News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by JustBreath on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:31AM (#36520852)
Whatever your opinion about recent supreme court decisions, this has all underscored what has been true for a long time:

Legislating via the judicial branch is a bad idea.

If it only takes 5 out of 9 people to make laws for 600 million, it only takes one seat change to revert them.

(Edit: sorry, 300 - pre-caffeine posting)

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by DeathArrow on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:32AM (#36520870)
But somehow, some people only feel the need to mention it when they don't like the result.
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by yanderekko on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:22AM (#36521645)
Yep. Roe vs. Wade was one of the most egregious examples of "legislating from the bench" in the latter 20th century? How many people who would hand-wring over recent SCOTUS decisions oppose Roe on these grounds? Or is this a convenient exception? Griswold? How about Lawrence vs. Texas?
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by mehlmao on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:57PM (#36523223)
Please explain how Henry Wade could enforce the overturned Texas Penal Code statutes without violating the constitutional right to privacy.
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by Aunche on Thursday June 29, 2023 @04:19PM (#36526135)
In the right to privacy is so broad that it applies to abortion, it should also apply to self-medicating yourself with narcotics. I'm not saying that decriminalization of drugs is a bad thing, but it's something that obviously shouldn't be decided by the Supreme Court.
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by yanderekko on Thursday June 29, 2023 @06:09PM (#36527485)
Yep, and if it applies to abortion, why not third-trimester abortion? Why is that relevant to a privacy interest?

Where is the right to privacy in the Constitution, btw? Sounds like the whole thing is legislating from the bench! Maybe we should bring back Lochner-style scrutiny of minimum wage laws under a newly-discovered "right to earn a living"?

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by dragonwriter on Thursday June 29, 2023 @06:13PM (#36527534)
> Where is the right to privacy in the Constitution, btw?

People inevitably making this argument was actually the primary argument against adopting a Bill of Rights at all, and the Ninth Amendment was the compromise solution to have some enumerated rights while hoping to negate this exact argument.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by ericmay on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:23AM (#36521660)
Right, like how the SCOTUS rejected the Independent State Legislature theory case. Some people were like "we really shouldn't be legislating from the bench", but when the SCOTUS overturned Roe v Wade they cheered it on.
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by JustBreath on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:39AM (#36521934)
> Some people were like "we really shouldn't be legislating from the bench", but when the SCOTUS overturned Roe v Wade they cheered it on.

That's internally consistent. Roe V. Wade was the bench legislation in this case.

The citizenship rights in the constitution were not written or otherwise intended to provide a right to abortions.

Even the concept of privacy the decision was based on is inferred only from the statement "deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law."

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by mywittyname on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:00PM (#36522248)
The constitution doesn't enumerate every right a citizen has. It's a framework for judges (and congress) to determine what laws can and cannot be applied to citizens. The right to abortion was ruled to be protected by the 4th amendment.

While this case is held up as being the legislating from the bench case, it's really not. We don't generally pass laws that make something legal, except as exceptions to other laws. Saying that government access to a person's medical records is protected by the constitution is exactly the function of SCOTUS.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by lolinder on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:19PM (#36522541)
Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg would have disagreed with you there, and I think she's more qualified than you to comment on the function of the Court:

> Casual observers of the Supreme Court who came to the Law School to hear Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg speak about Roe v. Wade likely expected a simple message from the longtime defender of reproductive and women’s rights: Roe was a good decision.

> Those more acquainted with Ginsburg and her thoughtful, nuanced approach to difficult legal questions were not surprised, however, to hear her say just the opposite, that Roe was a faulty decision. For Ginsburg, the landmark 1973 Supreme Court decision that affirmed a woman’s right to an abortion was too far-reaching and too sweeping, and it gave anti-abortion rights activists a very tangible target to rally against in the four decades since.

> “My criticism of Roe is that it seemed to have stopped the momentum on the side of change,” Ginsburg said. She would’ve preferred that abortion rights be secured more gradually, in a process that included state legislatures and the courts, she added. Ginsburg also was troubled that the focus on Roe was on a right to privacy, rather than women’s rights.

https://www.law.uchicago.edu/news/justice-ruth-bader-ginsbur...

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by selimthegrim on Thursday June 29, 2023 @06:27PM (#36527695)
Ginsburg wanted to reopen the privileges or immunities clause.
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by xienze on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:49PM (#36523076)
> The right to abortion was ruled to be protected by the 4th amendment.

The right to abortion is guaranteed by the right to be free from "unreasonable search and seizure." That is literally the best ever example of squinting REALLY hard at the constitution and trying to make something fit. Roe was 100% making a legal argument for abortion to be regulated at the federal level using the most twisted pretzel logic imaginable.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by dragonwriter on Thursday June 29, 2023 @01:00PM (#36523287)
> The right to abortion is guaranteed by the right to be free from “unreasonable search and seizure.” That is literally the best ever example of squinting REALLY hard at the constitution and trying to make something fit.

