News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTube Introduces 1080p Premium by wodenokoto on Monday July 10, 2023 @04:08AM (#36663385)
Am I seeing the past in a nostalgic light or were DVD 480p considerably better than YouTube 480p?

I feel like streaming services compress their streams so hard that the resolution indicators become meaningless.

Re:YouTube Introduces 1080p Premium by jiggawatts on Monday July 10, 2023 @04:32AM (#36663542)
I watch 4320p (8K) streams when possible because it noticeably improves the quality on my 4K screens — and this is with my worsening eyesight!

That shouldn’t be noticeable if the 4K stream was encoded properly.

Re:YouTube Introduces 1080p Premium by edvinbesic on Monday July 10, 2023 @05:41AM (#36664001)
I believe this is to some degree due to chroma key subsampling, where in a 4k stream you will only have 1080p worth of light intensity encoded (cluster of 4px). So if you play an 8k stream and downscale to 4k you actually have full chroma (1:1).

There could of course be other factors involved as well but this is definitely a pretty big contributor.

Re:YouTube Introduces 1080p Premium by olaulaja on Monday July 10, 2023 @08:25AM (#36665335)
You have chroma and luma the wrong way around, chroma is color and luma is light intensity. Chroma is still the thing being subsampled.

I've never really noticed effects from chroma subsampling so my guess would be the bitrate just being better with the higher resolution. Also "full res->compress->downsample" might be more efficient than "full res->downsample->compress" since downsampling is a (really bad) form of lossy compression as well.

Re:YouTube Introduces 1080p Premium by koromak on Monday July 10, 2023 @09:46AM (#36666357)
Similarly, 4K video looks much better on a 1080p screen than a 1080p video. A youtuber posted a comparison, its easy to see even in a still image. Its all in their encoding algorithm.
Re:YouTube Introduces 1080p Premium by kevincox on Monday July 10, 2023 @01:24PM (#36669633)
> That shouldn’t be noticeable if the 4K stream was encoded properly.

I don't think this is true. At some point there are diminishing returns. At some point if the 4k video has twice the bitrate it is going to have more information available. Some will be lost in the down sampling but it isn't "improper" to end up with more data on the screen.

It is true that YouTube bitrates are pretty "conservative" for the resolution but I don't think that is "improper" it is just a tradeoff based on common device an internet speeds. They could be more bandwidth efficient if they did a custom transcode for each user's screen size and bandwidth but that is infeasible. So it is fine that some users will not be able to stream the 4k transcode on their 4k screen and will need to use the 2k stream and some users will have extra bandwidth on their 1080p screen so will stream the 2k version for better quality. The goal isn't to be perfect for each device but to be good on average.

Re:YouTube Introduces 1080p Premium by oersted on Monday July 10, 2023 @04:55AM (#36663692)
It's interesting to see how tiny Netflix mobile download files are.

200MB - 300MB for full-length movies, ~150MB for series episodes. This is on "Standard quality", but still.

After some quick Googling (grain of salt) I see that a standard DVD of 4.7GB tends go have (usual encoding) up to 135 min of 480p video. That's a big difference! Even when considering that modern encoding might be more efficient. It is lossy compression, and the lossyness seems to be cranked way up.

Re:YouTube Introduces 1080p Premium by botanical on Monday July 10, 2023 @05:23AM (#36663889)
DVD's definitely didn't use up the entire 4.7GB. A movie was anything from 700MB to 1GB
Re:YouTube Introduces 1080p Premium by phonon on Monday July 10, 2023 @05:49AM (#36664054)
I think you're confusing them with MPEG-4 rips that are burned on DVD-R.
Re:YouTube Introduces 1080p Premium by antiloper on Monday July 10, 2023 @06:06AM (#36664170)
Yes, DVDs use the MPEG-2 codec which has a horrible compression ratio compared to H.264 (and CD audio is completely uncompressed).
Re:YouTube Introduces 1080p Premium by wodenokoto on Monday July 10, 2023 @07:03AM (#36664638)
I remember old dvd players had a noticeable pause in the movie when it changed layers.
Re:YouTube Introduces 1080p Premium by Sohcahtoa82 on Monday July 10, 2023 @01:09PM (#36669356)
Yup.

The movie producers would try to hide it by placing the layer change in a scene change, but I often still noticed it.

Re:YouTube Introduces 1080p Premium by SirMaster on Monday July 10, 2023 @09:40AM (#36666266)
Commercial DVD movies were bigger than this. They used dual-layer DVDs and the main movie was often 6-7GB.
Re:YouTube Introduces 1080p Premium by parsimo2010 on Monday July 10, 2023 @06:13AM (#36664198)
DVDs of movies were actually dual layer, and had ~9GB capacity. I remember this distinctly because to copy a movie rental to a DVD-R you had to use a program like DVD Shrink so you could strip out all the extra features and compress the video a bit more to get it to be under 4.7GB
Re:YouTube Introduces 1080p Premium by zamadatix on Monday July 10, 2023 @08:12AM (#36665220)
This will depend on the movie and dual layer was more an exception than the norm. Rarely, a movie could be spread across multiple discs as well. Most typically for the extras but sometimes just to fit longer movies in decent quality.
Re:YouTube Introduces 1080p Premium by defrost on Monday July 10, 2023 @05:44AM (#36664024)
In days of yore before upscaling was computationally practical a better standard was PAL region DVD's that were encoded from master (be that hires digital tape or direct from film).

