News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by slibhb on Monday July 17, 2023 @05:03PM (#36764039)
The economy doubling in size helps most people even if the resulting wealth is unevenly distributed. Goods, services, technologies, jobs, etc are good.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by notfromhere on Monday July 17, 2023 @05:08PM (#36764125)
No it doesn't. Growth in the economy has to increase real wages, and real wages need to keep pace with housing, food, healthcare, etc increases in order to be meaningful.

More jobs are only good if they actually provide a living wage.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by slibhb on Monday July 17, 2023 @05:21PM (#36764293)
I don't agree: having more stuff makes people's lives better even if that doesn't show up in terms of real wages.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by midasuni on Monday July 17, 2023 @05:46PM (#36764520)
No it doesn’t. If I spend $100 on takeout because I don’t have time to cook a fresh meal that increases gdp but makes my life worse.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by TeMPOraL on Monday July 17, 2023 @07:53PM (#36765822)
Not if they can't afford the basics, though. Another way of framing the problem GP is pointing out is: necessities are getting increasingly expensive relative to trinkets and niceties.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by smolder on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @01:22PM (#36776080)
It very much depends on what stuff you're talking about. Consumption and QoL are only loosely correlated. If we have a culture that values status signalling, everyone may might work harder to afford status signalling without any real benefit to their quality of life. Efficiency of consumption matters. The relationship between dollars spent to degree of life improvement is nowhere close to 1:1. Some purchases pay dividends in that sense while others come with hidden costs and fleeting benefits.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by Alupis on Monday July 17, 2023 @05:13PM (#36764190)
> More jobs are only good if they actually provide a living wage.

This is false if you spend even a few seconds thinking about it.

Not all jobs are intended to "live" off of. Most of your entry-level jobs were supposed to be for highschool and college kids working part time.

The problem is we have more and more people never graduating out of entry level positions, and today we have folks demanding those entry level positions support a comfortable lifestyle.

You're supposed to graduate out of entry level work after you acquire skills, training, and/or education. Why are people not "moving up" is the real problem...

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by Supermancho on Monday July 17, 2023 @07:21PM (#36765468)
> Most of your entry-level jobs were supposed to be for highschool and college kids working part time.

This is some soft language hiding some bad assumptions.

"supposed to be" - what does this mean? because it's a lot more interesting...low skilled jobs, are probably what we're going to be talking about. However, it's not the 1950s anymore. eg Staffing a movie theater is not a part-time job (which you would know if you have ever worked one), even post-covid.

Targeting for graduates (or current students) is reserved for economies like college towns, historically. Those places have also experienced wages rising noticeably over, at least, the last 2 decades. Industrial and metropolitan areas don't have enough "school labor" to staff all the unskilled positions, regardless.

> Not all jobs are intended to "live" off of

If you have a fulltime job, the minimum wage is intended to allow you to survive^. The main issue is that places with fulltime positions open to unskilled labor, have living costs that outpace the minimum wage...all the way out to the most rural of US towns. The financial guidelines for employees from McDonalds, Wallmart, etc are telling.

^Claiming that jobs that pay minimum wage and only allow working 30 hours a week, aren't intended to "live" off of, is cherry picking exploitative employers. This is not compelling, nor the common case, so we can focus the discussion on the issues that the majority of the economy deal with.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by Alupis on Monday July 17, 2023 @08:08PM (#36765959)
> If you have a fulltime job, the minimum wage is intended to allow you to survive

This is the issue - the idea that minimum wage is supposed to be "livable" is a modern notion.

Unskilled labor probably shouldn't be livable. If someone can be trained to replace you in a few minutes (i.e. unskilled labor), then the truth is your labor is not worth a lot.

We need more people moving up into skilled labor. It's really hard to imagine someone working 30+ years at a job and not developing skills... yet that is what's happening more often today than ever before.

Highschool and College kids don't need a living wage. They need flexible hours, and schedules that fit their available time (night shift, swing shift, whatever...).

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by klardotsh on Monday July 17, 2023 @08:40PM (#36766244)
Your entire argument is predicated on the idea that anyone should be incapable of paying rent, which you might find is not a universally-agreed upon opinion, or even an opinion some find worth the keystrokes it was written with.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by carlosjobim on Monday July 17, 2023 @08:33PM (#36766187)
> Unskilled labor probably shouldn't be livable.

The only way for that to work is to have a slave population, because why should a living and breathing human being waste their time and their life with work that doesn't even sustain them? The concept of "unskilled labour" is a lie. Otherwise you could hire dead people from the graveyard.