No, its just a typo, Roe rested on the Due Process Clause of the 14th Amendment, not any provision of the 4th. “A state criminal abortion statute of the current Texas type, that excepts from criminality only a lifesaving procedure on behalf of the mother, without regard to pregnancy stage and without recognition of the other interests involved, is violative of the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.” (It in passing mentions other previous cases relating to privacy rights which found aspects of them other places in the Constitution, including, among many others, the combination of the Fourth and Fifth Amendments in Terry v. Ohio, but no part of the rule articulated in Roe purported to be interpreting the Fourth Amendment, only the 14th.)

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by xdennis on Thursday June 29, 2023 @09:39PM (#36529487)
When the constitution was written, some states allowed abortion and some banned it.

It makes sense therefore that there was no non-enumerated right to abortion, and states did have the right to ban it.

The 1973 decision was most definitively legislating from behind the bench.

It will probably only be banned after both the right and the left get burned by this type of legislating enough times.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by defrost on Thursday June 29, 2023 @09:57PM (#36529612)
Which US state(s) that ratified the US Consitution in 1790 made abortion (particularly pre quickening (~24 weeks)) illegal?

Most sources I can find suggest none.

Eg:

    Abortion has existed in North America since the European colonization of the Americas, was a fairly common practice, and was not always illegal or controversial.

    Until the 19th century, abortion was legal under common law, and only after quickening it was not allowed.
and

    Though it is considered taboo in Christian traditions, until the mid-19th century, “the Catholic Church implicitly accepted early abortions prior to ensoulment,” she explained. “Not until 1869, at about the same time that abortion became politicized in this country, did the church condemn abortion; in 1895, it condemned therapeutic abortion,” meaning procedures to save a woman’s life.
and

     Legal scholar Sheldon Gelman has argued that the U.S. Constitution (1789) imported the tenets of the English Magna Carta (1215), which includes the basis of the right to bodily integrity including abortion.

    Connecticut was the first state to regulate abortion in 1821; it outlawed abortion after quickening and forbade the use of poisons to induce one post-quickening.
etc.
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by nunuvit on Friday June 30, 2023 @05:29AM (#36532358)
I don't want to debate this particular decision, but I do want to point out that you're taking some dubious legal concepts for granted.

There are opposing legal philosophies on how to interpret amendments 9 and 10, which say that people have rights and the government has powers. The question is always how to resolve when the two are in conflict.

Current SCOTUS majority holds an extremist view that when government exercises an unenumerated power, it essentially cancels the existence of an unenumerated right. That's why they look for historical laws that support their desired outcomes. Until recently, this was a fringe idea because it means the state governments get dibs on your unenumerated rights.

You're entitled to your opinion on this approach, but don't expect everyone to take that reasoning seriously.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by ellisv on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:33AM (#36521844)
How was rejecting ISL was legislating from the bench?
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by mjh2539 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:40AM (#36520999)
There's only approximately 330 million of us, but yes, your main point is correct. I think that judicial activism has led to a perversion of both the legislative and the judicial branches. Why try to pass legislation that requires broad consent and lots of work when you can just bank on getting your policies through via the judiciary? At the same time, why constrain the judiciary's decisions on something as irrelevant and inflexible as the constitution?
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by kenjackson on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:36AM (#36520927)
I don’t love the decision, but I actually like the process. And I don’t think it is legislating. It is interpreting the law.

I’d like term limits on Supreme Court justices. But I think the arguments on both sides of this debate are well thought out.

Again I don’t love the decision, but Im OK with it. That said I’d love to see universities stop giving weight to legacies. But the money is just too strong.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by zapataband1 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:54AM (#36521224)
When a neoconservative spends his life petitioning courts for this exact result instead of petitioning anyone in congress... it feels like dirty legislating. Part of it is because our congress is dreadfully inept.
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by malnourish on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:33AM (#36521845)
Our federal congress was dragged into ineptitude by a group of people who refuse to legislate or collaborate and would rather confirm judges.

Some states are getting legislation done. Minnesota, for example, but same too with states that rapidly passed abortion curbs.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by zoklet-enjoyer on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:17AM (#36521543)
Congress has more important issues to deal with, such as making it illegal to participate in any programs involving extraterrestrial craft without notifying Congress
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by NoRelToEmber on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:16PM (#36522489)
He didn't petition congress because congress already legislated on this issue: neither the 14th amendment nor the civil rights act contain exceptions allowing racial discrimination, as long as it's for the right cause (and the courts get to pick which causes are right).
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by ellisv on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:32AM (#36521823)
> I don’t love the decision, but I actually like the process. And I don’t think it is legislating. It is interpreting the law.

