Re:Affirmative action at US colleges has been banned
by vxNsr on Friday June 30, 2023 @12:58AM
(#36530678)
This one is interesting because ever since the Native American case, they’ve been carefully sidestepping this issue every time it came before the court, they’d rule very narrowly usually in favor of religious freedom, but would never establish any precedent, looks like they took the same tack here.
Indeed, just today, SCOTUS also released a unanimous opinion protecting a person's religious rights against his employer [1]. Sotomayor and Jackson left an addendum pointing out that this man had asked them to overrule a 50-year precedent in interpreting a law, and they explicitly chose not to do so (though they ruled in his favor in a different, narrower way) precisely for the reason I mentioned about Congress having the opportunity to correct the matter if they so choose.
The "liberal" justices usually get the most flack for "legislating from the bench" (although arguments can be made that the "conservative" ones do it too). But here we have the most liberal justice on the Court saying "The Court's respect for Congress's decision not to intervene promotes the separation of powers by requiring interested parties to resort to the legislative rather than the judicial process to achieve their policy goals."
If I could air a very broad-brush opinion, complaints people have about SCOTUS being a partisan institution these days are best levied against Congress (and litigants) for how they treat the Court, not against the Court for its own behavior. When people express low confidence in the Court, I'm always eager to see them aim their low confidence at Congress instead of (not in addition to) the Court.
[1] https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/22pdf/22-174_k536.pdf