News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by dtech on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:27AM (#36758631)
I would be so happy if can go back to a world where advertising happens purely based on the content like we've had for ages in TV/radio/magazines. The amount of privacy we've globally lost just for a few advertising dollars is atrocious.

I've never been convinced that it even adds that much value for advertisers, but they must think otherwise and I guess the sheer amount of money and effort that is put into targeted advertising shows otherwise.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by ChrisMarshallNY on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:42AM (#36758836)
> just for a few advertising dollars

The problem is that it isn't "just a few" dollars.

There are several multi-billion-dollar companies that have been founded on exactly that.

When there's that much money to be made, there's almost no way to stop it. Human history is rife with examples of greed run amok.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by w0m on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:49AM (#36758950)
You're conflating. As a small business, he can do small targeted advertising and expect some positive results. Untargeted simply wouldn't be feasible at a low scale to expect results.

Targeted advertising does allow 'the little guy' to reach their expected audience a bit better.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by codetrotter on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:31AM (#36759458)
Double check parent to the comment you responded to. It’s not responding to the one you think it’s responding to.

The comment was:

> I would be so happy if can go back to a world where advertising happens purely based on the content like we've had for ages in TV/radio/magazines. The amount of privacy we've globally lost just for a few advertising dollars is atrocious.

> […]

The one you are talking about meanwhile, is a different comment. A sibling comment which was also in response to the few dollars thing.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by w0m on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @11:01AM (#36787583)
I blame Spez. Thank you.
Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by imiric on Monday July 17, 2023 @12:40PM (#36760427)
Exactly. Advertising revenue increases with more accurate consumer targeting. If you can show an ad of a product to a consumer who's most susceptible to make a purchase, at exactly the right time they need it, a sale is pretty much guaranteed. Currently advertisers spend millions on ad campaigns that have very low and innacurate conversion rates. The more they know about the potential consumer, the more their user data and thus a targeted ad is worth.

Microtargeting is a sickening trend enabled by adtech, but the fact it works much better than traditional ad campaigns is a reason advertisers would never want to go back.

And then there's the data broker market, which on its own is worth billions of dollars. This is an entire adjacent industry symbiotic with adtech. None of this is going away anytime soon.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by shkkmo on Monday July 17, 2023 @01:10PM (#36760904)
>None of this is going away anytime soon.

Unless we make it illegal. Then it'll be restricted to shady enterprises for whom the legal risk doesn't matter.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by imiric on Monday July 17, 2023 @01:39PM (#36761362)
How do you suppose "we" make it illegal? Advertisers spend millions on lobbying to ensure pesky laws don't get in their way. They have politicians in their pockets, and millions of internet users behind them who think that giving up their data in exchange for a "free" internet is worth it.

The chances of this ever changing are practically zero.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by jacooper on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @07:15AM (#36770535)
Well the decision above shows that it's possible.
Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by idopmstuff on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:31AM (#36758684)
> I've never been convinced that it even adds that much value for advertisers

It does, particularly for small businesses. I own a small ecommerce company, and there's just no way I could profitably advertise in the way you're describing. Current digital advertising is far superior on multiple levels: - Scale: I started with a few bucks a day and can run very small tests. Neither possible with the kind of ads you're describing. - Targeting: The current digital advertising is simply much better at targeting, which means my returns are much higher because a much higher percent of people who click on it convert. As a point of comparison, I've done newsletters (and very targeted ones - I run a dog treat company, so there are some good magazines/newsletters for my audience) and they're much worse than Meta ads. - Feedback: At this point, I just won't do anything if I can't track the results. If you're investing in TV/radio/magazines, you're just guessing what works and burning a bunch of money on the stuff that doesn't.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by balder1991 on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:40AM (#36758812)
This is a perspective that’s not usually talked.
Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by bee_rider on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:04AM (#36759133)
Small, incredibly niche businesses come up often when we talk about ads. Probably because they are one of the few sympathetic business models that benefit from hyper-targeted ads.

It is nice that people can start these incredibly niche businesses, but we have to weigh that against the fact they we’ve built a massive surveillance apparatus and also the misinformation ecosystem that grew out of Facebook is screwing up politics around the world.

But ya know, dog treats, I guess it is a hard choice.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by hackerlight on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:04PM (#36767312)
> we’ve built a massive surveillance apparatus and also the misinformation ecosystem that grew out of Facebook is screwing up politics around the world.

