The policies could be hidden from the vast majority of informed public opinion in a way Western conspiracists or whataboutists alike can only dream is really correspondent or directly analogous to mainstream media manipulation.
It can still be true that China’s no one’s enemy except that the Party is everyone’s enemy (while the Chinese population will be the last ones to realize it).
Aside from the money standard and zero COVID bits, every part of this is true of the US. This conflict just boils down to “the hegemon doesn’t want any competition.”
> they undercut western manufacturing and all our manufacturing went there.
America’s oligarchs did this to the country. China just leveraged their short-sightedness and greed to the country’s own advantage.
It wasn’t just the effete slaver elite who opposed the tariff policy which kept funding Northern urbanization (a heritage of legacy institutions and robber-baron philanthropies and culture that’s retained there to this day) at Southern exports’ disadvantage and expense; it was the broader population. That’s pretty broadly explanatory…
Who knows if northern cities would have been the economic successes of the pre-Depression Era without that parasitic reverse subsidy through Congressional imbalances? Was ending slavery just a handy pretext for hegemony, then, just as on the Southern side the states’ rights issues were beholden to the argument for or against slave-keeping?
I’m not ready to claim that but it seems like you may ought to be, if this is how you view the West and the rest, with South lumped right into Yanqui kleptokapitalism that the South fought back against. It seems like an infinite regress of progressive virtue posturing results to hope to find, much less retain, a humanist alternative.
So far you said nothing to make my suggestion incompatible with anything beyond your preference. Whereas I was addressing the base assumptions of his or her attempt at criticism as I understand him or her to have seen fit to offer them. Being generous to your intentions, you have written, “By your own logic if you don’t like diverting the flow of an argument, then don’t do so in turn thx,” whereas I was writing, “By bugglebeetle’s own logic, if you don’t like mendacious hegemony so much that you think China and the US are only rivals against Africa and other tributaries, then why do you seem unhappy that anyone would distinguish themselves from the default, since we’re then all just taking turns anyhow betraying humankindness?” I hope that helps defuse the harshness of your commentary. If not, have a nice July 4th weekend, and enjoy our costly independence as the wheat and weeds continue to grow up in the same sunlight just like always. Peace.
The point was to bring slavery to the West. Not just for the free labor, but because slaves suppress the wages of everyone. The sons of the south getting mowed down in the trenches were fighting for those barons whose prosperity was dependent on their poverty. African slaves meant there was always readily identifiable people worse off than you.
The US doesn’t operate the world’s largest international surveillance network, including wide-scale spying on our ostensible allies, out of the goodness of its own heart.
> predatory infrastructure loans
Google “History of the IMF”
>Trade with sanction companies
The US dictates the sanction regime to its ideological and economic benefit. The US has done things like help perpetrate one of the worst genocides in modern history (Indonesia), but sure, Cuba is really scary and shouldn’t be able to buy medical supplies.
We’ve changed our laws to legalize corruption and subsidize export of key industries. Steel is hardly made in Cleveland and Pittsburgh anymore for a simple reason: our tax and regulatory structure was reformed, and makes it more profitable to ship that business to China or Mexico.
Recently, they've also sanctioned Australia after the Australian government requested an independent investigation into the origins of the virus. This escalated into a one-sided trade war, particularly targeting Australian barley, wine and iron/steel exports.
As well as Norway, in 2010, after the independent Norwegian Nobel committee granted the Nobel Peace Prize to jailed Chinese human rights activist Liu Xiaobo.
What is your opinion?
I offer this more for the sake of enlightenment and amusement than anything else.
Those interested might want to look at this as well: https://creativelawcenter.com/dickens-american-copyright
Predatory infrastructure loans: that's what USAID, IMF and World Bank are basically set up to do.
He was the most spectacular but hardly an isolated case. https://hbswk.hbs.edu/archive/trade-secrets-intellectual-pir...
We've been narrated to over the years that they are our enemies, yes.
> They use (basically) slave labor, unethical materials (e.g. live plucking), environmentally damaging materials (e.g. banned CFCs), they happily pollute the earth as if tomorrow isn't a concern.
Why is this all of a sudden a problem when China does it, but not when our firms do this in their off-shore sweatshops and subsidiaries and mining and agricultural interests?
It sounds like all of these things aren't a problem, it's that we aren't profiting from them that's the problem.
Ethically, they are our enemies in the same scope that our multi-nationals are our enemies. They too are incompatible with human rights and democracy.
It's certainly a problem! But the only thing we can really do about it is pass laws.
If it were a problem, Washington could get it resolved in a year.
It's not a problem, because half the people bankrolling political campaigns are neck-deep in it! Their businesses are built on it! On cheap labour, on captive markets, on sources of third-world resources that are accessed through theft, violence, or corruption!
