News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by ilikeitdark on Sunday July 09, 2023 @05:52PM (#36659321)
I for one, miss the old, grimey internet. Reddit is/was so good because of the possibility that you might find something disturbing while using it. Just about everyone is represented on there. YouTube was also much better when the sketchiness was easier to accidentally run into.
Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by swah on Sunday July 09, 2023 @07:24PM (#36660140)
It happens with Youtube sometimes, but you have to search for the exact name of the creator you heard somewhere else. Or you find very "pure creators" when you search how to fix your toilet.
Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by hnick on Sunday July 09, 2023 @07:55PM (#36660345)
Watching YouTubers come up with weird euphemisms to avoid saying "COVID" (to avoid the risk of automatic demonetisation) drove home how much self censorship there must be around content creation in general. I've also seen a few joke about whether they're allowed to swear or not yet since apparently the algorithm cares if they swear in the first 15 seconds, lest an easily damaged listener finds them by mistake.
Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by derefr on Sunday July 09, 2023 @08:18PM (#36660503)
Apparently you can't monetize a YouTube video that says the word "kill", even in the context of educational videos about wildlife ecology.

So you get serious educational content creators saying that a bird "un-alives" a fish.

Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by userbinator on Sunday July 09, 2023 @11:45PM (#36661805)
If only Orwell was still alive today.
Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by jrmg on Monday July 10, 2023 @12:57AM (#36662286)
This sounds like an urban legend.
Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by tourmalinetaco on Monday July 10, 2023 @01:49AM (#36662574)
I know true crime youtubers tend to avoid the word like a plague, so take that for what you will.
Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by bitwize on Monday July 10, 2023 @04:12AM (#36663423)
I've seen it myself. Casual Geographic does this a lot: https://m.youtube.com/@mndiaye_97

The thing is, the phrase has an origin in a parody of censorship. In one episode of Ultimate Spider-Man, Spider-Man teams up with Deadpool. Deadpool, being fourth-wall-savvy and well aware that he is in an animated kids' show, talks rather frankly about his plans to "un-alive" the criminal they are pursuing. To which Spider-Man responds "Un-alive... you mean KILL him?!"

Mr. Pool was applying standards and practices to his own speech that were common on 80s and 90s animated programs, in which characters obviously wielding rifles would assiduously avoid talking about killing or death. And now people are using his neologism to avoid being punished on a video platform ostensibly for adults primarily.

Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by RobotToaster on Monday July 10, 2023 @05:21AM (#36663880)
Apparently you can't mention silencers at all? which even as a non American seems weird.
Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by flagrant_taco on Monday July 10, 2023 @08:57AM (#36665688)
Assuming you're talking about gun silencers/suppressors, the US has a very confusing history with them in general.

The way in which they made it into Congress's list of heavily regulated weapons is an interesting story of inept politicians at work. I've also never understood why suppressors would be seen as anything other than a good thing, if we wanted to regulate them it'd make more sense to require them for carry guns rather than make them hard to get.

Shooting an unsuppressed handgun without hearing protection is really bad for your hearing, and carrying a surpressed pistols also much trickier if we're concerned with how many guns are legally carried in public.

Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by Nasrudith on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @03:16AM (#36677487)
You know the abundance of Hollywood bullshit on AI going to kill us all? The same thing happened long ago with silencers as they forget about hearing damage from firearms because it isn't seen in movies but worry about "the dangers" of firearms being suppressed to non-hearing damaging levels by equating it with the classic "mouse-fart" level of volume.

Hollywood has a lot to answer for in its damage to epistemology.

Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by flagrant_taco on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @10:43PM (#36689870)
As far as I understand it these restrictions on suppressors predate any meaningful impact of Hollywood action films. Suppressors were included in restrictions from the prohibition era largely targeting the fear of the use of automatic weapons by organized crime (the mob).