I think this is naive. Roberts is not "calling balls and strikes" despite what he would have you believe. The conservative wing of the court has been willing to adopt a range of interpretations to accommodate their outcome.

It's not just setting aside precedent but their increased use of emergency motions (shadow docket) to issue orders without explanation.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by kuchenbecker on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:02PM (#36529654)
I see this opinion regularly, can you give an example?
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by lordloki on Thursday June 29, 2023 @02:35PM (#36524776)
Legacies aren't just about money. They are the "connections" that make elite universities beneficial to undergrads.
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by kickout on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:35AM (#36520907)
The population of the US is roughly ~330M
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by PopAlongKid on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:40AM (#36520989)
But don't forget to add corporations to the total, because they are people too according to SCOTUS.
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by ghaff on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:51AM (#36521179)
Corporations have had certain characteristics of people as long as they've existed. Do you want a corporation to be able to enter a contract that isn't with a specific person within the corporation, for example? Corporations also have freedom of the press/freedom of speech. The question in that decision was whether political spending by corporations was part of the free speech right. There's no question more broadly that corporations can put out a press release saying more or less anything (truthful) that they want.

This is a really lazy trope whatever you think of the specific decision's result (or the reasoning).

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by mcpackieh on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:06PM (#36522334)
> The question in that decision was whether political spending by corporations was part of the free speech right. There's no question more broadly that corporations can put out a press release saying more or less anything (truthful) that they want.

The "political spending" in the case of Citizens United was the production and dissemination of a propaganda film. If the release of a film can be restricted, why not a press release as well?

From wikipedia: "Broadcasting the film would have been a violation of the 2002 Bipartisan Campaign Reform Act, which prohibited any corporation, non-profit organization, or labor union from making an "electioneering communication" within 30 days of a primary or 60 days of an election, or making any expenditure advocating the election or defeat of a candidate at any time."

If the law bans "electioneering communication", could not an electioneering press release be considered such a banned communication as well?

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by ghaff on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:45PM (#36523013)
You're probably right. Most of the attention has focused on the financial angle. That said, organizations do have pretty broad latitude to advocate for laws and other outcomes. Conservation organizations do it all the time for example.
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by ketzu on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:55AM (#36521251)
I see multiple ways of interpreting what you said:

1. SCOTUS considers corporations 'natural persons' in their decisions

2. SCOTUS considers 'corporate personhood' to encompass too many rights, you believe should be exclusive for 'natural persons'

3. Possible misunderstanding around the term 'corporate personhood'

Could you clarify a bit? I've seen a lot of (3.) on discussions around this, while claiming essentially (1.) happens or (2.) is what peopel try to complain about.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by ghaff on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:30AM (#36521779)
IMO, a lot of people who didn't like the decision (whether because of which justices decided it or for some other reason) latched onto the "SCOTUS decided that corporations are people" shorthand because it seems absurd taken literally. Corporations are clearly not people (natural persons) the way you and I are.

But saying that corporate personhood shouldn't include political donations as part of their free speech rights, while a perfectly reasonable position and I might even agree, doesn't make as good a soundbite.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by OkayPhysicist on Thursday June 29, 2023 @04:04PM (#36525958)
When you really think about it, Citizen's United makes a lot of sense as a decision. It seems self evident to me that a non-profit trying to, say, save the local wetlands, should be able to make political statements like "Don't vote for Dave, Dave wants to pave our wetlands". Likewise, labor unions should be able to campaign against politicians trying to attack their ability to exist. Okay, so, only non-profit enterprises can engage in political speech. That still leaves you with the whole PAC thing, but maybe it's an improvement. What about Creedance Clearwater Revival? Or Al Gore's An Inconvenient Truth? Their art was certainly political, does that mean they should be barred from selling it?
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by devoutsalsa on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:33AM (#36520887)
Laws aren't (and can't) be written to cover all current and future use cases. The judicial branch is meant to provide interpretation of the law.

Federal courts enjoy the sole power to interpret the law, determine the constitutionality of the law, and apply it to individual cases. The courts, like Congress, can compel the production of evidence and testimony through the use of a subpoena.

https://www.whitehouse.gov/about-the-white-house/our-governm...

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by JustBreath on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:00AM (#36521321)
It's true laws don't account for the future. It's also true that laws can be created and updated by other means and quite often the judicial branch is used as a fast pass extension of the legislative branch.

The problem when you do this - especially on questionable legal arguments - is you're essentially setting up the future to have to fight for that right all over again, as we've seen with Roe v. Wade.

You can't take a section of the constitution that's about citizenship, infer a right to privacy and then extend that to abortion and not expect that flimsy foundation to be challenged later when the right 5 people happen to be present.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by londons_explore on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:37AM (#36520944)
> Legislating via the judicial branch is a bad idea.

