Even the poor do better when there's more jobs available, more job mobility, more housing, more stores, etc. All things that are created by wealthy companies and individuals.
Everyone, including our poorest, benefit from a growing economy.
We just have to examine our average poverty-level person, and compare them to poverty-level persons of other nations to understand this point.
Only if those jobs offer a livable wage. If instead they are McJobs that result in workers spending more than they earn (e.g. SNAP), then poor people are doing worse, and it's a net-negative on society.
Why are people stagnating instead of moving up? That's a really good question.
And most importantly, how do you account for the fact that there in the U.S. there are about 53 million people in low wage jobs, but only about 33 million high school and college students? What are those other 20 million workers “supposed to” be?
If you are not "supposed" to earn a living wage, then the job should not exist. It's a simple matter of supply and demand: if you can't afford to pay your laborers a living wage, you have obviously failed as a company because you are unable to exist without slave labor.
> This misses the reason so-called McJobs don't pay a "living" wage.
Yes, this reason is called "profit". They pay so little because it is legal to do so, and people would rather work three jobs than see their kids starve.
> You're supposed to develop skills and move up in the working world.
If everyone moves up, who is going to do those jobs? And how exactly are you supposed to develop those skills if you have to work three jobs just to survive? There are only so many hours in a day, you know.
It's a difficult question to answer thoroughly, but there should be a few obvious factors. Most of the labor market is effectively priced out of acquiring higher valued skills/degrees that would improve their career. Their opportunities for advancement are laughable.
So, then, why is that?
Also parent: Why are people stagnating instead of moving up? It's a real puzzle.
No I'm not. I know exactly the point you were making. I'm disputing it.
The problem is the devil is in the details, and both the tired metaphor and your defense of it leave those details unspecified.
There is no good faith argument that exists to prove this incorrect.
> other economic articles, statistics, etc
Ah well, you're wrong. "other economic articles, statistics, etc" clearly do not support this.
I mean, "what can be asserted without evidence can also be dismissed without evidence." but lets bring the citations:
> trickle-down economics has never been advocated by any economist
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trickle-down_economics#Economi...
Did you know that?
To throw a wrench in that tired metaphor: a rising tide may raise all ships, but a fat lot of good that does to the poor, if it's only the well-of that can afford to buy a boat.