Feds pictured everyone in the mafia carrying military-grade Thompsons (Tommy guns) despite the fact that they were horribly expensive, produced in small quantities, and didn't sell well. There are actually congressional record of the hearings for the weapons law that make clear no justification was given for including suppressors, it just wasn't pressed by anyone involved.

Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by Loocid on Sunday July 09, 2023 @07:49PM (#36660296)
>Reddit is/was so good because of the possibility that you might find something disturbing while using it.

Why do you consider that good? There are plenty of places on the internet where you can find disturbing content, why does it have to something you can just stumble upon?

Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by sli on Sunday July 09, 2023 @07:56PM (#36660348)
Because it's a relatively safe level of risk compared to, say, 4chan's /b/. People love to dabble in risk in safe ways. I'd argue that's what many genres of fiction are explicitly for, e.g. horror, violent games, etc.
Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by Loocid on Sunday July 09, 2023 @08:40PM (#36660632)
But it's only that way because Reddit placed limits which goes against the "let the internet be grimy" hot-take. Back in the day there were subreddits that would rival the depravity of /b/.
Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by watwut on Monday July 10, 2023 @03:11AM (#36663021)
They never stayed contained I their own subs. They just needed to go out of their way to subs of their perceived enemies.
Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by Tao3300 on Sunday July 09, 2023 @09:29PM (#36660974)
Yeah, we need something where the risk level is a little lower than the "it's a crime if I don't call the FBI and tell them I saw this" level.
Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by andsoitis on Sunday July 09, 2023 @08:05PM (#36660415)
> Why do you consider that good? There are plenty of places on the internet where you can find disturbing content, why does it have to something you can just stumble upon?

Because what's disturbing to me is not disturbing to someone else.

Because, just like when I walk in a city, I run into interesting and surprising and occasionally things that test my sensibilities.

This is good because nobody can decide on my behalf what I should find disturbing or not.

Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by Red_Leaves_Flyy on Monday July 10, 2023 @12:54AM (#36662264)
No one is arguing over what disturbs you. Many people are rightfully arguing that vulnerable populations should not be needlessly exposed to content that is widely considered to be disturbing. Have you heard of tor? There’s tons of disturbing in every flavor imaginable with seedy purveyors ready to create whatever content you desire, if you can afford it. Let’s keep that off the clear net and amongst the criminals, for the good of, oh geez, everyone? I encourage you to get your kicks there so that regular people on regular internet can go about their business without seeing CSAM/gore/violent crimes/etc.

Communities that harbor disturbing content *will not* scale because the majority of people are not interested in these things so the stakeholders of these venues rightfully police their domains to make them as inviting as possible to as many people as possible. I’m not sure what you’re actually arguing for here. Do you actually want to happen upon beheading videos or CSAM while you read this site or something?

Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by tourmalinetaco on Monday July 10, 2023 @01:39AM (#36662522)
No one is advocating for looking at CSAM (well, except you). In fact there wasn’t even the suggestion of that.

They have a right to enjoy the content they choose, as long as is it law-abiding. Regardless of if that upsets your sensibilities or not. Frankly, aside from trying to pull the age old “think of the children” routine, do you even have a point? You are arguing that harboring (legal) disturbing content is tantamount to CSAM and should be censored because it “will not scale”, meaning you are focusing on a for-profit lens. Despite the fact that the conversation topic, the Fediverse, is not for-profit.

Why does someone enjoying their time in a legal way bother you to the point of indirectly accusing them of viewing CSAM?

Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by Gordonjcp on Monday July 10, 2023 @04:58AM (#36663716)
> Regardless of if that upsets your sensibilities or not.

So you'd be happy if I surrounded your house with huge billboards covered in pictures of dicks, and puppies being thrown into scrap metal shredders?

Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by tourmalinetaco on Monday July 10, 2023 @05:13AM (#36663833)
Why are you spending so much money to buy and post billboards around my house specifically? That’s not a viable return on investment. Let alone a sensible argument.
Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by Gordonjcp on Monday July 10, 2023 @05:53AM (#36664087)
Why would you spend money to run a website?
Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by tourmalinetaco on Monday July 10, 2023 @01:54PM (#36670243)
Websites and billboards are not comparable. If anything ads would be more comparable. So now I have to ask, why are you wanting to advertise dicks?
Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by flagrant_taco on Monday July 10, 2023 @08:49AM (#36665581)
If that's really how you want to spend your money, what the billboard owner wants on their signs, and legal content thensure why couldn't you do that?

We can't be censoring anything we find offensive, or even worse anything we think might offend someone else. Trying to draw a line for what is legally banned content is enough of a gray area, there's absolutely no way to draw a line when the metric is what may offend someone.

Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by Red_Leaves_Flyy on Monday July 10, 2023 @08:25PM (#36674970)
>No one is advocating for looking at CSAM (well, except you). In fact there wasn’t even the suggestion of that.

You’re being awfully charitable with such a contrived interpretation of the comment above mine. Fact is they didn’t say what bad stuff they think should be allowed in prominent online spaces frequented by children and vulnerable populations, legal or otherwise. Having read enough about the salacious corners of the clear net, it’s rather safe to assume CSAM is among the bad stuff this person was vaguely referencing. It would be helpful if they provided an enumerated list of the crap they enjoy seeing but that would also require them to expose themselves. Do you see the contradiction and need to read between the lines here?Every platform, even moderated one’s, faces this problem: Twitter, Facebook, instagram, Reddit, all of them. I’m not encouraging people to seek this stuff out, and your accusation that I am stands in stark contrast to the charity you gave the person above. Concerning. Regardless, if that’s their thing I hope they walk right into a honeypot.

>You are arguing that harboring (legal) disturbing content is tantamount to CSAM and should be censored because it “will not scale”, meaning you are focusing on a for-profit lens. Despite the fact that the conversation topic, the Fediverse, is not for-profit.

Bad faith argument and patent misinterpretation. Reddit, the front page of the internet, is mentioned in the context above and largely what I’m arguing in regards to. To be explicit, Reddit is not a federated platform and is for profit, and it’s reasonable to speculate on the intentions of the platforms leadership, especially when they state explicitly that they want more money. I’m not interested in arguing about what grimy stuff nobodies get up to on the fedoverse. It’s probably a lot like 4chan or the sites that spring up when abusive groups get hit by a ban wave on larger platforms: gab, truth social. The fefiverse will likely remain fringe for the foreseeable future for this very reason and isn’t an interesting discussion due to the limited audience. grimy people drive valuable/helpful users away necessitating the removal of said bad actors. Also, I’m not interested in the profitability of platforms. I’m interested in the health of the communities and grimy content pushes normal people away reducing the health of the community. I don’t care that the person above wants to look at grimy stuff, I care when the same people want to see their perverse interests made mainstream which is exactly what many people are arguing for, with concerningly vague terminology, in this thread. Gross.

ETA Interesting you didn’t speak to beheading videos…

Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by Loocid on Monday July 10, 2023 @02:02AM (#36662658)
>Because, just like when I walk in a city, I run into interesting and surprising and occasionally things that test my sensibilities.

Using your simile: cities aren't lawless wastelands just because some people like living in chaos, and neither should the internet be (in my opinion). Cities have places where more extreme content can be found for those that want it but is kept away from the general public. Why shouldn't the internet be the same?

Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by andsoitis on Monday July 10, 2023 @05:12PM (#36673031)
It’s a spectrum. Cities are more chaotic and unpredictable and fun than Disneyland.
Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by strken on Sunday July 09, 2023 @08:44PM (#36660659)
I don't use Reddit outside a few niche communities that unfortunately have a presence there, but disturbing content (as in genuinely disturbing, not merely porn and dead people) broadens one's horizons.