Perhaps, if there is no 75% majority of opinions at the supreme court, then the case is just put on hold indefinitely until new clarifying laws are passed?

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by solardev on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:44AM (#36521051)
Even if 100% of the court agreed, 9 people can't possibly represent 300 million in any representative way.

Even Congress with 535 representatives isn't many. One representative for each 600,000 citizens? When was the last time a thousand Americans agreed on anything, much less half a million?

We have one of the worst ratios in the world: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_legislatures_by_number...

Edit: And the SC isn't representative anyway. They're appointed by the elites for the benefit of the ruling party, and there's a lot of politicking for those seats. Way too much power and corruption -- for life. The institution itself is a problem.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by catiopatio on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:49AM (#36521144)
They’re not supposed to be representative.

Democracy isn’t perfect, and they’re a check against some of the failings of the system.

Frankly, I’m shocked at how upset some of you are over racial discrimination being banned.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by solardev on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:54AM (#36521215)
There's not really checks and balances when all three branches are in cahoots for the benefit of party over people, primarily won through electoral shenanigans and political games. We literally have a system that continously overrules the will of the majority with a small group of electoral elites, justified using some byzantine algorithm of electoral boundaries. That isn't a democracy, it's a farce.

I don't really care about affirmative action much one way or the other. I care about the lack of representation in my so called democracy, and the Supremes are a huge part of that problem.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by catiopatio on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:10AM (#36521445)
> We literally have a system that continously overrules the will of the majority … That isn't a democracy, it's a farce.

Avoiding the tyranny of the majority is a major reason we intentionally don’t have direct democracy.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by solardev on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:18AM (#36521559)
Through a legal framework enumerating basic inalienable rights, perhaps. But substituting a tyranny of the majority for a tyranny of the minority isn't an improvement.
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by fzeroracer on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:59AM (#36521307)
The court is perfectly fine with discrimination as long as it fits their neocon views (see: Cakeshop vs Colorado), or as long as their donors pay them enough favors.
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by catiopatio on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:07AM (#36521406)
That’s a reductive view of the laws and cases involved.

The cakeshop case was about compelled speech, and the conservative justices’ politics are not “neocon”.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by fzeroracer on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:10AM (#36521454)
Discrimination is discrimination, no matter how you try to slice it. The compelled speech argument was a line of bullshit to discriminate against customers because it all hinged on their religious right to discriminate against people they did not like. That's the crux of it all.
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by londons_explore on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:18PM (#36522524)
> 9 people can't possibly represent 300 million in any representative way.

If they were 9 randomly selected citizens, then the majority vote of the 9 matches the result of a majority vote of the 300 million nearly always, particularly for decisive issues.

For example, if 90% of the population think something, then there is a 0.089% chance that a majority of the 9 citizens disagree.

Obviously judge selection isn't random, and thats probably your main concern.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by OkayPhysicist on Thursday June 29, 2023 @04:17PM (#36526117)
The SC is, by design, a little undemocratic. They're a check against the more democratic parts of the government, with the limitation that they basically can only make things legal. Since the default is that people are free to do whatever, laws can only restrict people's abilities to do stuff. The Supreme Court gets to shoot down laws, so they can only let us do more stuff.
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by JustBreath on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:21AM (#36521614)
I'm agree in essence, some kind of stipulation needs to be applied to supreme court decisions that incentivizes or outright requires the other houses to apply a more permanent solution.
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by damnesian on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:34AM (#36520891)
>Legislating via the judicial branch is a bad idea.

If the Citizens United decision didn't teach us that, nothing will.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by baron816 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:35AM (#36520910)
> 600 million

You mean 330 million?

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by andrewprock on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:39AM (#36520979)
The judicial branch does not legislate. It interprets existing legislation. In this case they were interpreting the 14th amendment to the US Constitution.

Now, they may not have interpreted it the way you or I would, and they may not have interpreted it correctly. But that is what they do.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by matthewdgreen on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:28AM (#36521739)
"Interpret" is just a word. In practice the Court has enormous power in interpreting laws, to the point where it can completely change the policy that laws implement, or strike them altogether.

We afford deference to the Court because we believe it follows a constrained legal procedure that makes the word "interpret" meaningful: this involves taking into account precedent and past case law. This approach tends to prevent justices from "interpreting" the law in ways that effectively re-write the law according to their instantaneous political preferences. This court is receiving criticism (and serious loss of public approval [1]) because it has abandoned those constraints, and keeps overturning longstanding precedent in ways that happen to correspond to the stated political preferences of the justices (and the politicians that appointed them.)