I'm also concerned about the misinformation ecosystem, but why is the surveillance apparatus a primary cause? I'd say the primary causes are a lack of content moderation and the incentives that the platform creates by putting likes as the main way that ideas spread.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by dublinben on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:46AM (#36758899)
How was anyone able to sell dog treats before pervasive digital surveillance? Must not have been possible.
Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by BurningFrog on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:15AM (#36759257)
You probably had to be a major national brand.
Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by giaour on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:21AM (#36759330)
That's not true. I am old enough to remember that we had boutique dog treats in the 90s, too. The vet my parents used sold some, and I recall several nearby bakeries (not chains) selling house-made dog biscuits.
Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by pksebben on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:39AM (#36759545)
Yeah that’s the current situation is better for small businesses is a bit of a weird take, considering how consolidated the world has gotten in the last 20 years.

While there might be anecdotes to support such a claim, the numbers tell a different story. Any reduction in friction is bound to benefit the businesses with the largest footprint, as they can leverage economies of scale and recursive synergies.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by idopmstuff on Monday July 17, 2023 @02:24PM (#36762023)
> Yeah that’s the current situation is better for small businesses is a bit of a weird take, considering how consolidated the world has gotten in the last 20 years.

I think it's more nuanced than that - it's not that the current situation overall is better, it's that the state of advertising is better. On the other side of things, the ability of large corporations to achieve greater economies of scale is decidedly worse for small businesses, to your point. The fact that targeted advertising is there helps to offset that a bit.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by vasco on Monday July 17, 2023 @12:12PM (#36759979)
Yes but the barrier to start a internet-only small business with advertising is the lowest it's ever been. Before you were either only local (bad luck if there's already a pet store in your town), or you had to be huge. Online advertising is a great equalizer that has allowed many regular people to run successful businesses without much starting capital.
Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by JohnFen on Monday July 17, 2023 @01:29PM (#36761207)
> Online advertising is a great equalizer that has allowed many regular people to run successful businesses without much starting capital.

Maybe so, but I personally don't think that's worth abusing the public with tracking.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by digging on Monday July 17, 2023 @12:04PM (#36759880)
Local stores have always existed.
Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by w0m on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:48AM (#36758918)
because The Old Way is universally better.
Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by 93po on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:03AM (#36759122)
in this case it clearly is? i don't care about capitalism's ability to unethically try to manipulate me into giving it money. if it sucks for business owners then that's too bad - maybe they should do something different with their time.
Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by renewiltord on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:12AM (#36759229)
Yeah, well, that's where we differ. I think giving small business owners access to tools to show up in front of an audience that is interested in them is worthwhile while you believe almost all consumer products should be sold only by megaconglomerates who can afford large blocks of advertising.

That's a pretty big difference in our viewpoints and while HN currently tends towards yours, I have no doubt that my objectives lead to a better world for consumers (and actually, non-consumers as well) than yours.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by manuelmoreale on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:38AM (#36759531)
Considering you make a very bold claim would you mind expanding on how you think your viewpoint is actually better?
Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by bigbillheck on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:15AM (#36759253)
How about the option in which there's still at most limited ads and we also break up all those big corporations into lots of little ones?
Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by renewiltord on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:28AM (#36759420)
I don't think active management of company size works successfully. The enforcement division of any nation would be a significant portion of GDP. And what happens to products like the iPhone? After the ten thousandth iPhone, you're a $10 mm revenue company and someone else sells the next iPhone? I'm not convinced that's better for consumers and non-consumers.
Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by 93po on Monday July 17, 2023 @12:10PM (#36759954)
> That's a pretty big difference in our viewpoints and while HN currently tends towards yours

This is an interesting phenomenon no matter what the topic is - I experience it too. It's human nature to feel counter culture. I believe HN is pretty strongly pro-capitalism for reasons that are obvious due to the nature of the site.

I don't think small business owners are innately more deserving of money. They still make money off the backs of others, just at smaller scales. Competition is important to make capitalism less sociopathic but small business owners aren't meaningfully competing with Amazon.

