
Your estimate for the water is way too high. I pay $2 USD (as of today's exchange rates) for a cubic metre of water from my local utility. That works out to about 32 cents per "barrel" of water. A $75 USD barrel of oil is 234 times as expensive as the same amount of water.

From what I can gather, oil rigs have profit margins below 20% (at best) and margins decline as the pressure in the well head drops, until they become totally unprofitable and shut down to wait for oil prices to go up. Water prices would have to increase by more than 2 orders of magnitude to make this strategy begin to approach profitability!

Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by jjav on Monday July 24, 2023 @02:22AM (#36843747)
> I pay $2 USD (as of today's exchange rates) for a cubic metre of water from my local utility.

A cubic meter is ~264 gallons.

Here in my area of California (CA has lots of water agencies, so YMMV) 1000 gallons costs $38.66 (varies based on total consumption).

So that's $10.21 for a cubic meter.

Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by schiffern on Sunday July 23, 2023 @09:58PM (#36842198)
>Straws don’t work beyond 10 metres.

...straws surrounded by air don't work beyond 10 meters, because the external pressure at the bottom of the pipe doesn't exceed 1 atmosphere.

Obviously this isn't true if the pipe does down into the ocean.

Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by irrational on Sunday July 23, 2023 @06:06PM (#36840366)
Is economical important? If we really are desperate for fresh water, does the cost become immaterial?
Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by chongli on Sunday July 23, 2023 @06:16PM (#36840452)
It’s not just that it’s expensive, it’s also ridiculously complex. About the only thing I can think of that would be more complex is launching rockets into space in order to collect water from comets.
Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by function_seven on Sunday July 23, 2023 @07:40PM (#36841204)
Yes, economical is always important. In this case, we’re comparing a 231m deep unit with the “boring” existing design, and finding it less economical than the current designs.
Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by kelnos on Sunday July 23, 2023 @08:18PM (#36841470)
Cost is never immaterial. We look at the various ways we have to provide fresh water, and do whatever is cheapest. If shipping fresh water from places where it's abundant to places where it's scarce is cheapest, we do that. If/when that becomes expensive enough to make desalination attractive from a cost perspective, we start doing that. If the >230m below the surface idea turns out to be cheaper than surface level plants, we do that. But I don't think anyone really knows for sure if the underwater method could be cheaper, so we're all just guessing here.

I think a good analogy for this is oil extraction. These days we extract oil from places where it's more expensive and difficult to do so, because we can no longer meet demand with the cheaper options (many of which have simply dried up over time). But we'd never go after the expensive-to-extract oil 40 years ago (or whatever) when cheaper options were available that could meet demand.

Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by jrockway on Sunday July 23, 2023 @06:44PM (#36840742)
Yeah, 230m sounds like a lot but skyscrapers are taller than that and have running water at the top. So it's definitely possible to do.
Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by GhostVII on Sunday July 23, 2023 @07:00PM (#36840854)
Wouldn't pumping from 230 meters be exactly equivalent to just pumping through the membrane at sea level?

If you have a pump 230 meters below sea level trying to push water up a pipe, to get water to the surface that pump must be exerting the same amount of pressure as you'd be experiencing 230 meters below sea level (since otherwise it wouldn't be strong enough to push up the water column). So you might as well just take the pump up to sea level and have it pump water through the membrane, since it would be exerting the same amount of pressure.

Or alternatively, you could just find a hill that is 230 meters high, pump sea water to the top of it, and then have the sea water come down in a pipe and go through a membrane in the bottom. Should be totally equivalent without requiring anything underwater.

Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by kelnos on Sunday July 23, 2023 @08:02PM (#36841371)
I don't think that's correct. Pumping water from below the surface of the ocean is about overcoming gravity. The pipes themselves would need to be constructed to withstand the pressure of the water around it, of course, so the pipes don't collapse.

The reason you don't need to "pump" to force the water through the reverse-osmosis filter when you're down that low is because the overall pressure at that depth is sufficient to push the water through as-is. Merely raising water up 230m in the air and "dropping" it through a pipe into a filter sitting on the ground would not give you the same amount of pressure.

Put another way, the pressure of the water in a 230m-tall pipe on the filter on the ground is much lower than the pressure of all the water 230m under the surface of the ocean pushing on that submerged filter. While the pipe ensures that the water stays confined, it is not putting pressure on the water in the same way all the water in the ocean is putting pressure on the water that's being pushed into a 230m-submerged filter.

I imagine there is some way to do what you describe above-ground, my my intuition is that it would require essentially recreating a large ocean, suspended in the air (not as large as the Atlantic, say, but still fairly large). Much more efficient to just use the ocean we already have.

For the submerged filter approach, I think the biggest challenges are probably maintenance and keeping things stable and functioning at the pressures present at >230m below the surface. Those challenges might make it infeasible. I don't think the need to pump the desalinated water back to the surface is all that large a problem in comparison.

Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by lazide on Sunday July 23, 2023 @09:19PM (#36841902)
To be clear - unless there is work done to reduce the pressure at -230m below mean sea level, there is zero pressure gradient there. Anything sitting at -230m will feel a pressure gradient of essentially zero.

So you couldn't run a filter or anything, unless it's literally magic.

If someone put a pump at -230m and pumped out the water on one side of the membrane so that on one side the pressure was 'ocean' at -230m, and the other side was mean sea level, then yeah the membrane would work.