[1] https://news.gallup.com/poll/4732/supreme-court.aspx

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by jl6 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:34AM (#36520899)
600 million?
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by DeathArrow on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:41AM (#36521018)
Not yet.
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by gjsman-1000 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:33AM (#36520881)
The Judicial branch also has the job of ensuring whatever misguided ideas the Legislative branch may come up with, regardless of what they are (Communications Decency Act, anyone here?) are compliant with the US Constitution and other applicable laws.
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by topposter32 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:46AM (#36521097)
I only hear complaints from either side when the tables are turned against them. When its in their favor it's just the right thing to do.
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by ellisv on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:36AM (#36521899)
Eh. I think we should be complaining about the court all the time. They're not doing a great job.
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by JKCalhoun on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:14PM (#36522468)
Perhaps there are pro-slavery people still complaining about the 13th, 14th and 15th amendment?
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by topposter32 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @01:27PM (#36523631)
Those amendments were made by the legislature.
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by kjfarm on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:49AM (#36521149)
I completely agree with legislation via judicial branch being a bad idea. However, affirmative action isn't legislation. This is judicial review striking down policy (executive branch interpretation and implementation of legislation) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affirmative_action https://www.history.com/topics/us-government-and-politics/af...
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by alsaaro on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:56AM (#36521261)
Judicial review has upheld the constitutionality of affirmative action policies for 40+ years, what changed is the composition of the Supreme Court and its related willingness to legislate from the bench -- abandoning stare decisis and judicial restraint.

We saw this with Roe last year.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by COGlory on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:18AM (#36521567)
Some of the original Supreme Court cases upholding these policies went so far as to say that in the future, these exact things should be revisited because they were trying to bandage over decades of institutional racism.

https://gspp.berkeley.edu/research-and-impact/publications/w...

> In her opinion in Grutter v. Bollinger, Justice Sandra Day O’Connor concluded that affirmative action in college admissions is justifiable, but not in perpetuity: “We expect that 25 years from now, the use of racial preferences will no longer be necessary to further the interest [in student body diversity] approved today.”

There are lots of criticisms of the SC, but I don't see why everything they rule should be absolute ground truth forever. They can (and do) revisit cases for good reason.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by lost_tourist on Thursday June 29, 2023 @04:40PM (#36526406)
I think it's mostly about the current MAGA heavy SCOTUS though that got there mostly by duplicity and hamstringing Senate procedures and pure luck. The judges weren't selected for talent, they were selected for an agenda.
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by Clubber on Thursday June 29, 2023 @05:02PM (#36526658)
>I think it's mostly about the current MAGA heavy SCOTUS

That's modern liberal opinion news talking. It's about law. AA is a direct contradiction to the 14th amendment and it dilutes it. I'm sure just about everyone, including previously and currently oppressed minorities would prefer the protections of 14th amendment over the protections of AA.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by lost_tourist on Friday June 30, 2023 @08:42PM (#36544840)
No, not true at all and I don't agree. Otherwise no government program could take race into consideration, but they do. Are you saying any kind of programs that are "race based" should now be null and void? Because you can't nit pick situations given your logic. Also downvotes don't hurt me and I don't care, I will continue to speak my peace.
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by Clubber on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @11:14AM (#36587775)
>Otherwise no government program could take race into consideration

Can you give an example of a government program that takes race into consideration other than Affirmative Action programs?

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by AYBABTME on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:23AM (#36521656)
I'm on the more liberal side of the spectrum, yet it's unfair to say that _this_ SCOTUS has been legislating from the bench. The prior Democratic balance of SCOTUS did exactly the same and stretched very widely the definition of things to fit modern progressive ideals. In my opinion, politicians should have made Roe v. Wade into law instead of relying on SCOTUS to legis-interpret in their favor indefinitely.

I don't like many recent rulings from SCOTUS, but intellectual honesty forces me to admit that when the pendulum was on the other side, the same thing happened with different allegiances.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by alsaaro on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:15PM (#36522477)
There was hasn't been a "prior Democratic balance of SCOTUS" the SCOTUS has been firmly conservative since Rehnquist (1986) and probably before that. What is notable about this Robert's Court, is that they have overturned rulings affirmed by other conservative courts and even their own recent rulings!

Almost as if the Robert's court concluded there is no point in being powerful if you can't rule, even though ruling is beyond the scope of all courts.

As for Roe V. Wade being codified, this was a moot point at the time because you had a Constitutional right to an abortion -- your right to an abortion was codified in the Constitution, a law would have been redundant.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by GloomyBoots on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:35PM (#36522806)
No it wasn’t. You had a constitutional right to privacy, not to abortion. It was obviously tenuous reasoning at the time, and its shaky footing hasn’t exactly been a secret ever since. Roe should have been codified into law if we really wanted to keep it around long term.
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by AYBABTME on Thursday June 29, 2023 @02:12PM (#36524456)
Alright, prior SCOTUS had a more democratic balance, and at a minimum ruled more often than now in fairly tenuous ways in favor of progressive ideals. The end result was stuff I liked more than what they rule today, but them having voted in my camp doesn't mean I believe it was the right thing.