Also to be clear, I think all advertising is unethical. It's a spectrum for sure though.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by Dma54rhs on Monday July 17, 2023 @05:21PM (#36764289)
By being a monopoly in your region of course.
Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by wdawson4 on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:51AM (#36758973)
What you are describing is targeted advertising, not behavioral advertising. The article discusses a ban on behavioral advertising. Behavioral is targeting advertising based on how a user interacts with content on the internet, instead of basing it on their personally stated interests, which they have control over.

In your case, instead of targeting advertising at users that scroll past cat videos and choose to watch dog videos, you could target advertising to users in a dog owners FB group.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by bryan_w on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:58AM (#36759058)
> because a much higher percent of people who click on it convert.

And even better (for the consumer), a higher percentage of people who _see_ the ad are likely to actually be interested in the topic.

This compared to the annoying ShaneCo ads that have been plauging radio stations for years.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by seattle_spring on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:12AM (#36759232)
> the annoying ShaneCo ads

On the corner of State St and 7200 South. Open Monday through Fridays til 8, Saturdays til 5. Closed Sundays.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by idopmstuff on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:58AM (#36759810)
Totally - the most positive ad experience I've ever had was when I was looking for a gift for my then-girlfriend and was served an ad for a company that offered private tours of the SF Zoo where you got to meet the red pandas. I got a great experience that I otherwise would never have known about, and the company + zoo both made money. This is good!
Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by hackerlight on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:59PM (#36767286)
> And even better (for the consumer), a higher percentage of people who _see_ the ad are likely to actually be interested in the topic.

Which inadvertently means the consumer is forced to see less ads, since each ad is capable of generating more revenue and therefore there doesn't need to be as many of them.

So, you've sacrificed some privacy, and in exchange you get less ads and better targeted ads. Was this a good trade-off for the consumer? I don't know. It probably doesn't make a big difference to our lives one way or the other.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by dspillett on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:18AM (#36759296)
It seems obvious to me that there is genuine benefit: otherwise it is a giant scam against the advertisers as well as an invasion of individual privacy, and there would be lobbing from larger commercial entities affected to make the scam illegal if it were one.

Though that there is a benefit to businesses, however small, does not make me inclined to be happy that I am stalked throughout my personal life online by a great many advertising firms, and information about me gleaned from that stalking bought and sold between them, in order for those businesses to experience said benefit.

If it were banned globally, the “but how do I run my business otherwise?” question is a problem for the businesses, not me.

The “most people don't mind, you are just being contrary” argument that I've seen once or twice is bunkum. If that were the case it would not be so often be made such a faf to opt-opt.

One thing I feel current privacy laws are a little off, is disallowing blocking for people who don't opt in. I've quite happy to be given a choice of “let this list of hundreds of third parties track you, or go away” (in case you haven't guessed, I'll go away) as long as no tracking is initiated between my arrival and going away without opting-in.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by paulddraper on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:22AM (#36759334)
If it weren't banned globally, the “but how do I protect my privacy?” question is a problem for the consumers, not me.
Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by pksebben on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:35AM (#36759499)
“I don’t consume stuff”, says paragon of austerity.
Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by SoftTalker on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:43AM (#36759609)
I don't particularly care if advertisers build a profile of me for the purpose of advertising. I use ad blockers and I rarely if ever see ads when doing anything online.

My concern is that all this profile data is being slurped up by people who can really do harm: governments and their TLAs. People don't get sent to re-education camps (or worse) by companies trying to sell dog treats.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by dspillett on Monday July 17, 2023 @12:38PM (#36760404)
Like you, my problem isn't advertising, but the tracking. Though unlike your position this isn't because I block the adverts regardless. I wouldn't block the advertising if it were not for it being intimately linked with the tracking & recording. Apart from simply avoiding sites that carry rudely irritating adverts (huge pop-overs, auto-playing audio & video, …) that is.

> People don't get sent to re-education camps (or worse) by companies trying to sell dog treats.

No, but they might by state agencies that gain access to the data (by fair means, at least as defined by their laws, or foul) to use as part of a larger profile.

My personal concern isn't state entities. Maybe this is some of my old-fashioned-ness speaking out but the idea of being followed around is just icky much like being followed home from the pub of an evening, or otherwise tracked in the real world, would be.