And even if you aren't directly involved, our society will not function very well if we stop reaping the benefits of all the practices I've described. Nobody wants to pay $90 for a t-shirt, or $9 for a gallon of gas.
1. The west is doing immoral things and hiding it. Let's talk about it and force people in charge to change things or change the people in charge!
Or:
2. The west is doing immoral things. Let's root for these other guys who are also doing immoral things; eventually they will replace the west and then somebody will figure out how to stop them from doing the immoral things.
I think (2) is predicated on the fact that the west wrong doings are so old and irreparable and so they can be only washed away through a complete blank slate rewrite of the geopolitical order.
I think this is a relatively "natural" effect of our human psychology. We have an innate sense of "punishing" people and we often find ways to rationalize and explain why they should be punished. However these instincts are ill suited to handle geopolitics because there are many more people involved that the "tribe" size of our natural selection environment and also because the time scale of the changes is usually much longer than what people are used to in their day to day relationships.
I think logic (2) is flawed because once the new power structure is formed it will be hard to change exactly like (1) or even worse. Furthermore it will have done immoral things for quite some time by then because changes to geopolitical power balances will take a long time to actuate and thus they new power will also become "irreparable" and the only thing left to do will be to root for the next "underdog".
"The west is doing immoral things and hiding it"
The propaganda aspect you're mentioning is an integral part of "hiding it".
I don't think you're framing changes the options on the table: either you try to fix the system from within our you somehow hope that the others will be better just because.
Those factories migrated to the US South, then to Mexico, then to China. Not because of some conspiracy, but because we run our institutions based on quarterly financials.
I worked a long time ago on an effort to sue a large manufacturer whose supply chain was shipping counterfeit parts to certain customers. The Chinese partners ran a third shift with no QC and stuffed these parts into the distribution chain. They also stole defective parts and did the same thing. Everyone knew this was happening. But everyone was making money, so nobody gave a shit.
With respect to politics, well yeah, they are the other great power now. It’s in their interest to buffer themselves from whatever they perceive as a threat. The US is no babe in the woods here - our war plan from the 1950s onward was to attack China with nuclear weapons if the Soviets rolled into East Berlin - just in case.
The Chinese can’t compete with the US with air or sea power, so they seek to control their sphere of influence in other ways, and slowly build in preparation for the US decline in power.
China won this round fair and square... The smartest thing the west can do from now on is dump fiat currencies, switch to crypto and leave China holding the paper, but the longer the west fails to acknowledge that China beat it at its own game, the further it will fall.
Seriously? WTF?
From my perspective as a citizen, my government sold me out to China without my consent and now expects me to service the fiat paper which is now in their hands.
It's never the politicians or the elites who have to service all those IUOs that they hand out. If it was, they would probably hold onto them a little bit tighter.
As if China is the only country that holds US paper. This sort of idea is what could very well start WWIII.
No one has solved the elderly exploitation problem yet for the existing banking system. Not sure why it would be fair to hold crypto to a higher standard.
How did the government anoint Microsoft, Apple, Google, and Facebook?
If Americans could vote on their preferred time intervals to manage towards, they wouldn't pick quarterly. Quarterly screws the overwhelming majority of people who care about the future.But it's not up for discussion, debate or the political process.
It's similar to US foreign military aid. Nothing anyone says or does will change it. Whoever or whatever controls it is beyond the reach of the political process, at least the part that 99% of people can participate in.
People treat quarterly myopia like an emergent phenomenon, like it's some kind of maximum that the country naturally converged upon. Except there's nothing natural about it, and it only benefits a small number of unaccountable people.
I know someone who quite recently died of Covid. There is no longer a pandemic, but the virus is still deadly. Their concern is justified.
Economically, the US is critically dependent on China for facilitating consumer demand. The US cannot afford an adversary in China.
Ethically, the US is not offering a compelling framework or alternative that alleviates the issues you raise. This is a real concern.
China has lifted hundreds of millions of people directly out of extreme poverty. This is their prerogative and modus operandi.
The only way forward is cooperation, adjustment and coordination.
Regarding “lifting people out of poverty”, did hundreds of millions of people’s hard work have anything to do with lifting _themselves_ out of poverty or does the CCP get all the credit? If CCP gets the credit, there was certainly a lot of “trial and error” before they got it right. Was it worth the lives of 30 million people?
[1]: https://www.businessinsider.com/wuhans-mask-less-pool-party-...
Of course the moment you let Americans in to your country, you've given up your battle against COVID since we decided to just let it rip.