    In PAL regions, the PAL signal uses 625 signal lines, of which 576 (known as 576i signal) appear as visible lines on the television set, whereas NTSC formatted signal uses 525 lines, of which 480 appear visibly (480i).

    In PAL video, every second line has the phase of the color signal reversed, which leads to the signals flattening out the frequency between the lines.

    Effectively what this means is that damage to the signal appears as errors in saturation (level of color) rather than hue (shade of color) as it would appear in NTSC video, leading to a higher-fidelity picture of the original studio version.
Re:YouTube Introduces 1080p Premium by Macha on Monday July 10, 2023 @07:37AM (#36664947)
The difference is bitrate. DVD's were 10 mbit of MPEG-2 while YouTube 480p is 2.5mbit of h264 (or transcodes thereof). These are different encodings so it's not a 1 to 1 comparison of bitrates as h264 is efficient, but this article indicates that you'd need 4mbit of h264 (which is closer to that YouTube allocates to 720p video) to match the perceived quality of 10mbit of mpeg-2: https://streaminglearningcenter.com/articles/h264-vs-mpeg-2-...
Re:YouTube Introduces 1080p Premium by ksec on Monday July 10, 2023 @12:29PM (#36668700)
I am not sure where you get the 2.5Mbps and 4 Mbps number from because those are very high numbers for streaming ( or even for torrent downloading ) for those resolution and Youtube dont use any where near those number. A quick check shows Youtube only uses around 600Kbps on 720P video. And anywhere between 1.5 to 1.8Mbps for 1080P content. I am guessing their relatively low quality compared to their bitrate is because their encoding process optimise for encoding time rather than quality per bit simply because of the volume they have per day.
Re:YouTube Introduces 1080p Premium by Macha on Monday July 10, 2023 @12:34PM (#36668798)
2.5mbps are youtube's own recommendations: https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/1722171?hl=en#zipp...

They will then transcode it to h265, or webm which uses even less bandwidth, but I'm giving them the benefit of the doubt here and assuming they target their transcoding setup to preserve as much quality as they recommend providing them.

And of course this is VBR not CBR, so some scenes will use less.

4mbps is the linked article description of where h264 matches DVD quality. Yes, 4mbps is more than most streaming sites will give for 480p. This does mean that most streaming sites are inferior to DVDs at 480p. The fact that most streaming sites use less bitrate than a DVD-equivalent quality is therefore not surprising, giving that people have noticed that exact fact.

Streaming sites do not pick their bitrate to maximise quality given a fixed maximum filesize, so it's not surprising that they choose a lower bitrate (and therefore lower quality) than DVDs. They're instead optimizing for things like their server costs, time to playback start, or the ability to perform uninterrupted playback over the internet connection of users resorting to these lower resolution settings.

Re:YouTube Introduces 1080p Premium by ksec on Monday July 10, 2023 @12:41PM (#36668917)
>2.5mbps are youtube's own recommendations: https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/1722171?hl=en#zipp...

That is for uploading.

Re:YouTube Introduces 1080p Premium by Macha on Monday July 10, 2023 @12:45PM (#36668986)
It's like you didn't even read the very next sentence.
Re:YouTube Introduces 1080p Premium by ksec on Monday July 10, 2023 @12:46PM (#36668999)
You said transcode to H.265. And they dont transcode to H.265 or HEVC. ( Apart from some edge case of 360 degree video )

And your original claims of YouTube using 2.5Mbps and 4Mbps. Go and find me clip with those bitrate?

Re:YouTube Introduces 1080p Premium by Macha on Monday July 10, 2023 @12:47PM (#36669019)
Ok, sure, they also produce extra h264 files at various resolutions and quality levels. Transcoding can't invent quality that wasn't there in the input, so I don't see how that changes anything. That 2.5mbit/s upload they accept is therefore the ceiling.
Re:YouTube Introduces 1080p Premium by Saris on Monday July 10, 2023 @12:29PM (#36668708)
Yep, streaming sites use so much compression to save on costs that everything looks much worse then it should.
Re:YouTube Introduces 1080p Premium by SirMaster on Monday July 10, 2023 @01:26PM (#36669661)
Eh, this isn't really my experience these days.

Here is Disney+ stream vs a Disc 1:1 copy:

https://nicko88.com/misc/compare/Ant%20Man%20Quantumania/

https://nicko88.com/misc/compare/Avatar%20The%20Way%20of%20W...

Streaming looks only slightly marginally worse IMO.