Of course, there are people for whom state agencies are a concern, and not just state agencies but various negative activist groups and other undesirables: I know a few people who don't want parts of their personal lives (gender status, abortion, the fact they consider themselves atheist, etc.) tracked because in the wrong hands it could, even in 2023, lead them and/or their loved ones to come to harm. They don't want an advertising company holding information about them because this is just one hack away from a lot of other groups having the information, and while it is highly unlikely that they are tracking such information they likely have something that could help derive it (location data being the most obvious factor there, and advertiser love to track that).

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by SoftTalker on Monday July 17, 2023 @12:56PM (#36760688)
I agree, there's a creepiness to it, but demographic-based target marketing isn't exactly new. Remember when products used to come with a "warranty registration card" that not only asked for your name and address and phone number but your income, SSN, other products you owned, hobbies, age, marital status, etc? Or you'd enter a contest to win something, and the entry form asked for similar information?

All of that went into databases that were bought and sold, matched and merged with each other, for purposes of lead generation and target marketing.

What Meta and Google are doing is nothing new, they just have much better collection and segmentation than was ever possible, and it's much more covert than what was ever possible.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by JohnFen on Monday July 17, 2023 @01:26PM (#36761166)
> What Meta and Google are doing is nothing new

The new part is making it nonoptional.

You never had to enter a contest or send in a warranty card, after all.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by dspillett on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @04:54AM (#36769642)
All those were up-front and optional (though maybe the wording made the details seem less optional). The surveillance done by the advertising industry these days is definitely not up-front nor optional where they can possibly make it automatic/required/both.

> What Meta and Google are doing

It isn't just Meta and Google. It is a great many companies large and small.

> is nothing new

Even if I accepted the equivalence, the industry having done a smaller version of this surveillance in the past doesn't make it right. My friend traded a bit of weed in the 90s, that would be no reason for us to take an “it is what it is” attitude if he traded a ton of crack today!

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by the_other on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:53AM (#36759733)
So you DO care. A lot. Enough to install tools to frustrate the process.
Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by dmoy on Monday July 17, 2023 @12:08PM (#36759931)
To me it reads like

> I don't particularly care if advertisers build a profile of me for the purpose of advertising. [But I do care about not seeing ads in the first place, so] I use ad blockers and I rarely if ever see ads when doing anything online.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by SoftTalker on Monday July 17, 2023 @12:10PM (#36759958)
I block the ads because they are annoying, not out of concern that the advertiser per se has a profile about me.
Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by JohnFen on Monday July 17, 2023 @04:08PM (#36763354)
I am the reverse. I don't block ads per se, but I absolutely block scripts (which has the effect of blocking ads) because I find the spying completely unacceptable.
Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by idopmstuff on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:55AM (#36759770)
Yep, I agree with what you're saying here. My personal preference is to allow greater advertising, even putting my own use for it aside, because I both generally believe it's better to let markets do what they will and also because I have a significantly above-average understanding of what's being tracked and how it's being used. My preference is for transparency, education and possibly regulation around how data that is collected can be sold to/shared with others.

Still, I definitely the side of wanting to restrict it more in order to protect folks, and I think it's very much a worthy debate to have.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by uneoneuno on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:23AM (#36759354)
What digital advertising platform do you use? I am looking for methods to promote my small business and have an idea of my audience but want to understand the most efficient way to reach them.
Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by paulddraper on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:25AM (#36759386)
People are terrible at judging their own thoughts.

Pound for pound, people prefer ads that are relevant to ads that are irrelevant.

What they are annoyed by is the volume (in multiple senses) of the ads. That's it.

They just take it out on other things.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by JohnFen on Monday July 17, 2023 @01:32PM (#36761259)
So you're asserting that marketing companies know people better than they know themselves? If that's true, that's incredibly damning of marketing companies and is a great argument for why they should have access to less individualized data about people.
Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by paulddraper on Monday July 17, 2023 @04:52PM (#36763907)
> marketing companies know people better than they know themselves

Yes. I'm saying it's a low bar because people don't know themselves.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by mbgerring on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:46AM (#36759656)
You’re conflating several different things here. Facebook et al could easily change the targeting criteria to match the content your ads are being displayed next to, rather than the audience that is looking at it. Especially with AI content description and summarization tools. The fast feedback and targeting you can get from digital advertising could still be available without mass surveillance.
Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by idopmstuff on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:52AM (#36759729)
No, what you're suggesting misunderstands why these ads work well.

