So far you said nothing to make my suggestion incompatible with anything beyond your preference. Whereas I was addressing the base assumptions of his or her attempt at criticism as I understand him or her to have seen fit to offer them. Being generous to your intentions, you have written, “By your own logic if you don’t like diverting the flow of an argument, then don’t do so in turn thx,” whereas I was writing, “By bugglebeetle’s own logic, if you don’t like mendacious hegemony so much that you think China and the US are only rivals against Africa and other tributaries, then why do you seem unhappy that anyone would distinguish themselves from the default, since we’re then all just taking turns anyhow betraying humankindness?” I hope that helps defuse the harshness of your commentary. If not, have a nice July 4th weekend, and enjoy our costly independence as the wheat and weeds continue to grow up in the same sunlight just like always. Peace.
The point was to bring slavery to the West. Not just for the free labor, but because slaves suppress the wages of everyone. The sons of the south getting mowed down in the trenches were fighting for those barons whose prosperity was dependent on their poverty. African slaves meant there was always readily identifiable people worse off than you.
It wasn’t just the effete slaver elite who opposed the tariff policy which kept funding Northern urbanization (a heritage of legacy institutions and robber-baron philanthropies and culture that’s retained there to this day) at Southern exports’ disadvantage and expense; it was the broader population. That’s pretty broadly explanatory…
Who knows if northern cities would have been the economic successes of the pre-Depression Era without that parasitic reverse subsidy through Congressional imbalances? Was ending slavery just a handy pretext for hegemony, then, just as on the Southern side the states’ rights issues were beholden to the argument for or against slave-keeping?
I’m not ready to claim that but it seems like you may ought to be, if this is how you view the West and the rest, with South lumped right into Yanqui kleptokapitalism that the South fought back against. It seems like an infinite regress of progressive virtue posturing results to hope to find, much less retain, a humanist alternative.