> Highschool and College kids don't need a living wage.

Do you have any good arguments as to why you should be allowed to have a living wage?

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by FpUser on Monday July 17, 2023 @09:14PM (#36766519)
>"Unskilled labor probably shouldn't be livable. If someone can be trained to replace you in a few minutes (i.e. unskilled labor), then the truth is your labor is not worth a lot."

Then cometh Lenin

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by Supermancho on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:19PM (#36767004)
> We need more people moving up into skilled labor.

Need? No. Would it be better for society? Maybe. This is not really something that people disagree with. Dispensing with the repetition will save the distraction.

> the idea that minimum wage is supposed to be "livable" is a modern notion.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Living_wage - back to 1604, or earlier or later; what does it matter?

> Unskilled labor probably shouldn't be livable.

Why? Arguing the economic consequences are not a reasoning.

There will always be humans who are incapable of skilled labor (of any note) beyond newly educated students. eg The Calculator profession and other forms of industrial collapse as well as immigrants (legal or otherwise) and the disabled. It's not clear what you think is the obvious way to keep these people alive. Welfare/socialism or pretending they don't exist, relegating them to a slave class, or exile?

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by defrost on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:42PM (#36767172)
> the idea that minimum wage is supposed to be "livable" is a modern notion.

A notion that dates back centuries and one specifically enshrined in law in Australia, a G20 country, since 1902 (ish).

I dare say other G20 countries also support this notion (aside from any antiquated holdouts still clinging to non SI units).

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by notfromhere on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @01:03PM (#36789688)
Someone still has to work those unskilled jobs. It's not exclusively staffed by high school and college kids, they're staffed largely by poor adults and immigrants, and it turns out they still need to live and eat.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by OGWhales on Monday July 17, 2023 @07:36PM (#36765633)
> The problem is we have more and more people never graduating out of entry level positions, and today we have folks demanding those entry level positions support a comfortable lifestyle. That doesn’t sound right. To me it seems obvious the problem is these jobs used to provide more purchasing power than they do today. The increased grievance would be because of this drop in purchasing power, not because people are suddenly demanding a “comfortable” (<- loaded word) lifestyle out of the blue.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by kalleboo on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @04:12AM (#36769341)
> Most of your entry-level jobs were supposed to be for highschool and college kids working part time

Did McDonalds used to be closed during weekdays when all their cooks and register staff were in school? I don't remember that.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by notfromhere on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @01:00PM (#36789625)
You are fundamentally asking someone else to subsidize the cost of that labor.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by Retric on Monday July 17, 2023 @05:06PM (#36764082)
Hardly, 99% of the population can be worse off with a sufficiently uneven distribution despite 2x GDP growth. Read up on countries hit by the “resource curse” where dictators suddenly don’t care about the productivity of most of their citizens.

Also, extremely uneven economic distributions tend to be bad for large segments of the population due to inherently limited resources like desirable beach front property as well as artificially limited resources like city apartments.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by mepian on Monday July 17, 2023 @05:14PM (#36764202)
Ah yes, the good ol' trickle-down economics.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by Alupis on Monday July 17, 2023 @05:30PM (#36764368)
It's very difficult to argue in good faith "trickle-down" economics was/is a failure.

A rising tide obviously raises all ships, including the nation's poorest.

To create vast wealth generally requires vast resources, which requires vast amounts of people. Behemoths the size of Amazon, Walmart, Microsoft, Google, et al employ significant chunks of the population - and not just directly.

Trickle-down doesn't mean everyone will be a millionaire by doing nothing... instead, it means a ton of smaller companies are boosted while servicing larger companies, and so on - spreading wealth around in terms of employment and providing people with a living they can fairly earn.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by tivert on Monday July 17, 2023 @05:53PM (#36764588)
> A rising tide obviously raises all ships, including the nation's poorest.

To throw a wrench in that tired metaphor: a rising tide may raise all ships, but a fat lot of good that does to the poor, if it's only the well-of that can afford to buy a boat.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by Alupis on Monday July 17, 2023 @06:35PM (#36765017)
You're missing the point.

Even the poor do better when there's more jobs available, more job mobility, more housing, more stores, etc. All things that are created by wealthy companies and individuals.

Everyone, including our poorest, benefit from a growing economy.