I don't care what content you're looking at. I care who are you. Specifically, I care whether you're a person who owns a dog and spends money on high-quality/luxury dog goods. Whether you're looking at something related to dogs or a post by someone in your family about a wedding last weekend doesn't matter.

Displaying my ad next to dog-related content would be much, much worse from a targeting perspective. Instead of targeting the people who are likely to buy my product, it'd end up targeting people watching dog videos. The set of people who watch dog videos is much broader than my target audience - my mom watches dog videos sometimes, and she's a cat person!

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by shkkmo on Monday July 17, 2023 @12:59PM (#36760729)
> Specifically, I care whether you're a person who owns a dog and spends money on high-quality/luxury dog goods.

Thing is, that is non of your god damned business.

You can show your ads next to dog videos or whatever other content you like. You don't get to spy on me just because you think you'll learn better ways to try to manipulate me.

If targeted advertising were really about helping get the information to interested people who want that information, then content based advertising would accomplish that.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by nobody9999 on Monday July 17, 2023 @09:06PM (#36766446)
>I don't care what content you're looking at. I care who are you. Specifically, I care whether you're a person who owns a dog and spends money on high-quality/luxury dog goods. Whether you're looking at something related to dogs or a post by someone in your family about a wedding last weekend doesn't matter.

I think you have it backwards. You don't care who someone is. Rather, you care about "people most likely to buy my product," and much, much more about people who actually buy your product. Their name, family history, life story and other information is irrelevant.

Having the money to pay and the will to buy are the only important things.

As such, which was alluded to by others, instead of spying on/tracking people to hazard a guess (perhaps even a good guess, but not necessarily) what they're likely to purchase, let's just ask them up front to list the things they are interested in, with the ability to modify such a list whenever they like.

And make that list opt-in, of course.

Then use the database of those lists to target ads. People see ads for stuff they're interested in, those who aren't interested don't see them. Which is a win-win for consumers and advertisers. Consumers only see relevant ads and advertisers know their ad impressions are among folks who are actually interested.

Sure, there are lots of reasons to argue against a voluntary database like that, not least of which ad-supported sites would suffer.

But if you (like me) don't earn a living via ad-tech, even such a flawed idea seems like paradise compared to the current levels of spying/tracking which would make a Stasi[0] wet dream look decidedly soft-core.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stasi

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by crawsome on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:44AM (#36758870)
It's funny because this philosophy makes a lot of sense. Nobody has given it a name yet though as far as I know.

The philosophy that mass advertising is a malaise that hurts more than helps. That humans inherently can't be trusted with data. No matter how benevolent the cause may seem, that data is not going to be safely leveraged in the interest of the people that data represents.

Take Cambridge analytica scandal for example. People thought they could trust Facebook with their opinions. It turns out that data was being farmed and sent to a political aggravator who is being paid by the Republican party. Some could say it is one of the things that turned the election of 2016 to Trump. Zuckerberg had no problem with this.

This is the kind of philosophy I'm talking about. Getting rid of this kind of garbage.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by nceqs3 on Monday July 17, 2023 @12:37PM (#36760376)
>Some could say it is one of the things that turned the election of 2016 to Trump. Zuckerberg had no problem with this.

This is just patently false. There is no evidence for this whatsoever.

Also CA wasn't really Facebook's fault. A third party broke FB's TOS and committed perjury once FB caught them. Both parties have FAR more sophisticated ad targeting companies.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by shortrounddev2 on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:00AM (#36759083)
Targeted advertising keeps the internet open
Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by manuelmoreale on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:40AM (#36759562)
Why do you believe that to be the case?
Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by nceqs3 on Monday July 17, 2023 @12:38PM (#36760389)
Without targeted ads, everything will be behind a paywall.
Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by linguae on Monday July 17, 2023 @12:42PM (#36760472)
I remember the Web of the 1990s and early 2000s where there were plenty of sites operated by hobbyists and academics that had no ads at all. Of course, there were also e-commerce sites like eBay and Amazon that didn't have ads since their business models didn't rely on them.

The Web would look different without targeted ads, but not everything will be behind a paywall.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by shortrounddev2 on Monday July 17, 2023 @09:49PM (#36766755)
Yes, the internet would probably be nothing but tech people. YouTube would certainly not exist
Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by imiric on Monday July 17, 2023 @12:57PM (#36760695)
Advertising and paywalls aren't the only available business models. One would think that with all the modern technology we would have alternative sustainable business models on the web.