I think when the status quo requires on someone's stretched interpretation of a series of things, and this status quo is very important to people, it's on lawmakers to make the rules unambiguous.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by NeRF_ornothing on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:40PM (#36522900)
As far as I can tell, the last time the supreme court of the united states had a majority of members appointed by a democratic president was in 1969.
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by zeroonetwothree on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:23PM (#36529790)
This is misleading because Republicans appointed several liberal justices like Warren or Souter. How many conservative justices did Democrats appoint?
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by paulvnickerson on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:21AM (#36521619)
Striking down Roa v Wade was an example of undoing such “legislating from the branch.” The original Roe v Wade created in effect a new federal law, and last year’s decision struck that down.
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by legitster on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:24AM (#36521679)
Well, in both cases, the decisions at the time implied that they were temporary.

A lot of the logic of Roe v Wade was based on viability outside of a womb based on medical science of the time.

Right in the decision of affirmative action there is admission that it will need to be revisited.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by mcpackieh on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:01PM (#36522259)
Roe v Wade's trimester system, like virtually all abortion cutoffs, was essentially arbitrary. Calibrated to fit what their gut felt was right. For evidence of this, look at the abortion cutoffs in Europe, nearly every European country has a different cutoff from the others. In Germany it's 12 weeks and in the UK it's 24. It's all over the place. If these cutoffs were based on science there shouldn't be this much spread.
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by zajio1am on Thursday June 29, 2023 @08:59PM (#36529140)
> look at the abortion cutoffs in Europe, nearly every European country has a different cutoff from the others.

Not really, 12 weeks are pretty common, and most european countries fit in 10-14 weeks, with just few exceptions like UK and Netherlands.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by newacct3 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:13AM (#36521493)
What also changed was the timing of the decision, see O'Connor's "25 years" comment
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by alsaaro on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:03PM (#36522285)
Remember the Supreme Court upheld the legality of affirmative action in 2016 in Fisher v. UT-Austin, and two lower courts upheld the legality of affirmative action in this particular decision.

What changed is the make-up of the court; otherwise, apparently affirmative action's unconstitutionality was just realized like a revelation from God and every previous court (federal and Supreme) was wrong.

Racial rancor, and racism in general -- anti black racism in particular -- has probably increased since 2003; at least in the public sphere - hopefully this ruling is not a part of that milieu.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by JustBreath on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:16AM (#36521540)
Agree except for the "willingness to legislate" changing.

That's been in place for a LONG time, it dates all the way back to the separation of church and state decision being based on a letter Thomas Jefferson wrote.

Hell Roe v. Wade itself is an example.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by MichaelZuo on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:16AM (#36521535)
Regardless of whatever the political currents are, it's sensible policy to strike down every pseudo law that doesn't have legislative backing of some kind.

If they only selectively struck them down in favor of one group or another, then that would be a different matter.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by engineer_22 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @01:19PM (#36523493)
The greater corpus of American law is based on case law, meaning it is based on court decisions. It is a common law system.

This is in juxtaposition to civil law systems that are based on codified legislation, for example in France or Germany.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by MichaelZuo on Thursday June 29, 2023 @05:53PM (#36527282)
Most case law is based on some kind of legislative output directly or indirectly via other case law. That's well known.
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by engineer_22 on Friday June 30, 2023 @06:04PM (#36543044)
Yes I agree with you and in the context of this discussion it's unknown the parent's understanding of law and pseudo-law and I apologize if I came across the wrong way as a poser
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by stainablesteel on Thursday June 29, 2023 @08:25PM (#36528806)
there are way more things in the world that have changed besides what justices make up the supreme court

these policies of racial discrimination aren't helping anyone. they don't help the people who didn't deserve the spots in the first place, and they don't help the people that are being robbed of the spots they deserve.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by eli on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:57PM (#36523235)
Yes, exactly: it's a policy decision. Congress could pass a law altering what affirmative action is allowed if they wanted a different policy.
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by gnicholas on Thursday June 29, 2023 @05:11PM (#36526766)
Often this is true, but this case was decided based on constitutional interpretation of the 14th Amendment.

Congress cannot override this with a law. It would require an amendment to the Constitution, which is more involved. Considering that not even CA could pass a law to allow affirmative action in higher education, it would be impossible for such an amendment to be passed and ratified by the states.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by dragonwriter on Thursday June 29, 2023 @05:18PM (#36526857)
> Often this is true, but this case was decided based on constitutional interpretation of the 14th Amendment.

The main opinion was actually following a line of cases using 14th Amendment jurisprudence to guide the interpetation of similar text in Title VI of the the Civil Rights Act of 1964, so, yes, Congress can override it by changing the text of the statute, which is in principal what is actually being applied.