We just have to examine our average poverty-level person, and compare them to poverty-level persons of other nations to understand this point.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by sangnoir on Monday July 17, 2023 @07:30PM (#36765566)
> Even the poor do better when there's more jobs available

Only if those jobs offer a livable wage. If instead they are McJobs that result in workers spending more than they earn (e.g. SNAP), then poor people are doing worse, and it's a net-negative on society.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by Alupis on Monday July 17, 2023 @07:50PM (#36765780)
This misses the reason so-called McJobs don't pay a "living" wage. You're not supposed to earn a living wage doing zero skilled work. You're supposed to develop skills and move up in the working world.

Why are people stagnating instead of moving up? That's a really good question.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by Kerrick on Monday July 17, 2023 @09:12PM (#36766498)
What code says you’re “not supposed to”? Why is that morally correct?

And most importantly, how do you account for the fact that there in the U.S. there are about 53 million people in low wage jobs, but only about 33 million high school and college students? What are those other 20 million workers “supposed to” be?

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by crote on Monday July 17, 2023 @09:48PM (#36766743)
> You're not supposed to earn a living wage doing zero skilled work.

If you are not "supposed" to earn a living wage, then the job should not exist. It's a simple matter of supply and demand: if you can't afford to pay your laborers a living wage, you have obviously failed as a company because you are unable to exist without slave labor.

> This misses the reason so-called McJobs don't pay a "living" wage.

Yes, this reason is called "profit". They pay so little because it is legal to do so, and people would rather work three jobs than see their kids starve.

> You're supposed to develop skills and move up in the working world.

If everyone moves up, who is going to do those jobs? And how exactly are you supposed to develop those skills if you have to work three jobs just to survive? There are only so many hours in a day, you know.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by smolder on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @02:07PM (#36776836)
> Why are people stagnating instead of moving up? That's a really good question.

It's a difficult question to answer thoroughly, but there should be a few obvious factors. Most of the labor market is effectively priced out of acquiring higher valued skills/degrees that would improve their career. Their opportunities for advancement are laughable.

So, then, why is that?

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by SideburnsOfDoom on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @04:23PM (#36778577)
Parent poster: trickle-down economics definitely works. Just think about it.

Also parent: Why are people stagnating instead of moving up? It's a real puzzle.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by tivert on Monday July 17, 2023 @07:34PM (#36765607)
> You're missing the point.

No I'm not. I know exactly the point you were making. I'm disputing it.

The problem is the devil is in the details, and both the tired metaphor and your defense of it leave those details unspecified.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by Alupis on Monday July 17, 2023 @07:51PM (#36765790)
You've offered zero details about why this is incorrect. You've just asserted the meme that it's "obviously wrong"...

There is no good faith argument that exists to prove this incorrect.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by bandyaboot on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:10PM (#36766933)
I’m looking, but I must be missing the part where you provided details to justify your own assertion of it being obviously true.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by Alupis on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @01:10AM (#36768058)
TFA, among other economic articles, statistics, etc support this assertion.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by SideburnsOfDoom on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @03:06AM (#36768882)
The parent article is a tweet of a graph, and it says nothing about trickle-down.

> other economic articles, statistics, etc

Ah well, you're wrong. "other economic articles, statistics, etc" clearly do not support this.

I mean, "what can be asserted without evidence can also be dismissed without evidence." but lets bring the citations:

> trickle-down economics has never been advocated by any economist

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trickle-down_economics#Economi...

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by Sharlin on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:46PM (#36767200)
Sure, feel free to compare American poverty-level people to poverty-level people in countries with stronger safety nets.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by refurb on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:54PM (#36767260)
Analysis of inequality ignores government transfers.

Did you know that?

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by janalsncm on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @04:40AM (#36769551)
How about dividends and stock buybacks? How do those help the poor? If trickle down economics (read: giving money to rich people in hopes that they don’t just hoard it) actually led to more jobs, more housing, and better mobility instead of the opposite, you wouldn’t have to pay off economists for them to advocate for it.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by OGWhales on Monday July 17, 2023 @08:34PM (#36766200)
Considering the decline of economic mobility, increasing income inequality/wealth concentration and most importantly the stagnation of real wages[0], all of which started around the 1980s, it would seem the economic policies prior were more successful in raising all people.

I don’t mean to trivialize the complicated nature of the matter, with the effects of the world wars and globalization + many other factors, it is hard to separate things, but it really does not seem all that difficult to argue that trickle down economics is not better than what we were doing before and to do so in good faith.

Of course, the actual goal of trickle down economics was to concentrate wealth and power into the hands of a few and in that regard it is undeniably a success.

[0]: https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2018/08/07/for-most-...

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by crote on Monday July 17, 2023 @09:38PM (#36766672)
Amazon has workers pee in bottles and literally walk around the corpses of their dead coworkers. Walmart famously pays their employees so little they rely on food stamps to survive.