Turns out, we do. Brave's BAT is a great model, regardless of what you think of Brave Inc.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by manuelmoreale on Monday July 17, 2023 @01:09PM (#36760895)
I disagree.

You could run non targeted adds by sponsoring sites that are close to your business.

You could have a mix of premium and free content.

You could figure out other ways to connect with potential customers.

Targeted ads are not the be all and end all of web monetisation.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by Crabber on Monday July 17, 2023 @01:46PM (#36761450)
Searching for a niche topic on an internet without advertising: 10 results of pages run by hobbyists, who care so much about their topic of interest that they are willing to pay out of their own pocket to make information available to others

Searching for a niche topic on an internet with advertising: 1000000 results of SEO spam, senseless AI generated articles, 10 minute ad-filled youtube videos, posted by people who have no intent to actually provide high quality information but just see internet users as hoards of mindless meat to show advertisements to

Which kind of internet would you rather have?

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by manuelmoreale on Monday July 17, 2023 @02:07PM (#36761800)
It sucks that the middle ground has basically been abandoned. Simple sponsor slots on niche websites that are focused on specific topics. You have a blog about bicycles with an audience? Seems the perfect space for a bicycle related company to advertise on. Work out a deal for a rate and there you go. The brand can figure out if it’s worth it based on referrals or other metrics.

I get it, it involves a lot of manual labor and it messy and it’s easier to just slap some js code and forget about it.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by nceqs3 on Monday July 17, 2023 @02:05PM (#36761763)
Searching is the key word there. Without ads, Google would be behind a paywall. Without ads, Instagram, YouTube, Facebook, etc. would also be behind paywalls.
Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by nobody9999 on Monday July 17, 2023 @09:13PM (#36766511)
>Without ads, Instagram, YouTube, Facebook, etc. would also be behind paywalls.

And nothing of value would be lost.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by JohnFen on Monday July 17, 2023 @01:59PM (#36761654)
Being without targeted ads doesn't mean you can't do ads.

There was a time, not all that long ago, that targeted ads were simply impossible to do. And yet, ad-supported media existed nonetheless.

And there was a time when the vast majority of what you saw on the web wasn't ad-supported or behind a paywall. So clearly that model also works.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by shortrounddev2 on Monday July 17, 2023 @09:48PM (#36766747)
Some form of targeted ads have existed since at least the 1950s (if not the 1920s). Nielsen tracked sample demographics of the US population to see what kind of people watched what TV channels and shows at which times. When people refer to "Nielsen ratings", this is data provided by Nielsen to the publishers (show-runners) about how many people watched their shows, and what kind of people they were. Nielsen is still the largest advertising data provider to traditional TV
Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by marssaxman on Monday July 17, 2023 @06:46PM (#36765125)
The internet was full of useful information before the existence of advertising or paywalls.
Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by shortrounddev2 on Monday July 17, 2023 @09:46PM (#36766726)
Targeted ads exist as part of an open source ecosystem. Small websites cannot attract advertisers to email them directly to buy ad space, and so they auction off their unused inventory through open ad exchanges. To be pedantic, targeting is not a necessary part of this, and what qualifies as "targeting" may differ based on your views: is it targeting to serve an ad based on the content of the website, ignorant of the user seeing the ad? Most would probably say no. However, it is targeted advertising which improves the effectiveness of campaigns and brings in more revenue for those publishers. Without targeted ads, publishers such as blogs and newspapers would make less money and be less competitive with the larger, closed end-to-end ad platforms like Facebook and Google.

I believe that we have the choice between targeted advertising and an internet dominated by 3 or 4 websites (though some argue we're already there). I don't believe that most people would pay to get through paywalls, and so they would simply get their news and media from less reputable sources which spam misinformation on facebook to farm clicks

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by cm2012 on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:17AM (#36759286)
I do B2B advertising. Without behavioral targeting. It would not be possible.
Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by imiric on Monday July 17, 2023 @12:54PM (#36760663)
With respect, that's BS. First of all, of course it would be possible, but you would need to be smarter with your traditional campaigns to reach customers.

And secondly, if you do B2B advertising then your MO is cold contacting businesses, email campaigns, social media, trade shows, etc. Why do you need behavioral data of your users to advertise to them? And how would you even know they represent a business from just their behavior?