Notably, this requires roughly the same amount of work and energy as pumping water from the ocean at sea level into a filter so it has roughly the same pressure you would find if you did the first thing.

There is no free lunch.

Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by leovailati on Sunday July 23, 2023 @09:42PM (#36842064)
I think you are incorrect. If you build a 230-m tall pipe and fill it up with water, the water at the ground-level end of the pipe will be at the exact same pressure as the water 230 m deep in the ocean. Hydrostatic pressure only depends on the depth, not the container shape.
Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by lazide on Sunday July 23, 2023 @10:24PM (#36842400)
Uh no?

The water at the ground level on the ocean will have the same pressure as the water at ground level in the pipe. The water at 230m down in the pipe will be the same as the water 230m down in the ocean.

Even if the pipe is capped on both ends.

Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by jherico on Monday July 24, 2023 @12:21AM (#36843076)
a pipe 230m tall with the bottom at ground level would experience the same hydrostatic pressure as water 230m under the ocean. the pressure comes from the weight of water above it, not distance from sea level. this is literally how water towers work.
Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by lazide on Monday July 24, 2023 @12:26AM (#36843100)
That is literally what I said, yes.

The post I replied to said the opposite - that the pressure at the surface of the ocean would be the same as the pressure at the end of a pipe going under water, if there was a pipe.

Which clearly isn’t true or we’d have a trivial perpetual motion machine.

Edit: it looks like they changed their post?

Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by jlawson on Sunday July 23, 2023 @08:03PM (#36841382)
Yes, this is how normal reverse osmosis filters work. However, pumping water at that pressure obviously takes a motor and consumes energy. What's interesting about the OP's concept is that in theory it can be performed with no energy expenditure at all.
Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by lazide on Sunday July 23, 2023 @09:20PM (#36841912)
Except it can't because of thermodynamics, if you pencil it out.
Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by the_third_wave on Sunday July 23, 2023 @07:14PM (#36840951)
Add some wave/tidal/current power generators to the installation and you get those 2.3kJ/kg "for free".
Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by andbberger on Sunday July 23, 2023 @10:13PM (#36842308)
the single largest consumer of power in california is the DWR's pumping plants. don't underestimate the energy costs of pumping a state's worth of water up several hundred meters.

which really puts into perspective how insane desalination, with it's order of magnitude higher energy costs is. why spend all that energy when we could simply build more infrastructure to capture more peak runoff from the sierras

Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by analog31 on Sunday July 23, 2023 @11:24PM (#36842776)
At first glance, this suggests typical desalination has a roughly 15% to 23% efficiency. Also, desalination from some sort of submerged membrane and bringing the freshwater to the surface would itself not be 100% efficient.
Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by iancmceachern on Sunday July 23, 2023 @06:04PM (#36840352)
It seems there is one use case that would be viable.

If we use the water at depth. I think the way to go is underwater living pods.

If we go this route, I propose we also kickoff a solid Merpeople program (Mermaids, Merman, etc). The goal woukd be to gradually move the human race to be Merpeople. One day we will be viewed as the Neanderthals and Merpeople the people. As everyone knows, the hallmark of any reputable Merpeople program I'd breathing underwater, indefinitely, in Salt water. If we've been able to achieve that it's reasonable to assume we'd also be able to engineer the ability to "drink" seawater directly.

All this to say, I guess there isn't really an application for this.

Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by darkclouds on Sunday July 23, 2023 @06:15PM (#36840436)
> If we use the water at depth. I think the way to go is underwater living pods.

We need way more daylight than most people realise, look at what goes into a submarine who are already living in a what is effectively a cramped mobile blacked out cave.

Living under water in pods has been done before but damp was the biggest issue from what I remember.

Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by iancmceachern on Sunday July 23, 2023 @07:29PM (#36841117)
Excellent points. We need to add living without nearly as much sunlight, and living in damp or submerged environments to the goals of our Merpeople program.

I'd imagine there are stepping stones along the way. We won't make it all the way to fish people right away, we'll likely have amphibian people first. Those people, amphibian people, should be pretty good in living in damp environments.

All that to say, I think we're good.

Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by irrational on Sunday July 23, 2023 @06:08PM (#36840379)
Haven’t there been experiments with using wave motion to generate electricity? If practical, maybe wave motion at the top could be used to generate electricity for pumps at the bottom.
Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by barney54 on Sunday July 23, 2023 @06:59PM (#36840852)
Yes and they are expensive and unsightly. People don’t like to look offshore and see the ocean industrialized.

I like the idea of wave energy but the economics are really difficult in large part because the ocean is a difficult environment.

Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by irrational on Sunday July 23, 2023 @10:54PM (#36842601)
How often is the ocean 231 meters deep close enough to shore for people to see wave generators over the pump stations?
Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by Maxion on Monday July 24, 2023 @01:23AM (#36843400)
AFAIK there aren't any comercially deployed wave generators, probably because they would have too many moving parts.
Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by golergka on Sunday July 23, 2023 @07:30PM (#36841122)
If you would just build a pipe that goes up to the sea level, wouldn't the fresh water naturally go up it because of pressure enacted at it at 231 meters? You would only need to pump it up from the sea level.
Re:Why don't we get our drinking water from the ocean by tak... by lazide on Monday July 24, 2023 @12:37AM (#36843156)
The pressure differential the membrane experiences (and needs to function) drops as the water gets closer to the surface. So the more the pipe filled, the less water would flow.

If the membrane requires 231 meters of pressure differential, it would stop moving water when the water was still about 230 meters from the surface.