Even Congress with 535 representatives isn't many. One representative for each 600,000 citizens? When was the last time a thousand Americans agreed on anything, much less half a million?
We have one of the worst ratios in the world: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_legislatures_by_number...
Edit: And the SC isn't representative anyway. They're appointed by the elites for the benefit of the ruling party, and there's a lot of politicking for those seats. Way too much power and corruption -- for life. The institution itself is a problem.
Democracy isn’t perfect, and they’re a check against some of the failings of the system.
Frankly, I’m shocked at how upset some of you are over racial discrimination being banned.
I don't really care about affirmative action much one way or the other. I care about the lack of representation in my so called democracy, and the Supremes are a huge part of that problem.
Avoiding the tyranny of the majority is a major reason we intentionally don’t have direct democracy.
The cakeshop case was about compelled speech, and the conservative justices’ politics are not “neocon”.
If they were 9 randomly selected citizens, then the majority vote of the 9 matches the result of a majority vote of the 300 million nearly always, particularly for decisive issues.
For example, if 90% of the population think something, then there is a 0.089% chance that a majority of the 9 citizens disagree.
Obviously judge selection isn't random, and thats probably your main concern.
Perhaps, if there is no 75% majority of opinions at the supreme court, then the case is just put on hold indefinitely until new clarifying laws are passed?