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by shkkmo on Monday July 17, 2023 @01:12PM (#36760953)
Then you are incompetent at your job.
Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by avalys on Monday July 17, 2023 @12:12PM (#36759977)
> The amount of privacy we've globally lost just for a few advertising dollars is atrocious.

What is the actual consequence of this "lost privacy"? What would be tangibly different in your life right now if you hadn't "lost" it?

My answer - nothing whatsoever, no harm comes to me at all from some statistical algorithm calculating what ads I might want to see, and in fact I've bought several cool products off Instagram that I didn't know about otherwise. This is a completely illusory harm that has been made up by what is essentially a cabal of professional agitators and propagandists.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by Dirak on Monday July 17, 2023 @01:31PM (#36761245)
In fact, I would go further and say we would actually be worse off without personalized advertising. Personalized ads help connect innovative products with the people who would benefit from them. Without a way to reach these niche audiences, these products might not be able to exist, and the community would be worse off.
Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by JohnFen on Monday July 17, 2023 @01:34PM (#36761289)
You may suffer no harm, but there are plenty of real stories of others who have.

I maintain that it doesn't matter. Harm isn't necessary to reasonably object to being spied on. Just wanting to not be under surveillance is more than sufficient.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by gingerlime on Monday July 17, 2023 @03:15PM (#36762672)
What actual harm would come to you from someone watching you in your bedroom?

What harm would come to people simply registered as Jewish in Germany prior to WW2?

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by jensensbutton on Monday July 17, 2023 @12:30PM (#36760249)
Does that mean local business would be cut out of internet advertising because ads can't be shown based on your city/state/country? That would be a tangible loss. "The amount of privacy we've globally lost" doesn't seem like a real thing.
Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by s17n on Monday July 17, 2023 @12:55PM (#36760673)
I honestly just don’t understand why anyone would care about this distinction. I’d support a total ban on all advertising, but I simply can’t fathom giving a damn about exactly which data points were used in the targeting.
Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by mindcrime on Monday July 17, 2023 @02:06PM (#36761775)
Not me. I want ads to be hyper-personalized, because I want them to be relevant. I don't mind ads at all, *so long as they are for things I might actually be interested in*. What drives me nuts though, are ads that are so totally and obviously un-suited for me. Like, I see ads all the time on Facebook where if I click the "Why did I see this ad" button, it turns out the advertiser was "targeting" (if you can call it that) "people over 18 years of age, with a primary location in the United States."

Seriously, WTF? I wish FB didn't even allow ads to be so broadly scoped. There is approximately NOTHING that is legitimately going to be of interest to everybody in that group. It's bad for the advertiser, bad for the user, and probably bad for Facebook to even have that.

No, I say figure out that I'm a libertarian atheist with strong interests in open source software, bicycles, guns, and electronics test equipment, and show me ads for those things first and foremost. Target the hell out of me, please.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by Tainnor on Monday July 17, 2023 @03:05PM (#36762560)
But you don't get that choice. As long as ad companies have data about you, they can distribute you in whichever bucket they like. Similar to how I get recruiters offering me PHP positions on LinkedIn despite PHP not being anywhere close to my profile.

There's no way for you to say "you can use my data but only the way I like it" unless you sign some explicit agreement. When you give up your data, you also consent to be placed into whatever bin they want you to be placed in. They don't care about whether you get to see exactly the ads that you want to see, as long as they believe their cost to benefit ratio is right.

This is why you should want your data to belong to you, so that you could make an informed decision about what kind of content you see.

Re:Norwegian DPA: Temporary ban on behavioural advertising o... by orangecat on Monday July 17, 2023 @04:52PM (#36763902)
I want ads to be hyper-personalized, because I want them to be relevant.

I don't, because ads are 10% informing me of the existence of products I might be interested in, and 90% psychological manipulation trying to induce me to buy stuff whether it's in my best interest or not. If the advertiser knows more about me, that can increase the effectiveness of their manipulation.

I say figure out that I'm a libertarian atheist with strong interests in open source software, bicycles, guns, and electronics test equipment, and show me ads for those things first and foremost. Target the hell out of me, please.

It seems like a win-win solution would be for browsers to send an optional user-controlled header describing your interests. Sort of like Google's topics API, but entirely under your control rather than mined from your browser history.