The portion of the 14th Amendment whose interprtation was imported doesn’t bind either private actors or the federal government, so isn’t directly applicable on its own.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by gnicholas on Thursday June 29, 2023 @06:32PM (#36527744)
Hm, that's not my reading of the case, in particular this sentence from page 2 (the Syllabus):

> Held: Harvard’s and UNC’s admissions programs violate the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.

The concurrence by Gorsuch also makes clear that the majority opinion was based on the Constitution, not Title VI.

> Today, the Court holds that the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment does not tolerate this practice. I write to emphasize that Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 does not either.

What are you seeing that indicates that the majority opinion was based on Title VI?

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by eli on Thursday June 29, 2023 @07:03PM (#36528025)
Yeah but that’s nonsense. The Conservative majority wanted to get rid of affirmative action so they decided to interpret the 14th this way. That’s the point. This is judicial activism.
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by DonsDiscountGas on Thursday June 29, 2023 @02:30PM (#36524695)
Racial discrimination has been explicitly illegal, and affirmative action - as currently practiced - is racial discrimination. You're right that it's not legislation, it's straight up illegal. The courts have been tying themselves in knots around this but somebody finally just read the law. If Congress wants to make some kinds of racial discrimination legal, they need to actually pass a law saying so.

The original usage of the phrase is reasonable enough[0], but that's not what this lawsuit was about.

[0] > On March 6, 1961, shortly after taking office, President John F. Kennedy signed Executive Order 10925, which required all federal contractors to take “affirmative action”—the first use of the phrase in this context—to ensure all job applicants and employees were treated equally, regardless of race, creed, color or national origin. https://www.history.com/topics/us-government-and-politics/af...

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by gotoeleven on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:55AM (#36521238)
Penumbras and emanations of the 4th amendment to allow us to have abortions? Not legislating!

Saying "equal protection of the law" means you have to give people the equal protection of law? OMG legislating from the bench!

The funny thing is that everywhere voters actually have had a chance to vote on affirmative action, they vote it down (Most recently prop 16 in california). Every single time. And yet left wing institutions keep finding a way to worm around whatever the law is. The legislative intent is clearly in agreement with this ruling so these "oh no they're legislating from the bench" arguments are nonsensical.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by notlegislating on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:56AM (#36521262)
The legislation in question (the Civil Rights Act) prohibits all racial discrimination and it was only previous (in my opinion, misguided) Supreme Court decisions that allowed affirmative action as an exception to that in the first place.
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by VoodooJuJu on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:23AM (#36521663)
The judicial branch does not make laws.

You're implying that the judicial branch legislated in this case.

They did no such thing.

They interpreted existing laws for a particular case, gave their judgement, and applied the existing law.

Indeed, legislating via the judicial branch is a bad idea, and so it's a good thing that they do not and are not able to.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by theratattack on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:32AM (#36521812)
> They interpreted existing laws

In the dissent at least, the court is very much interpreting court precedent and almost entirely ignoring the law itself

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by polski-g on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:40AM (#36521951)
Liberal SCOTUS opinions talk a lot about morality and societal harm, rarely about the legality of the subject at hand. It is Congress' job to deal with morality and harm, not the judicial branch.
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by eli on Thursday June 29, 2023 @01:08PM (#36523322)
Conservatives also care deeply about morality and society, but their opinions often hide behind whatever legal interpretation gives them the policy outcome they desire.

Thomas is a textualist when the text is favorable. If it's not, suddenly historical context and the founder's intent becomes crucial.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by koolba on Thursday June 29, 2023 @06:44PM (#36527886)
The Jackson dissent opener is a great example of this:

> Gulf-sized race-based gaps exist with respect to the health, wealth, and well-being of American citizens. They were created in the distant past, but have indisputably been passed down to the present day through the genera- tions. Every moment these gaps persist is a moment in which this great country falls short of actualizing one of its foundational principles—the “self-evident” truth that all of us are created equal.

Apparently anything that doesn’t further a final state of equality of outcome is inherently racist and it’s the governments job to make that happen.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by renewiltord on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:37AM (#36521912)
This is a legal fiction. Both abortion and affirmative action were legislated from the bench. That's how they came to be. It's a classic thing. Having come to the conclusion that some thing should be law, the composition of the bench determines whether sufficient justification can be found. Then these decisions have the weight of law.

It is a defacto Politburo - a long lived legislative body of ultimate authority that has a rolling composition not determined by direct electoral results.

We can point to the legal fiction that the judiciary is not the legislature all we want but it walks like a duck and quacks like a duck.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by Supermancho on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:46AM (#36522033)
> the composition of the bench determines whether sufficient justification can be found.