Here are some disturbing things I've run across that I'm glad to have seen:

The Wethouse, a documentary on an alcohol-allowed hostel for alcoholics: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MF5wNsfKo84

Putin's essay "On the historical unity of Russians and Ukrainians": en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/66181 (it should be obvious from the literal kremlin.ru domain and the fact it's by Putin, but you want to read this one critically)

/r/deathgainers, a community of fetishists literally eating themselves to death and being egged on by other fetishists (no URL because it probably got wiped out in the drama and because it is actual porn; see also pro-anorexia communities, which for some reason tend to be banned while deathgainers are allowed)

Blindsight by Peter Watts, a hard-biology science fiction novel that raises questions about how we think: https://www.rifters.com/real/Blindsight.htm

The disturbing parts of the internet are more worthwhile than the Skinner boxes and can encourage more personal growth. Certainly if you're only a little concerned about the amount you drink, watching The Wethouse will change that; if you're sitting there in July of 2021 and not too worried about whether Russia will start a land war in Europe, reading Putin's essay and its echoes of blood-and-soil will change that too; if you eat too little or too much, seeing the fatal effects can be a wake-up call.

Many moderation policies would block some or all of those, though The Wethouse and Blindsight might escape. I'm glad to have seen all of them. I'm not sure whether I would have, if I had to explicitly go to the designated deviant zone and wade through thousands of gigs of porn to find them.

Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by Tao3300 on Sunday July 09, 2023 @09:37PM (#36661000)
Blindsight is disturbing? I guess the Captain did some questionable things...

I liked that book a lot. It'd be a tragedy to find that being censored anywhere.

Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by User23 on Sunday July 09, 2023 @09:42PM (#36661030)
I think the more disturbing part is the implications of consciousness being a kind of globally maladaptive local optimum. And it’s neat how the aliens are basically GPT-99.

That the protagonist had half his brain amputated is pretty squick too.

The vampire stuff isn’t really disturbing at all.

Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by Tao3300 on Sunday July 09, 2023 @09:56PM (#36661132)
The vampire stuff isn't disturbing per se, but:

uᴉɐʇdɐɔ ǝɥʇ ʎllɐǝɹ ʇ,usᴉ ǝɹᴉdɯɐʌ ǝɥʇ

Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by User23 on Sunday July 09, 2023 @09:41PM (#36661020)
* * *
Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by watwut on Monday July 10, 2023 @03:13AM (#36663029)
It is agood thing that US presidents don't write ahistorical self serving bs like this. Not that they would be saints, but not being Putin is a good thing.
Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by RobotToaster on Monday July 10, 2023 @05:20AM (#36663869)
Have you read George Bush's autobiography?
Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by flagrant_taco on Monday July 10, 2023 @08:52AM (#36665615)
I wonder if George Bush ever read George Bush's autobiography
Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by red-iron-pine on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @01:45PM (#36684538)
Obama was the head of the Harvard Law Review before getting active in politics, and almost certainly was a decent writer.

You're also assuming that Putin actually wrote this himself. I don't think it's impossible -- he was in the KGB and FSB, analysis could be something he's trained heavily in -- but if I had to bet money it's not his writing, just his byline.

Furthermore, even it it was his work it missed the mark pretty hard, and a lot of dudes are dying due to terrible assumptions made about Ukraine and it's military.

Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by api on Monday July 10, 2023 @08:48PM (#36675119)
Blindsight is an amazing sci-fi novel. It should be more well known.

I described it as cosmic horror where the monster is a thesis from evolutionary game theory… and the big reveal is actually scary.

About as high brow as you can get but manages it without being boorish or purple prose.

Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by LexiMax on Sunday July 09, 2023 @07:56PM (#36660349)
One of the reasons I find myself continuing to use the fediverse is because in many ways it reminds me of the old internet. There are parts of it that are rowdy and salacious like old Reddit and 4chan, but if just want a shared space to nerd out with like-minded people about hobbies and shared interests, you can have the early-2000's hobby forum experience as well.