China's not the only country that tried a zero COVID policy and for a while it was working in other places too thanks to management techniques, travel restrictions, quarantines, etc. (New Zealand is one, iirc) But when one of the biggest and most powerful countries in the world decides to just give up on the fight nobody else is going to win.
I mean it is not actually a matter of belief. We know how infectious COVID was, and we know life in China pretty much resumed as normal by August 2020, except for hard lockdowns wherever a case popped up. You cannot hide exponential growth of infections, it is simply impossible.
China made the wrong decision and almost sparked an internal collapse. They lost the youth and the hopelessness in the country is palpable.
Did anyone try and fail at that point? Were there experiments that tried to achieve zero covid, exhausted all practical methods and still failed?
I'd argue that even today, zero covid is not "scientifically" proven practically impossible. The fact that China tried and failed does not mean it's inherently practically impossible. For all I can tell, it's only "practically impossible" because only China was able to pull off the authoritarian measures to suppress the spread of the virus. In a more authoritarian world, we might have been able to eradicate covid. Does your "science" include a deep discourse in political systems?
-R0 was quite high
-Animals can hold and spread the virus, so even after vaccinations of humans it was going to be in the background
-not every country was trying for zero Covid, therefore at some point in the future if you ever hope to have an open border with a country that has open borders with that country, you get it eventually.
-there are no 100% secure borders
The matter of Tibet is complex, and I think "definitively" is handwaving away a lot of Tibetan history.
I think yours is the best reply to the post that reads more like a tantrum.
Wow, you make it sound like it was some devious Chinese plan where they intentionally made their people work for American manufacturers and lured them in with bribes.
The reality was that American corporations willingly went over to China because number must go up and paying their own people living factory wages wasn’t cutting it.
So tired of this stance - “China did it to us!”
America did it to itself.
Corporations outsourced manufacturing to China, because American corporations are independent from the US government and profit-motivated.
Ok buddy.
If GE decides it wants to build widgets in another country, GE does.
Make it more profitable (or at least net neutral) to manufacture onshore or nearshore.
A key start to it would probably be to (a) implement a carbon tax on all goods that enter the US via international maritime trade, according to the footprint of their transportation, (b) use the proceeds exclusively to fund a recapitalization of US merchant shipping [0] (new generation lower emission design construction and operation).
Preferably in cooperation with the EU.
Modernizing the provisions of the Jones Act [1] to support US shipbuilding and flagging for inter-national oceanic trade would be a good start.
Merchant shipping, like energy, is a pillar that a country's economy rests on, and shipyards are dual-use heavy economic assets with direct military implications.
[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_merchant_navy_capaci...
[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Merchant_Marine_Act_of_1920
American citizens could have voted with their wallets, and they could have voted at the booths to elect governments that would regulate the flow of American jobs overseas. But they didn't, and so here we are.
In the Chinese system, that's the market but always capped by political and CCP decisions, if they deign to care.
In the American system, that's resolutely only the market. The government has some limited second order control (tariffs, industrial policy, national security exclusions), but generally didn't use them against China 1990-2018.
Ergo, the deciders moving manufacturing to China were the CEOs of American companies, optimizing their own production costs.
I'd be curious to see an analysis of the rise of Walmart (and immolation of Sears) and later Target vis-a-vis Chinese manufacturing of consumer goods sold in America. I'd be surprised if the centralization of point-of-sale (vs previous more diverse and independent stores) didn't incentivize bulk, low-cost offshore manufacturing via volume.
So it's really more accurate to say that America chose to allow it to be profitable for corporations to outsource. Government policy could easily have been the opposite. So ultimately, America did do it to itself.
(BTW I'm not arguing this would have necessarily been good policy. Just that it is very much an explicit governmental decision.)
That's not how the world works. It takes years to switch a manufacturer depending on terms, who owns the molds, etc.
Placing tarrifs on China hurts American consumers. Instead, there should be tax incentives for producing stateside.
> It's the US companies that pay the tarrifs.
No, customers pay the tarriffs at the end of the day. Companies raise the prices of imported goods to cover the tarriffs, and tarriffs in this case are set so that the final retail price of imported goods matches (or exceeds) the domestic manufacturing price.
> The concept of 'if we increase the tarrifs, US manufacturing will come back"... It takes years...
The idea is generally to have tarriffs from the beginning so manufacturing never leaves. Because you're right, otherwise it does take years.
> Placing tarrifs on China hurts American consumers. Instead, there should be tax incentives for producing stateside.
There's no difference, they harm consumers equally. Corporate tax incentives mean reduced government income which needs to be made up for with... higher personal taxes. Or higher corporate taxes in other sectors which lead to higher prices. No matter what, the consumer is paying.