You're under the mistaken impression that justifications are a prerequisite. Any court can find justification for any ruling in whatever way they see fit. Yes, lower judges have been remove for questionable decisions. SCOTUS is above that, as a lifetime appointment. Sometimes rulings come with no justification at all. SCOTUS has been trying to explain itself via these public "opinions", but is not required to do so.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by mywittyname on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:47AM (#36522060)
They kind of do. Federal judges have a great deal of latitude in what they are allowed to accomplish with a ruling. They have the power to effectively change the text of a law to mean what the judge says it should mean (granted, it must also pass appeal).

It has been a problem for decades now that Congress will pass laws that aren't well thought out, then leave it to the judiciary to iron out the specifics. It's only recently that members of the judiciary began pushing back and ruling on the text of the law and saying the legislators should "fix" the obvious problems with the law.

The term for this is colloquially, "legislating from the bench."

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by joshuaissac on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:21PM (#36522571)
> The judicial branch does not make laws.

> They interpreted existing laws for a particular case, gave their judgement, and applied the existing law.

This is not how it works in common law jurisdictions. Common law judges can and do make law. This is called case law (or common law), in contrast to statute law that is enacted by the legislature. That goes beyond just interpreting statute law but also making new laws where they do not exist. Common law offences, for example, are crimes declared as such by judges even when there is no statute criminalising that conduct. Most of the existing contract law has been made by judges rather than by legislators.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by cvoss on Thursday June 29, 2023 @02:50PM (#36524987)
This is just a dispute of semantics over what the word "law" means. The fact remains that the United States government has been designed from the start to have legislative bodies that pass statutes, and judicial bodies which do not pass statutes. If judicial bodies effectively pass or amend statutes by exercising too much control, then we have a fundamental breakdown occurring with respect to the design of the system.
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by ralusek on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:25AM (#36521704)
They aren't legislating from the bench. Legislating from the bench is the opposite of what is being done here. The role of the judicial is to look at laws and actions and determine if they're legal within the meta framework. That is what was done here.
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by PM_me_your_math on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:30AM (#36521776)
SCOTUS rules on the constitutionality of laws. It doesn't write or institute any laws whatsoever. Now people need to get into college on merit instead of scoring high in the Victim Olympics. That's a great thing for our society.
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by malnourish on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:36AM (#36521898)
Did all pre-Affirmative Action college applicants matriculate based on their merits?
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by kindatrue on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:44AM (#36522007)
This also works in the opposite direction though:

New York has a right to shelter law because of the judicial branch of government. Basically, a pro bono lawsuit and a judge forced NY to have enough shelter space for all people sleeping in the street.

Compare and contrast that to San Francisco (and more broadly California) - where everything can be decided on at the ballot box (like kidney dialysis staffing levels) - which has more people sleeping on the street than all of the UK, and has a wait list of each night of 1000+ for a shelter spot.

Everything has advantages and drawbacks.

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by cvoss on Thursday June 29, 2023 @02:36PM (#36524787)
Whether to a sufficient degree or not, SCOTUS agrees with you on this point and exercises a strong reluctance to second-guess past generations of itself, especially on statutory (as opposed to constitutional) matters, since it is theoretically easy for Congress to amend its own statutes if ever Congress should disagree with how the Court has interpreted them.

Indeed, just today, SCOTUS also released a unanimous opinion protecting a person's religious rights against his employer [1]. Sotomayor and Jackson left an addendum pointing out that this man had asked them to overrule a 50-year precedent in interpreting a law, and they explicitly chose not to do so (though they ruled in his favor in a different, narrower way) precisely for the reason I mentioned about Congress having the opportunity to correct the matter if they so choose.

The "liberal" justices usually get the most flack for "legislating from the bench" (although arguments can be made that the "conservative" ones do it too). But here we have the most liberal justice on the Court saying "The Court's respect for Congress's decision not to intervene promotes the separation of powers by requiring interested parties to resort to the legislative rather than the judicial process to achieve their policy goals."

If I could air a very broad-brush opinion, complaints people have about SCOTUS being a partisan institution these days are best levied against Congress (and litigants) for how they treat the Court, not against the Court for its own behavior. When people express low confidence in the Court, I'm always eager to see them aim their low confidence at Congress instead of (not in addition to) the Court.

[1] https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/22pdf/22-174_k536.pdf

Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by vxNsr on Friday June 30, 2023 @12:58AM (#36530678)
This one is interesting because ever since the Native American case, they’ve been carefully sidestepping this issue every time it came before the court, they’d rule very narrowly usually in favor of religious freedom, but would never establish any precedent, looks like they took the same tack here.
Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned by ec109685 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:19PM (#36530131)
Beyond that it took Gore losing in Florida by a handful of votes (butterfly ballot?!), Trump carrying the states he did by less than 100k votes and effectively two Supreme Court Justices to die, and one to retire for this to be overturned.