And it's all very brand-unfriendly - there's relatively few celebrities, no advertising space to sell, no algorithm to optimize for, and nothing preventing a possible promotional post from a corporate account from appearing next to something NSFW in someone's timeline if that's who the user is following.

Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by nefarious_ends on Sunday July 09, 2023 @10:04PM (#36661178)
where can I get started learning more about this fediverse?
Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by SturgeonsLaw on Sunday July 09, 2023 @10:59PM (#36661532)
For the most early-Reddit-like experience, I would recommend Lemmy.

I was kinda interested in checking it out for a while but suffered from a bit of choice paralysis not knowing where to start, but since most of them are federated, you see content from a bunch of instances at once, so that removes a bit of the risk.

I ended up creating an account on lemmy.world which is (afaik) the largest instance by user count. Beehaw is (afaik) the second largest, and it has more of a "safety"/highly moderated approach - which is one of the reasons I wanted to distance myself from Reddit, so I crossed that one off my list.

This map was posted on HN if you want to examine the relative sizes of the instances and see the lay of the land: https://lemmymap.feddit.de/

Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by Eavolution on Monday July 10, 2023 @04:14AM (#36663431)
Personally I prefer using kbin, that's another option. Kbin and lemmy both can communicate so it doesn't matter which you use. feddit.de and kbin.social are kbin instances.
Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by twic on Monday July 10, 2023 @01:41PM (#36669975)
Great map! Sadly retarded.dev seems to be down, and there's no way i'm visiting cybercrime.zip at work.
Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by newoldhead on Monday July 10, 2023 @07:37AM (#36664943)
go to instances.social, pick a relatively small one and sign up for an account. now you're on mastodon and have a fediverse account. this account can interact with everything fediverse, from mastodon to pleroma to pixelfed to peertube. decentralized to the max. (don't join mastodon.social)
Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by red-iron-pine on Monday July 10, 2023 @02:35PM (#36670967)
lemmy.world

browse around, see how you like it

Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by bigger_inside on Monday July 10, 2023 @05:07AM (#36663795)
This. I want a brand-unfriendly internet, though of course putting it that way again puts the commercial aspect and the internet's relation to it front and center. I want an internet that isn't built commercially, not with monetization in mind. There are still places - AO3 is completely unsuited to any commercial association, and it is still the fanfiction center of the internet. Places like literotica survived the ages.

Of course, when regulatory moral panics take hold of it, they never say out loud that what they really protect and defend is commercial use...

Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by bobsmooth on Sunday July 09, 2023 @08:03PM (#36660397)
Checkout rdrama.net
Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by Tao3300 on Sunday July 09, 2023 @09:26PM (#36660951)
Can I find out on Threads what happens to a man when his shirtsleeve gets caught in an industrial lathe?

Can I find offensive jokes? Or will I just get headlines about someone who got in trouble for an offensive joke?

Can I post the raunchy limerick I've never written down for fear of being cancelled, doxxed, etc?

Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by thaumasiotes on Sunday July 09, 2023 @11:21PM (#36661676)
> Can I post the raunchy limerick I've never written down for fear of being cancelled, doxxed, etc?

You can already do that on Facebook.

Whether you see any consequences is more of a function of whether someone sets out to get you for something than it is of what you write.

Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by Red_Leaves_Flyy on Monday July 10, 2023 @01:04AM (#36662335)
Have you tried working for a mid sized privately owned company with a less than stellar reputation in a deeply conservative and economically depressed area? That sounds right up your alley, the guys will love your jokes and anyone that would be offended has likely already self selected out of those communities for the reasons you so eloquently elucidated.
Re:Let the Internet Be Grimy by chromanoid on Monday July 10, 2023 @05:41AM (#36664004)
While I agree with the sentiment of the article I can do without link traps that take me to a chainsaw execution gif under the guise of wedding bloopers.