In the dissent at least, the court is very much interpreting court precedent and almost entirely ignoring the law itself
Thomas is a textualist when the text is favorable. If it's not, suddenly historical context and the founder's intent becomes crucial.
> Gulf-sized race-based gaps exist with respect to the health, wealth, and well-being of American citizens. They were created in the distant past, but have indisputably been passed down to the present day through the genera- tions. Every moment these gaps persist is a moment in which this great country falls short of actualizing one of its foundational principles—the “self-evident” truth that all of us are created equal.
Apparently anything that doesn’t further a final state of equality of outcome is inherently racist and it’s the governments job to make that happen.
It is a defacto Politburo - a long lived legislative body of ultimate authority that has a rolling composition not determined by direct electoral results.
We can point to the legal fiction that the judiciary is not the legislature all we want but it walks like a duck and quacks like a duck.
You're under the mistaken impression that justifications are a prerequisite. Any court can find justification for any ruling in whatever way they see fit. Yes, lower judges have been remove for questionable decisions. SCOTUS is above that, as a lifetime appointment. Sometimes rulings come with no justification at all. SCOTUS has been trying to explain itself via these public "opinions", but is not required to do so.
It has been a problem for decades now that Congress will pass laws that aren't well thought out, then leave it to the judiciary to iron out the specifics. It's only recently that members of the judiciary began pushing back and ruling on the text of the law and saying the legislators should "fix" the obvious problems with the law.
The term for this is colloquially, "legislating from the bench."
> They interpreted existing laws for a particular case, gave their judgement, and applied the existing law.
This is not how it works in common law jurisdictions. Common law judges can and do make law. This is called case law (or common law), in contrast to statute law that is enacted by the legislature. That goes beyond just interpreting statute law but also making new laws where they do not exist. Common law offences, for example, are crimes declared as such by judges even when there is no statute criminalising that conduct. Most of the existing contract law has been made by judges rather than by legislators.
You're implying that the judicial branch legislated in this case.
They did no such thing.
They interpreted existing laws for a particular case, gave their judgement, and applied the existing law.
Indeed, legislating via the judicial branch is a bad idea, and so it's a good thing that they do not and are not able to.