The nation's poorest are not provided with a fairly-earned living. They are working themselves to death while not even earning enough to survive, and they can't get any other job because those "smaller companies" have been killed by the behemoths outcompeting them by using exploitative labor practices.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by SideburnsOfDoom on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @02:55AM (#36768796)
> It's very difficult to argue in good faith "trickle-down" economics was/is a failure.

Complete nonsense. You can look at the real-world effects.

Or the economists, who have done so and do not support it at all: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trickle-down_economics#Economi...

The citations that you want are linked there. Are you seriously saying that the whole "Economics" section of the Wikipedia article on trickle-down economics is "not good faith"?

Trickle down is a failure at its stated aims. It does not work. It never worked, and now people have noticed.

> A rising tide obviously raises all ships

A metaphor proves nothing. I might as well say "when money is concerned, no it doesn't: it's every man for himself" and leave it at that.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by SideburnsOfDoom on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @03:20AM (#36768990)
> It's very difficult to argue in good faith "trickle-down" economics was/is a failure. > A rising tide obviously raises all ships, including the nation's poorest.

Let me ask you one thing in addition: can you explain why "trickle-down" economics is superior to "trickle-up" economics: where the money goes directly to those poorest who need it, cutting out the middle-men; and then when they spend it until it inevitably trickles up to businesses and the more well-off?

How does does "trickle-down" economics compare to that?

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by noelherrick on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @07:39AM (#36770730)
You can definitely argue that trickle-down economics was a failure. London School of Economics does exactly that.[0] I am also a bit surprised that you haven't heard the absolute despair of Millennials and Gen Z. Wealth inequality is off the charts. If wasn't for Mark Zuckerberg, Millennials would have an average negative net worth (mostly joking). This isn't a matter of complaining that you have to cut down on avo toast, it's people not going to the doctor, dentist, having to pile into small houses, always be on the edge of your car breaking down. We're the wealthiest country in the world, but folks have to start GoFundMe's to pay for healthcare. Wild.

[0] https://www.cbsnews.com/news/tax-cuts-rich-50-years-no-trick...

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by masfuerte on Monday July 17, 2023 @05:21PM (#36764288)
AKA tinkle-down economics.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by midasuni on Monday July 17, 2023 @05:47PM (#36764536)
When the rich and powerful piss on everyone else.

Oh how far we’ve come since the economy of the 1960s.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by Sterm on Monday July 17, 2023 @05:09PM (#36764145)
If it did US life expectancy wouldn't lower today than it was in 2008.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by philwelch on Monday July 17, 2023 @07:32PM (#36765582)
That’s mostly due to obesity, which is a consequence of the quantity and (flavor) quality of food getting better over time; a side effect of economic prosperity.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by r00fus on Monday July 17, 2023 @07:42PM (#36765713)
s/economic prosperity/lack of regulation/

Palm oil is in everything in the US, in France there's a lot more lighter oils and butter.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by philwelch on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:22PM (#36767427)
The obesity epidemic hasn’t spared France either: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Obesity_in_France
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by actionfromafar on Monday July 17, 2023 @07:57PM (#36765850)
You meant getting worse.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by philwelch on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:20PM (#36767413)
No, I didn’t.

Obesity is a side effect of having so much food that calories are cheap and plentiful. That’s why obesity rates are rising everywhere in the first world. It’s also something virtually unprecedented in human history.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by actionfromafar on Thursday July 20, 2023 @09:42AM (#36800316)
And it won't last. Fossil fuels make up almost all fertilizer.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by Sterm on Monday July 17, 2023 @09:19PM (#36766549)
If food is killing you that's not an improvement in food.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by philwelch on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:17PM (#36767393)
If you have so much food even the poorest people can get fat, you are a richer and more prosperous society than 99.9% of human history.

Btw obesity is rising in Europe as well.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by elishah on Monday July 17, 2023 @08:00PM (#36765883)
That's a bit of a tenuous connection.

That decline is an anomaly. The majority of it is attributable to covid, and a significant minority attributable to fentanyl: https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/pressroom/nchs_press_releases/2022/...

I do agree that the "rising tide raises all boats" rhetoric is largely bunk. But I don't think that this one particular measure, taken at an anomalous time, is sound footing for a counterargument.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by louthy on Monday July 17, 2023 @07:46PM (#36765750)
Something D O O economics
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by FpUser on Monday July 17, 2023 @09:09PM (#36766475)
Not when more and more people can no longer afford place to live and lots of other things for which prices have skyrocketed.