Tarriffs or tax incentives have the same effect, but tax incentives are usually much more difficult to design and limit corporate flexibility in bad ways that are hard to foresee. Tarriffs have much more reliable enforcement and predictable effects.
This depends on the product and the type of demand. If it's inelastic, yes. if it's consumer focused, yes. But most of the time that's not the case. Tarrifs on material exports ar b2b, where pricing agreements are common.
At the end of the day, tarrifs create downward pressure on companies profit margins. If you instead, gave incentives it would put upward pressure on the companies who created fucundity for the economy.
Most people on HN basically have no idea what Marxism is, what the road to socialism is about, the stages of socialism, or why China really does what they do. I don't watch Xi's speeches on YouTube, but you could if you really wanted to.
They treat "not free market capitalism" as a monolith of ideas and states.
Even a light reading of Marxist economic theory with some other adjacent authors like Lenin, Mao, Trotsky, etc. would make clear exactly why Dengism was needed and why it worked and why Xi finds it necessary to return to straight Marxism.
The worst part is how greedy corporate oligarchs of the US sent all the jobs to China. That made Dengism work really well.
I mean, I don't really know what to say. If you wanted China to lose or not be Marxist, the US did a really bad job. It's really clear the only long-term planning the US does is lining pockets and that's probably going to be the death of the country.
But this is HN, so please pretend like I was complaining about wokeness or whatever other imaginary problem is popular here.
Notice that western itself is a collective of nation but all hell breaks lose if non western got manufacturing am I rite?
Having said that be thankful for ultra scaling up manufacturing in East Asia. Appliances and electronic prices keeps falling. Compare that to services or "western" exclusive manufacturing like vehicles, getting inflated like crazy.
I mean, not to say they aren’t bad but we need to have more acknowledgement of the things our countries did in the past and why they were wrong, and looking to make reparations where possible, and not just hypocritically pretending that we didn’t do them while accusing other emerging powers of the things we did…
The disturb the global standard, which happens to benefit the US greatly while hurting the rest of the world (especially the global south). Terrible!
> They use (basically) slave labor,
While it is true that China has a lot of manual labor and less worker rights than most western states, China isnt the sweatshop it used to be anymore.
Nearly every "simple" labor intensive industry, like textile industry, has moved to countries like Bangladesh, while strangely no one seems to care about their slave labor.
Also, wasn't the "slave labor" the reason why the US cooperated with China, essentially making them what they are today? [1]
> They manipulate their currency.
How dare they? https://brrr.money
> They entrap other nations with predatory loans for infrastructure.
I could write a book about this but whatcha doin' over there? [2]
> they happily pollute the earth as if tomorrow isn't a concern.
China is ranking 48 in Co2 emissions per capita, the US in ranking 14 (2021) [3]
Also they are investing more into renewable energy than every other country, by far [4]
> They are scraping the ocean clean to feed their people.
China fished 11.7 million metric tons in 2020, the US fished 4.23 million metric tons, China fishes approx. three times as much as the US. [5]
But China has 1.4 billion citizens, while the US has 331 million citizens, so China has over 4 times the citizens.
Also the average Chinese eats 40.3kg of fish every year, while average American eats 22.2kg of fish every year. [6]
So to sum up: China fishes three times as much as the US, while having 4 times the population that eats nearly twice as much fish as a US citizen does.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chimerica
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oil-for-Food_Programme
[3] https://www.dw.com/en/fact-check-is-china-the-main-climate-c...
[4] https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/china-invests-546...
[5] https://www.statista.com/statistics/240225/leading-fishing-n...
[6] https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/fish-and-seafood-consumpt...
Then this shall be taken as a counterpoint to the narratives you pointed to :)
the world is tired of the US finding applying double standards to whoever they want to make their enemy.
Here are some:
Economically, they're an adversary; they undercut western manufacturing and all our manufacturing went there. They manipulate their currency. They interfere with foreign owned businesses. They steal IP. They're seeking to upset the global money standard. They entrap other nations with predatory loans for infrastructure. They trade with our other enemies and flaunt sanctions, etc, etc.
Ethically, they're our adversary: They use (basically) slave labor, unethical materials (e.g. live plucking), environmentally damaging materials (e.g. banned CFCs), they happily pollute the earth as if tomorrow isn't a concern. They are scraping the ocean clean to feed their people. They oppress their citizens, they operate a crude faux-democracy, they have embarked on an extremely damaging zero covid approach long after it ceased to be relevant to save face for creating it, etc, etc.
Politically, they're our adversary, insulting foreign politicians, trying to annexe land and sea that definitively isn't theirs (Tibet, "South China" Sea), engaging in brinksmanship to force the issue, etc.
These are all things from media stories that I can think of from the top of my head. Not exactly representation as a best friend.